Ama's oven breaks
The supply lecture left Ama, the baker, with a problem. Her oven breaks. Nothing has happened to the price of pastries. Her customers want the same pastries at the same prices as last week. Yet she will bake fewer.
The supply curve cannot show this as a movement. A movement along the curve needs a change in the price, and the price has not changed. Something else has changed: what it costs Ama to bake each batch. The lecture promised to show how to draw that. Here it is.
The answer mirrors the demand side: when something other than the price changes the sellers' list, the whole curve moves. This lecture shows which changes do that, and which way. Then it tests the idea on a real market that lost millions of hens in one year.
Every shift starts with a lowest price
Go back to where the supply list came from. Each unit a seller could offer has a lowest price: the cost of producing it, including what the seller gives up. At each price, the quantity supplied counts every unit whose lowest price is that price or less.
So the list can change in only two ways. This is the same idea as the two routes for demand.
- Route 1: the lowest prices change. If producing each unit costs more, every lowest price rises. At any price you choose, fewer units are covered, so fewer are offered. If producing each unit costs less, the opposite happens.
- Route 2: the number of sellers changes. A new seller brings a whole new set of units to the list. A seller who leaves takes theirs away.
Either way, the quantity supplied changes at many prices at once. That is a shift of the supply curve.
An increase in supply means more is offered at every price: the supply curve shifts to the right, from S₁ to S₂. A decrease in supply means less is offered at every price: the curve shifts to the left.
A supply curve shifts only when something other than the good's own price changes.
A rise in cost, step by step
This example is invented. In the supply lecture, Ama's five batches of 40 pastries had lowest prices of $0.80, $1.00, $1.40, $1.90 and $2.50 per pastry. Now the price of flour rises, and each pastry needs $0.30 more flour. What happens to her supply?
Think first. Does the extra cost affect one batch or all of them?
All of them. Every pastry uses flour, so every batch's lowest price rises by $0.30. The new lowest prices are $1.10, $1.30, $1.70, $2.20 and $2.80. Now count the batches covered at each price, as before.
| Price per pastry ($) | Before (pastries per day) | After (pastries per day) |
|---|---|---|
| 1.00 | 80 | 0 |
| 1.50 | 120 | 80 |
| 2.00 | 160 | 120 |
| 2.50 | 200 | 160 |
| 3.00 | 200 | 200 |
At $2.00, the fourth batch used to cost $1.90 a pastry, and the price covered it. Now it costs $2.20, and the price does not. So Ama bakes 120 pastries instead of 160. The same happens at almost every price: she offers less. That is a decrease in supply, a shift to the left.
Check. At $3.00 nothing changes. Even the dearest batch now costs only $2.80, so all five are still covered. Her kitchen's limit of five batches decides the quantity there, not the cost. ✓ A decrease in supply means less or the same at each price, and never more. ✓
Look at the picture in two ways. Read across at any price, and the new staircase is to the left: fewer pastries. Read up at any quantity, and the new staircase is higher by exactly $0.30: to bake the same number, Ama now needs a price $0.30 higher. Left and up are the same move, seen from two directions.
That is it. That is the whole idea. Anything that raises the cost of each unit raises the sellers' lowest prices, and the supply curve moves up, which is to the left. Anything that lowers the cost moves it down, which is to the right.
What changes the sellers' lowest prices?
Every factor below works through route 1, the lowest prices, or route 2, the number of sellers. For each one, ask: does it make each unit cost more to produce, or less?
- 1. The prices of inputs. Inputs are the materials and factors of production a seller buys: flour, fuel, fertiliser, electricity, the wages of workers, the rent of a shop. When an input costs more, supply decreases (left). When it costs less, supply increases (right).
- 2. Technology. Better technology means more output from the same inputs. So each unit uses fewer inputs and costs less. Supply increases (right). It can also make sellers able to produce more than before, as a bigger oven would.
- 3. Taxes and subsidies on production. A tax charged on each unit sold is one more cost per unit, so supply decreases. A subsidy is a payment from the government for each unit produced. It works like a fall in cost, so supply increases.
- 4. Nature. Weather, floods and disease change how much a farm can produce from its land and animals. A drought or a disease decreases supply. An unusually good season increases it.
- 5. The prices of other goods the seller could make. Ama's oven could bake cakes instead of pastries. If cakes start to sell for much more, each batch of pastries now gives up more. Her lowest prices for pastries rise, and her supply of pastries decreases. This is the opportunity cost from the supply lecture, at work again.
- 6. The number of sellers. This is route 2. New firms joining a market increase supply. Firms leaving decrease it.
Try them on Ama's kitchen. Choose an event and watch her staircase. The old staircase S₁ stays in place, so you can see which way the new one went.
Choose an event. The dashed staircase S₁ is Ama's supply before the event, and S₂ is her supply after it. Then change the price to compare the two staircases at any price.
This box shows how seven events change Ama's supply. Her lowest prices per pastry start at $0.80, $1.00, $1.40, $1.90 and $2.50 for five batches of 40.
| Event | At $1.20 | At $2.00 | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Before any event | 80 | 160 | S₁ |
| Flour +$0.30 | 40 | 120 | left |
| Flour −$0.20 | 120 | 160 | right |
| Faster oven | 120 | 200 | right |
| Tax $0.40 | 40 | 120 | left |
| Subsidy $0.30 | 120 | 160 | right |
| Oven breaks | 0 | 120 | left |
| Price $2.00 → $2.50 | 160 → 200 | along S₁ | |
Quantities are pastries per day. The faster oven bakes six batches at $0.70, $0.80, $1.00, $1.30, $1.70 and $2.30. When her oven breaks, she rents a neighbour's oven at night: each pastry costs $0.50 more, and there is time for only four batches. A rise in the price of pastries changes no cost, so the staircase stays where it is and Ama moves along it.
You should have seen three patterns. Every event that raised a cost moved the staircase left, and every event that lowered a cost moved it right. The tax worked exactly like a rise in the cost of flour: for the seller, a tax per unit is a cost per unit. And the last event moved nothing. A higher price for pastries changes no cost, so Ama simply bakes more on the staircase she already had.
A tax of $0.40 is charged on every pastry. A student writes: "The supply curve shifts left by $0.40." Another writes: "The supply curve shifts up by $0.40." Which is right?
Show the answer
The second. The tax raises every lowest price by exactly $0.40, so every point of the curve moves up by exactly $0.40. "Left by $0.40" mixes up the two axes. Left and right are measured in quantity, in pastries, not in dollars. How far left the curve moves depends on how steep it is. At $2.00, Ama's quantity falls by 40 pastries. At $3.00 it does not fall at all, because her kitchen limit decides it there. So say it this way: the curve shifts left, and it moves up by exactly the tax.
Technology: the puzzle from the oil fields
The supply lecture ended with a puzzle. From mid-2014 to early 2016, the world price of oil fell by about three-quarters. Between October 2014 and May 2016, the number of rigs drilling for oil in the United States fell by about 80%. Yet US oil output in May 2016 was only about 2% below its level in October 2014.
Part of the answer was that old wells keep flowing. The other part is technology. The US Energy Information Administration (EIA) reported that oil from each new rig in the main shale regions was more than twice its 2013 level, because drilling methods had improved. (Source: EIA, Today in Energy, 5 August 2016.)
Now read that as an economist. Each rig now brought in much more new oil than before, with about the same crew and equipment. So the cost of each barrel fell, and many wells now had a lower lowest price per barrel than before. At any oil price, more barrels were worth producing. The supply curve shifted right.
So two things happened at once. The falling price moved the oil companies down along their supply curve, so they drilled far fewer wells. At the same time, better technology shifted the curve to the right. The shift held up output, even with 80% fewer rigs. Seeing the shift explains a result the law of supply alone could not.
Technology changes supply in many markets in the same way. The International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) reported that the cost of building a large solar power plant, per unit of capacity, fell by 81% worldwide between 2010 and 2020. It named improving technology, production on a larger scale, competition among suppliers and more experienced builders as the causes. (Source: IRENA, Renewable Power Generation Costs in 2020, 2021.) At any price for electricity, far more solar plants were now worth building.
More sellers or fewer
This example is invented. In the supply lecture, three bakeries, run by Ama, Tomás and Mei, supplied the market. A fourth baker, Kofi, opens a shop on the same street. Here is the market supply before and after, in pastries per day.
| Price per pastry ($) | Market before | Kofi | Market after |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 120 | 30 | 150 |
| 2 | 300 | 70 | 370 |
| 3 | 420 | 100 | 520 |
| 4 | 470 | 120 | 590 |
Think first. Did any seller's costs change?
No. Ama, Tomás and Mei offer exactly what they offered before. But market supply adds every seller's quantity at the same price, and now there is one more seller to add. So the market offers more at every price, and the market supply curve shifts right. This is route 2.
Check. At $2: . ✓ Every row of the new column is larger than the old one, so it is an increase at every price. ✓
If Mei closed her bakery instead, the market would lose her column, and supply would decrease.
Shift first, movement after
Real events often cause a shift and a movement one after the other. Students lose marks when they mix up the two. Here is a chain of reasoning about an invented town with one mistake in it. Find it.
One line of this explanation is wrong. Tap the line you think is wrong.
This box shows an explanation of a drought, with one wrong line.
- A drought destroys part of the vegetable crop on the town's farms.
- At every price, farmers can now offer fewer vegetables than before.
- So the supply curve of vegetables shifts to the left, from S₁ to S₂.
- With fewer vegetables on offer, the market price of vegetables rises.
- The wrong line: "The higher price then shifts the supply curve back to the right." A good's own price never shifts its own supply curve. The higher price only moves farmers along S₂.
- Farmers whose crops survived offer more at the higher price: a movement along the new curve, S₂.
The correct chain has one shift and one movement. The drought shifts the curve. The price change that follows moves sellers along the new curve. Always ask the same question about each step: did the good's own price cause it, or did something else?
A real case: when the hens fell ill
The situation. In February 2022, a deadly form of bird flu, highly pathogenic avian influenza, reached commercial poultry farms in the United States. Many infected birds die. To stop the disease spreading, all the birds on an infected farm are culled. By the end of December 2022, more than 43 million egg-laying hens had been lost. The losses came in two waves: 30.7 million from February to June, and 12.6 million from September to December.
The prediction. This is nature, cause 4. Fewer hens means fewer eggs can be produced at any price. Supply should decrease: the supply curve of eggs shifts left. The equilibrium lectures will show that a decrease in supply, with demand unchanged, should push the price up.
What happened. The flock shrank, production fell, and prices rose much more steeply than production fell.
| Measure | Figure |
|---|---|
| Egg-laying hens lost to bird flu, February to December 2022 | over 43 million |
| Flock of egg-laying hens, November 2022 | 308.8 million, 5.5% fewer than a year earlier |
| Egg production, November 2022 | 635.0 million dozen, 5.3% less than a year earlier |
| Average price of a dozen large eggs in US cities | $1.93 (January 2022) → $4.82 (January 2023) |
(Sources: USDA Economic Research Service, Chart of Note, 11 January 2023, and Livestock, Dairy, and Poultry Outlook, January 2023; US Bureau of Labor Statistics average price data.)
Verdict. The prediction came true. The supply of eggs decreased, the quantity produced fell, and the price rose. Two details are worth noticing. First, the price rose by about 150% while production fell by only about 5%. Buyers do not easily give up eggs, so a small fall in supply moved the price a lot; a later lecture on elasticity measures this. Second, other things were not perfectly equal: the USDA noted that demand for eggs stayed strong through the year. The story also has a second half. As farmers restocked their flocks, the curve shifted back to the right, and by May 2023 the average price had fallen to $2.67.
Three traps
When costs rise, the supply curve moves up, and students often call this an increase. It is a decrease. Up means sellers need a higher price for each quantity, so at each price they offer less. Describe supply shifts as left (decrease) and right (increase), and use "up" only to say how much the price needed for each unit has risen.
A change in a good's own price never shifts its own supply curve. In the drought, the price rise came after the shift and moved farmers along S₂. If you find yourself drawing a second shift because the price changed, you have counted one event twice.
A supply curve does not show sellers choosing a price. It shows what they would offer at each possible price. A rise in costs decreases supply. The price that buyers actually pay is then settled by supply and demand together, in the equilibrium lectures. Say "supply decreased", not "the price went up because sellers raised it".
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.
-
For a rice farmer's supply of rice, say whether each event shifts the supply curve left, shifts it right, or causes a movement along it. Give the reason. (a) The price of fertiliser falls. (b) A new rice variety gives 30% more grain per field. (c) A flood ruins half the fields. (d) The price of rice rises.
Hint 1
First ask: is the event a change in the price of rice itself? If so, it is a movement.
Hint 2
For the others, ask whether each kilogram of rice now costs more or less to produce.
Full answer
(a) Right. Fertiliser is an input, so each kilogram costs less to grow (cause 1). (b) Right. Technology gives more grain from the same field, seed and work, so each kilogram costs less (cause 2). (c) Left. Nature has destroyed part of what the farmer can produce (cause 4). (d) A movement along the supply curve: the quantity supplied rises, but supply does not change. Check: only (d) involves the price of rice itself, and it is the only one that is not a shift. ✓
-
In the supply lecture, the eight students of a cooking club had lowest prices of $1.00, $1.50, $2.00 and so on up to $4.50 a cup. Each makes at most 3 cups of juice a day. Now fruit costs $0.50 more per cup. (a) Write the new supply schedule for prices of $1.50, $2.50 and $3.50. (b) Compare it with the old schedule (6, 12 and 18 cups at those prices). Describe the shift in two ways.
Hint 1
Add $0.50 to every student's lowest price. Then count again.
Hint 2
The new lowest prices are $1.50, $2.00, … up to $5.00. At $2.50, who still makes juice?
Full answer
(a) New lowest prices: $1.50, $2.00, $2.50, $3.00, $3.50, $4.00, $4.50 and $5.00. At $1.50, one student: 3 cups. At $2.50, three students: 9 cups. At $3.50, five students: 15 cups. (b) At each of these prices, the club offers 3 cups fewer: supply has decreased, a shift to the left. Read the other way, every quantity now needs a price $0.50 higher: the curve has moved up by exactly $0.50. This is the shift from S₁ to S₂ in the first figure of this lecture. Check: at $2.50 the old schedule gave 12 cups, and . ✓
-
In the supply lecture, 20 students offered to walk dogs, one dog each per day. Their lowest prices were $2 (3 students), $3 (4 students), $4 (5 students), $5 (6 students) and $6 (2 students). The school now pays a subsidy of $1 for each walk. (a) Write the new supply schedule at prices from $1 to $6. (b) How many more walks are offered at $3? Is this a shift or a movement?
Hint 1
A subsidy lowers every lowest price by the amount of the subsidy.
Hint 2
The new lowest prices are $1 (3 students), $2 (4 students), and so on.
Full answer
(a) New schedule: $1: 3. $2: . $3: . $4: . $5: . $6: 20 walks per day. (b) At $3, the old schedule gave 7 walks and the new one gives 12, so 5 more. It is a shift to the right, an increase in supply: the price of a walk has not changed, but each student's lowest price has. Check: at $6 both schedules give all 20 students, because every student was already walking at $6. ✓
-
A stretch. In the same month, two things happen to Ama: flour costs $0.30 more per pastry, and she buys the faster oven. With the oven alone, her lowest prices would be $0.70, $0.80, $1.00, $1.30, $1.70 and $2.30 for six batches of 40. (a) Find her new lowest prices with both changes. (b) Compare her quantity supplied with the original S₁ at $1.00 and at $2.00. (c) Did her supply increase or decrease?
Hint 1
The flour cost applies to every pastry, so add $0.30 to every one of the oven's lowest prices.
Hint 2
Her original S₁ gave 80 pastries at $1.00 and 160 at $2.00. Count the new batches covered at each price.
Full answer
(a) $1.00, $1.10, $1.30, $1.60, $2.00 and $2.60. (b) At $1.00, one batch is covered: 40 pastries, compared with 80 before. At $2.00, five batches are covered: 200 pastries, compared with 160 before. (c) Neither answer is complete on its own. At low prices her supply fell. On the first two batches the oven saves only $0.10 and $0.20, less than the $0.30 of extra flour. At higher prices her supply rose. On the later batches the oven saves $0.40 or more, and it adds a sixth batch. When two changes pull in opposite directions, the result depends on their sizes, and here it even depends on the price. Check: and , so at exactly $1.00 and $2.00 those batches are just covered. ✓
Look at what every supply shift in this lecture had in common. Each one changed what it costs to produce one more unit, or how many sellers there were to produce it. A supply curve is a picture of costs. When you see it move, ask what happened to costs.
This links back to the production possibility frontier. Better technology and more resources shift a country's frontier outwards, because the economy can produce more from what it has. The same improvements, seen inside one market, shift that market's supply curve to the right. Over long periods, this is one reason why goods that were once rare and dear, such as printed books or cloth, became cheap. Their lists of lowest prices kept moving down. The next lecture puts the two lists, demand and supply, on one diagram and finds the price where they meet.
- A supply curve shifts only when something other than the good's own price changes the sellers' list.
- Every shift works by changing sellers' lowest prices, the cost of producing each unit, or by changing the number of sellers.
- Higher input prices, taxes, bad weather or disease, and better prices for other goods the seller could make decrease supply: the curve shifts left.
- Lower input prices, better technology, subsidies and more sellers increase supply: the curve shifts right.
- A rise in costs moves the supply curve up, which is the same as left, so "up" means a decrease in supply.
- A change in the good's own price causes a movement along the supply curve, never a shift.