Following the money the other way
The last lecture followed money from people and firms to the government, through taxes. It ended with a promise: the next lecture follows the money the other way, to see what governments spend it on. Here it is.
Start with a guess. Imagine the whole budget of a rich country's government. Which single area do you think takes the most money? Many students say the army. Others say schools, or the salaries of politicians. Commit to an answer before you read on.
Across the 38 member countries of the OECD (the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development), most of them rich, which area takes the largest share of government spending, on average? Choose one, then see the real figures for 2023.
The chart shows average government spending in OECD countries in 2023, as a percentage of GDP (OECD, Government at a Glance 2025). Social protection, mainly pensions and benefits, is the largest at 13.4% of GDP. Health is second at 8.4%. Defence is one of several smaller areas inside "all other areas", which add up to 9.9%.
Across OECD countries, total government spending averaged 42.6% of GDP in 2023 (OECD, Government at a Glance 2025). The largest part, about a third of it, went to social protection: pensions for older people, and benefits for people who are sick, disabled, raising children or out of work. Health came second, then a group called general public services, which includes running the government and paying interest on its past borrowing. Education came next.
The numbers vary a lot between countries. A poorer country with a young population usually spends a smaller share on pensions and a larger share on schools and roads. But one surprise holds almost everywhere: the biggest item is not something the government makes or buys. It is money the government passes on.
Two kinds of spending
That surprise points to the most useful split in this lecture. A government spends money in two very different ways.
- Spending on goods and services. The government pays for something to be produced and used. It pays teachers' salaries, buys medicines for public hospitals, builds roads and equips soldiers. The government decides what is used.
- Transfers. The government pays money to people who supply nothing in return at that moment, such as a pension or an unemployment benefit. You met transfers in the lecture on what governments do. Here the household decides what to buy with the money.
Why does the split matter? Spending on goods and services uses up real resources. A teacher who works in a public school cannot work somewhere else at the same time. A transfer uses up no resources directly. It moves buying power from taxpayers to the people who receive it. This means a country with a large pension bill is not "using up" a third of its economy on pensions. It is sharing out a third of what the government collects.
A second split is about time. Current spending pays for things used up this year, such as salaries and medicines. Capital spending pays for things that last for many years, such as a new bridge, a school building or a hospital. Some books call capital spending "investment" or "development spending".
An invented country spends $80 billion in one year: pensions $20bn, child and unemployment benefits $8bn, health $16bn, education $12bn, defence $5bn, police and courts $4bn, roads and transport $6bn, interest on past borrowing $5bn, and other services $4bn.
Sort. Transfers: pensions and benefits, . Goods and services: . Interest is a third kind of payment. It is paid to lenders for money borrowed in the past. It buys nothing this year, and it is not a benefit to households in need.
Shares. Transfers: . Goods and services: . Interest: .
Check. . ✓ The shares add up to 100%, allowing for rounding.
What it shows. Over a third of this budget is money passed on to households. Only the $47 billion is the government itself deciding what is produced.
Why each item is there
Every large item in a budget has a reason. You already know the reasons, from the lectures on market failure and on what governments do. A government has a foundation, the rules of the game, and three jobs: fix what markets get wrong, share income more fairly, and keep the economy steady. Here is how the spending fits.
| Spending | Main reason |
|---|---|
| Police, courts | The foundation: rules of the game must be enforced. |
| Defence, flood walls, street lights | Fix a market failure: things that are hard to sell, because non-payers cannot be kept out. |
| Schools, vaccination, much of health care | Fix a market failure: benefits reach people outside the trade, so the market makes too little. They also share chances more fairly. |
| Pensions, child benefits | Share income more fairly. |
| Unemployment benefits | Share income, and keep the economy steady: they rise by themselves in a recession. |
| Roads, ports, water pipes | Support all other production; some are hard to sell, others are best run as one network. |
| Interest on past borrowing | Not a choice this year: the cost of past decisions to borrow. |
Notice that one item can have several reasons. Education is the clearest case. An educated person earns more, but other people gain too: an educated workforce makes firms more productive and invents new things. Education also gives children from poor families the same start as others. And over many years, a better-trained workforce moves the whole production possibility frontier outward.
In Amara's country, primary school is free. Her friend says: "School costs nothing, so the government could make every school bigger and nobody would lose." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
"Free" only means the family pays nothing at the school gate. Teachers, buildings and books are still paid for, through taxes. So the school is paid for by everyone, not by nobody.
There is also an opportunity cost. The teachers and builders who work for bigger schools cannot also work in hospitals, on roads or in private firms. Every extra dollar spent on schools is a dollar not spent on something else. Bigger schools may still be the right choice. But it is a choice, with a cost.
Every budget is a choice
A government that wants to spend more on one thing has three ways to pay for it. It can spend less on something else. It can raise taxes, which leaves households and firms less to spend. Or it can borrow, which means paying interest every year afterwards. There is no fourth way that costs nobody anything.
That is it. That is the whole idea of public spending: scarcity does not disappear when the government is the buyer. The first lecture of this course said that every choice has an opportunity cost. A budget is that idea written in billions.
The government of the invented country wants $2 billion for new schools. It decides to borrow the money at an interest rate of 4% a year.
Interest each year. . That is $80 million every year, for as long as the loan is not repaid.
What else that could buy. If a teacher costs $50 000 a year, then . The yearly interest equals the pay of 1 600 teachers.
Over ten years. , so $800 million in interest, and the $2 billion is still owed.
Check. 1% of $2 billion is $20 million, so 4% is $80 million. ✓
Judgement. This does not mean borrowing is wrong. Schools last for decades, so spreading their cost over the years they are used can be fair. But the interest is a real cost, paid from future budgets.
A budget that changes with its people
The largest item, social protection, has been growing in many countries for a simple reason: people are living longer and having fewer children. More older people means more pensions and more health care. Fewer young people means fewer workers to pay the taxes. Try it in a simple model below.
An invented country has 10 million people. Each person aged 65 or over gets a pension of $10 000 a year. Of everyone else, 60% work. Choose the share of people aged 65 or over and watch what each worker must pay for pensions.
Presets:
The table shows the invented model: 10 million people, a $10 000 pension for everyone aged 65 or over, and 60% of everyone else working.
| Aged 65+ | Pension spending | Workers | Cost per worker |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10% | $10bn | 5.4m | ≈ $1 852 |
| 20% | $20bn | 4.8m | ≈ $4 167 |
| 30% | $30bn | 4.2m | ≈ $7 143 |
When the share of older people triples from 10% to 30%, pension spending triples, from $10 billion to $30 billion. But the cost per worker rises almost four times, from about $1 852 to about $7 143. This is because two things happen at once: there are more pensioners, and fewer workers to share the cost.
The model leaves a lot out. Many people work past 65. Workers become more productive over time, so each can afford to pay more. Some countries let more young workers move in. And people also save for their own old age. But the model shows why ageing countries argue about the same three choices: higher taxes, lower pensions per person, or a later pension age.
The policy. In August 1997, Mexico began a programme called Progresa for poor rural families. It was a transfer with a condition. Mothers received cash grants for each child, but only if the child stayed enrolled and attended school regularly. The grants were larger for older children, and larger for girls in secondary school, because that is when many children left school to work.
The prediction. Education has benefits that reach beyond the family. Poor families, though, may need a teenager's earnings now. So the government predicted that paying them to keep children in school would raise enrolment, especially in secondary school, where it was lowest. To test this fairly, 506 rural communities were chosen, and the programme started in 320 of them, picked at random, while 186 waited. The waiting communities showed what would have happened without the programme.
What happened. An evaluation by IFPRI (the International Food Policy Research Institute, 2001) found large effects. Before the programme, about 67% of girls and 73% of boys in these communities went on to secondary school. The programme raised girls' enrolment by about 7 to 9 percentage points, and boys' by about 4 to 6. The researchers estimated about 0.7 extra years of schooling per child. Families' food spending also rose.
Verdict. The transfer worked as predicted, and the random design makes the result unusually trustworthy. The idea spread: the programme was later renamed Oportunidades and then Prospera, and similar conditional transfers now run in more than 60 countries (Ibarrarán and others, 2017). Two cautions matter. More years in school does not by itself mean better learning, which depends on what happens inside the classroom. And in 2019 Mexico replaced Prospera with a looser scheme, so how best to design such a transfer is still debated. The case shows the main point of this lecture: a transfer can also pursue a goal that the government chooses, such as education.
A pension or a benefit does not buy anything for the government. It moves buying power to a household, which then decides what to buy. Keep transfers apart from spending on goods and services.
A free school or clinic is free at the point of use. It is still paid for through taxes or borrowing, and the people and materials used have an opportunity cost.
"The government spends too much" and "more spending is always better" both skip the real question. For each item, ask what problem it solves, whether the market would do better, and what the evidence says it achieved.
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.
-
For each item, say whether it is spending on goods and services or a transfer, and give its main reason: (a) the salaries of nurses in a public hospital; (b) a monthly pension; (c) a new sea wall; (d) unemployment benefit; (e) equipment for the army; (f) free meals served at school.
Hint 1
Ask: does the government decide what is used, or does a household decide what to buy?
Hint 2
School meals are cooked and served, so the government decides what is used, even though children benefit.
Full answer
(a) Goods and services; health has benefits beyond the patient and is shared more fairly. (b) Transfer; sharing income. (c) Goods and services, and capital spending; a flood wall protects everyone behind it, so non-payers cannot be kept out. (d) Transfer; sharing income, and it keeps spending up in a recession. (e) Goods and services; defence protects everyone. (f) Goods and services; better-fed children learn more, and poorer families gain most.
Check: only (b) and (d) put money in households' hands. ✓
-
An invented government spends $50 billion. Of this, $18 billion is transfers and $3 billion is interest on past borrowing. How much is spending on goods and services? Give each part as a share of the total.
Hint 1
Goods and services are whatever is left after transfers and interest.
Hint 2
.
Full answer
Goods and services: , so $29 billion. Shares: , , .
Check: 58% + 36% + 6% = 100%. ✓
-
A government has an extra $120 million a year. It can hire nurses at $50 000 a year each, or teachers at $40 000 a year each. How many of each could it hire? If it hires the nurses, what is the opportunity cost? Can the numbers alone decide which is better?
Hint 1
Divide the money by each salary.
Hint 2
The opportunity cost is the best thing given up.
Full answer
Nurses: . Teachers: . The opportunity cost of hiring 2 400 nurses is the 3 000 teachers not hired.
The numbers alone cannot decide. More teachers is a bigger number, but the question is which does more good: shorter hospital waits or smaller classes. That needs evidence and a judgement about what matters most.
Check: 2 400 × $50 000 = $120 million. ✓
-
In an invented country, 1.5 million people now receive a pension of $12 000 a year, paid for by 6 million workers. In 20 years there will be 2.5 million pensioners and 5 million workers. Find the pension cost per worker now and in 20 years. The government says it will borrow the extra $12 billion each year at 4% instead of raising taxes. How much yearly interest will it pay after five years of doing this? Suggest two other responses.
Hint 1
Cost per worker = pension spending ÷ number of workers.
Hint 2
After five years it has borrowed 5 × $12 billion in total.
Full answer
Now: , so $18 billion, and : $3 000 per worker. Later: $30 billion ÷ 5 million = $6 000 per worker. The cost per worker doubles.
Borrowing: after five years the debt is $60 billion, so the interest is , or $2.4 billion a year, and it keeps growing while the borrowing goes on. This cannot last for ever.
Other responses: raise the pension age, so there are fewer pensioners and more workers; or save in advance during good years, as a fund. Others are possible, such as a smaller pension per person or higher taxes.
Check: $30 billion − $18 billion = $12 billion, the extra each year. ✓
The lecture on what governments do ended with advice: save in good years, so you can spend in bad ones. A few countries do this on a large scale. Singapore's government has saved surpluses over many decades and invests them. Part of the returns, called the Net Investment Returns Contribution, now pays for about a fifth of its spending: about S$22.9 billion against total spending of S$106.9 billion in 2023 (Ministry of Finance, Budget 2024). Singapore's government does borrow, but by law it cannot spend that borrowing; it must invest it (MOF). In 2020, its four COVID-19 budgets came to S$92.9 billion, and about S$40 billion of the cost came from reserves saved by earlier generations (MOF).
Most countries work the other way: they borrow in bad years and pay interest afterwards. Neither choice is free. Saving means less spending, or more tax, today; borrowing means interest tomorrow. That trade-off is where this course began: scarcity, choice and opportunity cost. Markets, money, national income and government are all ways of answering the same question: what should we do with what we have?
- In rich countries the largest area of government spending is usually social protection, mainly pensions and benefits, followed by health.
- Spending on goods and services uses up real resources, while a transfer moves buying power to a household that decides what to buy.
- Current spending pays for things used up this year, and capital spending pays for things that last many years.
- Each spending item has a reason: the rules of the game, fixing a market failure, sharing income, or keeping the economy steady.
- More spending on one thing must be paid for by spending less elsewhere, taxing more or borrowing, so every budget has an opportunity cost.
- An ageing population raises pension and health spending while reducing the number of workers who pay for it.