A trade that both sides win, and a town that loses
The equilibrium lecture ended with a strong claim. At the equilibrium, every trade that both sides gain from takes place, and no other. It sounded perfect. But look at who was counted: one buyer and one seller. Nobody else.
Here is a trade that both sides win. In an invented town, a brick kiln sells loads of bricks to builders. Each builder has a highest price for one more load. The kiln has a lowest price for each load: the cost of making it, including what it gives up. A load is sold whenever the builder's highest price is at least the kiln's lowest price. So far, this is exactly the markets lecture.
Now add one fact. Firing each load sends smoke over the school next door. Children cough, and parents pay for medicine and lose days at work. Say the smoke from each load does $20 of harm to people who are not part of the trade.
Look at load 4. The builder would pay up to $70. The kiln would accept $55. They trade, and together they gain $15. But the smoke does $20 of harm next door. So the town as a whole is $5 worse off because load 4 was made.
Nobody did anything wrong. The builder and the kiln each made a sensible choice. The trouble is that the smoke has no price. Nobody pays for it, so nobody's choice takes it into account.
That is it. That is the whole idea of this lecture. A market counts only the gains and costs of the people in the trade. When a trade touches other people too, the market can get the quantity wrong.
What "market failure" means
The economic systems lecture said a market economy has weaknesses, and that a later lecture would look at them closely. This is that lecture. It promised three things: clean air, a road that everyone uses, and the weak signal sent by a family with little money. All three appear below, and the third turns out to be a different kind of problem.
A market failure happens when a market, left to itself, produces a quantity of something that is different from the quantity that is best for everyone affected.
The market makes too much of some things, too little of others, and sometimes none at all.
Notice two words in the definition. "Left to itself" means without rules, taxes or help from a government. "Everyone affected" means the buyer, the seller and anyone else the trade touches. A market failure is not a market that has stopped working. It is a market doing exactly what markets do, in a situation where that is not enough.
There are four common kinds. Each one has a different cause, so it helps to name them carefully.
Kind 1: harm to people outside the trade
The brick kiln is the first kind. A cost falls on people who are neither the buyer nor the seller. Economists call this an external cost, and the situation a negative externality. ("External" means outside: outside the trade.)
Examples are everywhere: smoke from a factory, waste in a river, noise from a road at night, a crowded beach where each extra visitor makes it worse for the others.
Why does the market make too much? Go back to the seller's lowest price. It includes every cost the seller pays. The smoke is a cost the seller does not pay. So the seller's lowest price is too low, compared with the true cost to the town. Too low a cost means too many units pass the test "highest price is at least lowest price". Some of those units cost the town more than they are worth.
Kind 2: benefit to people outside the trade
Now turn the story round. Some trades help people who are not part of them. This is an external benefit, and the situation is a positive externality.
A flu vaccination is the classic case. The person who is vaccinated is less likely to fall ill. That is the benefit they pay for. But they are also less likely to catch flu and pass it on, so the people around them are safer too. Nobody pays the vaccinated person for that. Other examples: a neighbour's flower garden that the whole street enjoys, or bees from one farm that pollinate the fruit trees on the next.
Here the market makes too little. The buyer's highest price includes only the benefit to the buyer. Some units would be worth making if the benefit to others were counted, but they fail the market's test, so they are never made.
Try both kinds in the model below. It uses the same eight loads as the picture above, but you choose what each unit does to the people outside the trade.
This is an invented market with eight units. Choose a preset, or move the slider to set what each unit does to people outside the trade. Watch which units the market trades, and which are worth making for everyone.
Presets:
What the model leaves out: real harms and benefits are hard to measure, they are not the same for every unit, and they may fall on people far away or not yet born.
The table shows the same invented market of eight units with three different effects on people outside the trade. The market always trades 4 units, because it does not see the effect.
| Effect of each unit on others | Market trades | Worth making for everyone | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| harm $20 | 4 | 3 | 1 unit too many; the town loses $5 |
| none | 4 | 4 | the right amount |
| benefit $20 | 4 | 5 | 1 unit too few; $15 of gain is missed |
| harm $40 | 4 | 2 | 2 units too many; the town loses $30 |
Whatever you chose, the market traded the same 4 units. It cannot react to something that has no price. Harm to others gave too many units, and benefit to others gave too few. Notice also the setting with only $10 of harm: the effect was real, but too small to change the answer. A market failure is about getting the quantity wrong, not about the effect existing at all.
If the smoke harms the neighbours by $20 a load, why don't the neighbours simply pay the kiln to make fewer loads?
Show the answer
Sometimes they can. If one neighbour is harmed by one kiln, the two may agree a deal. But smoke usually spreads over hundreds of people. Each one is harmed a little. Getting them all to agree, and to pay, is very hard. Each neighbour also hopes the others will pay, because a cleaner sky helps them either way.
So the deal that would fix the problem is rarely made. This is why most fixes come from a government rule, a tax or a payment. The next lecture looks at those tools.
Kind 3: things that are hard to sell
Some things are hard to sell at all. Think of a wall that protects a town from floods. Once it is built, it protects every house behind it. The builder cannot keep out the people who did not pay. And one more family living behind the wall does not leave less protection for anyone else.
A good with both of these features is called a public good. Street lighting and a town's fireworks display are other examples. So is the "road that everyone uses" from the economic systems lecture, as long as it is quiet and has no toll. (A crowded road, or one with a toll, is in between. The Upper Secondary lectures sort these cases.)
The problem is called free riding. In an invented village, 100 households each value a flood wall at $50, so together they value it at $5 000. The wall costs $3 000. It is clearly worth building. But a seller asks each household to pay, and each one thinks: "If the wall is built, it protects me whether I pay or not." Some pay, many wait for others, and the wall may never be built. So a market alone makes too little of a public good, and sometimes none.
Kind 4: when buyers misjudge
The last kind is different. Here the problem is not other people. It is the buyer's own judgement.
Markets trust each buyer's highest price. But a highest price is only as good as the buyer's information and patience. Someone who starts smoking at fifteen rarely weighs the illness it may bring at fifty. Someone saving for old age may save too little, because old age feels very far away.
Goods that people tend to use less than is good for them, such as vaccinations and schooling, are called merit goods. Goods that people tend to use more than is good for them, such as cigarettes, are called demerit goods. Be careful with these words. Deciding that people misjudge their own good is a judgement, and people disagree about where to draw the line.
Some goods fit more than one kind. Cigarettes harm the smoker, who may misjudge the risk. They also harm others through second-hand smoke. The World Health Organization estimates that second-hand smoke kills more than a million non-smokers a year. Its recent reports give figures between 1.3 and 1.6 million.
Now sort some cases yourself.
Put each card in the box that explains it. One box is for markets that are working well. Read the reason after each choice.
Ten cases, sorted into the four kinds of market failure and "market working".
- Harm to others: a factory's smoke drifts over a school; loud music from a late-night party keeps the street awake.
- Benefit to others: a neighbour's flower garden that the whole street enjoys; a vaccinated student is less likely to pass flu on.
- Hard to sell: a flood wall that protects every house behind it; a lighthouse that guides every passing ship.
- Buyers misjudge: teenagers start smoking without weighing the illness years later; people save too little for old age.
- Market working: mangoes cost more after a storm destroys half the crop; a popular new phone sells out, and its price rises until the queues go.
What market failure does not mean
Two cards went into "market working": the mangoes and the phone. This matters. A high price is not a market failure. When mangoes are scarce, a high price tells everyone to use them carefully, and it sends them to the people who value them most. That is the market doing its job.
Now the third promise from the economic systems lecture: a family with little money sends a weak signal. That is true, and it can be a serious problem. But it is a different problem. A market can make exactly the right quantity of rice and still share it in a way many people think is unfair. Economists keep the two questions apart. One asks "is the right amount made?" The other asks "is it shared fairly?" The lectures on taxes and government spending take up the second question.
Market failure also does not mean that markets are bad. Most goods you buy, from bread to bicycles, are made in roughly the right amounts by ordinary markets. Market failure names the particular situations where they are not. Good economics asks which situation you are in, then chooses the right response.
Real case: lead in petrol
The situation. In February 1923, petrol with lead added to it was first sold, in Dayton, Ohio, in the United States. The lead stopped car engines from "knocking", and it was cheap. Each sale suited the driver and the seller. But the lead came out of exhausts into the air, the dust and the soil. Everyone breathed it, including people who never owned a car. Lead harms the brain, and children are the most at risk. Within two years, workers making the additive had died of lead poisoning, and health experts had warned of the danger.
The market failure. This is Kind 1: harm to people outside the trade. The price of petrol included the cost of making it, but not the harm to everyone who breathed the lead. So leaded petrol stayed in use for decades.
The policy and the prediction. From the 1970s, the United States made refiners cut the lead in petrol, step by step. If the lead in petrol was harming people, then lead in people's blood should fall as the lead in petrol fell.
What happened. A national health survey measured blood lead across the country. Between 1976 and 1980, average blood lead in the United States fell by about 37%. The fall moved closely with the fall in lead used in petrol. The researchers found that changes in paint or diet were unlikely to explain it (Annest and others, New England Journal of Medicine, 1983). Leaded petrol for road vehicles was banned in the United States from 1 January 1996.
Other countries followed. In 2002 the UN Environment Programme (UNEP) began a campaign to end leaded petrol everywhere. The last country, Algeria, stopped selling it in July 2021. UNEP estimates that ending leaded petrol prevents more than 1.2 million early deaths a year and saves about US$2.45 trillion a year (UNEP, 30 August 2021).
Verdict. The market alone kept a harmful product for decades, because the harm had no price and was spread thinly over millions of people. A rule fixed what the market could not. Notice the time it took: more than 70 years from the first sale to the US ban, and almost a century worldwide. Harm that is spread thinly is hard to see, and hard to act on.
Market failure describes particular situations: harm or benefit to others, goods that are hard to sell, and buyers who misjudge. In most markets, prices do their job. Name the kind of failure before you say a market has failed.
The price a buyer pays is not an external cost, and neither is the seller's cost of materials. Both are inside the trade. An external cost falls on someone who is neither the buyer nor the seller. Ask: who pays, and were they part of the trade?
Governments run many schools and hospitals, but a school can keep out people who do not pay. A public good is defined by its features, not by who provides it: non-payers cannot be kept out, and one person's use does not leave less for others.
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.
-
Name the kind of market failure, if any, in each case. (a) A farm's fertiliser runs into a lake and kills the fish that other people catch. (b) A city puts on a free fireworks display over the harbour. (c) Concert tickets for a famous band are expensive because many people want them. (d) People who learn first aid sometimes save a stranger's life.
Hint 1
For each case, ask who gains or loses, and whether they were part of the trade.
Hint 2
One case is a market working. One is a good that is hard to sell.
Full answer
(a) Harm to others: the people who fish were not part of the farm's trades. (b) Hard to sell: anyone near the harbour can watch, and one more viewer does not spoil the view. (c) Market working: a high price shares out scarce tickets. (d) Benefit to others: the stranger gains, and nobody paid the first-aider for that. Check: every case was placed by asking who is affected, not by whether the price seemed fair. ✓
-
An invented paint factory can sell six tins a day. Buyers' highest prices for the tins are $60, $50, $40, $30, $20 and $10. The factory's lowest prices are $12, $22, $32, $42, $52 and $62. Fumes from each tin cause $15 of harm to neighbours. How many tins does the market sell? How many are worth making for everyone? What does the extra tin cost the town?
Hint 1
The market sells a tin when the highest price is at least the lowest price.
Hint 2
For everyone, add $15 to each lowest price, then use the same test.
Full answer
Market: tin 1 (60 ≥ 12), tin 2 (50 ≥ 22), tin 3 (40 ≥ 32) sell; tin 4 does not (30 < 42). So 3 tins. For everyone, the costs are $27, $37, $47, …: tins 1 and 2 pass (60 ≥ 27, 50 ≥ 37), tin 3 does not (40 < 47). So 2 tins. On tin 3, buyer and seller gain $40 − $32 = $8 together, but the neighbours lose $15. The town is $7 worse off. Check: 40 + (−15) − 32 = −7. ✓
-
In an invented village, 100 households each value a new flood wall at $50. The wall costs $3 000. (a) Is it worth building? (b) A builder asks for voluntary payments, and 40 households pay $50 each. What happens? (c) The village council instead charges every household $30. Is each household better off?
Hint 1
Compare the total value with the cost.
Hint 2
In (b), compare the money raised with the cost. In (c), compare each household's $50 of value with its $30 charge.
Full answer
(a) Yes: total value $5 000 is more than the $3 000 cost. (b) Only $2 000 is raised, so the wall is not built, although everyone would gain from it. The other 60 households hoped to ride free. (c) The charge raises 100 × $30 = $3 000, enough to build it. Each household gets $50 of protection for $30, so each is $20 better off. Check: total gain 100 × $20 = $2 000 = $5 000 − $3 000. ✓
-
An invented beekeeper earns $100 of honey from each hive. The cost of her 1st to 5th hives is $50, $80, $110, $140 and $170. Each hive's bees also pollinate a neighbour's apple trees, worth $50 to the neighbour. (a) How many hives does she keep on her own? (b) How many are best for both of them? (c) The neighbour offers to pay her $45 for each hive. How many does she keep now?
Hint 1
She keeps a hive when what it earns her is at least what it costs.
Hint 2
For both of them, each hive is worth $100 + $50 = $150. With the offer, it earns her $145.
Full answer
(a) Hives costing $50 and $80 pass; $110 does not. So 2 hives. (b) At $150 a hive, hives costing up to $140 pass. So 4 hives. The market alone makes 2 too few. (c) At $145, hives costing up to $140 still pass, so she keeps 4. The deal fixes the failure. This works because only two people are involved, unlike the smoke over a whole town. Real fruit growers do pay beekeepers to bring hives in some places, a case studied by the economist Steven Cheung in 1973. Check: hive 4 earns her $145 against a cost of $140, and hive 5 earns $145 against $170. ✓
The idea of costs and benefits outside the market was set out by the economist Arthur Pigou in 1920, in a book called The Economics of Welfare. It changed the question people ask about markets. The question is not "markets or government?" It is "in this situation, does the price carry all the information that matters?"
When it does, a market is a remarkable machine for making the right amount. When it does not, someone has to add the missing information. That might be a rule, as with lead in petrol, a tax, a payment, or a deal between neighbours. But governments can make mistakes too, and a fix can cost more than the failure it corrects. The next lecture looks at the tools governments use. Later lectures look at what happens when those tools go wrong.
- A market failure happens when a market, left to itself, makes a quantity that differs from the quantity that is best for everyone affected.
- Harm to people outside a trade (an external cost) leads a market to make too much, because sellers do not count it.
- Benefit to people outside a trade (an external benefit) leads a market to make too little, because buyers do not count it.
- A public good cannot be kept from non-payers and is not used up by one more user, so free riding leaves the market making too little.
- When buyers misjudge their own gain, merit goods are used too little and demerit goods too much.
- A high price or an unfair sharing of goods is not a market failure in this sense; fairness is a separate question.