- Measuring length, mass and time
- Changing state
- Diffusion — particles spreading out
- Kinetic theory
Three puzzles from one glass of water
You can walk through air, but not through a wall. Water takes the shape of any cup you pour it into, but a stone keeps its own shape. You can squash the air in a bicycle pump, but you cannot squash the water in a full plastic bottle.
Here is a stranger fact. Boil one small spoonful of water, and the steam it makes would fill a large bottle. The water did not gain anything. Nothing was added. Yet the same water now takes up far more space.
You see these things every day, so they may not seem like puzzles. But try to explain them. "Solids are hard" and "gases are light" only describe what happens. They do not say why. This lecture gives one idea that explains all of them. It is called the particle model, and it is one of the most useful ideas in all of science.
Everything is made of particles
The particle model starts with one claim. Every substance is made of very tiny particles. Depending on the substance, the particles may be atoms, molecules or ions. In this lecture we simply call them particles.
How tiny? A water molecule is about 0.28 nanometres across, and a nanometre is one billionth of a metre. So about 36 million water molecules would fit side by side across the width of your fingernail, which is about 1 cm. You cannot see them with an ordinary microscope, which uses light. Special microscopes, invented in the 1980s, can now show the positions of single atoms.
The model then makes two more claims:
- The particles are always moving. They never stop completely.
- The particles attract each other. The pull is strong when they are close together and becomes very weak when they are far apart.
Every difference between a solid, a liquid and a gas comes from two things: how the particles are arranged, and how they move. Hold on to that. It is the whole lecture in one sentence.
Solids, liquids and gases, particle by particle
Solids
In a solid, the particles are packed tightly together, touching their neighbours, usually in a regular pattern. The attraction between them is strong enough to hold each particle in its place. They still move: each one vibrates about a fixed position, like a person shivering in one spot.
Because no particle can wander away from its place, a solid keeps its own shape. Because the particles are already touching, there is almost no space to squash them into. So a solid has a fixed shape and a fixed volume.
Liquids
In a liquid, the particles are still touching. They are almost as close together as in the solid. This surprises many students, so look at the diagram again. The difference is that the particles are not held in fixed places. They have enough energy to slide past each other, and the arrangement is random.
Because the particles can slide, a liquid flows and takes the shape of the bottom of its container. Because they are still touching, the volume stays the same, and a liquid is very hard to squash.
Gases
In a gas, the particles are far apart. In the air around you, they are on average about 10 times their own width away from each other. The particles move very fast in straight lines. At room temperature, a typical air molecule moves at about 500 m/s, faster than a passenger jet. It travels in a straight line until it hits another particle or the wall of its container, then bounces off in a new direction.
Because the particles are far apart and move freely, a gas has no fixed shape and no fixed volume. It spreads out to fill whatever container it is in. And because most of a gas is empty space, a gas is easy to squash.
Now see the three states move.
Choose a state, then press Play (or Step). Watch two things: where each particle can go, and how close it stays to its neighbours.
How the particles move in each state:
| State | Arrangement | Movement |
|---|---|---|
| Solid | Touching, regular pattern | Vibrate about fixed positions |
| Liquid | Touching, random | Slide past each other |
| Gas | Far apart, random | Fast, in straight lines between collisions |
In the solid, every particle shivered but stayed in its own place. In the liquid, the particles stayed in contact but kept changing neighbours, and the whole group sat in the bottom of the box. In the gas, the particles raced across the whole box. Notice that the gas box has a lid. Without one, the gas would escape. A liquid in an open cup stays put, because its particles hold each other close.
A tug of war inside every substance
Why does one substance end up as a solid, another as a liquid and another as a gas? Think of two things pulling against each other.
- Attraction pulls the particles together.
- Movement carries the particles apart. The more energy the particles have, the faster they move.
In a solid, attraction wins completely. The particles cannot escape their places, so they can only vibrate. In a liquid, the two are close to balanced. The particles move enough to slide past each other, but attraction still keeps them touching. This is why a liquid stays in an open cup. In a gas, movement wins. The particles move so fast that attraction cannot hold them together, and they fly apart until a wall stops them.
This tug of war explains what happens when you heat a substance. Heating gives the particles more energy, so movement starts to win. That is how a solid becomes a liquid, and a liquid becomes a gas. The next lecture follows these changes step by step.
Solid: particles touching, in a regular pattern, vibrating about fixed positions. Fixed shape, fixed volume.
Liquid: particles touching, randomly arranged, sliding past each other. No fixed shape, fixed volume.
Gas: particles far apart, randomly arranged, moving fast in all directions. No fixed shape, no fixed volume.
When ice melts, a student says: "The particles melt too. They become soft and spread out." Is that right?
Show the answer
No. The particles in ice and in liquid water are exactly the same water molecules. They do not melt, soften, grow or shrink. What changes is how they are arranged and how they move. In ice they vibrate in fixed places. In water they slide past each other.
A state of matter is a property of the whole group of particles, not of one particle. A single water molecule is not solid, liquid or gas.
The idea at work: squashing
Now test the model on the puzzles from the start.
Question. A substance has a fixed volume but no fixed shape. Its particles slide past each other. Which state is it in?
Use each clue in turn.
- Fixed volume: it is not a gas, because a gas fills its container.
- No fixed shape: it is not a solid, because a solid keeps its shape.
- Particles slide past each other: this is how liquid particles move.
Answer. A liquid. Check: all three clues agree. ✓
Question. Mei seals the end of one syringe full of air and another full of water. She pushes each plunger. Explain what happens.
The air. The plunger moves in a long way. Air is a gas, so its particles are far apart, with a lot of empty space between them. Pushing the plunger moves the particles closer together into that space.
The water. The plunger hardly moves at all. Water is a liquid, so its particles are already touching. There is no empty space to push them into.
Check. The explanation uses only the spacing of the particles, and it predicts the result both ways. ✓
Question. 1 g of water takes up about 1 cm³. When it boils, the steam it makes takes up about 1700 cm³ (at 100 °C and normal air pressure). Explain this with the particle model. On average, how much further apart are the steam particles?
Same particles. No particles are added or lost. The same water molecules are just spread through a much bigger space.
How much further apart? The volume grows about 1700 times. A cube that holds 1700 times as much is about 12 times as wide in each direction, because 12 × 12 × 12 = 1728. So the particles are, on average, about 12 times further apart than in the liquid.
Check. In the liquid, the particles touch. In the steam, they are about 12 particle-widths apart, so most of the steam is empty space, as the model says. ✓
Question. Dry sand can be poured, and it takes the shape of a bucket. Ravi says sand must be a liquid. Is he right?
Look closer. Each grain of sand is a tiny piece of rock. Each grain keeps its own shape, and you cannot pour a single grain into a new shape. So each grain is a solid.
Why it pours. The grains are not particles in the sense of this lecture. Each grain contains billions of billions of particles. The grains can roll over each other because they are separate lumps.
Answer. No. Sand is a solid broken into many small pieces. Check: poured sand makes a heap with sloping sides, while a liquid settles with a flat, level top. ✓
Sorting by the particle picture
Use the model to sort these descriptions. For each one, think about the particles first.
Put each card in the state it describes. Read the reason after each choice.
The cards, sorted:
- Solid: keeps the same shape in any container · particles vibrate about fixed positions · particles in a regular pattern.
- Liquid: can be poured, but cannot be squashed · particles touch but slide past each other · settles with a flat top in the bottom of a container.
- Gas: spreads out to fill the whole container · easy to squash into a smaller space · particles far apart, moving fast in straight lines.
They do move. They vibrate about fixed positions. What they cannot do is move from place to place. Particles are never completely still.
In a diagram, liquid particles must be touching, almost as close as in the solid. Only their arrangement is different: random instead of regular. If you draw gaps, you have drawn a gas.
Between gas particles there is nothing at all: empty space. Air is itself a gas, made of particles. Air cannot be "between" its own particles.
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.
-
Name the state of each, and give one particle reason: (a) cooking oil, (b) the helium inside a balloon, (c) a candle at room temperature.
Hint 1
Ask: does it keep its own shape? Does it keep its own volume?
Hint 2
The helium fills the whole balloon, whatever its shape.
Full answer
(a) Liquid: it pours and takes the shape of the bottle, because its particles touch but slide past each other.
(b) Gas: it fills the whole balloon, because its particles are far apart and move freely in all directions.
(c) Solid: it keeps its shape, because its particles vibrate about fixed positions.
-
Explain, using particles, why a lot of gas can be squeezed into a small metal cylinder, but you cannot do the same with water.
Hint 1
Compare the space between particles in each.
Hint 2
Squeezing can only remove empty space.
Full answer
Gas particles are far apart, with mostly empty space between them. Squeezing pushes them closer together, so many more particles fit in the same space. Water particles already touch, so there is no space left to remove, and the water cannot be squeezed into a smaller volume.
-
Kofi draws ice with particles touching in rows, liquid water with particles spread far apart, and steam with particles touching in a random heap. Find his two mistakes and correct them.
Hint 1
Which state should have particles touching but random?
Hint 2
Which state should have particles far apart?
Full answer
The ice is right. The liquid water is wrong: its particles should be touching, in a random arrangement. The steam is wrong: its particles should be far apart, with arrows showing fast movement in all directions. Kofi has swapped the spacings of the liquid and the gas.
-
In air, the particles are on average about 10 times their own width apart. Imagine each particle sitting inside its own small cube, 10 particle-widths on each side. Roughly what fraction of the cube does the particle itself fill? What does this tell you about a gas?
Hint 1
Treat the particle as a small cube 1 width on each side. How many of those fit in the big cube?
Hint 2
The big cube holds 10 × 10 × 10 small cubes.
Full answer
The big cube holds 10 × 10 × 10 = 1000 particle-sized cubes, and only one of them is the particle. So the particle fills roughly 1 part in 1000 of the space. (A round particle fills even a little less.)
This tells you that a gas is about 99.9% empty space. That is why gases are so easy to squash, and why you can walk through air but not through a wall.
If particles are too small to see, how do we know they exist and keep moving? One famous clue came in 1827. The Scottish botanist Robert Brown looked through a microscope at tiny particles released from pollen grains in water. They jiggled about all the time, even though the water was perfectly still. In 1905, Albert Einstein explained why: the visible specks are being knocked about by the invisible, moving water molecules all around them. From 1908, the French physicist Jean Perrin measured this movement carefully and showed that Einstein was right. He received the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1926. This jiggling is now called Brownian motion.
You can see the particle model at work in an ordinary kitchen. Take a cold drink from the fridge on a humid day, and drops of water appear on the outside. They came from the air. Water particles in the air, in the gas state, hit the cold surface, slow down, and cling together as a liquid. The next lecture is about exactly these changes: melting, boiling, freezing and condensing.
- All matter is made of tiny particles that are always moving and that attract each other when they are close.
- In a solid, the particles touch in a regular pattern and vibrate about fixed positions, so a solid has a fixed shape and a fixed volume.
- In a liquid, the particles still touch but are randomly arranged and slide past each other, so a liquid flows but keeps its volume.
- In a gas, the particles are far apart and move fast in straight lines, so a gas fills its container and is easy to squash.
- The particles themselves do not change between states; only their arrangement and movement change.
- Water expands about 1700 times when it boils, because the same particles end up about 12 times further apart.