Two lists, one fair, and nobody in charge
The school fair is ready. On one side are Leila's 24 classmates from the demand lecture. Each will buy at most one cup of juice a day, and each has a highest price. On the other side are the eight students of the cooking club from the supply lecture. Each can make 3 cups a day, and each has a lowest price. The supply lecture ended with a promise: somewhere, these two lists must meet. This lecture finds where.
But first, notice something strange. Nobody is in charge of the price. No teacher announces it. Nobody knows all 32 numbers: each student knows only their own. Yet by the end of the afternoon, one price will usually have settled, and almost every cup will be sold at about that price.
How can a price be found that nobody chose? That is the question of this lecture. The answer is one of the most useful ideas in economics, and it needs only the two lists you have already built.
Put the two lists side by side
Here are the two schedules from the demand and supply lectures, written at the same prices. The last column compares them.
| Price of a cup ($) | Quantity demanded (cups per day) | Quantity supplied (cups per day) | Comparison |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.50 | 0 | 24 | 24 more offered than wanted |
| 4.00 | 3 | 21 | 18 more offered than wanted |
| 3.50 | 6 | 18 | 12 more offered than wanted |
| 3.00 | 9 | 15 | 6 more offered than wanted |
| 2.50 | 12 | 12 | equal |
| 2.00 | 15 | 9 | 6 more wanted than offered |
| 1.50 | 18 | 6 | 12 more wanted than offered |
| 1.00 | 21 | 3 | 18 more wanted than offered |
| 0.50 | 24 | 0 | 24 more wanted than offered |
Read down the table. As the price falls, the quantity demanded rises and the quantity supplied falls. At high prices, sellers offer more than buyers want. At low prices, buyers want more than sellers offer. Because one list rises and the other falls, they can be equal at only one price. Here it is $2.50, where both are 12 cups a day.
Now draw both curves on the same axes. Price goes up the side and quantity along the bottom, as in both lectures.
A market is in equilibrium when the quantity demanded equals the quantity supplied. The price at which this happens is the equilibrium price, P*. The amount bought and sold is the equilibrium quantity, Q*.
On a diagram, the equilibrium is where the demand curve and the supply curve cross.
The word comes from Latin for "equal balance". In science, something is in equilibrium when nothing pushes it to change, like a ball resting at the bottom of a bowl. Economists also say that at the equilibrium price the market clears: nothing is left over, and nobody who will pay that price is turned away.
What happens at any other price
A definition is not enough. Why should the price end up at $2.50 rather than anywhere else? To see why, try a different price and watch what the people at the fair do.
A price that is too high. Suppose the club charges $3.50. Six students make juice, 18 cups in all, but only 6 classmates will pay $3.50. By lunchtime, 12 cups sit unsold. This is a surplus, which some books call excess supply. Think about a club member whose lowest price is $2.00. She is charging $3.50 and selling nothing. Selling a cup at $3.00 is better for her than pouring it away, so she cuts her price. Others do the same. The price falls.
A price that is too low. Now suppose the price is $1.50. Only two club members are willing to make juice at that price, so 6 cups are made. But 18 classmates want a cup. A queue forms and the juice runs out. This is a shortage, which some books call excess demand. A student whose highest price is $3.50 is standing at the back of the queue. She would happily pay $3.00, so she offers it. Sellers notice the queue and raise their prices. The price rises.
Watch what each change of price does to the two lists. As the price falls from $3.50, the quantity demanded rises and the quantity supplied falls: two movements along the two curves. The gap closes from both sides. The same happens in reverse when the price rises from $1.50. Neither curve moves. Only the point on each curve moves.
Above the equilibrium price there is a surplus, and sellers with unsold goods push the price down.
Below the equilibrium price there is a shortage, and buyers who cannot get the good push the price up.
Only at the equilibrium price is there no push either way.
Try it on the fair's market below. Pay attention to one more number: how many cups are actually sold.
Move the price. At each price, compare the cups buyers want with the cups the club makes. Watch which way the price is pushed, and how many cups are actually sold.
This box shows the fair's market at a price above equilibrium and at a price below it, and how many cups are actually sold at every price.
| Price ($) | Wanted | Offered | Cups sold | Push on the price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4.00 | 3 | 21 | 3 | down (surplus of 18) |
| 3.50 | 6 | 18 | 6 | down (surplus of 12) |
| 3.00 | 9 | 15 | 9 | down (surplus of 6) |
| 2.50 | 12 | 12 | 12 | none (equilibrium) |
| 2.00 | 15 | 9 | 9 | up (shortage of 6) |
| 1.50 | 18 | 6 | 6 | up (shortage of 12) |
| 1.00 | 21 | 3 | 3 | up (shortage of 18) |
The cups sold are always the smaller of the two quantities. They are highest, 12, at the equilibrium price.
You should have seen three things. Above $2.50 there is always a surplus, and the push is down. Below $2.50 there is always a shortage, and the push is up. And the number of cups actually sold is largest at the equilibrium. A price that is too high and a price that is too low do the same damage: fewer cups change hands.
Every cup that is sold has a buyer. So the number of cups bought always equals the number sold, at any price. Does that mean the market is always in equilibrium?
Show the answer
No. Equilibrium compares plans, not sales. It asks whether the quantity buyers want at this price equals the quantity sellers offer. At $3.50, 6 cups are bought and 6 are sold, so those two numbers match. But the club made 18, so 12 cups are offered and not bought. That gap between the two plans is the surplus, and it is what pushes the price down.
Who trades at the equilibrium, and who does not
At $2.50, look at the people. Twelve classmates buy: the ones whose highest price is $2.50 or more. Four club members make juice: the ones whose lowest price is $2.50 or less.
Equilibrium does not mean that everyone who wants juice gets some. The classmates whose highest price is $2.00 or less do not buy. What equilibrium does mean is narrower, and more useful. Every buyer who values a cup at $2.50 or more can get one. Every seller who will make a cup for $2.50 or less can sell it.
Now ask about a thirteenth cup. The next buyer in line has a highest price of $2.00. The next seller has a lowest price of $3.00. The markets lecture showed that a trade happens only when the buyer's highest price is at least the seller's lowest price. Here it is not, so no price could make both of them willing. The thirteenth cup is not worth making.
That is it. That is the whole idea. The equilibrium makes every trade that both sides gain from, and no other. A lower price shuts out sellers whose cups were worth making. A higher price shuts out buyers who would gladly have paid more than the cups cost to make.
A real case: a market in a classroom
The situation. In 1956, the economist Vernon Smith wanted to test whether supply and demand really predict prices. He split a class of students into 11 buyers and 11 sellers. Each buyer got a card showing a highest price for one unit. Each seller got a card showing a lowest price. Each student saw only their own card. These are exactly the lists you built in the demand and supply lectures.
The prediction. Smith had written every card, so he could draw the true demand and supply curves. They crossed at a price of $2.00 and a quantity of 6 units. The students could not draw them. Buyers called out prices they would pay, sellers called out prices they would accept, and a trade happened whenever someone accepted. The market ran for five short trading periods, each of about five minutes.
Smith himself expected the market to fail. Before reading on, make your own prediction.
Twenty-two students, each knowing only their own card, traded for five periods of about five minutes. The curves that only Smith could see crossed at $2.00 and 6 units. What do you think happened to the prices?
This box explains what happened to prices in Vernon Smith's classroom market.
Prices moved quickly towards $2.00. In the last period, the average price was $2.03, and exactly 6 units were traded. The 6 buyers with the highest prices bought, and the 6 sellers with the lowest prices sold, even though no student knew the curves.
What happened. Prices moved quickly towards the equilibrium. In the last period, the average price was $2.03, and exactly 6 units were traded, by the 6 buyers with the highest prices and the 6 sellers with the lowest. Smith later wrote that he was "still recovering from the shock of the experimental results". From 1956 to 1960 he ran the experiment again under different rules and conditions, and the markets kept moving towards the predicted equilibrium. In 2002 he shared the Nobel Prize in economics, partly for this work. (Sources: V. L. Smith, "An Experimental Study of Competitive Market Behavior", Journal of Political Economy, 1962, as summarised in T. Cowen and A. Tabarrok, Modern Principles of Economics, chapter 4; The Concise Encyclopedia of Economics, "Vernon Lomax Smith", Econlib.)
Verdict. The prediction came true, and in a hard test: few traders, and nobody who could see the whole market. Each student only reacted to a surplus or a shortage, just as at the fair. Two cautions are fair. First, a classroom is simpler than a real market. There was one good, the cards did not change during a period, and the amounts at stake were small. Second, the price took several rounds to settle. Equilibrium is where a market is pushed towards, not where it starts.
Worked examples
This example is invented. Several stalls at a town market sell bowls of noodle soup. The table shows the market's demand and supply schedules, in bowls per day. Find the equilibrium. Then describe the market at $8 and at $3.
| Price ($) | Quantity demanded | Quantity supplied |
|---|---|---|
| 8 | 20 | 50 |
| 7 | 24 | 46 |
| 6 | 28 | 41 |
| 5 | 35 | 35 |
| 4 | 55 | 28 |
| 3 | 80 | 20 |
Think first. Look for the row where the two quantities match.
At $5, both are 35. So P* = $5 and Q* = 35 bowls per day.
At $8, the stalls make 50 bowls but buyers want 20. There is a surplus of bowls a day, and soup is thrown away. Stalls cut their prices, so the price is pushed down. At $3, buyers want 80 bowls but the stalls make only 20. There is a shortage of bowls a day, with long queues. Stalls raise their prices, so the price is pushed up.
Check. Above $5 the supply column is always bigger, and below $5 the demand column is always bigger. ✓ At both $8 and $3, only 20 bowls are sold, fewer than the 35 sold at equilibrium. ✓
This example is invented. A concert hall has 2 000 seats and sells tickets at $40. All the tickets are gone within ten minutes. Outside, people offer $90 for a ticket. At the same hall, a lunchtime talk at $25 has 300 empty seats. What do the signs say about each price?
Think first. You do not know either demand curve. But a shortage and a surplus leave clear signs.
The concert shows a shortage: tickets vanish at once and people offer far more than $40. So $40 is below the equilibrium price for that concert. The talk shows a surplus: seats stay empty at $25. So $25 is above the equilibrium price for that talk.
Check. The signs tell you the direction of the push, not the size of the gap. Nobody can tell from them alone whether the concert's equilibrium price is $60 or $90. ✓
Towards equilibrium, but not at once
People often say that markets "correct themselves". That is half true, and the false half matters. A market is pushed towards equilibrium. It does not jump there.
How long the journey takes depends on the market. At the fair, prices can change in minutes. Some ride-hailing apps raise fares automatically when many people want rides at once, so the price moves in seconds. But housing is different. When more people want homes in a city, it can take years to build new ones. In the meantime, shortages are real. People wait, rents rise, and some families cannot find a home. Some prices also change slowly because of contracts or rules.
So equilibrium is a tendency, not a promise. It tells you which way a price is being pushed. It does not tell you how fast the price will arrive, or whether the result will feel fair. Whether a government should act while a market adjusts is a separate question, and it comes later in the course, with price controls.
Three traps
A surplus is too much offered: the price is above equilibrium, and it is pushed down. A shortage is too little offered: the price is below equilibrium, and it is pushed up. Check by asking what the sellers can see: unsold goods (surplus) or a queue (shortage).
When a shortage pushes the price up, nothing shifts. The quantity demanded falls and the quantity supplied rises: two movements along the two curves. Write "the quantity demanded fell" and "the quantity supplied rose". A curve shifts only when something other than the good's own price changes, which is the next lecture's topic.
At equilibrium, everyone who will pay the equilibrium price can buy, and everyone who will sell at it can sell. Buyers whose highest price is lower go without. Equilibrium is also not a judgement that the price is fair or good. It is only the price at which the two plans match.
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.
-
For each situation, say whether the price is above or below equilibrium, and which way the price will be pushed. (a) At closing time, a flower stall has half its flowers left. (b) A new phone sells out on its first morning, and people pay more than the shop price to buy one from others. (c) A cinema shows a film at full price to a nearly empty room, day after day.
Hint 1
Ask what sellers can see: goods left over, or customers they cannot serve.
Hint 2
Left over means a surplus. Customers turned away, or buyers paying extra to others, means a shortage.
Full answer
(a) A surplus, so the price is above equilibrium and is pushed down. This is why flowers are often cheaper near closing time. (b) A shortage, so the price is below equilibrium and is pushed up. Buyers paying others more than the shop price shows that many buyers' highest prices are above it. (c) A surplus, so the price is above equilibrium and is pushed down, for example by cheaper tickets on quiet days. Check: (a) and (c) show goods left over, (b) shows buyers left over. ✓
-
This example is invented. A town's mango market has these schedules, in kilograms per day. Price $1: demanded 500, supplied 100. $2: 400 and 220. $3: 320 and 320. $4: 260 and 400. $5: 210 and 460. (a) Find P* and Q*. (b) Describe the market at $5 and at $2, including how many kilograms are actually sold.
Hint 1
Find the price where the two quantities are equal.
Hint 2
The amount actually sold is the smaller of the two quantities at that price.
Full answer
(a) P* = $3 and Q* = 320 kg per day. (b) At $5, sellers offer 460 kg but buyers want 210 kg: a surplus of kg, and 210 kg are sold. The price is pushed down. At $2, buyers want 400 kg but sellers offer 220 kg: a shortage of kg, and 220 kg are sold. The price is pushed up. Check: both 210 and 220 are less than the 320 kg sold at equilibrium. ✓
-
In the supply lecture, the three bakeries of Ama, Tomás and Mei together offered 120 pastries a day at $1, 300 at $2, 420 at $3 and 470 at $4. Suppose buyers in the town want 640 at $1, 520 at $2, 420 at $3 and 330 at $4. (a) Find the equilibrium. (b) Ama sets her price at $2 and says, "I sold all 160, so the market price is right." Explain why she may be wrong.
Hint 1
Compare the two lists price by price.
Hint 2
At $2, compare the 520 wanted with the 300 offered by all three bakeries. Selling out is a sign of what?
Full answer
(a) At $3, both quantities are 420, so P* = $3 and Q* = 420 pastries a day. (b) At $2 the market has a shortage: buyers want 520 pastries but the bakeries offer 300, so 220 buyers go without. Selling everything is not a sign that a price is right. It is a sign that the price may be too low. Buyers who miss out will offer more, and the price will be pushed towards $3. Check: at $4 there is a surplus of , so $3 is the only price in the list with no push. ✓
-
A stretch. The school decides that juice at the fair must cost $1.50 a cup. (a) Using the table in this lecture, find the shortage. (b) The 6 cups go to the first 6 people in the queue. Suppose one of them, Nia, has a highest price of $1.50, and the seventh person, Omar, has a highest price of $4.00. Omar offers Nia $3.00 for her cup. Explain why both would agree. (c) Compare the rule with the equilibrium. What is lost?
Hint 1
(b) Compare what Nia gives up with what she receives, and what Omar pays with what the cup is worth to him.
Hint 2
(c) How many cups are made at $1.50, and how many at $2.50? Think also about the time spent queuing: the demand lecture said that time works like a price.
Full answer
(a) At $1.50, 18 cups are wanted and 6 are made: a shortage of 12. (b) Nia values the cup at $1.50 and receives $3.00, so she gains. Omar values it at $4.00 and pays $3.00, so he gains too. This is the shortage pushing the price up, even though the rule forbids it at the stall. (c) At equilibrium, 12 cups would be made and sold. Under the rule, only 6 are. The 6 missing cups were worth making: buyers valued them at $2.50 or more, and they would cost the club $2.50 or less to make. Cups also go to whoever queues first, not to whoever values them most, and the time spent queuing is a cost too. Check: 18 − 6 = 12, and 12 − 6 = 6 cups lost. ✓ Price rules like this are studied in the lecture on price controls.
Go back to the question at the start. Nobody at the fair knew the 32 numbers, so how was $2.50 found? Each student knew one thing and reacted to one signal: unsold juice or a queue. Those small reactions added up to the one price at which the two lists agree. The lecture on economic systems said that a price works as a signal. Here you can see the signal being made. The price gathers information that is spread across many people and that no single person holds.
This also tells you what comes next. If the demand list or the supply list changes, the old price will leave a surplus or a shortage, and the market will be pushed to a new equilibrium. The next lecture uses this to explain cases from earlier lectures, such as why egg prices rose after a disease cut supply.
- A market is in equilibrium when the quantity demanded equals the quantity supplied, at the equilibrium price P* and the equilibrium quantity Q*, where the two curves cross.
- Above the equilibrium price there is a surplus, and sellers with unsold goods push the price down.
- Below the equilibrium price there is a shortage, and buyers who cannot get the good push the price up.
- A price moving towards equilibrium causes movements along both curves, not shifts.
- At equilibrium, every trade that both a buyer and a seller gain from takes place, and the most units are sold.
- Markets move towards equilibrium over time, quickly in some markets and slowly in others.