MathemagiciansLibraryExplorationsDeep Dives
← Economics · Lower Secondary
EconomicsLower Secondary

How households earn and spend money

LSE1.3.2 — Income and SpendingLecture 1 of 2~2670 words

How much did the family save?

The last lecture ended with a promise: to follow the money, and see how households earn it and decide what to do with it. Here it is. Start with a puzzle.

The Mensah family is invented, but their month is ordinary. This month the family receives $4 000. Income tax of $500 is taken from their pay. They spend $3 000 on rent, food, bus fares, school costs and everything else. They put $200 into a savings account at the bank. And they use $300 to buy shares in a company. How much did the Mensah family save this month?

Decide before you read on. Most people answer quickly, and most people answer wrongly.

Predict — how much did the Mensah family save?

The family received $4 000, paid $500 in income tax, spent $3 000, put $200 in the bank and bought $300 of shares. Choose your answer.

The four common answers, and why only one is right.

  • $200: wrong. The bank account is one place to keep saving, but not the only one.
  • $500: right. Saving is income after tax that is not spent on consumption: $4 000 − $500 − $3 000 = $500. The $200 in the bank and the $300 of shares are two places where that $500 went.
  • $1 000: wrong. This forgets the tax. The $500 of tax was never the family's to spend or save.
  • $0: wrong. Buying shares is not consumption. The family still owns the shares, and can sell them later.

The answer is $500. To see why, you need three ideas: where household income comes from, the three places it goes, and what economists mean by saving. This lecture builds each one.

Where household income comes from

A household is a person, or a group of people, living together and sharing their money. A family is a household. So is a student living alone.

In the lecture on factors of production, you met the four factors and their rewards. Firms need land, labour, capital and enterprise, and they pay for each one. Now look at the same payments from the other side. Who owns the factors? Households do. So the rewards that firms pay out become the income that households receive.

The household suppliesIt receivesExample
LabourWagesA nurse is paid for each month of work.
LandRentA farmer lets a field to a neighbour.
CapitalInterestA family's savings are lent through a bank to a firm that buys machines.
EnterpriseProfitA family runs a weekend food stall and keeps what is left after paying the costs.

Two of these need care. Interest is the reward for capital because a household's savings pay for capital. When a family keeps money in a bank, the bank lends it to firms, and the firms buy machines and buildings with it. The interest is the household's share of what that capital produces. Some households also own shares in companies. A share is a small part of a company, and it can pay the owner a part of the company's profit, called a dividend.

In most countries, wages are by far the largest of the four. Most people own no land to let and no business. What they own is their own time and skill, and they sell it.

There is one more source of income that is not a reward for any factor. Governments pay pensions to older people, support for children, and benefits to people who have lost their jobs. These are called transfers, because money is moved from taxpayers to the household without the household supplying anything in return at that moment.

The Mensah family's $4 000 is typical. It is $3 600 of wages from two jobs, $300 of profit from their weekend food stall, $50 of interest on their savings, and a $50 transfer for their youngest child.

Stop and think

The Mensah family sells their old car for $2 000. Is the $2 000 part of their income this month?

Show the answer

No. Income is a payment for supplying a factor of production, or a transfer. Selling the car supplies no factor. The family simply swaps one thing they own, a car, for another, $2 000 in money. They are no richer than before the sale. This is why economists keep income, a flow of payments over a period of time, apart from wealth, the stock of things a household owns at one moment. The car was part of the family's wealth, and so is the money.

Three places the money goes

Every dollar of income ends up in one of three places.

First, some is taken in tax. Income tax is usually taken before the household even sees its pay. What is left is called disposable income: the income a household is free to dispose of, to use as it chooses. For the Mensah family, disposable income is $4 000 − $500 = $3 500.

Second, most disposable income is spent on consumption: goods and services that are used up now. Rent for the home, food, bus fares, a haircut, electricity and a concert ticket are all consumption. Each one gives the household something it uses today.

Third, whatever is not consumed is saving. This is the key point, and it answers the puzzle. Saving is not defined by where money is put. It is defined as the part of disposable income that is not consumed.

Where household income goes

Income = tax + consumption + saving

Disposable income = income − tax = consumption + saving

So saving = disposable income − consumption. The saving rate is saving as a percentage of disposable income.

Income: $4 000 Disposable income: $3 500 Tax $500 Consumption $3 000 Saving $500 An invented household, one month
The Mensah family's month. Tax is taken first. Of the $3 500 left, $3 000 is consumed and $500 is saved. The saving rate is 500 ÷ 3 500 ≈ 14.3%.

One tax needs care. In many countries, a sales tax is included in the price of goods in the shop. When the Mensah family buy a $20 shirt, part of the $20 goes to the government. But from the household's side, the whole $20 is spending on a shirt. So taxes on spending sit inside consumption in this picture. Only taxes taken directly from income, such as income tax, are counted in the tax slice. The lecture on direct and indirect taxes looks at the two kinds side by side.

Saving is what you do not consume

Now the puzzle is easy. The Mensah family's disposable income was $3 500. They consumed $3 000. So they saved $500.

The $200 in the bank and the $300 of shares are not two different things. They are two places where the same $500 of saving went. A household can keep its saving in many forms: notes in a box at home, a bank account, shares, or a piece of land. Paying back part of a loan is also saving, because the household gives up consumption now to owe less later. In each case, the money is not used up this month. It is kept, in some form, for the future.

That is it. That is the whole idea. Consumption is the opposite of saving. Where the saving is kept is a separate question.

Notice one word. In everyday speech, buying shares is called "investing". Economists use "investment" for something narrower: spending by firms on new capital, such as machines and buildings. A family that buys existing shares from another owner has not built any new capital. It has chosen a place to keep its saving. The difference matters in later lectures, so keep the two words apart now.

Saving can also be negative. A household that spends more than its disposable income in a month must borrow, or use savings from earlier months. Economists call this negative saving, or dissaving. A student living on a loan, a retired couple living on past savings, and a family hit by a large hospital bill may all have negative saving for a while.

Now or later: the choice on every pay day

Every household faces the same choice each month. A dollar can be consumed now, or saved and used later. This is the opportunity cost idea from earlier in the course. The opportunity cost of $100 of saving is the $100 of things the family could have bought today. The opportunity cost of spending it is the larger amount, with interest, that it could have become.

Households save for reasons you can probably list. Families save for emergencies, such as a lost job or an illness. They save for large purchases, such as a home, or for school and university fees. And they save for old age, when they will stop working and their wages will stop.

But saving is much easier for some households than for others. A household must pay for food, rent and transport before it can save at all. When income is low, these needs can take nearly all of it. When income is higher, the needs are covered and there is room left over. So the share of income that a household saves usually rises as its income rises. The same idea shows up very clearly in what households buy.

Richer households spend more on food, and less of their budget

In 1857, the German statistician Ernst Engel studied the budgets of Belgian working families, collected a few years earlier by Édouard Ducpétiaux. He found a pattern. The poorer the family, the larger the share of its spending that went on food. It is now called Engel's law.

The pattern has two halves, and students often keep only one. A richer household usually spends more dollars on food than a poorer one. It buys better food, more meat, more meals out. But food takes a smaller share of its budget, because its spending on everything else grows faster. Both halves are true at once.

The model below is invented, but it follows Engel's pattern. Change the household's disposable income and watch food, other spending and saving.

Explore — a household's budget as income changes (invented model)

Change the monthly disposable income with the slider or the buttons. In this invented model, spending is $900 plus 60 cents of every dollar of income, and food is $380 plus 12 cents of every dollar.

This table shows the invented household's month at three levels of disposable income. Spending is $900 plus 60 cents of every dollar of income; food is $380 plus 12 cents of every dollar.

IncomeSpendingFood
(share)
Saving
(rate)
$1 500$1 800$560
(31.1%)
−$300
(−20.0%)
$3 500$3 000$800
(26.7%)
$500
(14.3%)
$8 000$5 700$1 340
(23.5%)
$2 300
(28.8%)

As income rises, the dollars spent on food rise, but food's share of spending falls, and the saving rate rises. Below an income of $2 250, this household spends more than it earns. The model leaves out debts, prices that differ between places, and the size of the household.

You should have seen both halves of Engel's law. At $1 500 the household spends $560 on food, and at $8 000 it spends $1 340: more dollars. But food falls from about 31% of spending to about 24%. You should also have seen the saving rate climb, and below $2 250 turn negative.

The real world shows the same pattern across countries. The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) compares household spending in more than a hundred countries. In 2022, households in Nigeria, Kenya, Myanmar and Bangladesh spent more than half of their consumer spending on food. In the United States and the United Kingdom, food bought from shops for eating at home was less than 10% of consumer spending in 2015 (USDA Economic Research Service). Households in poorer countries are not making a mistake. Food comes first, and when income is low, it takes most of the budget.

A real case: the year shops closed

The idea that saving is "whatever is not consumed" makes a sharp prediction. Here is a case where the world tested it.

What happened to households. In spring 2020, many countries closed shops, restaurants and cinemas to slow the spread of COVID-19. In the United States, the government also sent one-off payments to most households, a transfer, and paid larger benefits to people who lost their jobs.

The prediction. Use the identity: saving = disposable income − consumption. Many people lost wages, but the transfers were large. So disposable income might hold up, or even rise. Consumption, meanwhile, had to fall, because many things simply could not be bought. A smaller consumption taken from a similar income leaves a larger remainder. So saving, and the saving rate, should jump.

What happened. The US Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) measures exactly these quantities each month. In April 2020, wages and salaries fell by about 8%. But government payments to persons rose so much that total personal income rose by 10.5%, and consumer spending fell by 13.6% (BEA, Personal Income and Outlays, April 2020, published 29 May 2020). The personal saving rate went from 7.5% in February 2020 to 31.8% in April, by far the highest in its monthly records. (BEA's first estimate was 33.0%; the figures here are the revised ones.) As shops reopened, it fell back, to 18.3% by June.

Verdict. The prediction was right, and for exactly the reason the identity gives. Households did not suddenly decide to become careful. Their consumption was blocked, and their incomes were supported, so the remainder grew. This shows why the definition matters. A family that could not go out to eat "saved" the money whether or not they ever visited a bank. It also shows the limit of one month's figure. A saving rate of almost a third was not a new habit. It was the arithmetic of an unusual month.

Worked examples

Worked Example 1 — A monthly budget

An invented household has take-home pay of $3 600 a month, after income tax. It spends $1 000 on rent, $600 on food, $200 on transport, $300 on school costs, $200 on electricity, water and phone, and $300 on clothes and outings. Find its saving and its saving rate.

Think first. Take-home pay is disposable income, because the tax has already gone. Add the consumption, then subtract.

Consumption: $1 000 + $600 + $200 + $300 + $200 + $300 = $2 600.

Saving: $3 600 − $2 600 = $1 000.

Saving rate: 1 000 ÷ 3 600 × 100 ≈ 27.8%.

Check. $2 600 + $1 000 = $3 600, so every dollar is accounted for. ✓ Always make this check: consumption plus saving must equal disposable income.

Worked Example 2 — Negative saving

An invented retired couple receive a pension of $1 800 a month, a transfer from the government, and $200 of interest on their savings. They pay $100 in income tax. They spend $2 300 a month. What is their saving, and how do they pay for their spending?

Think first. Find disposable income first, then compare it with consumption.

Income: $1 800 + $200 = $2 000. Disposable income: $2 000 − $100 = $1 900.

Saving: $1 900 − $2 300 = −$400.

Their saving is negative. They spend $400 a month more than their disposable income, so they take $400 a month from savings built up while they were working.

Check. This is what saving for old age is for: positive saving while working, negative saving after. ✓

Three traps

Trap 1 — Saving means money in the bank

Saving is disposable income that is not consumed, wherever it is kept. Money in a box at home, shares and paying back a loan are all saving. Buying a meal is not, even if you paid with money from your savings account.

Trap 2 — Counting a sale of something you own as income

Selling a car, a phone or shares is not income. It swaps one form of wealth for another. Income is a payment for supplying a factor of production, or a transfer, over a period of time.

Trap 3 — "Richer households spend less on food"

They usually spend more dollars on food. What falls is the share of their budget that goes on food. Always say whether you mean the amount or the share.

Try it yourself

Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.

  1. For each payment, say whether it is wages, rent, interest, profit or a transfer: (a) Ana is paid $15 an hour at a supermarket. (b) Kwame lets a field to a farmer. (c) Mei receives a monthly pension from the government. (d) Rahul keeps what is left after paying the costs of his phone-repair stall. (e) Siosaia's bank adds $12 to her savings account.

    Hint 1

    Ask what the person supplied. If they supplied nothing in return, it is a transfer.

    Hint 2

    A field is land. Savings lent through a bank pay for capital.

    Full answer

    (a) Wages: Ana supplies labour. (b) Rent: Kwame supplies land. (c) A transfer: Mei supplies no factor this month. (d) Profit: Rahul organises the stall and takes the risk, so he supplies enterprise. (e) Interest: Siosaia's savings are lent on to pay for capital. Check: each answer names the factor supplied, or says that none was. ✓

  2. An invented household earns $2 400 in wages and $250 in profit from a small business, and receives a $150 transfer. It pays $300 in income tax and spends $2 300. Find its income, its disposable income, its saving and its saving rate.

    Hint 1

    Add every source, including the transfer, to find income.

    Hint 2

    The saving rate divides saving by disposable income, not by income.

    Full answer

    Income: $2 400 + $250 + $150 = $2 800. Disposable income: $2 800 − $300 = $2 500. Saving: $2 500 − $2 300 = $200. Saving rate: 200 ÷ 2 500 × 100 = 8%. Check: $300 + $2 300 + $200 = $2 800, so tax, consumption and saving add up to income. ✓

  3. Two invented families live in the same town. Family A spends $1 500 a month, of which $450 is food. Family B spends $6 000 a month, of which $900 is food. Which family spends more on food? Which spends a larger share of its budget on food? Explain how this fits Engel's law.

    Hint 1

    Compare the dollar amounts first, then the percentages.

    Hint 2

    Share = food ÷ all spending × 100.

    Full answer

    Family B spends more on food: $900 against $450. But food is 450 ÷ 1 500 × 100 = 30% of Family A's spending and only 900 ÷ 6 000 × 100 = 15% of Family B's. This is Engel's law: the richer family spends more dollars on food, but a smaller share. Check: B's food spending is twice A's, while B's total spending is four times A's, so B's share must be half of A's. ✓

  4. A stretch. Use the Mensah family: disposable income $3 500, consumption $3 000. (a) A lockdown blocks 30% of their usual spending, and their income does not change. Find their new saving and saving rate. (b) The government also gives them a one-off transfer of $600 that month, which is not taxed. Find the saving and saving rate now. (c) What do you predict happens to their saving rate when the shops reopen, and why?

    Hint 1

    30% of $3 000 is blocked, so consumption becomes 70% of $3 000.

    Hint 2

    In (b), the transfer raises disposable income, not consumption.

    Full answer

    (a) Consumption: 0.7 × $3 000 = $2 100. Saving: $3 500 − $2 100 = $1 400. Saving rate: 1 400 ÷ 3 500 × 100 = 40%, up from about 14.3%.

    (b) Disposable income: $3 500 + $600 = $4 100. Saving: $4 100 − $2 100 = $2 000. Saving rate: 2 000 ÷ 4 100 × 100 ≈ 48.8%.

    (c) When the shops reopen, consumption returns towards $3 000 and the one-off transfer ends, so the saving rate falls back towards about 14%. It could even fall below that for a while, if the family spends some of the saving built up in the lockdown on things they could not buy before. Check: this matches the real US figures, which rose from 7.5% to 31.8% and then fell back as shops reopened. ✓

The bigger idea

Look at the Mensah family's $3 000 of consumption from the other side. Every dollar they spend is a dollar of sales for some firm: the landlord, the food market, the bus company. The firms use that money to pay wages, rent, interest and profit, which are the incomes of other households. One household's spending is another household's income. The next lecture follows this loop all the way round, and the picture it draws is called the circular flow.

Saving fits into the same picture. Saving kept in banks is lent to firms, which buy new machines and buildings with it. So a household's decision to consume less today can become the capital that raises what the economy produces tomorrow.

Key concepts in this lesson