MathemagiciansLibraryExplorationsDeep Dives
← Physics · Upper Secondary
PhysicsUpper Secondary

Nuclear equations — balancing decay

PU6 — Modern Physics › PU6.2 — Radioactivity and NuclearLecture 2 of 4~2270 words

One element turning into another

For two thousand years, alchemists tried to turn one element into another, such as lead into gold. Chemistry finally said it could not be done. No chemical reaction changes an element. Atoms are rearranged, but every element on the left of a chemical equation is still there on the right.

Then, around 1901, two young scientists at McGill University in Montreal found something strange. Ernest Rutherford and Frederick Soddy were studying radioactive thorium. They found that it kept producing a new radioactive gas, which behaved chemically like argon. Years later, Soddy recalled shouting, "Rutherford, this is transmutation!" Rutherford told him not to use that word, because people would call them alchemists.

But it was transmutation. A radioactive nucleus does not just throw out a particle. It becomes the nucleus of a different element. The last lecture described what comes out: alpha, beta and gamma. It promised that the next step would write beta decay as an equation. This lecture does that for all three, and shows that two simple counting rules tell you exactly which new element appears.

Two numbers on every nucleus

Recall the notation from the lecture on isotopes. A nucleus of element X is written

The top number, the mass number A, counts the nucleons: protons plus neutrons. The bottom number, the atomic number Z, counts the protons. Because each proton carries a charge of +e, Z is also the charge of the nucleus, counted in units of e. And Z decides the element: 92 is always uranium, 88 is always radium.

In a nuclear equation, every particle gets a top number and a bottom number, including the particles that fly out. An alpha particle is a helium-4 nucleus, . A beta particle is an electron. It is not a nucleon, so its top number is 0. Its charge is −e, so its bottom number is −1. We write it .

The two rules that never break

Here is the whole method. In every nuclear decay:

Balancing a nuclear equation

The top numbers add up to the same total on both sides: nucleons are not created or destroyed.

The bottom numbers add up to the same total on both sides: electric charge is not created or destroyed.

Notice what is not on the list. A chemical equation balances the atoms of each element. A nuclear equation cannot, because the elements change. Instead, it balances two totals: nucleons and charge. Those two totals are enough to identify the new nucleus every time.

The nucleus that decays is called the parent. The nucleus left behind is the daughter.

Alpha decay: two places back

Uranium-238 decays by emitting an alpha particle. Write what you know, with a question mark for the daughter:

Top numbers: 238 = ? + 4, so the daughter has A = 234. Bottom numbers: 92 = ? + 2, so the daughter has Z = 90. Element 90 is thorium.

Check: top 238 = 234 + 4 ✓, bottom 92 = 90 + 2 ✓.

Every alpha decay does the same thing. The nucleus loses 2 protons and 2 neutrons, so A falls by 4 and Z falls by 2. The daughter is two places earlier in the periodic table.

Stop and think

A student says: "Uranium-238 loses an alpha particle, which has a mass number of 4. So the daughter has 4 fewer protons, and it is element 88." What has gone wrong?

Show the answer

The student used the top number of the alpha particle to change the proton count. The 4 counts nucleons: 2 protons and 2 neutrons. Only the 2 protons change the element. So Z falls by 2, to 90 (thorium), while A falls by 4, to 234.

Keep the two rows separate. The top row only ever talks about nucleons. The bottom row only ever talks about charge.

Beta decay: one place forward

The last lecture described beta-minus decay in words. A neutron in the nucleus turns into a proton. An electron is created and thrown out, together with an antineutrino. As an equation for the single neutron:

Check it with the two rules. Top: 1 = 1 + 0 ✓. Bottom: 0 = 1 + (−1) ✓. The antineutrino, written , has no charge and is not a nucleon, so it adds 0 to both rows.

Now apply this inside a nucleus. Carbon-14 is the isotope used in radiocarbon dating, and it is a beta emitter:

The mass number stays at 14, because a neutron became a proton and the nucleon count did not change. The atomic number rises from 6 to 7, because there is one more proton. Element 7 is nitrogen.

This is the hard part of the lecture, so spend time on the bottom row. The parent has 6. The daughter has 7. How can 6 = 7 + something? Only if the something is −1. That −1 is the electron. The electron's negative charge exactly balances the extra positive charge left in the daughter.

That is it. That is the whole idea of beta decay. Charge is not created: a neutral neutron splits into a positive proton and a negative electron. The proton stays, and the electron leaves. So the daughter is always one place later in the periodic table, with the same mass number.

The particle nobody could see

Why does the antineutrino belong in the equation? In 1914, James Chadwick found that beta particles from one kind of nucleus come out with a whole spread of energies. That was a puzzle. The decay always releases the same total energy, so some energy seemed to vanish.

On 4 December 1930, Wolfgang Pauli proposed what he called a "desperate remedy" in a letter to a meeting of physicists. A very light neutral particle, he suggested, leaves with the electron and carries off the missing energy. Enrico Fermi later named it the neutrino, "the little neutral one". In 1956, Clyde Cowan and Frederick Reines finally detected antineutrinos coming from a nuclear reactor at Savannah River in the United States, 26 years after Pauli's letter.

Many textbooks at this level leave the antineutrino out, because it changes neither row. Including it costs nothing and makes the equation complete. This course includes it.

Gamma: the nucleus calms down

A gamma ray is a photon. It has no charge and is not a nucleon, so its numbers are 0 and 0. Emitting it changes neither row. The nucleus stays the same element and the same isotope. It only loses energy.

Gamma emission usually follows an alpha or beta decay. The daughter is often left with extra energy, in an excited state, written with a star. It then drops to its normal state by sending out a gamma ray:

Put the three decays side by side on a chart of mass number against atomic number. Each decay is a fixed move.

Z − 2 Z − 1 Z Z + 1 A − 4 A − 3 A − 2 A − 1 A Atomic number (protons) Mass number (nucleons) parent (γ: stays here) after α after β⁻ A same, Z + 1 α: A − 4, Z − 2
The three decays as moves. Alpha: 2 to the left and 4 down. Beta-minus: 1 to the right, no change in mass number. Gamma: no move at all.

Use the two moves to follow a real nucleus. Uranium-238 does not stop at thorium-234. Thorium-234 is radioactive too, and so is its daughter. The decays continue until a stable nucleus is reached. Try to find the route.

Build it — the decay chain of uranium-238

Start at uranium-238. Press α or β⁻ to make one decay. The chart shows your path. Tick the box to compare it with the route that real nuclei take, ending at stable lead-206.

The real decay chain of uranium-238, each step with the main way it decays:

NuclideDecays byDaughter
²³⁸₉₂Uα²³⁴₉₀Th
²³⁴₉₀Thβ⁻²³⁴₉₁Pa
²³⁴₉₁Paβ⁻²³⁴₉₂U
²³⁴₉₂Uα²³⁰₉₀Th
²³⁰₉₀Thα²²⁶₈₈Ra
²²⁶₈₈Raα²²²₈₆Rn
²²²₈₆Rnα²¹⁸₈₄Po
²¹⁸₈₄Poα²¹⁴₈₂Pb
²¹⁴₈₂Pbβ⁻²¹⁴₈₃Bi
²¹⁴₈₃Biβ⁻²¹⁴₈₄Po
²¹⁴₈₄Poα²¹⁰₈₂Pb
²¹⁰₈₂Pbβ⁻²¹⁰₈₃Bi
²¹⁰₈₃Biβ⁻²¹⁰₈₄Po
²¹⁰₈₄Poα²⁰⁶₈₂Pb (stable)

In total: 8 alpha decays and 6 beta-minus decays.

Did you notice the pattern? Every alpha step goes down and to the left, and every beta step goes straight across to the right. The beta steps pull the chain back towards heavier elements, so the route zig-zags. Only alpha decays change the mass number. That fact is the key to Worked Example 5.

Worked examples

Worked Example 1 — Radium-226

Question. Radium-226, , is an alpha emitter. Write the equation and name the daughter.

Top row. 226 = A + 4, so A = 222.

Bottom row. 88 = Z + 2, so Z = 86. Element 86 is radon.

Check. 226 = 222 + 4 ✓ and 88 = 86 + 2 ✓. This radon-222 is the radioactive gas that seeps out of rocks and soil, the "inside the body" danger from the last lecture.

Worked Example 2 — Iodine-131

Question. Iodine-131, , is a beta-minus emitter. Write the equation and name the daughter.

Top row. 131 = A + 0, so A = 131.

Bottom row. 53 = Z + (−1), so Z = 54. Element 54 is xenon.

Check. 131 = 131 + 0 + 0 ✓ and 53 = 54 + (−1) + 0 ✓. Z went up, as it must for beta-minus.

Worked Example 3 — Working backwards

Question. An unknown nucleus X decays by alpha emission. The daughter is . Identify X.

Think first. The parent is on the left, so it holds the totals. Add the products together.

Top row. A = 222 + 4 = 226. Bottom row. Z = 86 + 2 = 88, which is radium.

Answer. X is . Check: this is exactly Worked Example 1, read backwards. ✓

Worked Example 4 — Cobalt-60: beta, then gamma

Question. Cobalt-60, , is used in hospitals as a gamma source. It decays by beta-minus emission to an excited state of nickel, which then emits two gamma rays, of about 1.17 MeV and 1.33 MeV. Write the equations.

Beta step. Top: 60 = A + 0, so A = 60. Bottom: 27 = Z − 1, so Z = 28, nickel. The daughter is excited:

Gamma step. The excited nickel loses its extra energy in two gamma rays:

Check. Both rows balance in each step ✓. The useful gamma rays come from the nickel daughter, even though the source is called "cobalt-60".

Worked Example 5 — Counting the steps in a chain

Question. Uranium-238 (Z = 92) ends, after a chain of decays, as lead-206 (Z = 82). How many alpha decays and how many beta-minus decays are in the chain?

Use the mass number first. Only alpha decay changes A, by 4 each time. A falls from 238 to 206, by 32. So there are 32 ÷ 4 = 8 alpha decays.

Then the atomic number. Eight alpha decays lower Z by 8 × 2 = 16, from 92 to 76. But lead is 82. Each beta-minus decay raises Z by 1, so there are 82 − 76 = 6 beta-minus decays.

Answer. 8 alpha and 6 beta-minus.

Check. A: 238 − 8 × 4 = 206 ✓. Z: 92 − 8 × 2 + 6 = 82 ✓. The real chain in the builder has exactly 8 and 6.

One mistake turns up in beta equations more than any other. See if you can find it.

Spot the error — the beta decay of strontium-90

Leila finds the daughter of strontium-90, a beta-minus emitter. One line is wrong. Tap it.

Leila's working, with the wrong line marked:

  • Line 1: Strontium-90 has A = 90 and Z = 38.
  • Line 2: Beta-minus decay emits an electron, ⁰₋₁e, and an antineutrino, which has 0 in both rows.
  • Line 3: Top row: 90 = A + 0 + 0, so the daughter has A = 90.
  • Line 4: Wrong: "Bottom row: 38 = Z + 1 + 0, so the daughter has Z = 37, rubidium." The electron's bottom number is −1, so 38 = Z − 1 and Z = 39, yttrium.
  • Line 5: Any gamma rays emitted afterwards would change neither row.
Trap 1 — Beta decay lowering Z

In beta-minus decay the atomic number goes up by 1. The −1 belongs to the electron on the right, so the daughter must have one more than the parent to make the bottom row balance. Ask: "A neutron became a proton. Did the proton count go up?"

Trap 2 — Balancing atoms as in chemistry

A nuclear equation does not keep the same elements on both sides. It balances only two totals: the top numbers and the bottom numbers. Do not try to put a "U" on the right of a uranium decay.

Trap 3 — Gamma changing the element

Gamma emission changes neither A nor Z. The nucleus before and after is the same isotope, written with a star before and without it after.

Try it yourself

Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.

  1. Write balanced equations for (a) the alpha decay of polonium-210, , and (b) the beta-minus decay of caesium-137, . Name each daughter. (Lead is element 82; barium is element 56.)

    Hint 1

    Alpha: subtract 4 from the top and 2 from the bottom. Beta-minus: keep the top and add 1 to the bottom.

    Hint 2

    (a) gives Z = 82; (b) gives Z = 56.

    Full answer

    (a) . The daughter is lead-206. Check: 210 = 206 + 4, 84 = 82 + 2 ✓.

    (b) . The daughter is barium-137. Check: 137 = 137 + 0, 55 = 56 + (−1) ✓.

  2. A nucleus decays to by emitting an alpha particle. Identify the parent. (Polonium is element 84.)

    Hint 1

    The parent holds the totals: add the products.

    Hint 2

    Top: 214 + 4. Bottom: 82 + 2.

    Full answer

    A = 218 and Z = 84, so the parent is polonium-218: .

    Check: it appears in the uranium-238 chain, straight after radon-222 ✓.

  3. Thorium-232 (Z = 90) decays through a chain to stable lead-208 (Z = 82). How many alpha and beta-minus decays are in the chain?

    Hint 1

    Start with the mass number: only alpha decays change it.

    Hint 2

    232 − 208 = 24, so there are 6 alpha decays. What Z do they leave?

    Full answer

    Mass number: 24 ÷ 4 = 6 alpha decays. They lower Z by 12, from 90 to 78. Lead is 82, so 82 − 78 = 4 beta-minus decays.

    Answer: 6 alpha and 4 beta-minus. Check: 232 − 6 × 4 = 208 ✓ and 90 − 12 + 4 = 82 ✓.

  4. A nucleus emits one alpha particle, then two beta-minus particles. Show that the final nucleus is an isotope of the original element. How many fewer neutrons does it have? Then apply this to uranium-238, and check it against the real chain.

    Hint 1

    Track A and Z through the three steps: (A − 4, Z − 2), then add 1 to Z twice.

    Hint 2

    Same Z means the same element. Neutrons are A − Z.

    Full answer

    After alpha: A − 4, Z − 2. After two betas: A − 4, Z. The atomic number is back to Z, so it is the same element, and A is 4 less, so it is an isotope.

    Neutrons: before A − Z, after (A − 4) − Z. So 4 fewer neutrons. (The alpha took 2, and each beta turned 1 more into a proton.)

    For uranium-238: alpha gives thorium-234, two betas give uranium-234. In the real chain, ²³⁸U → ²³⁴Th → ²³⁴Pa → ²³⁴U, exactly these three steps ✓. Uranium-234 is found in natural uranium for this reason.

The bigger idea

The two rules have a history. Around 1911–1913, Soddy and, separately, Kasimir Fajans noticed that an alpha decay moves an element two places back in the periodic table, and a beta decay one place forward. This was called the displacement law. You can now see that it is just the two rows of a nuclear equation.

The rules are special cases of two of the deepest laws in physics. The bottom row is conservation of electric charge, which no experiment has ever been seen to break. The top row is conservation of the number of nucleons. And the neutrino story shows the power of trusting such laws. Pauli did not see a new particle. He predicted one, because energy had to be conserved. It took 26 years to prove him right. In the next lecture, the question changes from what a nucleus becomes to when: half-life.

Key concepts in this lesson