- Nuclear equations
- Uses and dangers of radiation
- Magnetic force on a moving charge · coming soon
One word, three very different things
News reports talk about "radiation" as if it were one thing. It is not. In 1899, Ernest Rutherford placed thin sheets of aluminium foil over some uranium and measured how much radiation got through. Part of it was stopped almost at once. Another part went through many more sheets. He named the first part alpha and the second beta, the first two letters of the Greek alphabet. In 1900, Paul Villard found a third kind that was far more penetrating than either. Rutherford later named it gamma.
So an unstable nucleus can send out three very different things. One is stopped by a sheet of paper. Another passes through paper but not a few millimetres of metal. The third still gets partly through several centimetres of lead.
Here is a question to keep in mind. Which of the three is the most dangerous? Most people answer at once: gamma, because it is the hardest to stop. By the end of this lecture you will see that the honest answer is "it depends where the source is". To get there, we need to know what each kind is, and why some are stopped so quickly.
What each one is
Alpha. An alpha particle is two protons and two neutrons held together, with no electrons. That is exactly a helium-4 nucleus, written . Its charge is +2e and its mass is about 4 u, roughly 7300 times the mass of an electron. These are the same alpha particles that Geiger and Marsden fired at gold foil, in the lecture on the nuclear atom. That lecture left one question open: what an alpha particle actually is. In 1908 and 1909, Rutherford and Thomas Royds answered it. They collected alpha particles in a sealed glass tube and, after some days, found helium gas there.
Beta. A beta particle (more exactly, beta-minus, β⁻) is a fast electron. Its charge is −e and its mass is about 0.000 55 u. Here is the puzzle: there are no electrons in a nucleus, so where does it come from? It is made at the moment of decay. A neutron in the nucleus turns into a proton, and an electron is created and thrown out, together with a tiny neutral particle called an antineutrino. The lecture on isotopes showed that some nuclei have too many neutrons to be stable. Turning a neutron into a proton is one way such a nucleus moves towards stability. The next lecture writes this down as an equation.
Gamma. A gamma ray is not a particle of matter at all. It is a photon of electromagnetic radiation, the highest-frequency end of the spectrum you met in the lecture on electromagnetic waves. It has no charge and no mass, and it travels at the speed of light. A gamma ray is sent out by a nucleus that is left with extra energy, often just after an alpha or beta decay. A typical gamma photon carries about a million electronvolts (1 MeV). Compare that with the 13.6 eV needed to ionise a hydrogen atom.
| Alpha (α) | Beta (β⁻) | Gamma (γ) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | helium-4 nucleus | fast electron | high-energy photon |
| Charge | +2e | −e | 0 |
| Mass | ≈ 4 u | ≈ 0.000 55 u | 0 |
| Typical speed | ≈ 5% of the speed of light | up to almost the speed of light | the speed of light |
Why some stop quickly: ionisation
Radiation passing through matter loses its energy mainly by ionisation: it knocks electrons off the atoms it passes. Every ionisation costs energy. In air, it costs about 34 eV, on average, to make one pair of ions (one electron and the positive ion it leaves behind). So a particle with a fixed amount of energy can only make a fixed number of ion pairs. After that, it has nothing left and stops.
This is the key. If a particle ionises very strongly, it spends its energy in a short distance. If it ionises weakly, it travels much further before its energy runs out.
- Alpha ionises very strongly. Its charge is large (+2e), and it is slow, so it spends a long time near each atom it passes. Its pull on their electrons is strong and lasts long enough to tear them off.
- Beta ionises less. Its charge is half as big, and it moves much faster, so it spends less time near each atom.
- Gamma ionises weakly. It has no charge, so it does not pull on electrons as it passes. Most of the time it passes atoms without touching them. Now and then, it gives its energy to one electron in a single event, much as light knocks out an electron in the photoelectric effect. That fast electron then does the ionising.
An alpha particle with 5.0 MeV of energy travels about 3.5 cm in air. A beta particle with 1.0 MeV travels about 3.4 m in air. Compare how many ion pairs each makes per centimetre. Use 34 eV per ion pair.
Alpha. Ion pairs: . Per centimetre: .
Beta. Ion pairs: . Per centimetre: .
Compare. . The alpha particle makes about 500 times as many ion pairs in each centimetre.
Check. The alpha has 5 times the energy but stops in about of the distance. So it must spend energy about 500 times as fast. ✓
That is it. That is the whole idea of this lecture: strong ionisation and weak penetration are the same fact seen from two sides. Alpha stops quickly because it ionises so much. Gamma goes far because it ionises so little.
Gamma is the most penetrating of the three. Kemal says: "So gamma must also do the most damage to every cell it passes through." Is he right?
Show the answer
No. Gamma penetrates far precisely because it ionises weakly. In each small piece of tissue it passes, it does much less ionising than an alpha particle would. Its danger is different: it can reach cells deep inside the body from a source outside it.
An alpha particle does the opposite. It does a great deal of damage in a very short path, but from outside the body that path ends in the outer layer of dead skin.
Testing with absorbers
The same idea gives a simple experiment. Put a source in front of a Geiger counter, then place absorbers between them, one by one. Each kind of radiation is removed by a different absorber. Try it with an invented source that gives out all three.
Add paper, aluminium and lead, one control at a time. The bars show the average counts per minute of each kind reaching the counter. Watch which bar each absorber removes, and notice that the background never goes away.
The table shows average counts per minute from an invented source (alpha 900, beta 400, gamma 150) plus a background of 25. The gamma figures use halving thicknesses for cobalt-60's gamma rays: about 1.2 cm of lead and 4.6 cm of aluminium.
| Absorbers | Alpha | Beta | Gamma | Counter reading |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| none | 900 | 400 | 150 | 1 475 |
| 1 sheet of paper | 0 | 400 | 150 | 575 |
| paper + 5 mm aluminium | 0 | 0 | ≈ 139 | ≈ 164 |
| … + 2.4 cm lead | 0 | 0 | ≈ 35 | ≈ 60 |
Three things stand out. One sheet of paper removes all the alpha. A few millimetres of aluminium remove all the beta, but take only a small share of the gamma. And lead never removes the gamma completely: each extra 1.2 cm halves what is left, so the count falls towards the background but never reaches zero.
Alpha: helium-4 nucleus, +2e, strongly ionising, stopped by paper or a few cm of air.
Beta (β⁻): fast electron from the nucleus, −e, moderately ionising, stopped by a few mm of aluminium.
Gamma: high-energy photon, no charge, weakly ionising, reduced by thick lead or concrete but never stopped completely.
Bending in electric and magnetic fields
Charge gives a second way to tell the three apart. Between two charged plates, alpha particles are pulled towards the negative plate, beta particles towards the positive plate, and gamma rays go straight through. Opposite bends mean opposite charges. No bend means no charge.
A magnetic field also pushes on a moving charge. To find the direction, use Fleming's left-hand rule. Hold your thumb, first finger and second finger of your left hand at right angles. Point the First finger along the Field. Point the seCond finger along the Current. The thuMb then gives the direction of the force, and so of the Motion it causes. A positive particle moving is a current in its direction of motion. A negative particle moving is a current in the opposite direction. That is why alpha and beta always bend opposite ways.
Which bends more? Try predicting first.
Alpha particles (charge +2e) and beta particles (charge −e) enter the same magnetic field. The alpha particles have 5 MeV of energy and the beta particles 1 MeV. Which path bends more sharply?
Drawn to the true ratio for 5 MeV alpha particles and 1 MeV beta particles: the alpha path curves about 70 times more gently than the beta path, so it looks almost straight. The two bend in opposite directions, and gamma goes straight on.
The alpha particle is pushed harder, but it is so much heavier that it hardly turns. Strong magnets are needed to bend alpha particles noticeably. In 1903, Rutherford managed it, and the direction showed they were positive.
Alpha, beta and gamma radiation travel up the page into a magnetic field that points into the page. Which way does each bend?
Alpha. First finger into the page (field). Second finger up the page (current, because alpha is positive and moves up). The thumb points to the left. Alpha bends left.
Beta. Beta moves up, but it is negative, so its current points down the page. First finger into the page, second finger down. The thumb points to the right. Beta bends right.
Gamma. No charge, so no force. Gamma goes straight.
Check. Alpha and beta go opposite ways, as opposite charges must. ✓ (This is the arrangement in the figure above.)
A student measures counts per minute from an unknown source. Background alone: 24. No absorber: 1 240. One sheet of paper: 362. Paper and 5 mm aluminium: 360. Then 2.4 cm of lead as well: 108.
Paper. The count falls by . Something stopped by paper was there: alpha.
Aluminium. The count falls by only 2, which is within the normal random variation of counting. There is no beta.
Lead. What passes the aluminium is still well above background, so it must be gamma. Above background it is . With 2.4 cm of lead it is , which is one quarter: two halvings, as expected if each 1.2 cm halves it.
Answer. The source gives out alpha and gamma, but no beta.
Check. Always subtract the background before comparing counts. Here . ✓
A gamma source gives 640 counts per minute above background. Each 1.2 cm of lead halves the gamma that gets through. How much lead brings it down to 20 counts per minute above background? How much concrete would do the same, if concrete halves it every 6.6 cm?
Halve until 20. 640 → 320 → 160 → 80 → 40 → 20. That is 5 halvings, since .
Lead. cm. Concrete. cm.
Check. and . ✓ Notice that no thickness gives exactly zero. More shielding always means less, never none.
Inside or outside the body
Now return to the opening question. The danger of each kind depends on where the source is.
From outside the body, alpha is the least dangerous: it cannot get through the outer layer of dead skin. Beta can damage skin and eyes. Gamma is the most dangerous, because it reaches the organs inside.
From inside the body, the order turns round. A source of alpha that is breathed in or swallowed sits right next to living cells, and alpha's strong ionisation does great damage there. The clearest real example is radon, a radioactive gas that seeps out of the ground into buildings. Breathed in, radon and the atoms it decays into give out alpha particles in the lungs. The World Health Organization estimates that radon causes between 3% and 14% of all lung cancers in a country, depending on how much radon there is and how many people smoke.
Beta particles come from the nucleus. A neutron turns into a proton, and the electron is created at that moment. The atom's own electrons are not involved.
Alpha has twice the charge, but it is about 7300 times as heavy as an electron. In a magnetic field, beta bends far more. In both electric and magnetic fields, alpha and beta bend in opposite directions.
Lead and concrete reduce gamma, halving it again with each extra thickness, but never to zero. And the counter never reads zero either: subtract the background first.
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.
-
Name the radiation described in each case. (a) It is not deflected by an electric field. (b) It is a nucleus. (c) It has a negative charge. (d) It is stopped by a sheet of paper. (e) It is created when a neutron turns into a proton.
Hint 1
Use the table of what each one is, and the theorem box.
Hint 2
Only one of the three has no charge, and only one is made of protons and neutrons.
Full answer
(a) Gamma. (b) Alpha (a helium-4 nucleus). (c) Beta (β⁻). (d) Alpha. (e) Beta (together with an antineutrino).
Check: alpha is the answer to (b) and (d) because its large charge, mass and slowness make it ionise so strongly. ✓
-
Counts per minute, background 30: no absorber 530; paper 528; 3 mm aluminium 31. Which kinds of radiation does the source give out?
Hint 1
Look at the change caused by each absorber.
Hint 2
After the aluminium, compare the count with the background.
Full answer
Paper: a drop of 2, within random variation, so no alpha. Aluminium: a drop of 497, to almost exactly the background, so beta is present. After the aluminium only 1 count per minute is left above background, so there is no gamma (any gamma would still get through 3 mm of aluminium).
Answer: beta only. Check: , almost all removed by aluminium. ✓
-
A beam of beta particles travels to the right, across the page. A magnetic field points out of the page. Which way does the beam bend? Which way would an alpha beam travelling to the right bend? Between two charged plates, with the positive plate at the top, which way would each bend?
Hint 1
For beta, the current points opposite to the motion.
Hint 2
First finger out of the page, second finger to the left for beta. Where does your thumb point?
Full answer
Beta: current to the left, field out of the page, so the force is up the page. The beta beam bends up. Alpha: current to the right, so the force is down: alpha bends down, but much more gently.
Between the plates: beta is pulled towards the positive plate, so it bends up. Alpha is pulled towards the negative plate, so it bends down.
Check: in each field the two bend in opposite directions. ✓ Here the two fields happen to push each particle the same way.
-
A hospital stores a cobalt-60 source. Outside the storage room, the gamma radiation must be reduced to of what it would be with no shielding. Lead halves cobalt-60's gamma every 1.2 cm, and concrete every 6.6 cm. How thick must a lead wall be? How thick a concrete wall? Why might the hospital still choose concrete?
Hint 1
How many halvings make a number at least 1000 times smaller?
Hint 2
.
Full answer
9 halvings give , not enough. 10 halvings give , which is enough. Lead: cm. Concrete: cm.
Concrete is much thicker, but it is far cheaper than lead, strong enough to be the wall itself, and easy to pour into any shape. Where space allows, many shielded rooms are made of concrete.
Check: 1024 is more than 1000, and , the same as . ✓
The three names came before anyone knew what the radiations were. Rutherford simply ranked them by how far they got. In 1903, he measured the thickness of aluminium needed to stop each: about 0.0005 cm for alpha, 0.05 cm for beta, and 8 cm for gamma. Only later was each identified: beta as electrons, alpha as helium nuclei, and gamma, in 1914, as electromagnetic waves, when gamma rays were shown to reflect from crystals in the same way as X-rays.
Then the radiation became a tool. Alpha particles from radium were the probes that Geiger and Marsden fired at gold foil, and they revealed the nucleus. Ionisation, the property that makes radiation harmful, is also how every radiation detector works, and the next lectures follow what happens to the nucleus that sends the radiation out.
- An alpha particle is a helium-4 nucleus with charge +2e, a beta particle is a fast electron created in the nucleus, and a gamma ray is a high-energy photon.
- Radiation loses energy by ionising atoms, about 34 eV per ion pair in air, so strong ionisation means a short range.
- Alpha is stopped by paper, beta by a few millimetres of aluminium, and gamma is only reduced by thick lead or concrete, never to zero.
- In electric and magnetic fields alpha and beta bend in opposite directions, beta much more sharply, while gamma goes straight on.
- Fleming's left-hand rule gives the force on a moving charge, with the current taken opposite to the motion for a negative particle.
- Outside the body gamma is the most dangerous, but inside the body alpha does the most damage, as radon in homes shows.