- Solids, liquids and gases — the particle model
- Temperature vs heat · coming soon
A thermometer that stops moving
Put a thermometer into a glass of crushed ice and water, and set it on a warm table. Heat flows into the glass from the warm room the whole time. So you would expect the temperature to rise.
It does not. While there is still ice in the glass, the thermometer stays at 0 °C. Five minutes, ten minutes, twenty minutes: still 0 °C. Only when the last piece of ice has melted does the temperature begin to climb.
Something similar happens in a kettle. Once the water is boiling, the temperature stays at 100 °C, however long the kettle stays on. Energy keeps flowing in. The temperature stays still. So where is the energy going?
The last lecture ended with a tug of war between attraction and movement, and promised to follow the changes of state step by step. Here they are. The answer to the puzzle is the most important idea in this lecture, so spend your time on it.
Six changes, two directions
A substance can move between the three states in six ways. Each change has a name.
| Change | From → to | Energy |
|---|---|---|
| Melting | solid → liquid | taken in |
| Freezing | liquid → solid | given out |
| Evaporating or boiling | liquid → gas | taken in |
| Condensing | gas → liquid | given out |
| Subliming | solid → gas | taken in |
| Depositing | gas → solid | given out |
The pattern is simple. Every change that moves the particles further apart takes in energy. Every change that brings them closer together gives energy out. To see why, go back to the tug of war.
Where the energy goes
Particles attract each other. To pull them further apart, you must work against that attraction, and that takes energy. Think of pulling two magnets apart: you have to push to separate them. Particles are similar. When they come together again, the same energy is given back.
Now think about what temperature measures. Temperature tells you how fast the particles are moving, on average. Hotter means faster.
So energy that flows into a substance can do one of two jobs:
- Job 1: speed the particles up. The temperature rises.
- Job 2: pull the particles apart, against their attraction. The temperature does not change.
While ice is melting, the energy is doing Job 2. It is loosening particles from their fixed places, so that they can slide past each other. The particles are not moving any faster, so the temperature stays at 0 °C. Only when every particle is free does the energy go back to Job 1, and the liquid warms up.
That is it. That is the whole idea. During a change of state, the energy goes into changing how the particles are held together, not into making them faster. So the temperature stays still until the change is complete.
The heating curve
Here is what happens if you heat 1 kg of ice from −20 °C, steadily, and record the temperature every few seconds. The heater gives the same energy every second (1 kW, about the power of a small electric kettle).
Look at the two flat parts. The melting part lasts about 5.6 minutes. The boiling part lasts about 37.6 minutes, nearly seven times longer. Why such a difference?
The particle model answers it. When ice melts, the particles only loosen. They are still touching, so most of the attraction is still there. When water boils, the particles are pulled completely apart: in steam they are about 12 times further apart than in water, as the last lecture showed. Almost all of the attraction must be overcome. Measurements show that boiling 1 kg of water needs about 2256 kJ of energy, while melting 1 kg of ice needs about 334 kJ (Engineering ToolBox data). 2256 ÷ 334 ≈ 6.8.
Try the curve yourself. Add energy to the ice and see what each kilojoule does.
Start with 1 kg of ice at −20 °C. Move the slider to add energy, in kilojoules (kJ). Watch the temperature, and what the ice is turning into. Notice which kilojoules raise the temperature and which do not.
Presets:
Energy needed for each stage, for 1 kg of water, starting as ice at −20 °C:
| Stage | Energy (kJ) | Temperature |
|---|---|---|
| Warm the ice, −20 °C to 0 °C | ≈ 42 | rises |
| Melt the ice at 0 °C | 334 | stays at 0 °C |
| Warm the water, 0 °C to 100 °C | ≈ 419 | rises |
| Boil the water at 100 °C | 2256 | stays at 100 °C |
| Warm the steam, 100 °C to 120 °C | ≈ 40 | rises |
More than four fifths of all the energy goes into the two changes of state, while the temperature stays still.
Notice how much of the slider leaves the temperature still. By the time all the water has boiled, about 84% of the energy has gone into the two flat parts. Changing state is where most of the energy goes.
Melting, evaporating, boiling and subliming take in energy, which pulls the particles further apart against their attraction.
Freezing, condensing and depositing give out energy, as the particles come closer together.
For a pure substance, the temperature stays constant during a change of state, until the change is complete.
Test the idea on a kitchen question.
A pan of water is boiling gently at 100 °C. You turn the heat up high. What happens to the temperature of the water?
Turning up the heat makes the water boil faster, but its temperature stays at 100 °C.
So turning the heat up high does not cook pasta any faster once the water is boiling. It only boils the water away sooner. Cooks save energy by turning the heat down to a gentle boil.
Evaporating is not the same as boiling
A puddle dries up on a day at 30 °C. It never reached 100 °C. So how did it become gas?
In any liquid, the particles move at many different speeds. Even in cool water, a few particles at the surface are moving fast enough to break free from the others and escape into the air. This is evaporating. It happens at any temperature, but only at the surface, and it is usually slow.
Boiling is different. At the boiling point, particles all through the liquid have enough energy to form bubbles of gas inside it. The bubbles rise and burst. Boiling happens only at the boiling point, and it is fast.
Evaporating has a useful side effect: it cools what is left. The particles that escape are the fastest ones. They take their energy with them, so the average speed of the particles left behind falls. This is why sweat cools you. Evaporating sweat at body temperature takes about 2428 kJ for every kilogram (OpenStax College Physics), and that energy comes from your skin.
A kettle is boiling, and a white cloud rises from its spout. A student says, "The white cloud is steam, and steam is a gas." Is that right?
Show the answer
Not quite. Water as a gas is invisible. Look closely at a boiling kettle: there is a clear gap just in front of the spout. That gap is the real gas, water vapour.
The white cloud forms a little further away, where the gas meets the cooler air. There it condenses into millions of tiny liquid droplets, and the droplets scatter light. So the cloud you see is liquid water, not gas. Clouds in the sky are the same: tiny droplets, not water vapour.
Giving energy back
Freezing, condensing and depositing run the tug of war the other way. As the particles come together, the attraction pulls them in and energy is given out to the surroundings.
- Condensing: water vapour in the air meets a cold glass and becomes droplets on the outside. The glass gets slightly warmer as it collects the energy.
- Freezing: the temperature of freezing water stays at 0 °C until all of it has frozen, because energy is given out the whole time.
- Depositing: on a cold, clear night, water vapour can turn straight into ice crystals on grass or car windows. This is frost.
Subliming is the reverse of depositing. Solid carbon dioxide, called dry ice, does not melt at normal air pressure. At about −78 °C it turns straight into gas. In very cold, dry places, snow can also slowly disappear without ever becoming water.
Melting and boiling points: a fingerprint
Every pure substance melts and boils at its own fixed temperatures. Pure water melts at 0 °C and boils at 100 °C at normal air pressure. Mercury melts at about −39 °C and boils at about 357 °C. These numbers are so reliable that chemists use them to identify a substance, and to check whether it is pure. A later lecture uses this to tell pure substances from mixtures.
There is one condition for boiling points: the air pressure. To boil, the particles must form bubbles that push back against the air above the liquid. Where the air pressure is lower, this is easier. On the top of Mount Everest, the pressure is about a third of normal, and water boils at about 71 °C.
Worked examples
A substance is heated steadily from −20 °C to 120 °C. Its heating curve has two flat parts, at 0 °C and at 100 °C. What are its melting and boiling points? What state is it in at 50 °C, and during each flat part?
Melting point. The first flat part: 0 °C. There, solid and liquid are both present.
Boiling point. The second flat part: 100 °C. There, liquid and gas are both present.
At 50 °C. Between the two flat parts, so it is all liquid.
Check. The second flat part is much longer than the first, as expected: boiling pulls the particles completely apart.
A test tube of liquid substance X (invented data) is left to cool in the air. Its temperature falls from 90 °C to 54 °C in 3 minutes. It then stays at 54 °C for 6 minutes, while crystals form. Then it falls again.
What is happening at 54 °C? X is freezing. Its freezing point, which is the same as its melting point, is 54 °C.
Why does the temperature stop falling, although the tube is still losing energy to the air? As X freezes, its particles settle into fixed places, and the attraction gives out energy. That energy replaces what the tube loses to the air. So the temperature stays still until all of X has frozen.
Check. A flat part on a cooling curve means a change of state that gives out energy, here freezing. ✓
A bottle taken from the fridge is soon covered in water droplets on the outside. Explain this with the particle model.
Where does the water come from? Not from inside the bottle. The air always contains some water as a gas, water vapour.
What happens at the surface? Water vapour particles hit the cold bottle and lose energy to it. They slow down. The attraction between them can now hold them together, so they gather into liquid droplets.
Name the change. Gas → liquid: condensing. It gives out energy, which slightly warms the bottle.
During melting and boiling, the energy goes into changing state, and the temperature stays still. The temperature rises only when no change of state is happening.
Evaporating happens at any temperature, at the surface. Boiling is the one that needs the boiling point, and it happens all through the liquid.
When water melts or boils, the water molecules stay whole: each is still H₂O. What is overcome are the forces of attraction between the molecules. Breaking the molecules themselves would be a chemical change, not a change of state.
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.
-
Name the change of state in each case, and say whether energy is taken in or given out: (a) frost forming on a car window; (b) butter softening into a liquid in a hot pan; (c) dew on grass in the early morning; (d) wet clothes drying on a line; (e) dry ice making a "smoke" on a stage; (f) water in an ice-cube tray in a freezer.
Hint 1
For each one, decide the starting state and the final state.
Hint 2
Further apart means energy taken in; closer together means energy given out.
Full answer
(a) Depositing, gas → solid: given out. (b) Melting: taken in. (c) Condensing, from water vapour in the air: given out. (d) Evaporating: taken in. (e) Subliming, solid CO₂ → gas: taken in. The visible "smoke" is water vapour in the air condensing into droplets, because the cold gas chills it. (f) Freezing: given out.
-
Mercury melts at about −39 °C and boils at about 357 °C. (a) What state is mercury in at room temperature, 25 °C? (b) Sketch its heating curve from −60 °C to 400 °C. (c) Melting 1 kg of mercury needs about 11.8 kJ, and boiling it needs about 272 kJ. Which flat part is longer, and by about how many times?
Hint 1
25 °C is between the melting and boiling points.
Hint 2
With steady heating, the length of each flat part is proportional to the energy it needs.
Full answer
(a) Liquid, because 25 °C is above its melting point and below its boiling point.
(b) Rising line from −60 °C to −39 °C, flat at −39 °C, rising to 357 °C, flat at 357 °C, then rising again.
(c) The boiling part, about 272 ÷ 11.8 ≈ 23 times longer. Boiling separates the particles completely, while melting only loosens them. (Values from OpenStax College Physics.)
-
Steam at 100 °C gives a much worse burn than the same mass of water at 100 °C. Use these numbers for 1 g of each, cooling to skin temperature (37 °C): condensing 1 g of steam gives out about 2.26 kJ; cooling 1 g of water from 100 °C to 37 °C gives out about 0.26 kJ. About how many times more energy does the steam give to your skin?
Hint 1
Steam first condenses into water at 100 °C, then that water cools.
Hint 2
Add the two amounts for the steam, then divide by the amount for the water.
Full answer
Steam: 2.26 + 0.26 = 2.52 kJ. Water: 0.26 kJ. Ratio: 2.52 ÷ 0.26 ≈ 9.7, so roughly 10 times as much energy.
Almost all of the extra comes from condensing, the energy given out when the particles come back together on your skin.
-
On the top of Mount Everest, water boils at about 71 °C. (a) Explain, using particles, why water boils at a lower temperature there. (b) A climber boils rice for the usual time, but it is still hard. Why? (c) A pressure cooker traps the gas so the pressure inside rises above normal. Predict what happens to the boiling point inside, and why rice cooks faster in one.
Hint 1
To boil, the particles must make bubbles that push back the air above the water.
Hint 2
Rice cooks faster in hotter water. What is the hottest that boiling water can be?
Full answer
(a) There is less air pressing on the water. The particles need less energy to form bubbles that can push back, so bubbles form at a lower temperature: about 71 °C.
(b) Boiling water there cannot be hotter than about 71 °C, because extra energy only boils it away faster. Rice cooks more slowly at 71 °C than at 100 °C, so it needs much longer.
(c) The higher pressure makes bubbles harder to form, so the boiling point rises above 100 °C. The water, and the rice in it, can be hotter, so the rice cooks faster.
The whole water cycle is changes of state powered by the Sun. Sunlight evaporates water from the oceans and leaves the salt behind. The vapour rises, cools and condenses into the droplets of clouds, then falls as rain or snow. Every rain shower is fresh water made from salt water, by evaporating and condensing.
People copy this to make fresh water. Boiling salt water and condensing the vapour, called distillation, gives pure water, because the salt does not evaporate. But it needs a huge amount of energy, the 2256 kJ per kilogram you met above. This is why many modern plants use other methods instead. Singapore's desalination plants, for example, push seawater through very fine membranes at high pressure, a method called reverse osmosis (PUB). The energy in a change of state is real, and engineers have to pay for every kilojoule.
- There are six changes of state: melting, freezing, evaporating or boiling, condensing, subliming and depositing.
- Changes that move particles further apart take in energy, and changes that bring them closer together give energy out.
- During a change of state, the energy goes into changing how the particles are held together, so the temperature stays constant until the change is complete.
- Boiling needs much more energy than melting, because it separates the particles completely, while melting only loosens them.
- Evaporating happens at any temperature at the surface of a liquid, while boiling happens throughout the liquid at the boiling point.
- Each pure substance has its own melting and boiling points, and the boiling point is lower when the air pressure is lower.