- Alpha, beta and gamma radiation
- Nuclear equations
- Nuclear binding energy and mass defect · coming soon
A nucleus that weighs too much
Rutherford's experiment showed that an atom has a tiny, positive nucleus. Soon physicists could measure two things about each nucleus: its charge and its mass. The numbers did not fit.
Take helium. Its nucleus has a charge of , the charge of two protons. But its mass is about four times the mass of a proton. If the nucleus were made only of protons, two protons would give the right charge and half the mass. Four protons would give the right mass and twice the charge.
The same problem appeared in every element except hydrogen. The nucleus always weighed about twice as much as its charge suggested, or more.
For years, the favourite answer was that the nucleus held extra protons, with electrons stuck between them to cancel the extra charge. Helium would be four protons and two electrons. In 1920 Rutherford suggested something different: a neutral particle with about the mass of a proton. Nobody could find it, because a particle with no charge leaves no track and is not pushed by electric fields. In 1932 James Chadwick showed that it exists. He called it the neutron.
So helium's nucleus is two protons and two neutrons. That is the whole answer to the puzzle. But it opens three new questions, and this lecture answers each one. How do we label a nucleus? Why do atoms of one element come in different masses? And what holds protons together, when they repel each other so strongly?
Two numbers for every nucleus
Protons and neutrons together are called nucleons, because they are the particles of the nucleus. Two numbers describe a nucleus completely.
The atomic number is the number of protons. It is also called the proton number.
The mass number is the number of nucleons: protons plus neutrons. It is also called the nucleon number.
The neutron number is .
Each number controls something different. fixes the charge of the nucleus, . That charge decides how many electrons a neutral atom holds: exactly . The electrons decide how the atom bonds and reacts. So decides which element the atom is. Change , and you have a different element.
fixes the mass. A proton and a neutron each have a mass very close to 1 unified atomic mass unit (u), and an electron is about 1800 times lighter. So the mass of an atom in u is very close to .
A nucleus with a particular and is called a nuclide. It is written with the mass number at the top left and the atomic number at the bottom left:
Carbon-12 has 6 protons and neutrons. Uranium-238 has 92 protons and neutrons. The bottom number is a little redundant, because the symbol already tells you the element. It is written anyway, because it makes the counting in nuclear equations easy, as a later lecture shows.
Compare and : protons, neutrons, and electrons in a neutral atom.
Protons. Both have . That is why both are uranium.
Neutrons. Uranium-235: . Uranium-238: .
Electrons. A neutral atom has as many electrons as protons, so both have 92.
Check: and . ✓ They differ by exactly three neutrons and nothing else.
An iron ion is written . How many protons, neutrons and electrons does it have?
The nucleus is not changed by losing electrons. So it still has 26 protons and neutrons.
A neutral iron atom has 26 electrons. The charge means three have been lost, leaving 23.
Check: charge . ✓ An ion changes the electrons. Only a nuclear process can change or .
Isotopes: one element, several masses
Uranium-235 and uranium-238 are isotopes: nuclides with the same number of protons and different numbers of neutrons. The word was suggested to the chemist Frederick Soddy in 1913 by the doctor Margaret Todd. It is Greek for "same place", because isotopes share one place in the periodic table.
Why do isotopes behave the same way in chemistry? Because chemistry is done by electrons. Isotopes have the same nuclear charge, so they hold the same electrons in the same arrangement. Carbon-12, carbon-13 and carbon-14 all burn to carbon dioxide in exactly the same way.
Isotopes differ in two ways. Their masses differ, so anything that depends on mass changes a little: heavier molecules move more slowly at the same temperature, for example. And their nuclei differ. Carbon-12 and carbon-13 are stable. Carbon-14 is radioactive: its nucleus changes by itself, after a time that cannot be predicted for any one atom. Only about one carbon atom in is carbon-14, but that is enough to date ancient wood and bone, as a later lecture explains.
Argon-40, potassium-40 and calcium-40 all have mass number 40. Are they isotopes of one another?
Show the answer
No. Argon has 18 protons, potassium 19 and calcium 20. They are three different elements that happen to have the same total number of nucleons. Argon-40 has 22 neutrons, potassium-40 has 21 and calcium-40 has 20.
Isotopes share , not . The mass number alone never tells you the element. Only the proton number does.
Here is the surprise. Not every combination of protons and neutrons makes a nucleus that lasts. Explore it below.
Change the protons and the neutrons, one at a time, or choose a preset. Watch what changes: the element, the mass number, and whether the nucleus is stable. Dark dots on the chart are the stable nuclei up to calcium.
Presets:
The table shows five nuclei. Only some combinations of protons and neutrons are stable.
| Nuclide | Z | N | Stable? |
|---|---|---|---|
| carbon-12 | 6 | 6 | stable |
| carbon-14 | 6 | 8 | radioactive: too many neutrons for 6 protons |
| beryllium-8 | 4 | 4 | falls apart at once, although beryllium-9 is stable |
| chlorine-37 | 17 | 20 | stable |
| calcium-40 | 20 | 20 | stable |
Three things should stand out. Changing the protons changed the element every time. The stable nuclei sat in a narrow strip close to the line , with a few more neutrons as grew. And the exact numbers matter: beryllium-8 splits into two helium-4 nuclei almost at once, although beryllium-9 is stable, and sulfur has stable nuclei with 16, 17, 18 and 20 neutrons but not 19. The next section explains the strip.
What holds a nucleus together
This is the hard part of the lecture. Spend time here.
Protons repel each other. Inside a nucleus they are only about 2 femtometres apart (2 fm m). Coulomb's law gives the push between two protons at that distance:
That is about the weight of a 6 kg bag of rice, acting on one particle with a mass of about kg. Something must pull harder.
That something is the strong nuclear force. It attracts every nucleon to its neighbours: proton to proton, proton to neutron, neutron to neutron. At a distance of a nucleon's width it is far stronger than the electric push. But it has a very short range. A few femtometres away it is almost nothing. So each nucleon is held only by the few nucleons touching it.
The electric force is different. It reaches across the whole nucleus. Every proton pushes on every other proton, not just its neighbours. Count the pushing pairs. With protons there are pairs:
| Nucleus | Protons | Pairs of protons pushing apart |
|---|---|---|
| helium-4 | 2 | 1 |
| carbon-12 | 6 | 15 |
| calcium-40 | 20 | 190 |
| iron-56 | 26 | 325 |
| lead-208 | 82 | 3 321 |
Look at what happens. Double the protons, and the pushing pairs roughly multiply by four. But the strong pull grows only in step with the number of nucleons, because each one only grips its neighbours. So in a large nucleus, the push grows faster than the pull.
Neutrons are the answer. A neutron adds strong pull and no push at all. So heavier nuclei need more neutrons per proton to stay together. That is why the strip of stable nuclei bends away from .
The band does not go on for ever. Lead, with 82 protons, is the heaviest element with a stable isotope. Above it, no number of neutrons is enough. Bismuth-209 was long thought to be stable, but in 2003 a team in Orsay, France, measured its decay. Its half-life is about years, a billion times the age of the universe. Counting every element, about 251 stable nuclides are known, shared among 80 elements. Two light elements, technetium (43) and promethium (61), have no stable isotope at all.
A nucleus outside the band changes itself until it reaches the band. Carbon-14 has too many neutrons for 6 protons, so one of its neutrons turns into a proton, and it becomes nitrogen-14. How that happens, and what comes out, is the subject of the radioactivity lectures.
That is it. That is the whole idea. Stability is a balance: a short-range pull that every nucleon gives, against a long-range push that only protons give.
Weighing isotopes: relative atomic mass
Isotopes were discovered by weighing atoms one at a time. In 1913 J. J. Thomson sent a beam of charged neon atoms through electric and magnetic fields. The fields bend a light ion more than a heavy one. Neon left two marks: a strong one at mass 20, and a faint one at 22. In 1919 Francis Aston, who had worked as Thomson's assistant, built a better instrument, the mass spectrograph. He confirmed neon-20 and neon-22, and found chlorine-35 and chlorine-37. He received the 1922 Nobel Prize in Chemistry. Today's version is called a mass spectrometer.
The periodic table gives one number for chlorine: 35.45. This is the relative atomic mass, : the average mass of the atoms in a natural sample, compared with one twelfth of the mass of a carbon-12 atom. Because it is an average over many atoms, each isotope counts in proportion to how common it is. This is a weighted average.
Natural chlorine is 75.76% chlorine-35 and 24.24% chlorine-37. Find its relative atomic mass, first using the mass numbers, then using the measured masses, 34.969 u and 36.966 u.
With mass numbers. .
With measured masses. .
The second answer matches the table. The first is close, because each nuclide's mass is close to its mass number, but not equal to it. Exam questions usually give mass numbers. Real tables use measured masses.
Check: the answer lies between 35 and 37, and much nearer 35, because three atoms in four are chlorine-35. ✓
Here is one student's version of the same calculation. One line is wrong.
Tap the line that contains the mistake.
The working below has one wrong line, line 3.
- Chlorine is 75.76% chlorine-35 and 24.24% chlorine-37. (Correct.)
- The relative atomic mass is the average mass of the atoms in a natural sample. (Correct.)
- So Ar = (35 + 37) ÷ 2 = 36. (Wrong: this gives each isotope the same weight. The weighted average is 0.7576 × 35 + 0.2424 × 37 ≈ 35.48.)
- Check: 36 lies between 35 and 37. (True, but this check cannot catch the mistake.)
The weighted average is what the scales in a laboratory measure. One mole of chlorine atoms has a mass of 35.45 g, even though no single atom has a mass of 35.45 u.
In Aston's time, neon's relative atomic mass was given as 20.2. Assume it is a mixture of neon-20 and neon-22 only. What fraction is neon-20?
Let the fraction of neon-20 be . Then the fraction of neon-22 is , and
So , which gives and . About 90% of neon is neon-20.
Check: . ✓ Modern measurements give 90.48% neon-20, with a little neon-21 as well.
In , the protons are 17, the bottom number. The top number counts protons and neutrons together, so it is always the larger one. Neutrons are top minus bottom: .
No chlorine atom has a mass of 35.45 u, and no atom has half a neutron. The relative atomic mass is a weighted average over many atoms. Each isotope counts in proportion to its abundance, never equally.
Some are, but most isotopes found in nature are stable, such as carbon-12, carbon-13 and both isotopes of chlorine. An isotope is any nuclide of an element. Whether it is stable depends on its balance of protons and neutrons, not on being an isotope.
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.
-
Give the numbers of protons, neutrons and electrons in a neutral atom of , and in the ion .
Hint 1
The bottom number is the protons. Neutrons are top minus bottom.
Hint 2
The ion has the same nucleus. Only the electrons change.
Full answer
Atom: 82 protons, neutrons, 82 electrons. Ion: 82 protons, 125 neutrons, electrons. Check: charge . ✓
-
Magnesium is 78.99% magnesium-24, 10.00% magnesium-25 and 11.01% magnesium-26. Find its relative atomic mass using the mass numbers.
Hint 1
Turn each percentage into a fraction and multiply by its mass number.
Hint 2
.
Full answer
(to 4 s.f.). The table value, from measured masses, is 24.31. Check: the answer is close to 24, because almost four atoms in five are magnesium-24. ✓
-
Use the explorer, or the idea of the band, to decide which of these are stable: oxygen-16, oxygen-19, neon-20, sodium-24. For each unstable one, say whether it has too many or too few neutrons.
Hint 1
Work out and for each. For light nuclei, stable ones have close to .
Hint 2
Oxygen's stable isotopes have 8, 9 or 10 neutrons. Sodium has only one stable isotope, sodium-23.
Full answer
Oxygen-16 (8 protons, 8 neutrons): stable. Oxygen-19 (8, 11): unstable, too many neutrons, since oxygen's stable isotopes stop at 10. Neon-20 (10, 10): stable. Sodium-24 (11, 13): unstable, one neutron more than sodium-23, the only stable one. Check: both unstable ones lie above the band, on the neutron-rich side. ✓
-
Bromine has two isotopes, bromine-79 and bromine-81, and a relative atomic mass of 79.904. (a) Estimate the fraction of bromine-79 using the mass numbers. (b) Repeat with the measured masses, 78.918 u and 80.916 u. (c) Why do the answers differ so much, when chlorine's two methods agreed closely?
Hint 1
Write for part (a).
Hint 2
For (b), replace 79 and 81 by the measured masses. Notice that both measured masses are about 0.08 below their mass numbers.
Full answer
(a) , so : about 55% bromine-79. (b) , so and : about 51%, which matches the measured 50.69%. (c) Both measured masses are about 0.08 u below their mass numbers, so using mass numbers shifts the answer. Here the target, 79.904, is almost exactly halfway between the two isotopes. Near the middle, a small shift in the masses changes the fraction a lot: 0.08 out of a gap of 2 is a 4% change. Check: . ✓
Aston's instrument was precise enough to show that nuclide masses are close to whole numbers, but not exactly. Try it with carbon-12. Its mass is exactly 12 u, by definition. Now add up its parts: 6 protons (1.007 276 u each), 6 neutrons (1.008 665 u each) and 6 electrons (0.000 549 u each). The total is about 12.099 u.
The carbon-12 atom is lighter than its own parts, by about 0.1 u. Where did that mass go? When the nucleons were pulled together by the strong force, energy was released, and that energy carried mass away with it. This "missing mass" measures how tightly a nucleus is held together. It is the key to why the Sun shines and why nuclear power works, and it is the subject of the Pre-University lecture on binding energy.
- The atomic number Z is the number of protons, the mass number A is the number of protons plus neutrons, and the neutron number is N = A − Z.
- Z fixes the charge of the nucleus and so the number of electrons, which is why it decides the element and its chemistry.
- Isotopes have the same Z and different N, so they react in the same way but differ in mass and in nuclear stability.
- The strong nuclear force pulls neighbouring nucleons together over a very short range, while every proton repels every other proton.
- Heavy nuclei need more neutrons per proton to be stable, and no element above lead has a stable isotope.
- The relative atomic mass is a weighted average of the isotope masses, using each isotope's abundance.