MathemagiciansLibraryExplorationsDeep Dives
← Chemistry · Lower Secondary
ChemistryLower Secondary

Pure substances vs mixtures — the difference

LSC1.2 — Pure Substances and MixturesLecture 1 of 2~2120 words

What does "pure" mean?

Here are four drinks of water. Water from the sea. Water from a tap. Water from a bottle in a shop. And water from a chemistry laboratory, made by boiling water and collecting the steam. Which of them are pure?

In everyday life, "pure" means clean, or natural, or with nothing bad added. A carton of orange juice might say "100% pure". To a chemist, that juice is not pure at all. It is mostly water, with sugars, acids and many other substances in it.

In chemistry, "pure" has one exact meaning, and it is different from the everyday one. This lecture gives that meaning. It also keeps a promise. The lecture on changing state said that melting and boiling points would one day tell pure substances from mixtures. Here is how.

Pure substances: only one substance

In chemistry, a pure substance contains only one substance. Every particle in it is the same kind of particle. Nothing else is there.

There are two kinds of pure substance.

An element: copperCuCuCuCuCuCuCuCuCuCuCuCuCuCuCuCuCuCuCuCuCuA compound: water (H₂O)HHOHHOHHOHHOHHOHHOHHOHHOHHOA mixture: nitrogen and oxygen (as in air)NNOONNNNOONNNNNNNN
Particle pictures (not to scale). Top: an element, one kind of atom. Middle: a compound, every molecule the same, each made of different atoms joined together. Bottom: a mixture, two different substances side by side, not joined to each other.

Mixtures: more than one substance, not joined

A mixture contains two or more substances that are mixed together but not chemically joined. Air is a mixture. It contains nitrogen molecules, oxygen molecules, argon atoms, carbon dioxide molecules and some water vapour. They move around among each other, but they are not joined.

Mixtures have three properties that come from this. Each one has a reason.

Why does a mixture of gases or liquids stay mixed? The lecture on diffusion answered this. Particles move randomly, so they spread out evenly and stay spread out. Separating a mixture means working against diffusion, which is why it always takes some effort.

Elements, compounds and mixtures

Element: one kind of atom only. A pure substance.

Compound: two or more kinds of atom chemically joined in a fixed ratio. A pure substance.

Mixture: two or more substances not chemically joined, in amounts that can vary. Not a pure substance.

A compound is not a mixture of elements

This is the hard part of the lecture, so take your time. A compound contains more than one element. So does a mixture of elements. They can sound the same. They are not.

Think about iron and sulfur. Iron is a grey metal, and a magnet picks it up. Sulfur is a yellow powder. Stir iron filings and sulfur powder together and you have a mixture. You can still see grey and yellow bits. A magnet can pull the iron out and leave the sulfur behind. You can use any amounts you like.

Now heat the mixture strongly. It glows, and a new substance forms: iron sulfide, a compound. The iron atoms and sulfur atoms are now joined in a fixed ratio, one to one. Iron sulfide is a dark solid that does not behave like either of its elements. A magnet can no longer pull the iron out, because there is no separate iron left. To get the iron back you would need another chemical reaction.

Water shows the same thing even more clearly. Hydrogen and oxygen are both gases at room temperature, and a mixture of them can explode. Water, the compound they make, is a calm liquid that puts out fires. A compound is a new substance with new properties. That is it. That is the whole difference: in a mixture the substances are only side by side; in a compound the atoms are joined, and a new substance has been made.

Three questions decide it every time:

Stop and think

Tap water is clean and safe to drink. Is it a pure substance?

Show the answer

No. Tap water contains small amounts of dissolved minerals, such as calcium and magnesium compounds, and often a little chlorine added to kill germs. So it is a mixture, even though it is clean. Water left to dry in a kettle leaves a white crust behind; that crust is some of the dissolved minerals. In chemistry, "pure" is about how many substances there are, not about whether something is safe or clean. Distilled water, made by boiling water and condensing the steam, is very nearly pure.

Practise the three questions with the cards below.

Sort — element, compound or mixture?

Tap a card, then tap the box it belongs in. Read the reason after each choice.

Ten everyday materials, sorted.

MaterialBoxReason
Copper wireElementCopper is made of only one kind of atom, copper atoms.
Oxygen gasElementOxygen molecules are two oxygen atoms joined together. Only one kind of atom, so it is an element.
Pure (distilled) waterCompoundEvery particle is the same H₂O molecule: hydrogen and oxygen atoms joined in a fixed ratio of 2 to 1.
Carbon dioxideCompoundEvery particle is a CO₂ molecule: one carbon atom joined to two oxygen atoms.
Table salt (sodium chloride)CompoundSodium and chlorine joined in a fixed ratio, 1 to 1. It is one substance with its own properties.
AirMixtureNitrogen, oxygen, argon, carbon dioxide and water vapour, mixed but not joined. The amounts can vary.
SeawaterMixtureWater with many salts dissolved in it. The amount of salt varies from sea to sea.
Tap waterMixtureWater with small amounts of dissolved minerals and other substances. Clean is not the same as pure.
A 22-carat gold ringMixture22 carat means 22 parts gold in 24. The other parts are other metals mixed in.
Orange juiceMixtureMostly water, with sugars, acids and other substances dissolved or floating in it.

The purity test: melting and boiling points

Seawater and pure water look exactly the same. How can a chemist tell them apart without tasting them? The answer is temperature.

The lecture on changing state showed that a pure substance melts and boils at fixed temperatures. While pure ice melts, the temperature stays at 0 °C until all of it has melted. While pure water boils at normal air pressure, the temperature stays at 100 °C. Every pure substance has its own fixed values, like a fingerprint.

A mixture behaves differently, for a reason you can picture with particles. In a pure solid, all the particles are the same, so they fit together in a neat, regular pattern. Every part of the pattern needs the same energy to break up, so it all melts at one temperature. In an impure solid, other particles sit among them and spoil the pattern. Some parts of it are weaker and start to break up early. So an impure solid usually starts melting at a lower temperature, and it melts over a range of temperatures instead of at one.

Boiling changes the other way. Dissolved particles get in the way of water molecules escaping from the liquid, so a solution needs a higher temperature to boil. What happens to the temperature as seawater boils? Commit to an answer first.

Predict — boiling seawater

Seawater is heated until it boils, and it keeps boiling. What does the thermometer in it do while it boils? Choose, then see the measured starting point and how the temperature changes.

The temperature of pure water and of seawater while they boil, zoomed in to the range 99.5 °C to 101.5 °C.

99.5100100.5101101.50246810Time since boiling began (minutes)Temperature (°C)

—— pure water · —— seawater (35 g of salts per kilogram)

Pure water stays at 100 °C. Seawater with 35 g of salts in each kilogram starts boiling at about 100.6 °C. As water boils off, the salt left behind is in less water, so the boiling temperature keeps rising. The curve is drawn for steady heating until half of the water has gone; the later part is an estimate.

The same seawater also freezes at a lower temperature than pure water: about −1.9 °C instead of 0 °C. Salt lowers the freezing point and raises the boiling point. Both changes have the same cause: other particles getting in the way.

Testing for purity

A pure substance melts and boils at sharp, fixed temperatures that match the values in a data table.

An impure substance usually melts over a range of temperatures, starting below the pure value, and boils at a higher temperature than the pure liquid.

Worked examples

Worked Example 1 — Which sample is pure?

Two white solids, A and B, are both sold as sodium chloride (table salt). Pure sodium chloride melts at 801 °C. Sample A melts at 801 °C, and the temperature stays there until it has all melted. Sample B starts melting at 790 °C and has finished at 798 °C. Which is pure?

76078080082084002468101214Time (minutes)Temperature (°C)

—— sample A: flat at 801 °C · - - - sample B: melts from 790 °C to 798 °C

Heating curves of the two samples (invented readings). A stays flat at 801 °C while it melts. B rises slowly through its melting range, starting 11 °C below the pure value.

Read the evidence. A melts at one sharp temperature, and it matches the known value. B melts over a range of 8 °C, and the whole range is below 801 °C.

Answer. A is very likely pure sodium chloride. B contains impurities, which lowered its melting point and spread it out.

Check. Both signs of impurity point the same way for B: a range, and a lower start ✓.

Worked Example 2 — Element, compound or mixture?

Classify: (a) iron; (b) carbon dioxide; (c) air; (d) salt water.

(a) Iron is made of only iron atoms: an element.

(b) Every carbon dioxide molecule is one carbon atom joined to two oxygen atoms, CO₂, always 1 to 2: a compound.

(c) Air is nitrogen, oxygen, argon, carbon dioxide and water vapour, not joined, in amounts that vary a little from place to place: a mixture.

(d) Salt water is water and salt, two compounds mixed together. You can add more salt or more water: a mixture.

Check. Carbon dioxide appears in (b) as a pure compound and in (c) as one part of a mixture. That is fine: the same substance can be pure on its own or one part of a mixture ✓.

Worked Example 3 — How pure is gold?

Gold jewellery is often 22 carat, stamped "916". Investment gold bars are 24 carat, stamped "999" or "999.9". Carats count parts of gold out of 24. (a) What fraction of a 22-carat ring is gold? (b) Is a 22-carat ring a pure substance? (c) Is a 24-carat bar?

(a) 22 parts out of 24: 22 ÷ 24 ≈ 0.917, or about 91.7% gold. The stamp "916" means 916 parts in 1000, which is 91.6%.

(b) No. The other parts, about 8%, are other metals, usually silver and copper, mixed in to make the ring harder. A mixture of metals like this is called an alloy.

(c) Very nearly. "999" means 99.9% gold, and "999.9" means 99.99%. Even the best refiners cannot remove the last tiny traces, so "pure" in practice always means "pure to a stated level".

Check. 24 carat would be 24 ÷ 24 = 100% in theory, and the real bars come within 0.1% or less of that ✓.

Trap 1 — Pure means clean

In chemistry, pure means "one substance only". Clean tap water, fresh air and "100% pure" juice are all mixtures. A poisonous substance can be perfectly pure.

Trap 2 — A compound is a mixture of elements

In a compound the atoms are chemically joined in a fixed ratio, and a new substance with new properties has formed. A magnet pulls iron out of an iron and sulfur mixture, but not out of iron sulfide.

Trap 3 — Every pure liquid boils at 100 °C

100 °C is the boiling point of pure water at normal air pressure. Every pure substance has its own value: pure ethanol boils at about 78 °C. A test for purity compares a sample with the value for that particular substance.

Try it yourself

Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.

  1. Classify each as an element, a compound or a mixture, and give a reason: (a) nitrogen gas; (b) sugar (sucrose, C₁₂H₂₂O₁₁); (c) a fizzy drink; (d) steel (iron with a little carbon); (e) pure ice.

    Hint 1

    Ask: how many substances are there? If one, how many kinds of atom?

    Hint 2

    A chemical formula with more than one element symbol means a compound.

    Full answer

    (a) Element: only nitrogen atoms (in N₂ molecules). (b) Compound: carbon, hydrogen and oxygen joined in a fixed ratio. (c) Mixture: water, sugar, flavourings and dissolved carbon dioxide. (d) Mixture: an alloy, iron and carbon not joined in a fixed ratio; different steels have different amounts of carbon. (e) Compound: pure ice is water, H₂O, as a solid. Changing state does not change the substance. Check: the two pure substances, (b) and (e), each have one formula ✓.

  2. Pure benzoic acid melts at 122 °C. Three samples melt like this: X at 122 °C, sharp; Y from 114 °C to 119 °C; Z from 121 °C to 122 °C. Put them in order from most pure to least pure, and explain.

    Hint 1

    Look at two things: how wide the range is, and how far below 122 °C it starts.

    Hint 2

    A small impurity gives a small change; a larger impurity gives a larger one.

    Full answer

    X, then Z, then Y. X melts sharply at the pure value. Z melts over a narrow range of 1 °C, starting just below 122 °C: slightly impure. Y melts over a range of 5 °C, starting 8 °C below the pure value: the most impure. Check: the further below 122 °C a sample starts melting, the more impure it is, and the order X, Z, Y follows that ✓.

  3. Mei has two beakers of clear, colourless liquid. One is distilled water and one is salt water. Describe two ways she could tell them apart without tasting them.

    Hint 1

    Think about what happens when each one boils.

    Hint 2

    Think about what is left behind when all the water has gone.

    Full answer

    First, boil a sample of each and measure the temperature: distilled water stays at 100 °C, while salt water boils above 100 °C and its temperature keeps creeping up. Second, let a little of each evaporate in a clean dish: distilled water leaves nothing, while salt water leaves white salt crystals. (Measuring the freezing point would also work: salt water freezes below 0 °C.) Check: each test uses a property that is fixed for a pure substance and changed by dissolved particles ✓.

  4. In cold countries, salt is spread on icy roads in winter. Seawater, which has about 35 g of salts in every kilogram, freezes at about −1.9 °C. (a) Use the idea of "other particles getting in the way" to explain why salt makes ice melt at temperatures a little below 0 °C. (b) Why does this stop working on very cold days?

    Hint 1

    Salty water needs a lower temperature to freeze than pure water does. What does that mean for ice touching salty water at −1 °C?

    Hint 2

    Think about how much salt can dissolve in the thin layer of water on the ice. Is there a limit?

    Full answer

    (a) Salt dissolves in the thin film of water on the ice. Its particles get in the way of water molecules fitting into the regular pattern of ice. So salty water stays liquid below 0 °C, and ice touching it melts into it, as long as the temperature is above the salty water's freezing point. (b) The more salt dissolves, the lower the freezing point goes, but only so much salt can dissolve. Below the lowest freezing point a salty solution can reach, ice stays frozen whatever you add. (For common salt this limit is roughly −21 °C.) Check: seawater at −1.9 °C fits the pattern: some salt, a freezing point a little below 0 °C ✓.

The bigger idea

Purity matters wherever people need a substance to behave exactly as expected: in medicines, in food, in electronics. A medicine factory checks every batch, because an impurity can change how a medicine works. Melting point is one of the oldest and cheapest checks. Chemists even use a clever version of it: they mix an unknown solid with a little of a known one. If the melting point stays sharp and unchanged, the two are the same substance. If it drops and spreads, they are different.

Nothing is ever perfectly pure. Even the best gold is "only" 99.99% gold. So "pure" in chemistry always comes with a question attached: pure enough for what? The next lecture shows how mixtures are separated, which is how every pure substance you will ever use was made.

Key concepts in this lesson