The other half of the market
The demand lectures looked at a market through the buyers' eyes. They showed that "how much do you want?" has no single answer until you know the price. Now turn around and stand behind the stall.
Suppose you sell fresh juice at your school fair. How many cups will you make tomorrow? You cannot answer that either. At $1 a cup, it may not be worth your fruit and your morning. At $3 a cup, you might make every cup your blender can manage. The honest answer is again a list: so many cups at this price, so many at that price.
That list is what economists mean by supply. The lecture on what shifts demand ended with the masks of 2020, and with sellers who could not make 100 times more masks in a few weeks. It promised that the supply side would come next. Here it is. This lecture builds the sellers' list, shows why it slopes upwards, and tests the idea in a real market where the price collapsed.
What economists mean by supply
Supply is the quantity of a good or service that sellers are willing and able to offer for sale at each possible price, in a given period of time.
The definition mirrors the definition of demand, and each part does a job.
- Willing. The price must be high enough that the seller wants to sell. Below some price, the seller would rather keep the time, the fruit or the oven for something else.
- Able. Wanting is not enough. A student with one blender may wish to sell 500 cups at the fair, but she can make perhaps 30. Supply counts only what sellers can actually produce and deliver.
- At each possible price. Supply is not one number. It is the whole list.
- In a given period of time. "200 pastries" means nothing until you add "per day" or "per week".
As with demand, one number from the list has its own name. The amount sellers offer at one particular price is the quantity supplied at that price. "Supply" is the whole list, and "quantity supplied" is one line of it.
Where the list comes from: each seller's lowest price
The lecture on how markets work gave every seller a lowest price: the least they would accept. Below it, they would rather not sell. Where does that number come from? It is the cost to the seller of producing and selling one more unit. That cost includes the money spent on materials. It also includes the opportunity cost of the seller's time: the next best thing they could have done with it.
This example is invented. At the same fair as Leila's juice stall in the demand lecture, eight students from the cooking club offer to make juice. Each has one blender and time to make at most 3 cups a day. Their lowest prices differ. Some get fruit cheaply from home, and some would give up a paid job that morning. In this club, the lowest prices happen to be spread evenly: one student says $1.00 a cup, one says $1.50, and so on, up to one who says $4.50.
Think first. If the price is $2.50 a cup, who makes juice?
Every student whose lowest price is $2.50 or less. That is the students who said $1.00, $1.50, $2.00 or $2.50. Four students make 3 cups each, so . At $2.50, the quantity supplied is 12 cups per day.
Do the same count at every price, and you have the whole list.
| Price of a cup ($) | Students whose lowest price is this or less | Quantity supplied (cups per day) |
|---|---|---|
| 0.50 | no one | 0 |
| 1.00 | 1 student | 3 |
| 1.50 | 2 students | 6 |
| 2.00 | 3 students | 9 |
| 2.50 | 4 students | 12 |
| 3.00 | 5 students | 15 |
| 3.50 | 6 students | 18 |
| 4.00 | 7 students | 21 |
| 4.50 | all 8 students | 24 |
Check. Below the lowest answer, $1.00, nobody makes juice. ✓ At $4.50, all 8 students make 3 cups: 24. ✓ Each rise of $0.50 brings in exactly one more student and 3 more cups. ✓
A table like this is called a supply schedule. Its numbers rise for a reason. Each rise in price passes some seller's lowest price, so a new seller joins. Plot it with price up the side and quantity along the bottom, the same axes as demand, and you get the supply curve, S.
Compare it with Leila's demand curve. Demand sloped down, because a higher price passes buyers' highest prices and they leave. Supply slopes up, because a higher price passes sellers' lowest prices and they join. It is one idea, seen from the two sides of the stall.
Why one seller makes more: each extra unit costs more
New sellers joining is one reason the curve slopes up. But a single seller also offers more at a higher price, and the reason is less obvious. It lives in the cost of each extra unit.
This example is invented. Ama runs a small bakery and sells pastries in batches of 40. Her first batch is cheap to make: the oven is already hot and the morning is hers. The second costs a little more. The third means staying late, so she gives up her evening. The fourth means paying a helper extra hours. The fifth means renting a second oven at night. Her kitchen cannot manage a sixth batch in one day. So each batch has its own lowest price per pastry: $0.80, $1.00, $1.40, $1.90 and $2.50.
Move the price below and see how many pastries she will bake.
Each bar is one batch of 40 pastries. Its height is the lowest price per pastry that covers that batch. Change the price. Ama bakes every batch whose bar is at or below the price line.
This box shows how many pastries Ama bakes at each price. Each batch of 40 has its own lowest price per pastry, and she bakes a batch only when the price covers it.
| Price per pastry ($) | Batches covered | Quantity supplied (pastries per day) |
|---|---|---|
| 0.50 | none | 0 |
| 1.00 | batches 1 and 2 | 80 |
| 1.50 | batches 1 to 3 | 120 |
| 2.00 | batches 1 to 4 | 160 |
| 2.50 | all 5 batches | 200 |
| 3.00 | all 5 batches (the kitchen's limit) | 200 |
You should have seen two things. First, a higher price covers more batches, so Ama bakes more. Second, the bars climb. Each extra batch costs more than the one before, because it uses time and equipment that are less and less suited to the job. This is the bowed frontier from the lecture on the production possibility frontier, now inside one bakery: the more you produce of one thing, the more you give up for each extra unit.
The tops of the bars are Ama's supply curve. It is a staircase because she bakes in whole batches. A market with many sellers smooths the steps into a line, as the cooking club did.
The law of supply
Other things being equal, when the price of a good rises, the quantity supplied rises. When the price falls, the quantity supplied falls.
"Other things being equal", ceteris paribus in Latin, means that only the price changes: not the cost of fruit, not the number of ovens, not the weather. The law describes the effect of the price alone. There are three reasons it holds.
- 1. New sellers join. A higher price passes more sellers' lowest prices, as in the cooking club.
- 2. Each seller makes more. Extra units cost more to produce, as in Ama's kitchen. A higher price covers more of them.
- 3. Sellers switch from other goods. A farmer can plant one field with tomatoes or with onions. If tomatoes sell for more and onions do not, giving up the onions is now worth it, so more land goes to tomatoes.
That is it. That is the whole idea. A seller offers a unit only when the price covers what that unit costs, including what the seller gives up to make it. A higher price covers more units, from more sellers, so the quantity supplied rises.
Quantity supplied changes, supply does not
The same pair of words protects this topic as protected demand. When the price of a pastry rises from $1.50 to $2.50, Ama bakes 200 instead of 120. Her costs, her kitchen and her batches are the same. The point simply moves along her supply curve. The quantity supplied rises, but supply, the whole list, has not changed. Economists call this a movement along the supply curve. Some books call a rise in quantity supplied an extension, and a fall a contraction.
Supply itself changes only when something other than the price changes the list. Suppose Ama's oven breaks. Then she can bake fewer pastries at every price, and the whole curve moves. That is a different event, and the next lecture shows how to draw it.
In an invented town, private tutors charge $20 an hour. When parents start paying $30 an hour, more people offer tutoring, including some who used to do other work. A news report says: "Higher fees have increased the supply of tutors." Is that the right economic phrase?
Show the answer
No. The fee is the price of tutoring. A rise in the price brings in sellers whose lowest price is between $20 and $30. That is a movement along the supply curve: the quantity supplied of tutoring rose. Supply, the list of how many hours would be offered at each fee, has not changed. Whoever would tutor at $30 was always on that list. The correct sentence is "higher fees have increased the quantity of tutoring supplied". Something like a new training course that makes tutors able to teach more subjects would change supply itself.
Adding sellers together: market supply
A market's supply list adds up all its sellers' lists, price by price, exactly as market demand did.
This example is invented. Ama's bakery has two neighbours, run by Tomás and Mei. Here is how many pastries each would bake per day at four prices.
| Price per pastry ($) | Ama | Tomás | Mei | Market |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 80 | 0 | 40 | 120 |
| 2 | 160 | 60 | 80 | 300 |
| 3 | 200 | 120 | 100 | 420 |
| 4 | 200 | 150 | 120 | 470 |
Think first. Do you add the prices or the quantities?
The quantities, at the same price. At $2, the market offers pastries a day. All three bakers face the same price, so prices are never added.
Look at Tomás. At $1 he bakes nothing, because his lowest price is above $1. At $2 he joins the market. That is reason 1. Mei's quantity rises at every step, which is reason 2. Ama stops at 200, her kitchen's limit: at $3 and $4 she is willing to bake more, but not able.
Check. Every column rises or stays level as the price rises, so the total must too. ✓ 120, 300, 420, 470 rises. ✓
A real case: when the price of oil collapsed
The situation. In the United States, companies drill new oil wells with drilling rigs. A new well costs a great deal, so a company drills only when it expects the price of oil to cover the cost. In June 2014 the world price of oil (the Brent price) was about $115 a barrel. By January 2016 it had fallen below $30, a fall of about three-quarters.
The prediction. The law of supply predicts a fall in the quantity supplied: a movement down the supply curve. Wells that only paid at $100 a barrel stop being worth drilling.
Before reading on, make your own prediction.
The number of rigs drilling for oil in the United States peaked at 1 609 in October 2014. What do you think it had become by May 2016, after the oil price fell by about three-quarters?
This box explains what happened to oil drilling in the United States when the oil price fell.
The number of rigs drilling for oil fell from 1 609 in October 2014 to 316 in May 2016, a fall of about 80%. As the price dropped below the cost of more and more wells, those wells stopped being drilled. Companies did not drill more to make up their lost income: each new well had to pay for itself at the new price, and most no longer could.
What happened. Drilling fell steeply, just as the law of supply predicts.
| Date | Brent oil price | Oil rigs drilling in the US |
|---|---|---|
| June 2014 | about $115 a barrel | — |
| 10 October 2014 | — | 1 609 (the peak) |
| January 2016 | below $30 a barrel | — |
| 27 May 2016 | — | 316 |
But the quantity of oil produced fell far less. The US Energy Information Administration (EIA) reported that crude oil output in May 2016 was only 2% below its level in October 2014, and 6% below May 2015. Employment in oil and gas production fell by 26% over the same period. (Sources: EIA, Today in Energy, 22 March 2016 and 5 August 2016. Rig counts: weekly data from the oilfield-services firm Baker Hughes, as reported by the Oil & Gas Journal and others. Brent prices: news reports of the time.)
Verdict. The prediction came true where the decision was made fresh: whether to drill a new well. There, the response was large and fast. Output responded slowly for two reasons. First, wells already drilled keep flowing. Their drilling cost was already paid and could not be recovered, so it was a sunk cost, and it no longer affected the decision to pump. Second, other things were not equal. The EIA found that oil from each new rig in the main shale regions was more than twice its 2013 level, because drilling methods had improved. Better technology is a change in something other than the price, which is the next lecture's topic. The case also shows the role of time: sellers can stop new work within months, but the whole quantity they produce adjusts more slowly.
Three traps
A change in a good's own price changes the quantity supplied. It moves the point along the supply curve. Supply, the whole list, has not changed. Write "the quantity supplied rose" and "a movement along the supply curve". The supply curve itself moves only when something other than the good's own price changes.
Supply tells you what sellers offer at each price. How much is actually sold also depends on the buyers. If Ama bakes 200 pastries at $2.50 but buyers want only 120 at that price, 80 are left over. Putting the two lists together is the job of the equilibrium lecture.
Supply counts only what sellers are willing and able to offer. A baker who would love to sell 1 000 pastries a day but has one small oven does not supply 1 000. And every quantity needs a period: 200 pastries per day is a very different business from 200 per month.
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.
-
Which of these describe supply in the economic sense? Explain each. (a) Nadia would sell 500 cakes a day at $5 each, but her oven can bake only 60 a day. (b) A farmer offers 300 kg of mangoes a week at $2 a kilogram. (c) A report says: "The supply of eggs in the town is 2 000."
Hint 1
Check each case against the parts of the definition: willing, able, a price, a time period.
Hint 2
(a) How many cakes is Nadia able to offer? (c) Which two things are missing?
Full answer
(a) Not 500. Nadia is willing to sell 500 but able to bake only 60, so the quantity she supplies at $5 is at most 60 cakes a day. (b) Yes. The farmer is willing and able, and there is a price and a time period: a quantity supplied of 300 kg per week at $2 a kilogram. (c) Incomplete. It gives one quantity with no price and no time period. Supply is a list of quantities at different prices, each "per" some period. Check: only (b) has every part, and (a) becomes correct once "able" limits it to 60. ✓
-
At a school fundraiser, 20 students offer to walk neighbours' dogs, one dog each per day. Their lowest prices for a walk are: $2 (3 students), $3 (4 students), $4 (5 students), $5 (6 students) and $6 (2 students). (a) Write the supply schedule for prices of $1, $2, $3, $4, $5 and $6. (b) How many more walks are offered when the price rises from $3 to $5? Which reason for the law of supply is this?
Hint 1
At each price, count everyone whose lowest price is that price or less.
Hint 2
At $3, the walkers are those who said $2 or $3: .
Full answer
(a) $1: 0. $2: 3. $3: . $4: . $5: . $6: walks per day. (b) From 7 to 18, so 11 more walks. Each student walks at most one dog, so every extra walk comes from a new seller joining: reason 1. Check: the quantities never fall as the price rises, and at $6 all 20 students are walking. ✓
-
Two farms sell tomatoes in the same market. Farm A would supply 100 kg a week at $1 a kilogram, 160 kg at $2 and 200 kg at $3. Farm B would supply 40 kg at $1, 90 kg at $2 and 130 kg at $3. (a) Write the market supply schedule. (b) The price falls from $3 to $2. Describe the change in two correct economic phrases.
Hint 1
Add the quantities at the same price.
Hint 2
Which changed: the price of tomatoes, or something else? Use "quantity supplied" and "along".
Full answer
(a) $1: kg. $2: kg. $3: kg per week. (b) The quantity supplied falls from 330 kg to 250 kg, a fall of 80 kg per week. This is a movement along the supply curve (a contraction). Supply itself has not changed. Check: , and each farm supplies less at $2 than at $3 (40 kg less and 40 kg less). ✓
-
A stretch. In an invented town, the fee for private tutoring rises from $20 to $30 an hour and then stays there. In the first month, the hours of tutoring offered each week rise from 400 to 460. Two years later, at the same $30 fee, 700 hours a week are offered. (a) Find each rise as a percentage of the original 400 hours. (b) Explain, using the reasons in this lecture, why the response is so much bigger after two years. (c) Is either change a shift of the supply curve?
Hint 1
(a) Percentage rise = rise ÷ original × 100. (b) What can a tutor, or a would-be tutor, do in a month? What can they do in two years?
Hint 2
(b) Think about how long it takes to learn to teach a new subject, to free up time, or to leave another job. Compare the oil wells: stopping new work was fast, the full response was slow.
Full answer
(a) First month: , and . After two years: , and . (b) In a month, only existing tutors can respond, by adding a few hours (reason 2), and a few people with spare time can start at once (reason 1). Over two years, many more people can arrange their lives to tutor: they can learn a subject, leave a job they would otherwise keep, or move teaching time from other work (reasons 1 and 3). The longer the period, the more ways sellers have to respond. (c) No. The fee is the price of tutoring, and nothing else changed. Both are movements along a supply curve; the curve for a two-year period is simply flatter than the curve for one month. How strongly quantity supplied responds is measured in a later lecture on the price elasticity of supply. Check: and . ✓
Put the two lists side by side, and you can see how a market is built. Demand comes from buyers' highest prices: each point on the demand curve says what one more unit is worth to some buyer. Supply comes from sellers' lowest prices: each point on the supply curve says what one more unit costs some seller to make, including what they give up. The markets lecture showed that a trade happens only when a buyer's highest price is at least a seller's lowest price.
So every market holds two lists of numbers, one sloping down and one sloping up. The cooking club and Leila's buyers are at the same fair, with prices from $0.50 to $4.50. Somewhere their lists must meet. Before that, the next lecture shows what moves the supply curve itself: costs and technology. Then the equilibrium lecture brings the two lists together.
- Supply is the quantity of a good that sellers are willing and able to offer for sale at each possible price, in a given period of time.
- A supply schedule can be built by counting, at each price, the units whose lowest price, the cost of producing them, is at most that price.
- The law of supply says that, other things being equal (ceteris paribus), a higher price means a higher quantity supplied.
- The supply curve slopes up because new sellers join, each seller makes more units that cost more to produce, and sellers switch from other goods.
- A change in a good's own price is a movement along the supply curve and changes the quantity supplied, not supply.
- Market supply is found by adding every seller's quantity at the same price.