MathemagiciansLibraryExplorationsDeep Dives
← Chemistry · Lower Secondary
ChemistryLower Secondary

Physical vs chemical changes — reversible vs not

LSC1.3 — Physical and Chemical ChangesLecture 1 of 1~2150 words

Two ways to destroy a piece of paper

Take a sheet of paper and tear it into small pieces. Now take a second sheet and burn it. In both cases the sheet is gone. You cannot write on either of them any more.

But something very different has happened. The torn pieces are still paper. You could glue them back, or soak and press them into a new sheet. The burnt sheet has become ash, smoke and invisible gases. There is no paper left at all, only new substances that were not there before.

That difference is one of the most important ideas in chemistry. Many books describe it as "reversible or not". That is a useful clue, but this lecture will show that it is not the real test. The real test is one question: has a new substance been made?

One question decides it

Physical and chemical changes

A physical change changes the form, shape or state of a substance, but no new substance is made.

A chemical change, also called a chemical reaction, makes one or more new substances, with different properties from the substances you started with.

You have met both already. Melting, boiling and freezing are physical changes. So are dissolving and every separation method: filtration, evaporation, distillation and chromatography change how substances are mixed, but each substance stays itself. When iron and sulfur were heated together, the mixture glowed and became iron sulfide, a new substance that a magnet cannot pull. That was a chemical change.

The particle model shows why the two are so different.

Physical change: ice meltingIce (solid)Water (liquid)16 water molecules before, the same 16 afterChemical change: carbon burningCarbon + oxygenCarbon dioxidecarbon atomoxygen atom
Top: when ice melts, each water molecule stays whole; only the arrangement and spacing change. Bottom: when carbon burns, carbon atoms and oxygen molecules break apart and rejoin as carbon dioxide molecules, which are new particles. The atoms are the same atoms, rearranged.

In a physical change, the particles themselves do not change. When ice melts, energy pulls the water molecules a little further apart, so they can slide past each other. But every molecule is still a water molecule: two hydrogen atoms joined to one oxygen atom. As the lecture on changing state said, breaking the molecules themselves would be a chemical change, not a change of state.

In a chemical change, the atoms are rearranged. The joins between atoms break, and new joins form, so the particles at the end are different particles. That is why the products have new properties. Carbon is a black solid and oxygen is a gas that keeps things burning. Carbon dioxide is a colourless gas that puts flames out.

Notice one more thing in the pictures. In both changes, no atom appears and no atom disappears. In the chemical change, the four carbon atoms and eight oxygen atoms on the left are all still there on the right, in new molecules. This is why the total mass stays the same in every change, physical or chemical, as long as nothing escapes or enters.

The clues that a reaction has happened

You usually cannot see molecules. So how can you tell when a new substance has formed? Chemists look for clues:

Every one of these is a clue, not a proof. Water boiling in a kettle bubbles, but the bubbles are water vapour, so no new substance has formed. Some substances get very cold when they dissolve, with no reaction at all. Copper sulfate crystals turn water blue when they dissolve, but the copper sulfate is still copper sulfate. So use the clues together, and always come back to the one question: is there a new substance?

Stop and think

When you open a bottle of fizzy drink, it bubbles. When you drop a piece of zinc into dilute hydrochloric acid, it also bubbles. Are both chemical changes?

Show the answer

No. The fizzy drink contains carbon dioxide that was dissolved under pressure. Opening the bottle lets the gas come out of solution again. Nothing new forms, so it is a physical change. The zinc is different: it slowly disappears, the acid warms up, and the gas is hydrogen, which was not there before. Zinc chloride forms in the solution. New substances mean a chemical change. The bubbles look the same; what they are made of is not.

Reversible is a clue, not the rule

Most physical changes are easy to reverse: freeze the water, evaporate the salt solution. Most chemical changes are hard to reverse: you cannot unburn paper. That is why "reversible or not" is a good first guess. But it is not the definition, and it fails in both directions.

Some physical changes are very hard to reverse. A dropped glass shatters into pieces, but every piece is still glass. No new substance has formed, so this is a physical change, even though you cannot put the glass back together.

Some chemical changes can be reversed. Blue copper sulfate crystals contain water locked inside the crystal. If you heat them, the water is driven off as steam, and a white powder is left. This white powder is a different substance, called anhydrous copper sulfate ("anhydrous" means "without water"). Now let it cool, and add a few drops of water. What do you think will happen?

Predict, then reveal — water on white copper sulfate

A spatula of cooled white anhydrous copper sulfate is in a dish. You add a few drops of water. Choose what you think happens.

When a few drops of water are added to cooled white anhydrous copper sulfate, the powder turns blue again where the water lands, and it becomes hot. Hydrated copper sulfate has formed again. This reaction is reversible: heat drives the water off, and water added back reverses it.

The powder turns blue and gets hot. Heating made a new substance, and adding water made the first substance again. Both directions are chemical changes, and together they form a reversible reaction. Chemists even use the colour change as a test for water: if a liquid turns white anhydrous copper sulfate blue, it contains water.

That is it. That is the whole idea. Reversibility, colour, bubbles and heat are all clues. The new substance is the test.

Energy: both kinds of change need it

You may read that physical changes involve "no real energy change". That is not true. Melting 1 kg of ice at 0 °C takes 334 kJ of energy. Boiling away 1 kg of water at 100 °C takes 2256 kJ, about seven times as much. These are large amounts of energy, and melting and boiling are physical changes. So a change of temperature or a flow of energy alone cannot tell you which kind of change you are watching.

Chemical changes always involve energy too, because joins between atoms break and new joins form. A reaction that gives out energy to its surroundings, so they get warmer, is called exothermic: burning and zinc in acid are examples. A reaction that takes in energy from its surroundings, so they get colder, is called endothermic. Heating blue copper sulfate is endothermic: it only happens while you keep heating. Plants also take in energy, from sunlight, to make sugar in photosynthesis. The reverse direction of a reversible reaction always has the opposite energy change, which is why the white powder gets hot when water is added.

Now use the one question on some everyday changes.

Sorter — physical or chemical?

Put each change in the right box. Read the reason that appears.

Nine everyday changes, sorted with the reason for each.

  • Physical: Butter melting in a hot pan. Solid butter becomes liquid butter. Cool it and it sets again: same substance.
  • Chemical: Toast turning black under a grill. The black layer is mostly carbon, a new substance. It will not turn back into bread.
  • Chemical: An iron gate going rusty. Rust is a new substance made from iron, oxygen and water.
  • Physical: Sugar dissolving in tea. The sugar is still sugar, spread through the water. Evaporate the water and it comes back.
  • Chemical: Milk going sour. Bacteria turn the milk's sugar into lactic acid, a new substance with a new taste.
  • Physical: Water boiling in a kettle. Steam is still water. The bubbles are water vapour, not a new gas.
  • Physical: A glass bottle shattering. The pieces are still glass. It cannot be undone easily, but no new substance has formed.
  • Chemical: A firework exploding. Burning makes new substances, with light, heat and smoke.
  • Physical: Salt water evaporating to leave salt. Both the water and the salt keep their identity; they only separate.

The shattered bottle and the boiling kettle are the ones that catch people. One cannot be undone; the other bubbles. Both are physical, because no new substance forms.

Worked examples

Worked Example 1 — Classify and give a reason

Classify each change as physical or chemical, with a reason. (a) Ice melting. (b) Magnesium ribbon burning in air with a bright white flame, leaving a white powder. (c) Salt dissolving in water. (d) An egg being fried.

(a) Physical. The water molecules stay whole; only their arrangement changes. Freezing gives ice back.

(b) Chemical. A new substance, magnesium oxide, forms. The magnesium atoms have joined with oxygen atoms from the air. There is light and heat, and you cannot get the shiny metal back by cooling.

(c) Physical. The salt spreads out through the water but is still salt. Evaporating the water gives the salt back, unchanged.

(d) Chemical. The clear, runny egg white becomes white and solid, because the substances in it change. Cooling the egg does not make it runny again, and it tastes and smells different.

Check. Each answer is decided by "new substance or not", and the clues only support it ✓.

Worked Example 2 — Reading the clues

A student adds zinc to dilute hydrochloric acid. She sees bubbles forming on the zinc, the test tube getting warmer, and the zinc slowly disappearing. Give three pieces of evidence that a chemical change has taken place.

1. Bubbles: a gas is being made. It is hydrogen, which was not present before.

2. Warming: energy is given out, so the reaction is exothermic.

3. The zinc disappearing: the zinc is being used up to make a new substance, zinc chloride, which stays dissolved in the solution.

Check. Each clue alone could fool you (boiling also bubbles). Together, and with a gas that is a new substance, they show a reaction ✓.

Worked Example 3 — Where does the extra mass come from?

(a) 50 g of ice melts. What is the mass of the water? (b) 2.4 g of magnesium ribbon is burned in air, and all of it becomes magnesium oxide. The white powder has a mass of about 4.0 g. Has mass been created?

(a) 50 g. In a physical change, the same particles are still there.

(b) No. The extra 4.0 − 2.4 = 1.6 g is oxygen from the air. The oxygen atoms joined with the magnesium atoms, so they are now part of the powder. If the magnesium were burned in a closed container, the total mass of everything inside would not change.

Check. 2.4 g of magnesium + 1.6 g of oxygen = 4.0 g of magnesium oxide ✓. Atoms are rearranged in a chemical change, never created or destroyed.

Trap 1 — "It disappeared, so it reacted"

When salt or sugar dissolves, the solid seems to vanish. It has not reacted: its particles have spread out among the water particles. Evaporate the water and you get the same salt back. Disappearing from sight is not the same as becoming a new substance.

Trap 2 — "It can be reversed, so it is physical"

Blue copper sulfate can be turned white by heating and blue again with water. But both steps make new substances. A shattered glass cannot be put back, but it is still glass. Decide by the new substance, then use reversibility only as supporting evidence.

Trap 3 — One clue taken as proof

Bubbles, colour changes and temperature changes can all happen without a reaction. Boiling bubbles. Some salts get cold as they dissolve. Coloured crystals colour the water they dissolve in. Use the clues together, and name the new substance if you can.

Try it yourself

Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.

  1. Classify each as a physical or chemical change, and give a reason. (a) Chocolate melting in your hand. (b) Bread dough rising as yeast makes carbon dioxide. (c) Wax melting near the flame of a candle. (d) Wax burning at the wick of the same candle.

    Hint 1

    For each, ask: is there a substance at the end that was not there at the start?

    Hint 2

    A candle shows both kinds of change at the same time.

    Full answer

    (a) Physical: it is still chocolate, and it sets again when cooled. (b) Chemical: yeast turns sugar into new substances, including carbon dioxide gas, which makes the bubbles. (c) Physical: liquid wax is still wax, and it hardens again as it drips down. (d) Chemical: burning wax makes carbon dioxide and water vapour, with heat and light. Check: (c) and (d) happen in the same candle, so one object can show both kinds of change ✓.

  2. A student mixes vinegar with baking soda. The mixture fizzes strongly, and the beaker feels colder. (a) Is this a physical or chemical change? Give two pieces of evidence. (b) Is the change exothermic or endothermic? (c) The gas turns limewater milky. What is it?

    Hint 1

    Look for the clues in the list: gas, temperature, colour, precipitate.

    Hint 2

    If the beaker gets colder, energy is moving from the surroundings into the reacting mixture.

    Full answer

    (a) Chemical: a gas is given off that was not there before, and there is a temperature change. Together these point to new substances. (b) Endothermic: the mixture takes in energy from its surroundings, so the beaker feels cold. (c) Carbon dioxide: turning limewater milky is the test for carbon dioxide. Check: the gas is a new substance, which is the deciding point ✓.

  3. Using the values in this lecture, find the energy needed (a) to melt 2.5 kg of ice at 0 °C, and (b) to boil away 0.5 kg of water at 100 °C. (c) Explain why these answers show that "physical changes involve no energy change" is false.

    Hint 1

    Melting needs 334 kJ for each kilogram; boiling needs 2256 kJ for each kilogram.

    Hint 2

    Multiply the energy per kilogram by the number of kilograms.

    Full answer

    (a) 2.5 × 334 = 835 kJ. (b) 0.5 × 2256 = 1128 kJ. (c) Melting and boiling make no new substance, so they are physical changes. Yet each needs a large amount of energy, so energy alone cannot separate physical from chemical changes. Check: half a kilogram boiled needs more energy than 2.5 kg melted, because boiling needs about seven times as much per kilogram (2256 ÷ 334 ≈ 6.8) ✓.

  4. Two powders are heated in turn. P is white: it turns yellow while hot, and white again when it cools; its mass does not change. Q is green: it turns black, a gas comes off that turns limewater milky, and 1.24 g of Q leaves 0.80 g of black powder that stays black. (a) Which powder shows a chemical change? Give three pieces of evidence. (b) Which shows a physical change? Explain why its colour change does not count as a reaction. (c) Where did the missing 0.44 g of Q go?

    Hint 1

    For each powder, ask whether a new substance is made, and whether anything leaves.

    Hint 2

    A colour that comes and goes with temperature, with no change of mass, means the same substance is still there.

    Full answer

    (a) Q: a new gas forms (it turns limewater milky, so it is carbon dioxide), a new black solid forms that stays black when cool, and the mass of solid falls. (b) P: its colour changes back when it cools and its mass stays the same, so the same substance is present before and after. The colour depends on temperature, not on a new substance. (P behaves like zinc oxide, and Q like copper carbonate.) (c) 1.24 − 0.80 = 0.44 g left as carbon dioxide gas, which escaped into the air. Check: mass was not destroyed: 0.80 g of solid + 0.44 g of gas = 1.24 g ✓.

The bigger idea

Rusting is a chemical change that never stops. Iron reacts slowly with oxygen and water from the air to make rust, which is hydrated iron(III) oxide. Rust is a new substance: brown, crumbly and weak, where iron was grey and strong. It cannot be turned back into iron by drying or cooling it.

This one reaction is very expensive. A 2016 study by NACE International, the corrosion engineers' society, estimated the world's yearly cost of corrosion at about US$2.5 trillion, roughly 3.4% of world GDP. Where the air is warm and damp, rusting is faster. In Singapore, for example, the mean relative humidity at the Changi climate station is around 80%. So steel structures there are protected all the time: coated with zinc (galvanised), painted, or connected to a more reactive metal that corrodes in their place.

Every one of those methods works in the same way: it stops a chemical change by keeping iron away from oxygen and water. Ask "is a new substance forming, and what is it made from?". Then you can understand why things rust, burn, rot or cook, and how to stop or speed them up. That question is where the whole of chemistry begins.

Key concepts in this lesson