MathemagiciansLibraryExplorationsDeep Dives
← Economics · Lower Secondary
EconomicsLower Secondary

What governments do in an economy

LSE1.4.1 — Why Governments InterveneLecture 2 of 2~2580 words

A morning with the government in it

Follow an invented student, Leila, through one ordinary morning. She wakes up and drinks a glass of water from the tap. The street light outside her window has just switched off. She checks the label on a cough medicine before taking it. She pays her bus fare with coins. At school, her lessons are free. On the way, she passes her grandfather, who collects a pension each month although he no longer works.

Leila has not bought anything from the government. Yet it was part of almost every step: the water, the light, the label, the coins, the school and the pension.

Now remember the last lecture. It showed four ways a market can make the wrong amount of something. The street light fits: it is hard to sell. The medicine label fits too: buyers can misjudge what they cannot see. But the grandfather's pension does not fit any of the four kinds. Neither do the coins in Leila's pocket. So governments must be doing more than fixing market failures. What exactly are they doing, and why?

Three jobs on one foundation

Economists sort what governments do into a few jobs. Different books use different words for them, but the ideas are the same.

The foundation: rules of the gameproperty, contracts, courts, money, fair competitionJob 1Fix whatmarketsget wrongJob 2Shareincomemore fairlyJob 3Keep theeconomysteadyWhat governments do in an economy
Governments set the rules that every market needs. On top of that, they do three jobs in the economy.

The foundation is the rules of the game. A market only works if people can own things, make promises and trust money. If anyone could take your bicycle, nobody would buy one. If a contract meant nothing, no firm would sign one. So governments protect property, run courts that enforce contracts, provide a trusted money and stop firms from cheating their competitors. Leila's coins belong here.

On that foundation, governments do three jobs.

Every country does all three, in very different amounts. This is the mixed economy from the economic systems lecture, decided good by good.

Job 1: fixing what markets get wrong

The last lecture promised that this one would look at the tools governments use. Here they are. Each kind of market failure has its own cause, so each needs a tool that removes that cause.

Kind of market failureThe market makesCommon tools
Harm to people outside the tradetoo mucha rule or limit; a tax on each unit
Benefit to people outside the tradetoo littlea payment for each unit (a subsidy); providing it free
Things that are hard to selltoo little, or nonethe government provides it, paid for by taxes
Buyers misjudgetoo much or too littleinformation, such as labels; rules, such as age limits; taxes or subsidies

The cleverest tool is the tax on harm. It puts a price on the thing the market could not see. Watch it work on the brick kiln from the last lecture.

Worked Example 1 — A tax that fixes the brick market (invented)

In the invented town, builders' highest prices for eight loads of bricks are $100, $90, $80, $70, $60, $50, $40 and $30. The kiln's lowest prices are $25, $35, $45, $55, $65, $75, $85 and $95. Each load sends $20 of smoke harm over the school.

Without a tax. A load is sold when the highest price is at least the lowest price. Load 4 passes ($70 against $55). Load 5 does not ($60 against $65). So the market makes 4 loads. The last lecture showed that only 3 are worth making for the town.

With a tax of $20 a load. The kiln now pays $20 to the government for every load. So its lowest price for each load rises by $20: $45, $55, $65, $75, … Load 3 still passes ($80 against $65). Load 4 now fails ($70 against $75). The market makes 3 loads, exactly the right amount.

What the tax raises. 3 loads × $20 = $60. The town could use it to help the families near the school, but the main point of the tax is the change in the kiln's choice.

Check: a tax equal to the harm makes the kiln's lowest price equal to the true cost to the town. So the kiln's own test, "is the price at least my cost?", becomes the town's test. ✓

That is it. That is the whole idea of Job 1. The government does not have to decide how many bricks to make. It adds the missing cost to the price, and then the market's own test finds the right amount.

Stop and think

The smoke harms children. Why not simply ban the kiln? Surely no smoke is better than some smoke.

Show the answer

A ban makes 0 loads. But loads 1 to 3 are worth making even after the harm is counted. Load 1, for example, is worth $100 to a builder and costs the kiln $25 plus $20 of harm. Banning it throws away that gain, and the town needs bricks for its houses.

A ban is the right tool when no amount of the harm is worth the gain. Leaded petrol, in the last lecture, was like that: lead-free petrol did the same job without poisoning anyone. So the choice of tool depends on the size of the harm and on what else is possible.

The other tools follow the same logic. A subsidy on vaccinations raises what each one is worth to the person who buys it, so more people choose it. A government builds the flood wall, because a market would leave it to free riders. Information and age limits help buyers who would otherwise misjudge.

Job 2: sharing income more fairly

The last lecture kept two questions apart. One asked, "Is the right amount made?" The other asked, "Is it shared fairly?" Job 1 answers the first. Job 2 is about the second.

In a market economy, your income depends on what you have to sell. The household income lecture showed that income comes from four places: wages for work, rent for land, interest for savings and profit for owning a firm. Someone with skills in high demand earns a lot. Someone who is too young, too old or too ill to work may have nothing to sell at all. Leila's grandfather is in that position. A market alone would give him no income.

Governments change this in three ways. They take more tax from people with higher incomes. They make transfers: payments to people who supply nothing in return at that moment, such as pensions, child benefits and unemployment benefits. And they provide some services free or cheaply, such as schools and clinics, which are worth more, as a share of income, to poorer families. Moving income from some people to others in these ways is called redistribution.

How much to redistribute is a judgement, and people disagree about it. Some stress fairness: no family should go without food or school. Others stress incentives: if taxes take too much of each extra dollar earned, some people may choose to work or invest less. How strong that effect is in real life is still debated. Economics cannot settle the judgement. It can show what a choice does. Try one in the model below.

Model — a tax and a transfer in an invented town

This is an invented town of five households, A to E. Choose a tax rate on each household's income above $10 000. All the tax collected is shared equally among the five households as a transfer. Watch each household's income after tax and transfer.

Presets:

What the model leaves out: it assumes nobody works less or more when the tax changes. Real transfers usually go to the people who need them most, not equally to everyone. Real taxes have several rates, which the next lecture explains. And collecting taxes and paying transfers has its own cost.

The chart shows five invented households before and after a 30% tax on income above $10 000, with all the tax shared equally. The table shows other tax rates. The total income of the town is $200 000 in every row.

A$15kB$21kC$29kD$46kE$89kbeforeafter tax and transfer
Tax rateTransfer to eachA afterE afterE ÷ A
0%$0$6 000$110 000≈ 18.3
20%$6 160$12 160$96 160≈ 7.9
30%$9 240$15 240$89 240≈ 5.9
40%$12 320$18 320$82 320≈ 4.5

Look at what happened. The total income of the town did not change. It was only moved. The gap between the richest and the poorest household shrank fast: at 30%, household E has about 6 times what A has, instead of about 18 times. Notice household D too. Even at 20%, D pays more in tax than it gets back, although D is not the richest. Every real system has to decide where that line falls. That is the judgement, and the numbers do not make it for you.

Job 3: keeping the economy steady

An economy does not grow smoothly. In some years, spending and output rise fast. This is a boom. In other years, they fall. A fall in output that lasts for some months is called a recession. In a recession, firms sell less, so they need fewer workers, and some people lose their jobs.

The circular flow lecture explains why a recession can feed itself. One person's spending is another person's income. When households spend less, firms earn less. Then firms cut jobs and pay, so households earn less, and they spend less again. A government can push against this loop. But first, test your own instinct about what a careful government should do.

Predict — a recession and a careful government

An invented economy normally spends $100 billion a year: $60 billion by households, $20 billion by firms and $20 billion by the government. A recession hits. Households cut their spending to $54 billion and firms to $16 billion. Taxes fall too, so the government cuts its own spending to $16 billion, to avoid borrowing. What does the government's cut do to the recession? Choose one.

The chart shows total spending in an invented economy. In a recession, households and firms spend $70 billion instead of $80 billion. Total spending is $86 billion if the government cuts its spending, $90 billion if it keeps it, and $94 billion if it spends more. Cutting makes the fall deeper.

$100bnNormalyear$86bnRecession,gov. cuts$90bnRecession,gov. keeps$94bnRecession,gov. addshouseholdsfirmsgovernment

This surprises many people. A family whose income falls should spend less. But a government is not one family. Its spending is a large part of everyone else's income. So in a recession, governments usually do the opposite of the family. They keep spending, or spend more, and they borrow to pay for it. In a boom, when spending is rising too fast, they can do the reverse: spend less and collect more tax.

Some of this happens by itself. In a recession, people earn less, so they pay less tax. More people lose their jobs, so more receive unemployment benefit. Both changes leave more money in households' hands, without any new decision. These are called automatic stabilisers. On top of them, a government can choose to act: build roads and schools sooner, cut taxes, or pay firms to keep their workers. Using government spending and taxes in this way is called fiscal policy.

A second tool belongs to the central bank, which issues a country's money. Most central banks lower interest rates in a recession, to make borrowing cheaper, and raise them in a boom. This is called monetary policy. Later lectures look at both tools closely.

Real case — Paying firms to keep their workers, United Kingdom, 2020 to 2021

The situation. In March 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic closed shops, restaurants and offices across the United Kingdom. Many firms suddenly had no customers. Without help, they would have dismissed millions of workers. Those workers would then spend less, and the loop of the recession would turn.

The policy. The government announced the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme on 20 March 2020. It is often called "furlough". It paid 80% of the wages of workers who could not work, up to £2 500 a month, as long as their employer kept them on. The scheme ran until 30 September 2021.

The prediction. If the scheme worked, unemployment should rise far less than output fell. In July 2020, the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) published scenarios for the economy. Its central scenario, which assumed the scheme would end in October 2020 and that some furloughed workers would then lose their jobs, had unemployment reaching 11.9% at the end of 2020.

What happened. The economy shrank by about a tenth in 2020, its largest annual fall for at least a hundred years (ONS). But unemployment in October to December 2020 was 5.1% (ONS, February 2021). Over its life, the scheme supported 11.7 million jobs from 1.3 million employers, and claims totalled about £70 billion (HMRC; HM Treasury and HMRC evaluation, 2023). Many other countries ran similar schemes, such as Germany's short-time work and Singapore's Jobs Support Scheme.

Verdict. Unemployment stayed far below the level the OBR had described, while output fell sharply. That is what a stabiliser is meant to do. But the comparison is not perfect. The OBR scenario assumed the scheme would end in 2020, and in fact it was extended. The cost was very large, and the National Audit Office estimated fraud and error across the support schemes at about £4.5 billion. Some jobs that were kept would also have been lost later anyway. The scheme did its main job, at a high price, and economists still debate whether a cheaper design was possible.

When the fix goes wrong

None of this means that government action always helps. A government can make things worse. This is called government failure. It is the other side of the last lecture's market failure.

Here is an invented example. Bread becomes expensive, so a government sets a legal maximum price for a loaf, below the equilibrium price. The equilibrium lecture showed what happens below equilibrium: buyers want more than sellers offer. Bakeries make less bread at the lower price, so shelves empty and queues form. The rule meant to help poor families leaves some of them with no bread at all.

Governments can also fail because they do not know the true size of a harm, because help reaches the wrong people, or because decisions follow votes rather than results. So the useful question is not whether markets or governments are better in general. It is which of them does better in this case, and with which tool. The Upper Secondary lectures on government failure study this question in detail.

Trap 1 — "Everything a government does fixes a market failure"

A pension fixes no market failure. Neither does spending more in a recession. Name the job first: fixing a failure, sharing income, or keeping the economy steady. Each job has its own reason and its own tools.

Trap 2 — Treating the government like a family in a recession

A family whose income falls should spend less. A government that does the same takes more spending out of the economy, and the recession gets deeper. Government spending is other people's income.

Trap 3 — "If the market fails, the government will fix it"

A market failure shows that a market alone gets something wrong. It does not show that a government will get it right. Compare what the market does with what a real government, with real information and real limits, is likely to do.

Try it yourself

Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.

  1. Which job, or the foundation, does each action belong to? (a) A court makes a firm pay a supplier it owed money. (b) A tax on sugary drinks. (c) Free school meals for children from low-income families. (d) Building a new hospital sooner than planned because the economy is in a recession.

    Hint 1

    Ask what problem each action solves: broken promises, a market making the wrong amount, an unfair share, or a falling economy.

    Hint 2

    One of them could fit two jobs. Decide which reason is the main one.

    Full answer

    (a) The foundation: enforcing contracts. (b) Job 1: buyers may misjudge the harm to their own health, so drinkers buy more than is good for them. (c) Job 2, sharing income: it helps families with less. It also has a Job 1 side, because well-fed children learn better, a benefit that spreads to others. (d) Job 3: it adds spending when other spending is falling. Check: each answer names the problem first, then the job. ✓

  2. An invented paint factory can sell six tins a day. Buyers' highest prices are $60, $50, $40, $30, $20 and $10. The factory's lowest prices are $12, $22, $32, $42, $52 and $62. Fumes from each tin do $15 of harm to neighbours. (a) How many tins does the market sell? (b) The government puts a tax of $15 on each tin. How many now? (c) What if the tax is only $5?

    Hint 1

    A tax of $15 adds $15 to each of the factory's lowest prices.

    Hint 2

    With the $15 tax, the lowest prices become $27, $37, $47, … Compare each with the buyer's highest price.

    Full answer

    (a) Tins 1 to 3 pass ($60 ≥ $12, $50 ≥ $22, $40 ≥ $32); tin 4 fails ($30 < $42). So 3 tins. (b) With $15 added: tin 2 passes ($50 ≥ $37), tin 3 fails ($40 < $47). So 2 tins, the right amount, because the tax equals the harm. It raises 2 × $15 = $30. (c) With $5 added: tin 3 still passes ($40 ≥ $37). So 3 tins: a tax smaller than the harm may not change the choice at all. Check: tin 3 is worth $40 to the buyer but costs $32 + $15 = $47 to the town, so stopping it is right. ✓

  3. An invented town has two households. One earns $8 000 and the other $72 000. The government taxes 25% of each household's income above $8 000 and shares all the tax equally between the two. Find each income after tax and transfer. How many times richer is the richer household before and after?

    Hint 1

    Only the richer household has income above $8 000.

    Hint 2

    Tax = 25% of $64 000. Each household gets half of it back.

    Full answer

    Tax = 0.25 × $64 000 = $16 000. Each household receives $8 000. The poorer one has $8 000 + $8 000 = $16 000. The richer one has $72 000 − $16 000 + $8 000 = $64 000. Before: 72 000 ÷ 8 000 = 9 times. After: 64 000 ÷ 16 000 = 4 times. Check: the total is $80 000 before and after. ✓

  4. An invented country's government normally collects $50 billion in tax and spends $50 billion. In a recession, tax collected falls to $45 billion, and unemployment benefits push its spending up to $52 billion. (a) How much must it borrow? (b) Which of these changes were automatic stabilisers? (c) An adviser says: "Cut spending by $7 billion so we do not borrow." Explain what this would do to the recession, and suggest how a country can prepare for years like this.

    Hint 1

    Borrowing is the gap between spending and tax collected.

    Hint 2

    Think of the predict question above. Then think about what a government could do in the good years before the recession.

    Full answer

    (a) $52 billion − $45 billion = $7 billion. (b) Both: tax fell and benefits rose by themselves, without a new decision, and both leave more money with households. (c) Cutting $7 billion of spending removes $7 billion of other people's income, and probably more as the loop spreads. It also cancels the help the automatic stabilisers were giving, so the recession deepens. A country can prepare by saving in good years, collecting a little more than it spends, so it has savings to use or room to borrow when a recession comes. Check: with the cut, spending would be $45 billion, equal to tax, so no borrowing, but $7 billion less spending in a weak economy. ✓

The bigger idea

Countries choose very different amounts of each job. Some collect high taxes and pay large transfers. Others keep taxes low and leave more to families and markets. Neither choice is simply right. Each is a judgement about fairness, freedom and growth, made by the country's people and their governments.

What economics adds is a set of good questions. Which job is this action doing? Which tool fits the cause? Who pays? Can the government do better than the market here? Those questions work in Chennai, Singapore, Barbados or anywhere else.

Every job in this lecture costs money. The next lecture asks where that money comes from: taxes, and the difference between taxing what people earn and taxing what they spend.

Key concepts in this lesson