MathemagiciansLibraryExplorationsDeep Dives
← Chemistry · Lower Secondary
ChemistryLower Secondary

Diffusion — particles spreading out

LSC1.1 — States of MatterLecture 3 of 3~2080 words

A puzzle about speed

The first lecture in this topic said that air particles move at about 500 metres per second. That is faster than a passenger jet.

Now someone opens a box of hot food at the back of a classroom, 10 metres away. At 500 metres per second, a particle could cross the room in two hundredths of a second. But the smell takes several seconds to reach you. And if the air in the room were perfectly still, with no draught at all, it would take weeks.

So the particles are fast, but the spreading is slow. Something slows the journey down. To find out what, we need one new idea: diffusion. The idea itself is simple. The surprise is in how slow it is, and why. Spend your time there.

What diffusion is

Put a few drops of purple dye at the bottom of a beaker of still water. At first, the purple particles are crowded in one place. Elsewhere, there are none. We say the dye has a high concentration in one place and a low concentration elsewhere. Concentration means how crowded the particles of a substance are in a space.

Leave the beaker alone. Slowly, the purple spreads, until the whole beaker is the same pale colour. This spreading is diffusion.

Diffusion

Diffusion is the net movement of particles from a place where they are more concentrated to a place where they are less concentrated, caused by their random movement.

It continues until the particles are spread evenly.

Two words in that box carry the whole idea: random and net.

Why it happens: a numbers game

The particle model says particles are always moving. In a gas or a liquid, each particle moves in a random direction, and changes direction every time it collides with another particle. It has no idea where the other dye particles are. It does not "want" to go anywhere.

So how can random movement produce spreading in one direction? Imagine an invisible line across the beaker. On the left, there are 50 dye particles. On the right, there are 10. In the next moment, suppose each particle has the same small chance of crossing the line. Then about five times as many particles cross from left to right as cross from right to left. Particles still cross both ways. But more go one way than the other.

The difference between the two is the net movement. It is from crowded to less crowded, simply because there are more particles on the crowded side to make the crossing.

That is it. That is the whole idea. No particle chooses to spread out. More particles happen to leave the crowded side, because more particles are there.

Watch it happen. Each dot below moves in a random direction at every step.

Simulation — random moves, net spreading

60 dye particles start in the left part of a box of still water. Press Play. Watch the counts in the five strips, and the crossings of the middle line in each direction. Then try it hot.

Temperature:

One run of the same model: 60 dye particles start in the left fifth of a box and move randomly. The table shows how many are in each fifth of the box after different numbers of steps.

StepsStrip 1 (left)Strip 2Strip 3Strip 4Strip 5 (right)
0600000
504515000
2004410510
8001721985

The particles never stop moving, and some move back to the left at every stage. But the counts creep towards 12 in each strip, the even spread.

Did you see both kinds of crossing? Particles crossed the middle line in both directions all the time. The net movement was to the right only because more particles started on the left. With the hot setting, each particle moves further in each step, so the spreading is faster.

Stop and think

After a long time, the dye is spread evenly through the whole box. Have the particles stopped moving?

Show the answer

No. They move exactly as fast as before. What has stopped is the net movement. With equal numbers on both sides, about as many particles cross from left to right as from right to left. The two flows cancel, so the colour stays even.

So diffusion does not "finish" because the particles stop. It stops changing anything, because the random crossings now balance.

Why it is slow: the zig-zag path

Back to the puzzle. In air at room temperature, gas particles are about 10 particle-widths apart, as the first lecture showed. A particle travels only a tiny distance, much less than a thousandth of a millimetre, before it hits another particle and goes off in a new direction. Each second, it makes billions of these collisions.

So its path is not a straight line across the room. It is a zig-zag in every direction, going back on itself again and again. This is called a random walk. The particle covers a huge total distance, but its overall progress away from the start is small.

A random walk has a strange property. To get twice as far from the start takes about four times as long, not twice as long. Ten times as far takes about a hundred times as long. So diffusion is very fast over tiny distances and very slow over large ones.

DistanceRough time by diffusion alone, in still airRough time by diffusion alone, in still water
1 mma twentieth of a secondabout 8 minutes
1 cmabout 5 secondsabout 14 hours
10 cmabout 8 minutesabout 2 months
1 mabout 14 hours—

These are estimates for small particles, and real values vary from one substance to another. But they solve the puzzle. If diffusion alone carried a smell across a room, it would take days or weeks. In a real room, the air is always moving a little, in draughts and in warm air rising. These currents carry the smell across the room in seconds. Diffusion does only the last, short part of the journey. The same is true for the purple dye. If a beaker turns evenly purple within minutes, small currents in the water have done most of the mixing. In truly still water, it would take days.

Do not confuse a random walk with Brownian motion. Brownian motion is the jiggling of a visible speck, such as a smoke particle or a pollen grain, as invisible particles hit it from all sides. The first lecture used it as evidence that particles move. A random walk is the path of any single particle, visible or not.

Gases, liquids and temperature

Diffusion in a liquid is roughly ten thousand times slower than in a gas. The reason is in the particle model. In a liquid, the particles are touching. A dye particle can hardly move at all before it bumps into a neighbour. Each step of its random walk is tiny, so its progress is far slower. In a solid, the particles only vibrate about fixed positions, so diffusion is slower still. It is extremely slow, but not quite zero.

Temperature matters too. At a higher temperature, particles move faster. Each step of the random walk is quicker, so diffusion is faster. Hot tea takes colour from a tea bag much faster than cold water does.

Heavy and light particles

At the same temperature, lighter particles move faster than heavier ones. So lighter particles diffuse faster. A classic experiment shows this.

A long glass tube has cotton wool soaked in ammonia solution at one end and cotton wool soaked in hydrochloric acid at the other. Ammonia gas spreads from one end, and hydrogen chloride gas from the other. Where they meet, they react to make a white solid, ammonium chloride, which forms a ring on the glass. Predict where the ring appears.

Predict — where does the white ring form?

An ammonia particle (NH₃) has a relative mass of 17. A hydrogen chloride particle (HCl) has a relative mass of 36.5. Both ends are opened at the same moment. Where does the white ring form?

The white ring forms nearer the hydrochloric acid end, because the lighter ammonia particles diffuse faster and travel further in the same time.

ammoniahydrochloric acidwhite ring of ammonium chloridedashed line: the middle of the tube
The ring forms closer to the hydrochloric acid end. The ammonia particles, which are lighter, have travelled further in the same time.

The ring takes several minutes to appear, even in a tube less than a metre long, because both gases are random-walking through the air in the tube. That is diffusion's slowness again.

Worked examples

Worked Example 1 — Bromine rises

A gas jar of brown bromine gas is placed under an upside-down gas jar of air, with a cover between them. The cover is removed. After many minutes, both jars are the same pale brown. (a) Bromine is much denser than air. Why does it still spread upwards? (b) Why does it take many minutes, not a split second?

(a) Every bromine particle moves randomly, up as often as down. At the start, there are many bromine particles in the bottom jar and none in the top jar. So more bromine particles cross upwards than downwards. The net movement is upwards, even though bromine is denser. Diffusion depends on the difference in concentration, not on which way is "up".

(b) Each bromine particle collides with air particles billions of times a second, and its path is a zig-zag random walk. Its overall progress up the jar is far slower than its speed between collisions. A gas jar is many centimetres tall, and diffusion alone takes many minutes over that distance.

Check. The colour ends up even, not darker at the bottom. Once spread out, the bromine stays mixed, because random movement keeps the two flows balanced.

Worked Example 2 — Hot and cold water

Amira (an invented student) puts one drop of food colouring into a beaker of water at 10 °C, and an identical drop into a beaker at 70 °C. The colour spreads evenly in the hot water about three times faster. Explain this using the particle model.

Particles. At 70 °C, the water particles and the colouring particles move faster than at 10 °C.

Random walk. Each colouring particle makes its zig-zag steps more quickly, so it gets further from the drop in the same time.

Result. The net spreading from high to low concentration happens faster, so the hot beaker becomes evenly coloured first.

Honest note. In a real beaker, the hot water also has stronger currents, as warm water rises and cooler water sinks. These currents help the mixing too. A fair test would try to keep the water as still as possible.

Worked Example 3 — The square rule

In still air, a gas spreads about 1 cm by diffusion in roughly 5 seconds. Roughly how long does it take to spread 10 cm? And 1 m?

10 cm. That is 10 times the distance, so about 10 × 10 = 100 times the time: about 500 seconds, roughly 8 minutes.

1 m. That is 100 times the distance, so about 100 × 100 = 10 000 times the time: about 50 000 seconds, roughly 14 hours.

Check. The answers match the table above. They show why diffusion alone cannot explain a smell crossing a room in seconds.

Trap 1 — "Particles want to spread out"

Particles have no wishes, and they are not attracted to empty space. Each one moves randomly. Spreading happens because more particles leave a crowded place than arrive in it.

Trap 2 — "Diffusion stops when the particles stop"

When the concentration is even, the particles are still moving as fast as ever. Only the net movement has stopped, because the flows in both directions are now equal.

Trap 3 — Calling every kind of spreading diffusion

Wind, stirring and currents carry particles along together, in one direction. That is a flow of the whole gas or liquid, not diffusion. In everyday life, flows often do most of the spreading, and diffusion does the final short distances.

Try it yourself

Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.

  1. Explain why diffusion is much faster in a gas than in a liquid. Use the words "touching", "collide" and "random".

    Hint 1

    How far can a particle move before it hits another, in each state?

    Hint 2

    Compare the size of each step in the random walk.

    Full answer

    In a liquid, the particles are touching, so a particle can hardly move before it collides with a neighbour. Each step of its random path is very short. In a gas, the particles are far apart and move very fast, so each step between collisions is much longer, and many more steps happen each second. So particles in a gas spread much faster.

    Check: the answer uses all three words and links each to the particle model ✓.

  2. Put these in order, from fastest diffusion to slowest, and give a reason for each step: (A) ammonia gas in air at 40 °C; (B) a dye in water at 20 °C; (C) ammonia gas in air at 20 °C; (D) hydrogen chloride gas in air at 20 °C.

    Hint 1

    Gas or liquid first, then temperature, then mass.

    Hint 2

    Ammonia (17) is lighter than hydrogen chloride (36.5).

    Full answer

    A, C, D, B.

    A is fastest: a light gas at the highest temperature. C is the same gas, cooler, so a little slower. D is a heavier gas at the same temperature as C, so slower than C. B is slowest by far, because it is in a liquid, where diffusion is roughly ten thousand times slower than in a gas.

    Check: each step changes one thing only, so each reason can be tested on its own ✓.

  3. Kenji says: "When I put a tea bag in a cup of still water, the colour spreads because the tea particles are attracted to the clear water." Write two corrections for Kenji.

    Hint 1

    Do particles move towards anything on purpose?

    Hint 2

    What about the water? Is it really still?

    Full answer

    First: the tea particles are not attracted to the clear water. They move randomly. More of them leave the crowded area near the bag than come back, so there is a net movement outwards.

    Second: diffusion in water is slow. If the colour spreads through the cup in a few minutes, currents in the water, such as warm water rising, are doing much of the mixing. Diffusion alone would take many hours.

    Check: both corrections use the particle model, not wishes or attractions ✓.

  4. In your lungs, oxygen must pass from the air into your blood. It does this by diffusion across a wall about 1 micrometre thick (a thousandth of a millimetre). Diffusion through a watery layer 1 mm thick takes about 8 minutes. (a) Use the square rule to estimate how long diffusion takes across 1 micrometre. (b) Explain why the body moves oxygen around in blood instead of relying on diffusion from the lungs to the toes.

    Hint 1

    1 micrometre is a thousand times shorter than 1 mm. What happens to the time?

    Hint 2

    8 minutes is about 500 seconds. Divide by 1000 × 1000.

    Full answer

    (a) A thousand times shorter distance means about 1000 × 1000 = 1 000 000 times less time. 500 seconds ÷ 1 000 000 = 0.0005 seconds, half a thousandth of a second. So oxygen crosses the lung wall almost instantly.

    (b) Diffusion over a metre of watery body tissue would take years. So the body uses diffusion only for the very short distances: into the blood at the lungs, and out of the blood near each cell. The blood is pumped by the heart, a flow that carries the oxygen the long way round in seconds.

    Check: the square rule gives 1000² = 1 000 000 ✓, and 500 ÷ 1 000 000 = 0.0005 ✓.

The bigger idea

Diffusion works everywhere, but only over short distances. Living things are built around that fact. The walls of the tiny air sacs in the lungs, and of the smallest blood vessels, are thinner than a thousandth of a millimetre, so oxygen crosses them by diffusion almost instantly. For any longer distance, the body uses flows: breathing moves air in and out, and the heart pumps blood. A cell is small enough to rely on diffusion. An elephant is not.

Diffusion also matters for what comes next. The next topic asks how to tell a pure substance from a mixture, and how to separate one from another. A mixture of gases or liquids stays mixed because diffusion keeps it mixed. So separating a mixture means working against diffusion, which is why it always takes effort.

Key concepts in this lesson