MathemagiciansLibraryExplorationsDeep Dives
← Economics · Lower Secondary
EconomicsLower Secondary

The circular flow — households and firms

LSE1.3.2 — Income and SpendingLecture 2 of 2~2500 words

Where does the money go next?

The last lecture ended with a promise: to follow the money all the way round. Here it is.

Remember the Mensah family, who are invented. This month they spent $3 000 on rent, food, bus fares and everything else. From the family's side, that money is gone. It has left their pocket, and they will not see it again.

But look at it from the other side. Every one of those dollars arrived somewhere. The rent went to a landlord. The food money went to a market stall. The bus fares went to the bus company. Each of them now has money it did not have before, and each of them will use it to pay someone: workers, suppliers, owners. Those people are households too. Some of the Mensah family's $3 000 may even come back to the Mensah family, as wages for the father's work at the bus company.

So money does not disappear when it is spent. It moves. That raises two questions this lecture answers. If every dollar spent becomes someone's income, can a country's income keep going round and round for ever? And if it can, what makes it grow, or shrink?

Two kinds of actors

A real economy has millions of people and firms. To see the pattern, economists start with a model that has only two kinds of actors.

Households own the factors of production you met in an earlier lecture: land, labour, capital and enterprise. A worker owns her labour. A family owns a piece of land. A saver owns the capital her savings paid for. Firms use those factors to produce goods and services. Every firm is owned by households in the end, so its profit flows to households too.

For now, the model makes three simplifying assumptions: there is no government, no trade with other countries, and households spend all of their income. Later in this lecture, each assumption is removed. A model is like a map. It leaves things out on purpose, so that the important roads are easy to see.

Two loops, going opposite ways

Households and firms trade with each other twice.

First, households sell their factors to firms. The worker sells her labour, the family rents out its land, the saver lends her capital. In return, firms pay factor incomes: wages, rent, interest and profit. This is where household income comes from, as the last lecture showed.

Second, firms sell goods and services to households. In return, households pay for them. That spending is the firms' revenue.

Put the two together, and you get two loops that run in opposite directions.

HouseholdsFirmsSpending on goods and services ($)Income: wages, rent, interest, profit ($)Goods and servicesFactors of productionMoney: solid arrows. Real things: dashed arrows.
The circular flow in its simplest form. Money goes round clockwise: households spend it at firms, and firms pay it back to households as income. Real things go round the other way: factors of production to firms, goods and services to households.

The inner loop carries real things: hours of work, use of land and machines, and the goods and services they produce. The outer loop carries money. For every real thing that moves one way, money moves the other way to pay for it. This picture is called the circular flow of income.

The circular flow (simplest model)

Households sell factors of production to firms and receive income. Households spend that income on the goods and services firms produce.

So in this model, total income = total spending = the value of everything produced.

Why must those three be equal? Follow one dollar. A household spends $1 at a firm. That is $1 of revenue, and $1 of output produced and sold. The firm uses it to pay wages, rent and interest. Whatever is left over is profit, which is income for the households that own the firm. So every dollar of revenue ends up as a dollar of someone's income.

That is it. That is the whole idea. Your spending is someone else's income, and their spending is yours.

Stop and think

A family stops buying meals at a local restaurant and cooks at home instead. They spend the money they save on nothing else. Who loses income, and is it only the restaurant?

Show the answer

The restaurant loses revenue first. But the restaurant's revenue was the income of other households: the cooks' wages, the rent to the landlord, the profit to the owner, and the income of the farms and firms that supplied the food. All of them receive less. The family's choice is private, but its effect spreads round the loop.

An old picture

The circular flow is one of the oldest ideas in economics. In 1758, François Quesnay, a French doctor at the court of King Louis XV, published a table called the Tableau économique, showing money moving between landowners, farmers and craftspeople. As a doctor, he compared it to blood flowing round a body. Many of his other ideas were later shown to be wrong, but this one survived: an economy is a set of connected flows, and a change at one point travels round to every other point.

Leakages: money that leaves the loop

Now remove the simplifying assumptions, one at a time. Each one opens a door through which money can leave the loop. Money that is received as income but not spent on goods and services from the country's own firms is called a leakage. There are three.

A leakage is not money destroyed. It only means that this money is not, for now, buying the output of the home economy's firms.

Injections: money that enters the loop

Money can also enter the loop from outside the household-to-firm spending. This is called an injection. Again there are three, and each one matches a leakage.

HouseholdsFirmsIncome ($)SpendingSTMIGXLeakagesleave the loopInjectionsenter the loop
The loop with its doors open. Saving, taxes and imports leak money out of the loop. Investment, government spending and exports inject money in. Each leakage has a matching injection: S with I, T with G, M with X.

One payment needs care. A pension or an unemployment benefit is a transfer: money given without anything produced in return. It is not counted in G. It works like a tax cut: only the part households spend at firms enters the loop.

Sort the events below. For each one, ask: does this money leave the loop, enter it from outside, or simply go round it?

Sort — leakage, injection, or inside the loop?

Choose a card, then choose its box. Read the reason after each choice.

Eight events in one economy, sorted by whether the money leaves the household-to-firm loop, enters it, or goes round it.

EventBox
A family buys rice grown and sold by local firms.Inside the loop
A factory pays wages to its workers.Inside the loop
A family puts $200 of its pay into a savings account.Leakage (saving)
Income tax is taken from a worker's pay.Leakage (tax)
A family buys a phone made in another country.Leakage (import)
A bakery buys a new oven from a local firm.Injection (investment)
The government pays a teacher's salary.Injection (government spending)
Tourists from abroad pay for hotel rooms.Injection (export)

Why the flow settles where leakages equal injections

Now the important question. Is the flow growing or shrinking? Compare the money leaving with the money arriving.

Growing, shrinking or steady

If injections are bigger than leakages, more money enters the loop than leaves it, and the flow of income grows.

If leakages are bigger than injections, the flow shrinks.

If leakages equal injections, the flow stays the same size.

Think of a bath with the tap on and the plug out. The level rises if the tap adds more than the drain removes, and falls if the drain removes more. But a fuller bath drains faster. So the level settles where the drain removes exactly what the tap adds.

The circular flow works the same way. Leakages are a share of income: when income grows, households save more, pay more tax and buy more imports. So a growing flow leaks more until leakages catch up with injections, and a shrinking flow leaks less until they fall to match. Either way, the flow settles where leakages equal injections.

Some books say leakages "must" equal injections. Not quite. When they differ, the flow is changing. Equality is where it comes to rest. The simulation shows this happening.

Simulate — an invented economy, month by month

The economy is invented. Each month, households receive income. A share of it leaks out as saving, tax and imports. Injections of investment, government spending and exports come in. Choose the leak share and the injections, then press Step or Play and watch the flow.

Try:

This table follows the invented economy for two years. Income starts at $1 000 million a month. Then households decide to save more, so the leak share rises from 20% to 25%. Injections stay at $200 million a month. Next month's income = this month's income − leakages + injections.

MonthIncome ($ million)Leakages (25%)Injections
01 000250200
1950≈ 238200
2≈ 913≈ 228200
6≈ 836≈ 209200
12≈ 806≈ 202200
24≈ 800≈ 200200

While leakages are bigger than injections, income falls. It stops falling at $800 million, because 25% of $800 million is $200 million: leakages equal injections again.

You should have seen three things. "Balanced" does not change, because 20% of $1 000 million is already $200 million. "Households save more" shrinks, quickly at first and then slowly, to about $800 million. "Government spends more" grows to about $1 500 million. Each time, the flow comes to rest where leakages equal injections.

The paradox of thrift

Look again at "Households save more". Every household saved a bigger share of its income. You might expect total saving to rise. In the model it does not: leakages end at $200 million a month, the size of the injections. Households save a bigger share of a smaller income, and everyone's income has fallen by a fifth.

This is called the paradox of thrift. ("Thrift" means being careful with money.) Saving more is often wise for one household. But if every household does it at once, and nothing else changes, total income falls, and total saving may not rise. The economist John Maynard Keynes made the idea famous in 1936.

Notice "nothing else changes". In a real economy, extra saving can be lent to firms for investment, replacing some of the lost spending. Economists still argue about how strong the paradox is; it is strongest in a slump, when firms do not want to invest. The lesson is about thinking: what is true for one household need not be true for all households at once.

A real case: the 2008 payments in the United States

The policy. Early in 2008 the US economy was slowing. In February 2008, Congress passed the Economic Stimulus Act. Its main part was about $100 billion of payments to households: up to $600 per adult, plus $300 per child. About 130 million households were paid, mostly between May and July 2008 (IRS; Parker and others, American Economic Review, 2013).

The prediction. The payments were transfers, so they raised disposable income. The circular flow says only the part households spent would reach firms. Any part saved, including any part used to pay back debts, would leak out. So the boost depended on one question: how much would households spend?

What happened. Two careful studies measured it differently. One used an official spending survey, and the fact that payment dates were decided by the last digits of people's Social Security numbers. In the three months after receiving them, households spent about 12–30% of their payments on everyday goods and services. Once bigger purchases, mainly cars, were included, the figure was about 50–90% (Parker, Souleles, Johnson and McClelland, 2013). The other study asked households directly. Only about one in five said the payment led them mostly to spend more, and over half said mostly to pay off debt (Sahm, Shapiro and Slemrod, Federal Reserve, 2009). They estimated that about one third of the money was spent within a year.

Verdict. The circular flow pointed to the right place to look: a payment becomes firms' revenue only if it is spent, and a large part leaked out as saving and debt repayment. How large a part, the model cannot say by itself. That needs measurement, and two careful methods gave different answers. And remember from the last lecture: paying off a debt is saving, so in circular-flow terms it is a leakage.

A worked example

Worked Example — Growing or shrinking?

In an invented economy, income this month is $1 000 million. Households save 10% of income, pay 15% in tax and spend 15% on imports. Firms invest $150 million, the government spends $180 million and exports are $90 million. Is the flow growing or shrinking, and what will next month's income be?

Think first. Add up the leakages and the injections separately, then compare.

Leakages: of $1 000 million, which is $400 million.

Injections: $150 million + $180 million + $90 million = $420 million.

Injections are $20 million bigger than leakages, so the flow is growing. Next month's income is $1 000 million − $400 million + $420 million = $1 020 million.

Check. The flow will keep growing until 40% of income equals $420 million, which is at $1 050 million. Next month's $1 020 million is on the way there. ✓

Three traps

Trap 1 — "A leakage is money that is lost"

No money is destroyed. Saving still belongs to the saver, tax pays for public services, and import spending is income abroad. A leakage is only money that is not, for now, spent on the home economy's output.

Trap 2 — "Leakages must always equal injections"

They can differ. When they differ, the flow is growing or shrinking. Equality is where the flow settles, not a rule it obeys at every moment.

Trap 3 — Calling saving "investment"

In everyday speech, buying shares is "investing". In the circular flow, investment means firms' spending on new capital, which is an injection. Buying shares is a place to keep saving, which is a leakage. Keep the two words apart.

Try it yourself

Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.

  1. Priya works as a nurse at a private hospital and is paid $2 500 a month. She spends $400 at a local supermarket. Describe both flows, money and real, for each of these two payments.

    Hint 1

    In each payment, one thing moves one way and money moves the other way.

    Hint 2

    Her wage is a factor income. Which factor does she supply?

    Full answer

    Wages: Priya supplies labour (a factor of production) to the hospital, a firm. The hospital pays her $2 500 of income. Real flow: households to firms. Money flow: firms to households. Supermarket: the supermarket supplies groceries (goods) to Priya. She pays $400 of spending. Real flow: firms to households. Money flow: households to firms. Check: in each payment the money goes the opposite way to the real thing. ✓

  2. An invented economy has income of $2 000 million a month. Leakages are 30% of income. Injections are $500 million a month. (a) Is the flow growing or shrinking? (b) What is next month's income? (c) Where will it settle?

    Hint 1

    Find the leakages in dollars first: 30% of $2 000 million.

    Hint 2

    It settles where 30% of income equals $500 million.

    Full answer

    (a) Leakages are $600 million, bigger than injections of $500 million, so the flow is shrinking. (b) $2 000 million − $600 million + $500 million = $1 900 million. (c) Income settles where 0.3 × income = $500 million, so income ≈ $1 667 million (500 ÷ 0.3 ≈ 1 666.7). Check: 30% of $1 667 million ≈ $500 million. ✓

  3. A government sends $100 million of transfers to households. Households spend 40% of it on goods from home firms, 10% on imported goods, and save the rest. (a) How much enters the home economy's spending loop? (b) How much leaks out, and through which doors?

    Hint 1

    A transfer is not itself an injection. Follow what households do with it.

    Hint 2

    Only spending on home firms' output reaches home firms as revenue.

    Full answer

    (a) 40% of $100 million = $40 million is spent at home firms and enters the loop. (b) $10 million leaks out as imports and $50 million as saving: $60 million in all. Check: $40 million + $10 million + $50 million = $100 million. ✓ This is the 2008 case in miniature: the boost to home firms depends on the share that is spent at home.

  4. A stretch. In some small countries, exports are bigger than the whole value of what the country produces. How can that be? Use this invented case. A firm imports phone parts worth $80, assembles them into a phone, and exports it for $100. (a) How much do exports and imports rise? (b) How much of the $100 is income for households in the home country? (c) Explain why a country that trades like this has very large leakages and injections, and why a fall in world trade would hit its circular flow hard.

    Hint 1

    The $80 of parts was produced in another country. Only what is added at home pays home wages and profit.

    Hint 2

    Compare the size of the export with the size of the home income it creates.

    Full answer

    (a) Exports rise by $100 and imports by $80. (b) Only $100 − $80 = $20 is new income at home: the wages, rent, interest and profit of the assembly firm. (c) The export, an injection of $100, is five times the home income it creates, and $80 of it leaks straight out again as imports. A country full of firms like this has exports and imports much bigger than its own income. If world demand for phones falls, the injection falls and, with it, the home income that depends on it. Check: $100 injected − $80 leaked = $20 of home income. ✓ Real example: in 2024, the World Bank measured Singapore's exports at about 179% of its GDP.

The bigger idea

Countries differ hugely in how much of their flow passes through other countries. The World Bank adds exports and imports and compares the total with GDP, the size of a country's own output. In 2024 this was about 322% for Singapore, about 45% for India and about 25% for the United States (World Bank, World Development Indicators). For Singapore, exports and imports are enormous compared with its own income, so a fall in world trade, as in 2008–09 or 2020, reaches its circular flow quickly.

The circular flow also explains why an economy can be measured in three ways that should agree: the income earned, the spending on output, and the value of the output. The next lecture shows how a country measures the size of this flow, with a number called GDP.

Key concepts in this lesson