- Physical and chemical changes
- Treating water · coming soon
- Chromatography in detail · coming soon
Three problems in one bucket
Someone spills sand into a bucket of seawater. Now there are three things in the bucket: sand, water and dissolved salt. Can you get each of them back, separately?
Getting the sand out is easy to imagine. Getting the salt out is harder, because you cannot see it. Getting pure water out, with no salt in it, is harder still. Each job needs a different method. The previous lecture promised to show how mixtures are separated. Here it is. And there is one idea behind every method, so you will not need to memorise a list.
That lecture also said that separating a mixture means working against diffusion. Particles mix themselves by random movement, all on their own. Unmixing never happens by itself. Every method in this lecture needs something extra: a barrier, or heat, or a moving solvent. That is why separating always takes effort.
The one idea behind every method
In a mixture, each substance keeps its own properties. So look for a property in which the substances differ, and use that difference to pull them apart. That is it. That is the whole idea.
- Size: sand grains are big; dissolved salt and water are single tiny particles. This is filtration.
- Whether it turns into a gas: water evaporates easily; salt does not. This is evaporation, and, if you want the water back, distillation.
- Boiling point: two liquids boil at different temperatures. This is distillation again.
- How far a solvent carries it: dissolved dyes travel up paper at different rates. This is chromatography.
None of these methods makes a new substance. They are physical changes. The salt that comes out is the same salt that went in.
Filtration: separating by size
Filter paper looks solid, but it is a mat of fibres with tiny holes between them. Pour sandy seawater into a funnel lined with filter paper. The water and everything dissolved in it pass through the holes. The sand grains are far too big, so they stay on the paper.
The solid trapped on the paper is called the residue. The liquid that comes through is the filtrate. Filtration works only for a solid that does not dissolve in the liquid. Such a solid is called insoluble.
The filtrate from sandy seawater is perfectly clear. Is it pure water?
Show the answer
No. It is clear salt water. When salt dissolves, it breaks up into particles far smaller than anything you can see. The holes in filter paper are roughly a hundredth of a millimetre across; the dissolved particles are tens of thousands of times smaller still. They pass through as easily as the water does. "Clear" means "nothing big enough to scatter the light". It does not mean "pure".
Evaporation and crystallisation: keeping the solid
To get the salt, heat the filtrate in an evaporating dish. The water turns into vapour and escapes into the air. The salt does not, so it is left behind as white crystals. This is evaporation. It works because the solid does not evaporate, and the liquid does.
Two cautions. First, near the end, heat gently. As the last water goes, the crystals can spit hot salt out of the dish. Second, some solids are spoiled by strong heat. Blue copper sulfate crystals contain water locked into the crystal itself. Heat them to dryness and that water is driven off, leaving a white powder. Sugar heated too strongly turns brown and burns.
For these, use crystallisation. Heat the solution only until it is saturated: so concentrated that it cannot hold any more solid. A simple test: dip a glass rod in and lift it out. If small crystals form on the rod as it cools, stop heating. Then leave the solution to cool slowly. Less solid can stay dissolved in cold water, so crystals grow out of the solution. Filter them off and dry them gently.
Distillation: getting the liquid back
Evaporation keeps the solid and loses the water into the air. To keep the water, you must catch its vapour and turn it back into a liquid. This is distillation.
Heat the salt water in a flask. Steam rises, passes the thermometer and enters the condenser: a tube surrounded by a jacket of flowing cold water. The steam gives out energy to the cold glass and condenses. Pure water drips into the collecting flask. This liquid is the distillate. The salt cannot evaporate, so it stays behind.
Every detail of the apparatus has a reason. The thermometer bulb sits at the entrance to the side arm, not in the liquid, because it must measure the temperature of the vapour that is leaving. For water, it reads 100 °C. The cold water enters the condenser at the bottom and leaves at the top, so the jacket stays completely full and the coldest water meets the vapour just before it leaves.
The thermometer also keeps a promise from the last lecture. A pure liquid boils at one fixed temperature. While pure water is distilling, the reading stays steady at 100 °C. If the reading starts to change, something else is starting to come over.
Distillation can also separate two liquids, if their boiling points are far enough apart. The liquid with the lower boiling point evaporates more and reaches the condenser first. As a rough guide, simple distillation works well when the boiling points differ by more than about 25 °C.
For liquids closer than that, use fractional distillation. A tall fractionating column, packed with glass beads or rings, is added above the flask. The rising vapour condenses and evaporates again many times on the way up. Each time, the vapour gets richer in the liquid with the lower boiling point. By the top, it is almost pure. Oil refineries use giant columns like this to split crude oil into petrol, diesel and other fractions.
Fractional distillation has limits. Ethanol boils at about 78 °C and water at 100 °C. But a mixture of about 96% ethanol and 4% water boils at 78.2 °C, as if it were one substance. So distillation alone can never take ethanol beyond about 96% pure.
Chromatography: separating colours
Some mixtures contain several dissolved substances, such as the dyes in a black ink. Filtration cannot separate them, because they are all dissolved. Distillation cannot either, because none of them boils away. Paper chromatography can.
Draw a pencil line about 1.5 cm from the bottom of a strip of chromatography paper. This is the start line. Put a small spot of ink on it. Stand the paper in a beaker with a little solvent, such as water, below the line. The solvent soaks up the paper and carries the dyes with it.
Each dye is pulled two ways. It dissolves in the moving solvent, which carries it up. It also sticks to the paper, which holds it back. A dye that dissolves well and sticks weakly travels far. A dye that sticks strongly stays near the start. So the dyes spread out into separate spots.
When the solvent has nearly reached the top, take the paper out and mark how far the solvent got. This line is the solvent front. Then compare each spot with the front.
Both distances are measured from the start line, to the centre of the spot. Rf has no unit and is always less than 1. For one substance, with the same solvent and paper, it is always the same.
Why use a ratio, and not just the distance? Because the distance depends on how long you wait. The ratio does not. Try it below.
Ink X and three known dyes (A, B and C, all invented) are spotted on the start line. Move the slider to let the solvent rise. Watch the distances, and watch the Rf values. Which dyes are in ink X?
Solvent front: 4.0 cm
The chromatogram after the solvent front has moved 10.0 cm. Ink X has split into a blue spot and a yellow spot. They are level with dye A and dye B, so ink X contains A and B, and not C.
As the solvent rose, every spot moved further. But the Rf values never changed: 0.75, 0.25 and 0.5 at every moment. That is why Rf can identify a substance. Ink X split into a blue spot and a yellow spot, level with dyes A and B. So ink X is a mixture of A and B. A pure substance gives only one spot.
Choosing the method
You now have four methods. The skill that matters most is choosing between them. For each job below, ask the question from the start of the lecture: in which property do the parts differ?
Choose a job, then the method that does it. Read the reason after each choice.
Nine jobs, each matched to the method that uses the right difference between the parts.
- Filtration: sand from sandy seawater; chalk powder from water; tea leaves from tea.
- Evaporation or crystallisation: solid salt from seawater; copper sulfate crystals from its solution.
- Distillation: pure water from seawater (simple); ethanol from a mixture with water (fractional).
- Chromatography: the dyes in a black ink; checking whether a food colouring is one dye.
Every card was decided by the same question. Insoluble and big: filtration. Dissolved, and you want the solid: evaporation or crystallisation. You want the liquid back: distillation. Several dissolved coloured substances: chromatography. Real problems often need two or three methods in a row, as the worked examples show.
Worked examples
A student has a mixture of copper sulfate crystals (which dissolve in water) and sand (which does not). How can she get pure copper sulfate crystals?
Step 1. Add warm water and stir. The copper sulfate dissolves; the sand does not.
Step 2. Filter. The sand is the residue. The blue copper sulfate solution is the filtrate.
Step 3. Heat the filtrate gently until it is saturated (the glass-rod test). Do not heat to dryness, or the blue crystals will turn into white powder.
Step 4. Leave it to cool. Filter off the crystals and dry them between filter papers.
Check. Each step used one difference: solubility (steps 1–2), then that water evaporates and copper sulfate does not (steps 3–4) ✓.
In a chromatography experiment, the solvent front moves 12.0 cm from the start line. A blue spot moves 9.0 cm. A reference table (invented) gives Rf = 0.75 for a dye called P in this solvent. Could the blue spot be dye P?
Rf = 9.0 ÷ 12.0 = 0.75. This matches dye P, so the blue spot could be P.
"Could be", not "is". Two different dyes can have the same Rf in one solvent. To be more certain, run the test again with a different solvent and check that the two still match.
Check. 0.75 × 12.0 = 9.0 ✓. And 0.75 is less than 1 ✓.
Back to the bucket of sandy seawater. How can you get dry sand, pure water and solid salt?
Step 1. Filter. The sand is the residue; rinse it with a little pure water and let it dry.
Step 2. Distil the filtrate. Pure water collects as the distillate.
Step 3. Keep heating the flask gently. When the water has gone, the salt is left in the flask.
Why distil instead of evaporating? Evaporation would give the salt but lose the water into the air. Distillation gives both.
Check. Three substances, three differences used: size, then whether each part evaporates ✓.
Filtration cannot remove a dissolved substance. Dissolved particles are far smaller than the holes in the paper. A clear filtrate can still contain salt, sugar or dye.
Strong heating spoils crystals that contain water, such as copper sulfate, and burns substances such as sugar. Heat only until the solution is saturated, then let it cool.
Draw the start line in pencil, because ink would dissolve and run. Keep the solvent below the start line, or the spots will dissolve into the solvent in the beaker instead of travelling up the paper.
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.
-
Choose a method for each job, and name the difference it uses. (a) Clear water from muddy river water. (b) Sugar crystals from sugar solution. (c) Petrol from crude oil. (d) Checking whether a drink contains a banned food colouring.
Hint 1
For each, ask: is the thing I want dissolved or not? Is it a liquid I want back?
Hint 2
Mud does not dissolve. Sugar burns if heated strongly. Crude oil is a mixture of liquids with boiling points close together.
Full answer
(a) Filtration, by size: the mud is insoluble. The water is clear but not pure; dissolved substances remain. (b) Crystallisation, because water evaporates and sugar does not; heat only to saturation, because sugar burns. (c) Fractional distillation, by boiling point; the liquids in crude oil boil at temperatures close together. (d) Chromatography: compare the drink's spots, and their Rf values, with a spot of the banned colouring. Check: each answer names one property in which the parts differ ✓.
-
The solvent front moves 8.0 cm. An ink gives two spots, at 2.0 cm and 5.6 cm from the start line. (a) Find both Rf values. (b) Dye M has Rf 0.70 in this solvent. Could the ink contain dye M?
Hint 1
Divide each spot's distance by the front's distance.
Hint 2
2.0 ÷ 8.0 is a quarter.
Full answer
(a) 2.0 ÷ 8.0 = 0.25 and 5.6 ÷ 8.0 = 0.70. (b) Yes, the second spot matches dye M. It could be M; a second solvent would make the match more certain. Check: 0.25 × 8.0 = 2.0 and 0.70 × 8.0 = 5.6 ✓.
-
A mixture contains sand, salt and iron filings. Plan how to get all three back, separately and dry.
Hint 1
One of the three is attracted to a magnet.
Hint 2
After the iron is out, the problem is the bucket problem again.
Full answer
1. Pass a magnet (wrapped in paper or plastic) over the dry mixture to pull out the iron filings. 2. Add water and stir to dissolve the salt. 3. Filter: sand is the residue; rinse and dry it. 4. Evaporate the filtrate to get the salt (or distil it, to keep the water too). Check: each step uses one difference: magnetism, solubility, size, then whether the part evaporates ✓.
-
Two dyes, P and Q, both have Rf 0.40 when the solvent is water. With ethanol as the solvent, P has Rf 0.30 and Q has Rf 0.65. (a) In water, the front moves 9.0 cm. Where are the spots? (b) In ethanol, the front also moves 9.0 cm. Where are the spots now, and how far apart are they? (c) What does this tell you about identifying a dye with one solvent?
Hint 1
Rearrange: distance moved by the substance = Rf × distance moved by the front.
Hint 2
0.40 × 9.0, then 0.30 × 9.0 and 0.65 × 9.0.
Full answer
(a) Both at 0.40 × 9.0 = 3.6 cm, on top of each other; they look like one spot. (b) P at 0.30 × 9.0 = 2.7 cm and Q at 0.65 × 9.0 = 5.85 cm, about 5.9 cm. They are 3.15 cm apart, about 3.2 cm. (c) One matching Rf value shows only that a dye could be the reference dye. A second solvent can separate dyes that the first one could not, and a real match must hold in both. Check: 5.85 − 2.7 = 3.15 ✓.
Chromatography began with leaves. Around 1900, the botanist Mikhail Tsvet poured an extract of green leaves through a glass tube packed with chalk powder. The pigments stuck to the chalk by different amounts and spread into coloured bands. In 1906 he named the method from the Greek for "colour writing". Today, chromatography with machines instead of paper is used to test medicines, check food for harmful substances, and find drugs in a blood sample, most of which have no colour at all.
The same ideas are used to make drinking water from the sea, but the choice of method has changed. For a long time, most of this water came from huge distillation plants. Today about 69% of the world's capacity uses a different idea: pushing seawater at high pressure through a membrane whose holes let water molecules through and hold the dissolved salt back. It is a kind of filtration at the level of single particles, and it uses much less energy than boiling the sea.
- Every separation method uses a physical property in which the substances in a mixture differ, and no new substance is made.
- Filtration separates an insoluble solid from a liquid by size: the solid is the residue and the liquid is the filtrate.
- Evaporation keeps a dissolved solid, and crystallisation does this gently for solids that strong heat would spoil.
- Distillation evaporates a liquid and condenses it again, so the liquid is collected; fractional distillation separates liquids with close boiling points.
- In paper chromatography, dissolved substances travel different distances, and the Rf value, distance moved by the substance divided by distance moved by the solvent front, identifies them.