The same tax, a different weight
"I am a student. I have no job, so I pay no tax." Many students believe this, but it is not true.
In many countries, when you buy a snack, a notebook or a phone charger, part of the price is a tax. The shop collects it and passes it on to the government. You paid it, even if you never noticed.
Now a harder puzzle. A rich family and a poor family buy the same notebook and pay exactly the same tax on it. Is that tax equally fair to both? Most people say yes. By the end of this lecture, you will see why economists say no.
The lecture on what governments do ended with a question: where does their money come from? For most countries, the answer is mainly taxes. This lecture looks at the two big families of taxes, and at what makes a tax fair.
What a tax is
A tax is a payment to the government that the law requires. It is compulsory, and you get no particular thing in return.
That makes a tax different from buying something. A bus fare buys you a ride; a tax buys you nothing directly. Instead, the money pays for the government's work as a whole: the rules of the game and the three jobs of fixing what markets get wrong, sharing income more fairly and keeping the economy steady.
Economists sort taxes into two groups: by what is taxed, and by how the money reaches the government.
Taxing what you earn: direct taxes
A direct tax is a tax on the income or wealth of a person or a firm. The person or firm being taxed pays it to the government. The main examples are:
- Income tax: a tax on what people earn from work, savings and other sources.
- Tax on company profits (also called corporate tax or corporation tax): a tax on what a firm earns after its costs.
- Property tax: a yearly tax on the value of land or buildings that someone owns.
Many workers never hand income tax over themselves: their employer takes it out of their pay. It is still a direct tax, because it is a tax on the worker's own income.
Taxing what you buy: indirect taxes
An indirect tax is a tax on buying and selling goods and services. The seller collects it from buyers as part of the price, then passes it on to the government. The buyer pays it, but indirectly, through the seller. The main examples are:
- Sales tax: a percentage added to the price of most goods and services. Singapore and India call theirs GST (goods and services tax). Many other countries, such as Barbados and the United Kingdom, call theirs VAT (value added tax).
- Excise duty: an extra tax on a few particular goods, such as tobacco, alcohol and petrol.
- Customs duty (also called an import duty or tariff): a tax on goods brought into the country.
Excise duties link back to market failure. Tobacco harms other people through second-hand smoke, and smokers often misjudge the harm to themselves. A tax on each packet raises the price, so fewer packets are bought. It works like the tax on the brick kiln's smoke in the lecture on what governments do.
Sort the cards below to test the difference.
Put each tax in the right box. Ask: is this a tax on someone's income or wealth, or a tax on buying something? Read the reason on each card.
Each tax below is sorted into direct or indirect, with the reason.
| Tax | Type | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Tax taken from a teacher's monthly pay | Direct | a tax on her income, even though the school sends it |
| Tax on a company's profit for the year | Direct | a tax on what the firm earns |
| A yearly tax on the value of a house | Direct | a tax on wealth the owner holds |
| Tax on the interest from bank savings | Direct | interest is part of a person's income |
| 9% added to the price of a new phone | Indirect | a sales tax, collected by the shop |
| An extra tax on each packet of cigarettes | Indirect | an excise duty, built into the price |
| A tax on cars brought into the country | Indirect | a customs duty, passed on in the car's price |
| A tax on each litre of petrol | Indirect | an excise duty, paid at the pump |
Taxes with several rates
The tax-and-transfer model in the lecture on what governments do used one tax rate for everyone. It promised that the next lecture would explain how real taxes use several rates.
Most income taxes cut income into slices called tax bands. Each band has its own rate. Here are the bands of an invented country:
| Band (yearly income) | Rate on each dollar in this band |
|---|---|
| The first $10 000 | 0% |
| From $10 000 to $40 000 | 10% |
| Above $40 000 | 30% |
Each rate applies only to the dollars inside its own band. Someone who earns $60 000 does not pay 30% on all of it. Her first $10 000 is taxed at 0%, her next $30 000 at 10%, and only her last $20 000 at 30%.
So there are two rates to keep apart. The marginal rate is the rate on the next dollar you earn. The average rate is your total tax as a share of your whole income. Some books call the average rate the effective rate. Explore them below.
Choose an income. The orange step line shows the tax rate on each extra dollar. The shaded area is the tax: each band's width times its rate. The dashed horizontal line is the average rate.
Presets:
The graph shows the invented tax bands for an income of $60 000. The tax is the shaded area: $3 000 from the 10% band and $6 000 from the 30% band, $9 000 in all. The dashed line is the average rate, 15%. The table shows other incomes.
| Income | Tax | Average rate | Marginal rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| $8 000 | $0 | 0% | 0% |
| $25 000 | $1 500 | 6% | 10% |
| $60 000 | $9 000 | 15% | 30% |
| $150 000 | $36 000 | 24% | 30% |
First, once you reach a taxed band, the average rate is below the marginal rate, because the lower bands are taxed less. Second, the average rate climbs as income rises: 6% at $25 000, 15% at $60 000, 24% at $150 000. A richer person pays not only more dollars, but a bigger share of their income.
Ana earns $39 000. Her employer offers her a rise to $41 000. A friend warns her: "Don't take it. You will move into the 30% band, and you will end up poorer." Is the friend right?
Show the answer
No. Only the dollars above $40 000 are taxed at 30%. At $39 000, Ana pays $2 900 and keeps $36 100. At $41 000, she pays $3 000 on her first $40 000, plus 30% of the last $1 000, which is $300. That is $3 300, so she keeps $37 700.
She is $1 600 better off. In a band system, earning more never leaves you with less after income tax, because the higher rate touches only the new dollars.
Singapore's income tax for residents has 13 bands, used from the 2024 tax year onwards (IRAS). The first S$20 000 is taxed at 0%. The next three bands are 2%, 3.5% and 7%, and the bands above them are 11.5%, 15% and 18%. The top rate is 24%, on income above S$1 million.
| Band | Rate | Tax in this band |
|---|---|---|
| First S$20 000 | 0% | S$0 |
| Next S$10 000 | 2% | S$200 |
| Next S$10 000 | 3.5% | S$350 |
| Next S$40 000 | 7% | S$2 800 |
| Next S$40 000 | 11.5% | S$4 600 |
| Next S$40 000 | 15% | S$6 000 |
| Next S$40 000 | 18% | S$7 200 |
Income S$80 000. Tax: . Average rate: . Marginal rate: 7%.
Income S$200 000. Add the next three bands: . Tax: . Average rate: . Marginal rate: 18%.
The second person earns 2.5 times as much but pays more than 6 times as much tax.
Check: IRAS's own table gives S$3 350 on the first S$80 000 and S$21 150 on the first S$200 000. ✓ (Real tax bills are lower still, because people can subtract some allowances, called reliefs, before the bands are applied.)
Progressive, proportional and regressive
Economists judge a tax by one question: as income rises, what happens to the share of income paid in this tax?
- A progressive tax takes a larger share of income from people with higher incomes. Income tax with bands is progressive.
- A proportional tax takes the same share from everyone, such as 10% of every income.
- A regressive tax takes a larger share of income from people with lower incomes.
Notice the word "share": a regressive tax can still collect more dollars from the rich.
Now return to the notebook puzzle. A sales tax charges everyone the same rate on what they buy. That sounds proportional. But it is a share of spending, not of income. A family with a low income has to spend almost all of it. A family with a high income can save a large part. So the tax takes a larger share of the poorer family's income.
An invented country has a 10% sales tax on everything. Family A earns $20 000 a year and spends $18 000 on goods before tax. Family B earns $200 000 a year and spends $80 000 before tax. It saves most of the rest.
Tax paid. Family A: 10% of $18 000 = $1 800. Family B: 10% of $80 000 = $8 000.
As a share of income. Family A: . Family B: .
Family B pays more than four times as many dollars, but the tax takes 9% of A's income and only 4% of B's. Measured against income, the sales tax is regressive.
Check: Family A's spending plus tax is $19 800, which fits inside its $20 000 income. ✓
That is it. That is the whole idea of this lecture. The same rate does not mean the same weight. To judge whether a tax is fair, compare what it takes with what each family has.
Governments soften this in two ways. Some leave basic needs, such as fresh food, out of the sales tax. Others tax almost everything and give money back to poorer families, as in the real case below.
A tax inside a price
A sales tax is usually included in the price on the label. How much of what you pay is tax? Less than the rate.
A drink costs $5.50, including a 10% sales tax. How much of that is tax?
Think about the price before tax. The shop adds 10% to its own price. So the label shows 110% of the price before tax.
Price before tax. . Tax. .
Share of what you paid. , not 10%. The 10% is a share of the price before tax, not of the price you pay.
Check: 10% of $5.00 is $0.50, and $5.00 + $0.50 = $5.50. ✓ In the same way, Singapore's 9% GST is of a price that includes it, so about 8 cents in every dollar paid.
The policy. Singapore has had a GST since 1994. It falls on nearly all goods and services. In Budget 2012, the government created a permanent GST Voucher scheme. It gives lower- and middle-income citizens cash, help with utility bills and, for older people, top-ups to their medical savings (Ministry of Finance, MOF). In 2022, the government announced a rise in the GST rate from 7% to 8% on 1 January 2023, and to 9% on 1 January 2024. A temporary Assurance Package of payments came with it, first S$6.6 billion and later S$8 billion.
The prediction. A sales tax on its own is regressive, so a higher rate should hurt lower-income households most, as a share of income. The government predicted that the Assurance Package would cover at least five years of the extra GST for most households, and about ten years for lower-income households (IRAS, 2024).
What happened. Both rises took effect on time (IRAS). MOF reported that from 2018 to 2020, the permanent vouchers covered on average 84% of the GST paid by the poorest fifth of households (MOF, 2021). MOF also says that, after the offsets, the poorest tenth of households pay no GST at all. Looking at all taxes and benefits together, the poorest fifth of households paid less than 10% of all taxes but received almost 30% of all benefits (MOF, 2020).
Verdict. The GST on its own is regressive. The GST together with the vouchers works more like a progressive system, because the money given back is a much larger share of a poor family's income. Three cautions matter. The figures come from the ministry that designed the policy. The Assurance Package is temporary, so its cover runs out. And the payments are set per person or per home, so they fit some families better than others. The case shows the main point of this lecture: whether a tax is fair depends on the whole system, not only on one tax.
Why governments use both
If indirect taxes are regressive, why not use only income tax? Each type has strengths and weaknesses.
Direct taxes can be made progressive with bands. But they are very visible on every payslip, and very high rates may lead some people to work less or hide income. Indirect taxes are hard to avoid, because everyone buys things. They are cheap to collect and can discourage harmful goods. But they are regressive, and people underestimate them, because the tax is hidden inside prices. So most countries use a mix, and argue about the balance.
A government raises the excise duty on cigarettes. It wants two things: far fewer smokers, and a large amount of money for hospitals. Can the tax fully achieve both?
Show the answer
Not fully. The tax raises money only on packets that are still bought. If it worked perfectly and everyone stopped smoking, it would raise nothing. The more it succeeds at the first aim, the less it achieves of the second.
Many smokers find it hard to quit, so in practice the tax does some of both. But whenever a tax has two aims, look for this conflict.
A band's rate applies only to the dollars inside that band. Moving into a higher band raises the tax on the new dollars, not on the old ones. Always work band by band.
A sales tax charges everyone the same rate on spending. But poorer families spend a larger share of their income, so the tax takes a larger share of their income. Judge a tax by the share of income it takes.
The seller hands the tax to the government, but usually adds it to the price. So buyers pay at least part of it, including students with no job. Who carries how much of a tax is studied in a later lecture on tax incidence.
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck. Questions 1, 3 and 4 use this lecture's invented bands: 0% on the first $10 000, 10% from $10 000 to $40 000 and 30% above $40 000.
-
Find the income tax and the average rate for an income of $32 000 and for an income of $80 000.
Hint 1
Split each income into the three bands first.
Hint 2
$80 000 is $10 000 at 0%, $30 000 at 10% and $40 000 at 30%.
Full answer
$32 000: the second band holds $22 000, so the tax is $2 200. Average rate: .
$80 000: . Average rate: .
Check: the higher income has the higher average rate, as a progressive tax should. ✓
-
Decide whether each tax is progressive, proportional or regressive, using two incomes, $20 000 and $100 000. (a) Every adult pays $200 a year. (b) Everyone pays 5% of their income. (c) A 20% tax on air tickets, when the first family spends $500 a year on flights and the second spends $10 000.
Hint 1
Work out each tax as a share of each income.
Hint 2
For (a), $200 is 1% of $20 000. What share is it of $100 000?
Full answer
(a) 1% against 0.2%: the share falls as income rises, so it is regressive.
(b) 5% against 5%: proportional.
(c) $100 is 0.5% of $20 000, and $2 000 is 2% of $100 000. The share rises with income, so this tax is progressive, because richer families spend much more on flying.
Check: whether a tax on spending is regressive depends on who buys the good. ✓
-
Priya earns $40 000. She can earn $2 000 more by working extra hours. How much of the extra will she keep? What happens to her average rate?
Hint 1
Which band does every one of the extra dollars fall in?
Hint 2
All $2 000 is above $40 000, so it is taxed at 30%.
Full answer
Extra tax: 30% of $2 000 = $600. She keeps $1 400. Her total tax goes from $3 000 to $3 600, and her average rate rises from 7.5% to .
Check: after tax, $37 000 becomes $38 400, a rise of $1 400. ✓ Whether $1 400 is worth the extra hours is Priya's choice. This is the incentive question from the lecture on what governments do.
-
The invented country also has a 10% sales tax. Family P earns $25 000 and spends $22 000 before tax. Family R earns $120 000 and spends $60 000 before tax. Find each family's total tax (income tax plus sales tax) as a share of income. Is the sales tax regressive? Is the whole system progressive? What happens to Family P's share if the government gives it a $1 000 voucher?
Hint 1
Work out four amounts: two income taxes and two sales taxes.
Hint 2
Family R's income tax is .
Full answer
Income tax: P pays $1 500; R pays . Sales tax: P pays $2 200; R pays $6 000.
Sales tax alone: P 8.8% of income, R 5%. It is regressive.
All taxes: P pays $3 700, which is 14.8%; R pays $33 000, which is 27.5%. The whole system is progressive.
With the voucher, P's net tax is $2 700, which is 10.8% of its income.
Check: this is the same pattern as the Singapore case: one regressive tax inside a progressive system, made more progressive by money given back. ✓
Is there a perfect tax? People have asked this for centuries. In 1776, in The Wealth of Nations, Adam Smith set out four rules for a good tax, which are still taught today. People should pay in proportion to their ability. A tax should be certain, not decided at an official's whim. It should be collected at a time and in a way that is convenient. And it should cost as little as possible to collect, beyond what it brings in.
No single tax meets all four rules well. Income tax with bands matches ability. A sales tax is convenient and cheap to collect, but regressive. So real systems mix several taxes, and every budget debate is partly an argument about the mix. The next lecture follows the money the other way: what governments spend it on.
- A tax is a compulsory payment to the government, which pays for its work as a whole rather than buying a particular thing.
- A direct tax falls on what a person or firm earns or owns, such as income tax, tax on profits and property tax.
- An indirect tax falls on buying and selling, such as sales tax, excise duty and customs duty, and the seller collects it in the price.
- In a band system, each rate applies only to the dollars inside its band. So earning more never leaves you worse off after income tax.
- A tax is progressive, proportional or regressive according to the share of income it takes as income rises, not according to its rate.
- A sales tax is regressive on its own, but a whole system of taxes and money given back can still be progressive.