A disease on the farm, a higher price in the shop
In January 2022, a dozen large eggs in the United States cost $1.93 on average. A year later, they cost $4.82: two and a half times as much. Over the same year, an outbreak of bird flu killed or forced the removal of more than 43 million egg-laying hens (sources: US Bureau of Labor Statistics average price data, via FRED; US Department of Agriculture, Economic Research Service, 11 January 2023).
The lecture on what shifts supply used this case to show supply falling: a disease is a change in nature, so the supply curve moved left. But it left one question open. Why should a disease on a farm raise the price that a shopper pays? The equilibrium lecture promised to answer it. This lecture does, and it gives you one method for every case like it.
The supply-shift lecture also said that a decrease in supply should push the price up, and that the equilibrium lectures would show exactly how far. That second promise is kept too, using the school fair.
The method in four steps
Every question of this kind asks the same thing: something changed, so what happens to the price and the quantity? Answer it in four steps, each with a reason.
- 1. Which curve moves? Ask whose plans have changed. A change for buyers (incomes, tastes, the prices of related goods) moves demand. A change for sellers (costs, technology, nature, the number of sellers) moves supply. A change in the good's own price moves neither: that is a movement along the curves.
- 2. Which way? More wanted or offered at every price means a shift right. Less means a shift left.
- 3. What happens at the old price? After the shift, the two plans no longer match at the old price. Is there a shortage or a surplus? The equilibrium lecture showed which way each one pushes the price.
- 4. Where is the new equilibrium? Find where the new curve crosses the curve that did not move. Compare the new price and quantity with the old.
Step 3 is the heart of the method. A shift does not change the price by itself. It creates a shortage or a surplus at the old price, and the people in the market then push the price, exactly as in the last lecture.
A supply shift at the fair
Go back to the fair. Leila's 24 classmates buy juice, the cooking club makes it, and the equilibrium is $2.50 and 12 cups a day. Now suppose fruit costs the club $1 more for every cup. Every club member's lowest price rises by $1.
Step 1: the change is a cost for the sellers, so supply moves. Demand does not: the classmates' highest prices are the same. Step 2: each member now needs $1 more per cup, so the supply curve moves up by $1, which is the same as left. The supply-shift lecture showed that left and up are the same move.
Step 3: at the old price of $2.50, the club now offers only 6 cups, because only the members whose old lowest price was $1.50 or less still cover their costs. Buyers still want 12. There is a shortage of 6, so the price is pushed up. Step 4: as the price rises, some classmates drop out (a movement along the demand curve), and more club members join in again (a movement along the new supply curve). The two plans meet at $3.00 and 9 cups.
Now the second promise: how far? The cost rose by $1, but the price rose by only $0.50. Why not the full dollar? Because at a price of $3.50, which would pass on the whole cost, only 6 classmates would buy, and 12 cups would be offered. That is a surplus, and it pushes the price back down. The price settles where buyers' and sellers' plans match, so the extra cost is shared. Buyers pay $0.50 more per cup, and the club keeps $0.50 less per cup after paying for fruit.
How the cost is shared depends on how steep the two curves are. Here they are equally steep, so the cost is split in half. If buyers hardly reacted to the price, sellers could pass on more of it. The Upper Secondary lecture on who really pays a tax works this out in full.
A student says: "The price of juice rose, so demand fell. Then the demand curve moved left too, and that is why fewer cups were sold." What has gone wrong?
Show the answer
Only one thing changed: the cost of fruit, which moved supply. Nothing changed for buyers. Their highest prices are the same, so the demand curve stays where it is. When the price rose, some classmates stopped buying, but that is a fall in the quantity demanded, a movement along the same demand curve. Shifting demand as well would count the same effect twice.
This example is invented. The equilibrium lecture's noodle-soup stalls had an equilibrium of $5 and 35 bowls a day. During a festival, visitors want 13 more bowls a day at every price. Find the new equilibrium.
Think first. Visitors are buyers, so demand moves, to the right. Add 13 to every quantity demanded, and leave supply alone.
| Price ($) | Quantity demanded, festival | Quantity supplied |
|---|---|---|
| 7 | 37 | 46 |
| 6 | 41 | 41 |
| 5 | 48 | 35 |
| 4 | 68 | 28 |
At the old price of $5, buyers now want 48 bowls but the stalls make 35: a shortage of 13. The price is pushed up. At $6, both are 41, so the new equilibrium is $6 and 41 bowls a day.
Check. A demand shift right should raise both the price and the quantity: $5 to $6, and 35 to 41. ✓ The quantity rose by 6, not by the full 13, because the higher price turned some festival buyers away. ✓
Try every change at the fair
The same four steps work for any change, on either side of the market. Try them below. For each event, decide which curve moves and which way before you press it.
Choose an event. The old curves stay dashed, the new curve is drawn solid, and the old and new equilibria are marked. Predict the direction of the price and the quantity before you look at the readout.
This table shows how each event moves the fair's market. On a hot day every classmate's highest price is $1 higher; on exam day it is $1 lower. Dearer or cheaper fruit changes every club member's lowest price by $1. Before any event, the equilibrium is $2.50 and 12 cups.
| Event | Curve that moves | At $2.50 | New price | New quantity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A hot day | demand, right | shortage of 6 | $3.00 | 15 |
| Exam day | demand, left | surplus of 6 | $2.00 | 9 |
| Fruit costs $1 more | supply, left | shortage of 6 | $3.00 | 9 |
| Fruit costs $1 less | supply, right | surplus of 6 | $2.00 | 15 |
| Hot day and dearer fruit | demand right, supply left | shortage of 12 | $3.50 | 12 |
| Hot day and cheaper fruit | demand right, supply right | no gap | $2.50 | 18 |
A demand shift moves the price and the quantity the same way. A supply shift moves them opposite ways. When both curves move, one of the two results depends on the sizes of the shifts.
You should have seen a pattern. A demand shift moves the price and the quantity in the same direction: a hot day raises both, and exam day lowers both. A supply shift moves them in opposite directions: dearer fruit raises the price but lowers the quantity. When both curves move, one result is certain and the other depends on the sizes. A hot day with dearer fruit certainly raises the price, but here the quantity ends up unchanged.
That is it. That is the whole idea. A shift creates a shortage or a surplus at the old price, and the market's push does the rest.
For each event, use the four steps. Put it in the box that shows what happens to the equilibrium price and quantity in that market.
This box sorts eight events by their effect on the equilibrium price and quantity.
- Price up, quantity up (demand right): a heatwave, in the market for ice cream · higher incomes, in the market for restaurant meals
- Price down, quantity down (demand left): a report that a snack is harmful · a cheaper substitute for tea, in the market for tea
- Price up, quantity down (supply left): a disease kills many egg-laying hens · bakers' wages rise, in the market for bread
- Price down, quantity up (supply right): a new machine halves the cost of making bicycles · a record mango harvest
A real case: eggs in the United States, 2022 to 2023
The situation. From February 2022, an outbreak of highly pathogenic avian influenza, a form of bird flu, spread through egg farms in the United States. Infected flocks had to be removed. By the end of 2022, more than 43 million egg-laying hens had been lost (source: USDA Economic Research Service, Chart of Note, 11 January 2023).
The prediction. Step 1: the disease affects sellers, so supply moves. Step 2: fewer hens means fewer eggs at every price, so supply shifts left. Step 3: at the old price there is a shortage, so the price is pushed up. Step 4: the new equilibrium has a higher price and a lower quantity.
What happened.
| Date | Average price, a dozen large eggs |
|---|---|
| January 2022 | $1.93 |
| January 2023 | $4.82 |
| May 2023 | $2.67 |
The USDA reported that in November 2022, the number of laying hens was 5.5% lower than a year earlier, and egg production was 5.3% lower. (Sources: US Bureau of Labor Statistics average prices, via FRED, series APU0000708111. The May 2023 price is from news coverage of BLS data. The flock and production figures are from the USDA Economic Research Service, Livestock, Dairy, and Poultry Outlook, January 2023, as summarised by farmdoc, University of Illinois.)
Verdict. The prediction came true on both counts: the price rose sharply and the quantity fell. Notice the size. A fall of about 5% in quantity came with a rise of about 150% in price. That tells you buyers barely reacted to the price: the demand curve for eggs is very steep, because people keep buying eggs even when they are dear. With a steep demand curve, a small shift in supply moves the price a long way. This is the "how far" question again. Then, as farms restocked in 2023, supply shifted back to the right, and the price fell. One caution: other things were not perfectly equal. Feed and fuel also cost more in 2022, which pushed supply left as well.
Demand shifts work the same way. In February 2020, fear of the coronavirus was spreading. The World Health Organization reported that demand for protective masks was up to 100 times higher than normal, and prices were up to 20 times higher (source: WHO Director-General, media briefing, 7 February 2020). The demand lecture used this case to show demand shifting right. Now you can finish the story: the shift created a huge shortage at the old price, and the shortage pushed the price up.
Three traps
"Oil costs more, so petrol supply shifts left, the price rises, and then demand for petrol falls, so demand shifts left too." The second shift is wrong. Nothing changed for buyers. The fall in the quantity bought is a movement along the demand curve, caused by the higher price. Shift a curve only for a change other than the good's own price.
When demand shifts right and the price rises, sellers offer more. That is a rise in the quantity supplied, a movement along the supply curve, not an increase in supply. The supply curve has not moved.
When a cost rises by $1 per unit, the supply curve moves up by $1, but the equilibrium price usually rises by less. Some buyers leave as the price rises, so part of the cost stays with the sellers. How the cost is shared depends on how steep the two curves are.
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.
-
Use the four steps for each event. Say which curve moves, which way, and what happens to the equilibrium price and quantity. (a) A popular film makes cycling fashionable, in the market for bicycles. (b) A storm destroys many banana trees, in the market for bananas. (c) A new ferry service begins, in the market for bus tickets on the same route.
Hint 1
Ask whose plans changed: buyers' or sellers'?
Hint 2
(c) The ferry is a substitute for the bus. What happens to the number of people who want bus tickets at each price?
Full answer
(a) Tastes change for buyers: demand shifts right. Shortage at the old price, so price up and quantity up. (b) Nature affects sellers: supply shifts left. Shortage at the old price, so price up and quantity down. (c) A new substitute appears for buyers: demand for bus tickets shifts left. Surplus at the old price, so price down and quantity down. Check: (a) and (c) are demand shifts, so price and quantity move together; (b) is a supply shift, so they move apart. ✓
-
At the fair, exam day lowers every classmate's highest price by $1. (a) What happens at the old price of $2.50? (b) Find the new equilibrium, using the demand and supply schedules from the equilibrium lecture.
Hint 1
Each classmate's highest price falls by $1, so at $2.50 the buyers are those whose old highest price was $3.50 or more.
Hint 2
The new demand at price P equals the old demand at P + $1. Look for the price where this equals the club's supply.
Full answer
(a) At $2.50, buyers now want what they used to want at $3.50: 6 cups. The club still offers 12. A surplus of 6, so the price is pushed down. (b) At $2.00, buyers want what they used to want at $3.00: 9 cups. The club offers 9 at $2.00. So the new equilibrium is $2.00 and 9 cups. Check: a demand shift left should lower both price and quantity: $2.50 to $2.00, 12 to 9. ✓
-
A hot day and dearer fruit happen on the same day. (a) Explain, without any numbers, which result is certain and which is not. (b) Use the fair's numbers ($1 each way) to find the new equilibrium.
Hint 1
Each change on its own: what does it do to the price? To the quantity?
Hint 2
Both changes push the price the same way. Do they push the quantity the same way?
Full answer
(a) A hot day (demand right) raises the price and the quantity. Dearer fruit (supply left) raises the price and lowers the quantity. Both raise the price, so the price certainly rises. They pull the quantity in opposite directions, so the quantity depends on which shift is bigger. (b) Demand at price P is now the old demand at P − $1, and supply at P is the old supply at P − $1. At $3.50, buyers want what they wanted at $2.50, 12 cups, and the club offers what it offered at $2.50, 12 cups. So the new equilibrium is $3.50 and 12 cups. Check: the price rose, as it must, and here the two quantity effects cancel exactly. ✓
-
A stretch. The school charges the cooking club a fee of $1 for every cup it sells. (a) How does this move the supply curve, and what is the new equilibrium price? (b) After paying the fee, how much does the club keep per cup? (c) Who really pays the $1: the buyers or the club? (d) Would your answer to (c) change if the classmates kept buying the same number of cups whatever the price?
Hint 1
A fee per cup works exactly like a cost per cup. Compare it with dearer fruit.
Hint 2
(c) Compare the price buyers pay, and the amount the club keeps, with $2.50. (d) If buyers never drop out, can there be a surplus when the price rises?
Full answer
(a) The fee raises every member's lowest price by $1, so supply moves up by $1, as with dearer fruit. The new price is $3.00, with 9 cups. (b) The club keeps $3.00 − $1.00 = $2.00 per cup. (c) Buyers pay $0.50 more than before ($3.00 instead of $2.50), and the club keeps $0.50 less ($2.00 instead of $2.50). Each side pays half of the fee. (d) Yes. If buyers kept buying 12 cups at any price, the demand curve would be vertical. The price could rise by the full $1 without creating a surplus, so buyers would pay all of it. Check: in (c), $0.50 + $0.50 = $1.00, the whole fee. ✓ The Upper Secondary lecture on who really pays a tax builds on exactly this.
This is the main use of demand and supply. Anything that happens in the world, such as a disease, a heatwave, a new machine or a new law, changes someone's plans. If it changes buyers' plans, demand moves. If it changes sellers' plans, supply moves. The equilibrium then tells you which way the price and the quantity will go, before anyone has collected a single price.
The method also shows its own limits. It tells you directions with confidence, but sizes only when you know how steep the curves are. And it describes where the market is pushed, not how fast it gets there, as the last lecture warned. Economists spend much of their careers measuring those slopes and speeds. You now have the tool they start from.
- To trace any change: decide which curve moves, decide which way, find the shortage or surplus at the old price, then find the new equilibrium.
- A shift changes the price only through the shortage or surplus it creates at the old price.
- An increase in demand raises both price and quantity; a decrease lowers both.
- An increase in supply lowers the price and raises the quantity; a decrease raises the price and lowers the quantity.
- When both curves shift, one of price or quantity changes in a certain direction, and the other depends on the sizes of the shifts.
- A cost rise usually raises the price by less than the cost, and how it is shared depends on how steep the curves are.