Same price, more cups: a puzzle the curve cannot answer
Go back to Leila's juice stall at the school fair. Her demand schedule said that at $2.00 a cup, 15 students buy each day. Then a very hot week arrives. The price is still $2.00, but now 21 students buy.
Look at the demand curve from the last lecture. At $2.00 it gives one quantity: 15 cups. It has no room for 21. So the curve is not wrong. It has moved.
The last lecture ended with a bigger version of this puzzle. In February 2020, mask prices rose up to 20 times, and yet people tried to buy far more masks. That lecture said something other than the price had changed, and promised to show how to draw it. This lecture keeps that promise. You will see what makes a whole demand curve move, which way it moves, and why.
Where a shift comes from
In the last lecture, Leila built her demand schedule by asking every student for their highest price. At each price, she counted the students whose highest price was that price or more. So the whole list depends on two things:
- The buyers' highest prices. How much is a cup worth to each student?
- The number of buyers. How many students are there to ask?
The price Leila charges is not on this list. It only decides which line of the schedule you read. But if anything changes the highest prices, or the number of buyers, the whole schedule changes. Then every line of it changes at once.
In this invented example, the hot weather makes a cup of juice worth exactly $1.00 more to every student. So the 24 students now have highest prices from $1.50 to $5.00, three students at each level. Write the new schedule.
Think first. At $2.00, who buys now? Everyone whose new highest price is $2.00 or more. Before the heat, that was 5 groups of 3. Now 2 more groups qualify: the students whose old highest price was $1.00 or $1.50. So 7 groups, or 21 cups.
| Price of a cup ($) | Usual week (cups per day) | Hot week (cups per day) | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.50 | 18 | 24 | +6 |
| 2.00 | 15 | 21 | +6 |
| 2.50 | 12 | 18 | +6 |
| 3.00 | 9 | 15 | +6 |
| 4.00 | 3 | 9 | +6 |
| 5.00 | 0 | 3 | +3 |
At each price from $1.50 to $4.50, six more cups are demanded. At $5.00 the change is smaller, because only the top group's highest price reaches $5.00. Below $1.50, nothing can change: all 24 students already buy.
Check. A $1.00 rise in every highest price is two steps of $0.50. Each step brings in one group of 3. So 2 × 3 = 6 more cups at each price. ✓
Draw both schedules, and you get two curves. The new one sits to the right of the old one.
When something other than the good's own price changes what buyers want, the whole demand curve moves.
An increase in demand is a shift to the right, from D₁ to D₂: at every price, buyers want more.
A decrease in demand is a shift to the left: at every price, buyers want less.
Compare this with the last lecture. There, the price changed and the point slid along one curve. The quantity demanded changed, but demand did not. Here, the price stays the same and the curve moves. Demand itself has changed. That is it. That is the whole idea. A change in the good's own price moves you along the curve. A change in anything else that affects buyers moves the curve.
In the figure, D₂ is to the right of D₁. But it is also above it. Is a rise in demand a shift to the right, or a shift up?
Show the answer
Both, and they say the same thing in two ways. Read across at one price: at $2.00, buyers now want 21 cups instead of 15. That is "to the right": more at every price. Now read up at one quantity: on D₁, the 15th cup was worth $2.00 to its buyer. On D₂, the 15th cup is worth $3.00. That is "up": buyers would pay more for every cup. The hot day raised every highest price by $1.00, so the curve moved up by $1.00 and right by 6 cups. Economists usually say "right", because it describes the quantity at each price.
Five things that move the curve
Every factor below works through one of the two routes: it changes buyers' highest prices, or it changes the number of buyers. If you can name the route, you can work out the direction. You never need to memorise a list of arrows.
1. Income
When people earn more, they can afford more, so their highest prices for most goods rise. Demand for these goods increases. Economists call them normal goods: most goods are normal, from fresh fruit to bicycles.
But some goods are bought mainly because buyers cannot afford what they prefer. When incomes rise, some buyers switch to the better option. Their highest price for the cheaper good falls, and demand for it decreases. These are called inferior goods. Which goods are inferior depends on the buyers: for some families it may be the cheapest kind of rice, or a long bus journey instead of a flight. "Inferior" does not mean "bad". It only describes how demand reacts to income.
2. The prices of related goods
This is the factor students most often get backwards, so take it slowly. The price that changes is the price of a different good.
- Substitutes are goods that can replace each other, such as tea and coffee, or a bus ride and a shared taxi. If shared-taxi fares rise, the bus now looks better value. Some people's highest price for a bus ride rises, compared with the taxi. So demand for bus rides increases. The substitute's price rose, and our demand rose.
- Complements are goods used together, such as printers and ink, or cinema tickets and popcorn. If cinema tickets get dearer, fewer people go to the cinema, so fewer people are there to buy popcorn. Demand for popcorn decreases. The complement's price rose, and our demand fell.
3. Tastes and information
A good becomes fashionable, or a health report says it is good for you: buyers' highest prices rise, and demand increases. A report that it contains too much sugar works the other way. The goods have not changed. What buyers know or feel about them has.
4. Population: the number and age of buyers
More people means more buyers at every price. The age of the population matters too, because people of different ages buy different things. A country with fewer children needs fewer school uniforms; one with more older people needs more health care. This is happening worldwide. The United Nations projects that by the late 2070s, people aged 65 or over will outnumber children under 18 (United Nations, World Population Prospects 2024: Summary of Results, July 2024).
5. Expectations about the future
If buyers expect a good to become dearer, or to run out, it is worth more to them to buy it now. Demand today increases. If they expect a price cut next month, many will wait, and demand today decreases.
Now try the whole test yourself. Choose an event below and watch what happens to Leila's demand curve.
Choose an event. The usual curve D₁ stays in solid colour, and the new curve D₂ appears dashed. Then move the price to compare the two curves at any price.
This table shows how each event changes the number of cups demanded at $2.00 a cup, and why. Before any event, 15 cups per day are demanded at $2.00.
| Event | Cups at $2.00 | Result |
|---|---|---|
| A hot week | 15 → 21 | shift right |
| A cold, rainy week | 15 → 9 | shift left |
| 8 new students join | 15 → 20 | shift right |
| Cheaper lemonade | 15 → 12 | shift left |
| Cheaper sandwiches | 15 → 18 | shift right |
| Leila charges $3.00 | 15 → 9 | along D₁ |
The reasons: the hot week raises every highest price by $1.00, and the cold week lowers it by $1.00. The new students make 4 buyers at each highest price instead of 3. Lemonade is a substitute, so cheaper lemonade lowers every highest price for juice by $0.50. Sandwiches are a complement, so cheaper sandwiches raise it by $0.50. Leila's own price changes nothing for the buyers, so the point moves along D₁ to 9 cups at $3.00.
The figure above shows the hot week. Every other shift looks the same, except that a fall in demand moves the curve to the left.
You should have seen one pattern. Five of the events moved the curve, because each one changed the students' highest prices or their number. Only Leila's own price change left the curve where it was. Notice also that 8 new students did not move the curve the same distance at every price. A shift does not have to be parallel. It only has to change the quantity at the same price.
Two worked examples with numbers
In an invented fishing town, incomes rise. At unchanged prices, the fish market sells 480 kg of fresh fish a week instead of 400 kg, and 240 kg of the cheapest dried fish instead of 300 kg.
Think first. Prices did not change, so neither change is a movement along a curve. Both are shifts. Which way, and why?
Fresh fish: the quantity at the same price rose by 80 kg, which is 80 ÷ 400 × 100 = 20%. Demand increased, so fresh fish is a normal good here. Dried fish: the quantity fell by 60 kg, which is 60 ÷ 300 × 100 = 20%. Demand decreased, so dried fish is an inferior good for these buyers. With more money, some families switched from dried fish to fresh.
Check. Each change happened at an unchanged price. ✓ The two goods are substitutes for each other, so it makes sense that one gained while the other lost. ✓
In an invented town, the cinema raises its ticket price from $8 to $12. Weekly visits fall from 2 000 to 1 400. On average, every second visitor buys a box of popcorn at $3. Describe what happens in each market.
Think first. In which market did the good's own price change?
Cinema tickets. Their own price rose. So the fall from 2 000 to 1 400 visits is a fall in the quantity demanded: a movement along the demand curve for tickets. Demand for tickets has not changed.
Popcorn. Its price is still $3. But there are fewer people at the cinema to buy it. At $3, popcorn sales fall from 2 000 ÷ 2 = 1 000 boxes to 1 400 ÷ 2 = 700 boxes a week. The number of buyers fell, so this is a decrease in demand: the popcorn curve shifts left.
Check. Tickets and popcorn are complements, and the complement's price rose, so popcorn demand should fall. ✓ Visits fell by 30%, and so did popcorn sales, because each visitor buys the same amount. ✓
Notice the two different words for one event. The same price rise caused a movement in one market and a shift in the other. The test is always the same: was it this good's own price that changed?
Use that test on the events below. Every card is about the market for juice at Leila's stall.
Put each event in a box. Ask first: is it the price of juice itself that changed?
This box sorts nine events in the market for Leila's juice, with the reason for each.
- Shift right. A heatwave: highest prices rise. Parents give more pocket money: income, and juice is a normal good. 100 more students join the school: more buyers. The canteen cuts its sandwich price: a complement is cheaper. Leila announces a price rise for next week: buyers expect a higher price, so they buy now.
- Shift left. Lemonade nearby gets cheaper: a substitute is cheaper. A news report says the juice has too much sugar: tastes and information.
- Movement along. Leila raises her price from $2 to $3. Leila lowers her price for one day.
The rule: only a change in the good's own price moves along the curve. Anything else that changes buyers' highest prices or the number of buyers shifts the whole curve.
The two "movement along" cards were the only ones about the price of juice itself. Every other card changed what the buyers were willing to pay, or how many buyers there were.
A real case: masks in early 2020
The situation. In January and February 2020, a new coronavirus was spreading from China to other countries. Masks had always been on sale. Few people outside hospitals bought them.
What changed. Not the price of masks, at first. Fear of infection changed. For millions of people, a mask was suddenly worth far more: their highest prices rose. Many people who had never bought a mask became buyers. And many expected masks to run out, so they bought ahead. Three of the five factors, tastes, the number of buyers and expectations, pushed in the same direction.
The prediction. A very large increase in demand: the demand curve shifts far to the right. At every price, many more masks are wanted.
What happened. On 7 February 2020, the Director-General of the World Health Organization (WHO) spoke about protective equipment such as masks. He said that demand was up to 100 times higher than normal, and prices were up to 20 times higher. He also warned of backlogs of four to six months, and urged people not to stockpile. (Sources: WHO Director-General's opening remarks at the media briefing, 7 February 2020; E. Mahase, BMJ 2020;368:m543; UN News, 7 February 2020.)
Verdict. The prediction fits. A huge rightward shift explains why people tried to buy far more masks even at much higher prices. So the law of demand was not broken: the whole curve had moved. One question is left. Why did the price rise so much? A shift of demand on its own does not say. The answer lies with the sellers, who could not make 100 times more masks in a few weeks. That is the supply side, which the next lectures build. One caution: news reports often use "demand" loosely, for the amount people tried to buy. In this lecture, demand always means the whole list.
Three traps
A change in a good's own price never shifts its own demand curve. It moves the point along the curve. Only changes in other things shift the curve. If your answer has the price of the good causing a shift of its own curve, start again.
For a substitute, its price and our demand move the same way: dearer coffee, more demand for tea. For a complement, they move in opposite ways: dearer printers, less demand for ink. Do not learn this as a rule. Ask what the buyer would do, and the direction follows.
That is true for normal goods, which are most goods. For an inferior good, demand falls when incomes rise. In an exam, say which kind of good you are assuming, and why.
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.
-
Think about the market for umbrellas in a town. For each event, say whether it causes a shift of demand (left or right) or a movement along the curve, and name the factor. (a) A long rainy season is forecast. (b) Raincoats become much cheaper. (c) Umbrella shops raise their prices. (d) A large new housing estate opens and 5 000 people move in.
Hint 1
First ask: is it the price of umbrellas that changes? If yes, it is a movement.
Hint 2
Raincoats and umbrellas do the same job. What does a cheaper raincoat do to the value of an umbrella?
Full answer
(a) Shift right. The forecast changes expectations: an umbrella is worth more to people, so their highest prices rise. (b) Shift left. Raincoats are a substitute; cheaper raincoats make umbrellas look worse value. (c) A movement along the curve: the umbrella's own price changed, so the quantity demanded falls, not demand. (d) Shift right: more buyers at every price (population). Check: only (c) involves the good's own price, so only (c) is a movement. ✓
-
In an invented town, the demand schedule for bus rides is: $1: 900 rides a day, $2: 700, $3: 500, $4: 300. Then shared-taxi fares rise, and 150 more bus rides are wanted at every price. (a) Write the new schedule. (b) At $2 a ride, how many more rides are wanted? (c) Are buses and shared taxis substitutes or complements?
Hint 1
Add 150 to every quantity. The prices stay the same.
Hint 2
(c) The taxi's price went up and demand for buses went up. Same direction or opposite?
Full answer
(a) $1: 1 050. $2: 850. $3: 650. $4: 450 rides a day. (b) 850 − 700 = 150 more rides, at the same price. (c) Substitutes: the taxi's price and the demand for buses moved in the same direction, because some people switched from taxis to buses. Check: every quantity rose and no price changed, so this is an increase in demand, a shift right. ✓
-
A shop sells new school uniforms and second-hand ones. Incomes in the town rise by 10%. At unchanged prices, sales of second-hand uniforms fall from 200 to 170 a month, and sales of new uniforms rise. (a) Which uniform is the inferior good here? Explain. (b) By what percentage did demand for second-hand uniforms fall at the same price? (c) What would you predict if incomes fell instead?
Hint 1
An inferior good is one whose demand falls when incomes rise.
Hint 2
(b) Fall ÷ original × 100.
Full answer
(a) The second-hand uniform. With more income, some families switch to new uniforms, so demand for second-hand ones falls at the same price. (b) 30 ÷ 200 × 100 = 15%. (c) The opposite: demand for second-hand uniforms would increase (shift right), and demand for new ones would decrease. Check: "inferior" describes how buyers react to income, not the quality of the uniform. ✓
-
A stretch. At Leila's stall, two things happen in the same week. A hot week raises every student's highest price by $1.00. At the same time, a nearby stall cuts the price of lemonade, which lowers every highest price for juice by $0.50. (a) At $2.50 a cup, how many cups are demanded before and after? (b) Which way did demand shift overall? (c) Suppose the lemonade cut had lowered every highest price by $1.50 instead. Which way would demand shift now? What does this tell you about two changes at once?
Hint 1
Combine the two changes first: +$1.00 and −$0.50 is a net change of +$0.50 in every highest price.
Hint 2
At $2.50, count the students whose old highest price was $2.00 or more. Each group has 3 students.
Full answer
(a) Before: students with a highest price of $2.50 or more, 4 groups, so 12 cups. After: each highest price is $0.50 higher, so the students whose old highest price was $2.00 or more now buy. That is 5 groups, so 15 cups. (b) Demand increased: the curve shifted right, by 3 cups at each price. (c) Now the net change is +$1.00 − $1.50 = −$0.50, so demand decreases and the curve shifts left. When two factors pull in opposite directions, the direction of the shift depends on which change is bigger. Without numbers, an economist cannot say which way the curve moves. Check: +$0.50 is one step of $0.50, which brings in one group of 3, and 12 + 3 = 15. ✓
Every demand curve is drawn for one set of conditions: one level of income, one set of other prices, one season, one group of buyers. That is what "other things being equal" really means. The price is the only thing allowed to vary along the curve. Change any of the conditions, and you need a new curve.
Mathematics has the same idea. Moving a graph without changing its shape is called a translation. The hot week translated Leila's curve 6 cups to the right, which is the same as $1.00 up, just as a translation moves every point of a graph by the same amount. Economics adds the reasons: why the graph moves, and which way.
The masks case left one question open: why did the price jump? Demand is only one side of a market. The next lectures build the sellers' side, supply, and then put the two together. Then you will be able to say not only which way a curve shifts, but what happens to the price and the quantity sold.
- A change in a good's own price causes a movement along its demand curve, while a change in anything else that affects buyers shifts the whole curve.
- An increase in demand is a shift to the right, meaning more is demanded at every price; a decrease in demand is a shift to the left.
- Every shift works through one of two routes: it changes buyers' highest prices, or it changes the number of buyers.
- The five main factors are income, the prices of related goods, tastes and information, population, and expectations about the future.
- Demand for a normal good rises with income, while demand for an inferior good falls when income rises.
- A substitute's price and our demand move in the same direction, while a complement's price and our demand move in opposite directions.