- How households earn and spend money
- Effects of inflation
- What is money: functions and forms · coming soon
Paid in pigs
In 1875 the English economist William Stanley Jevons began his book on money with a strange story. A singer from a Paris theatre, Mademoiselle Zélie, was touring the world. She gave a concert in the Society Islands, in the Pacific Ocean, for a share of the ticket money. But there was very little money on the islands. So the audience paid in goods. Her share, Jevons reports, was 3 pigs, 23 turkeys, 44 chickens, 5 000 coconuts, and large amounts of bananas, lemons and oranges.
She was rich, in a way. But she could not eat 5 000 coconuts, and she could not carry the pigs to her next concert. While she looked for a way to turn her fee into something useful, the fruit was fed to the pigs and the chickens. (Source: W. S. Jevons, Money and the Mechanism of Exchange, 1875, chapter 1.)
The markets lecture showed that trade does not need money. Two neighbours can swap mangoes for eggs, and both can gain. That is barter: exchanging goods and services directly for other goods and services, with no money. So here is the puzzle. If barter works, why does every modern economy use money? What exactly goes wrong without it?
The answer is not "barter is old-fashioned". Barter has three specific problems, and each one points to a specific job that money does.
The first problem: two people must want each other's goods
A barter trade needs two things to be true at the same time. The other person must have what you want. And you must have what the other person wants. Jevons called this the double coincidence of wants. "Coincidence" means two things happening together. "Double" means it must happen on both sides.
Here is a small invented market. Three traders each have one good and want one other good.
Look for a pair that can swap. Amara wants Diego's vegetables, but Diego does not want fish. Diego wants Mei's rice, but Mei does not want vegetables. Mei wants Amara's fish, but Amara does not want rice. Every pair fails the double coincidence. All three go home with what they did not want, even though everything each of them wanted was in the market.
Barter can still be rescued here. Amara could take Mei's rice for her fish, even though she does not want rice, and then swap the rice with Diego for vegetables. But now Amara must accept a good she does not want, hold it, carry it and hope. That is an extra trade, extra effort and extra risk. With three traders it is just possible. With hundreds of traders and hundreds of goods, it becomes hopeless.
Now add money. Mei pays Amara $10 for fish. Amara pays Diego $10 for vegetables. Diego pays Mei $10 for rice. (These prices are invented.) Each trade is simple, between two people, and nobody has to find a perfect partner. The same goods move to the same people as before.
Money cuts every barter trade into two halves. First you sell what you have, to anyone who wants it, for money. Later you buy what you want, from anyone who has it, with that money. The person who wants your good and the person who has your good no longer need to be the same person.
That is it. That is the whole idea of money as a medium of exchange: something that almost everyone accepts in payment, because they know that everyone else will accept it from them.
How much harder is barter?
The difficulty grows very fast as the number of goods grows. The model below is invented and simple, but it shows the size of the problem. There are some number of different goods in a market. You meet traders one at a time. Assume that one in every (goods − 1) traders has the good you want, and, separately, one in every (goods − 1) traders wants the good you have.
Change the number of different goods in the market. Compare the meetings you need, on average, to get the good you want by barter and with money. The model is invented and simple.
This table shows, for the invented model, the average number of traders you would need to meet to get the good you want.
| Different goods | Barter: one partner with both | Money: one sale, then one purchase |
|---|---|---|
| 2 | 1 | 2 |
| 3 | 4 | 4 |
| 5 | 16 | 8 |
| 10 | 81 | 18 |
| 20 | 361 | 38 |
| 30 | 841 | 58 |
With barter, one trader in every (goods − 1) has what you want, and one in every (goods − 1) wants what you have, so you need both at once: about (goods − 1) × (goods − 1) meetings. With money, you first sell to anyone who wants your good, about (goods − 1) meetings, and then buy from anyone who has what you want, about (goods − 1) more. The model leaves out amounts that do not match, goods that go bad, and trust.
You should have seen that the gap explodes. With 10 goods, barter needs about 81 meetings and money needs about 18. With 30 goods, it is about 841 against 58. Barter's number is the money number multiplied by itself, roughly, because barter needs two pieces of luck at once while money needs only one at a time. Notice also that with only 2 goods, barter wins: every trader you meet is a perfect partner. This is why barter can work well in a very small village, and why it breaks down in a town.
The second problem: too many prices
Does barter have prices?
Show the answer
Yes. The markets lecture said that in a barter trade "the price is paid in goods". If 4 eggs swap for 1 mango, the price of a mango is 4 eggs. The problem is not that barter has no prices. The problem is that it has far too many of them.
In a barter market, every good has a price in terms of every other good. A mango costs 4 eggs. A fish costs 2 mangoes. A bag of rice costs 3 fish. Each pair of goods needs its own price. With 4 goods there are 6 pairs, so 6 prices. With 100 goods there are prices. Nobody can remember 4 950 prices, and nobody can tell quickly whether a deal is good.
Now use money. Every good gets one price, in dollars. With 100 goods there are 100 prices. And any two goods can be compared at once: if a fish is $6 and a mango is $3, a fish is worth 2 mangoes. Money is a common measuring stick. This job is called being a unit of account: the unit in which prices are written, wages are agreed, and a business adds up its accounts.
The third problem: goods do not keep
Mademoiselle Zélie's fruit was going bad while she waited. A farmer paid in fish today cannot save that fish to buy shoes next year. Many goods rot, get eaten by pests, or cost a lot to store. Others, such as a cow, cannot be cut into small pieces without being destroyed.
Money lets you separate the moment you sell from the moment you buy. You can sell your harvest in March and spend the money in December. This job is called being a store of value: money holds its buying power from today until a later day.
Medium of exchange: accepted in payment for goods and services, so a trade no longer needs a double coincidence of wants.
Unit of account: the common unit for writing prices, so every good needs only one price and any two goods can be compared.
Store of value: keeps its buying power over time, so selling and buying can happen on different days.
Each function answers one problem of barter. Check that you can match them.
Put each example in the box for the function of money it shows. Ask: is money being used to pay, to measure, or to keep?
This box sorts eight examples by the function of money each one shows.
- Medium of exchange (paying): paying a bus fare with coins · a farmer selling rice for money and later buying a bicycle with it · a worker accepting wages in money
- Unit of account (measuring): a café menu with every price in dollars · working out that a phone costs as much as 40 meals · a business adding up its costs for the year
- Store of value (keeping): putting money in a savings box for a gift next year · a family keeping savings in a bank for school fees in five years
Notice that the store-of-value job is the weakest of the three. Money keeps its value well only while prices stay steady. If prices doubled, $100 saved under a mattress would buy only half as much as before. (That example is invented.) A general rise in prices is called inflation, and later lectures look at who it harms. For now, the point is this: money is a better store of value than fish or fruit, but it is not a perfect one.
A real case: cigarettes as money in a prison camp
The situation. Richard Radford was a British soldier held in prisoner-of-war camps in Italy and Germany during the Second World War. After he was freed, he wrote a description of the camps' economy. Each prisoner received the same food parcels from the Red Cross: tinned milk, jam, butter, biscuits, chocolate, sugar, and cigarettes. Everyone received the same goods, but people's tastes differed. Non-smokers wanted chocolate. Smokers wanted cigarettes. The camp money that existed could buy almost nothing, so nobody used it.
The prediction. This lecture predicts three things. First, people will trade, because swapping goods that you value less for goods that you value more makes both sides better off. Second, barter will be clumsy, because of the double coincidence of wants. Third, one good that almost everyone accepts will start to be used as money.
What happened. Trade began almost at once, at first as barter. Then cigarettes rose from being an ordinary good to being the camp's money, although barter never disappeared completely. Prices were written in cigarettes, so cigarettes became the unit of account as well. Even non-smokers accepted cigarettes in payment, because they could use them to buy food from someone else, at another time and place. When the Red Cross deliveries were interrupted, cigarettes ran short, prices in cigarettes fell, and trade slipped back towards barter. When a large delivery arrived, several hundred thousand cigarettes could come in about two weeks, and prices shot up. (Source: R. A. Radford, "The Economic Organisation of a P.O.W. Camp", Economica, November 1945.)
Verdict. The prediction came true on all three counts. Without any government or bank, the prisoners created money because it solved the problems of barter. Cigarettes worked as money because they were wanted by many people, easy to carry, easy to count, easy to recognise, and could be split into small amounts (a single cigarette). The case also shows money's weak point. When the amount of cigarettes in the camp changed, every price changed with it, so cigarettes were an unreliable store of value. Radford traced most of the camp's economic trouble to that instability.
The same thing can happen in reverse. When money stops working well, people return to barter, even in a modern industrial economy. In Russia in the 1990s, many firms had little cash, and many customers could not pay. Firms began paying each other in goods. According to surveys of Russian industrial firms, barter rose from about 5% of industrial sales in 1992 to about 50% in 1998. It then fell sharply after the financial crisis of August 1998. (Sources: Russian Economic Barometer surveys of industrial firms, as reported by S. Commander and C. Mumssen in an IMF seminar paper, 2000, and by D. Marin and colleagues, University of Munich.) All the problems of barter returned: the search for partners, the long chains of swaps, and goods that had to be stored and resold.
Did money really grow out of barter?
The story in this lecture's first sections is a model. It shows clearly why money is useful. But is it history? Adam Smith told a similar story in 1776: first people bartered, and then they invented money to escape the problems. Many textbooks still tell it as fact.
Anthropologists, who study how real societies live, have looked for that barter stage and have not found it. The Cambridge anthropologist Caroline Humphrey wrote in 1985 that "no example of a barter economy, pure and simple, has ever been described" (Man, 1985). The anthropologist David Graeber made the same argument at length in his book Debt (2011). In small communities where people know each other, they mostly share, give gifts and keep track of who owes whom. Barter appears mainly between strangers, or, as in the prison camp and in Russia, among people who already know money but cannot get enough of it.
So hold two ideas apart. The logic of this lecture is not in dispute: barter really does suffer from the double coincidence of wants, too many prices, and goods that do not keep, and money really does solve all three. The history of how money first appeared is still debated. Some economists reply that a period of barter could have existed where no records survive. It is a fair question to leave open.
Three traps
Barter has prices, written in goods: 4 eggs for a mango. Its problem is that it needs a separate price for every pair of goods. Money gives every good one price in one unit.
A note is printed paper, and most money today is just a number in a bank account. Money works because people accept it, and they accept it because they are confident that others will accept it from them. Cigarettes in the camp were accepted by non-smokers for exactly this reason. Money is also not a factor of production: as the factors lecture showed, money on its own makes nothing.
Money keeps its value only as well as prices stay steady. When prices rise, each dollar buys less. In the camp, every large cigarette delivery made each cigarette buy less. Say "money stores value fairly well over short periods", not "money keeps its value".
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.
-
In each case, is there a double coincidence of wants? (a) Kofi has a football and wants a book; Lina has a book and wants a football. (b) Kofi has a football and wants a book; Lina has a book and wants a bicycle. (c) Kofi has a large goat and wants one bag of salt; Lina has many bags of salt and wants a goat.
Hint 1
Check both sides: does each person have what the other wants?
Hint 2
In (c), think about the amounts as well as the goods.
Full answer
(a) Yes. Each has exactly what the other wants. (b) No. Lina has what Kofi wants, but Kofi does not have what Lina wants. Kofi would need to find a third person. (c) The goods match, but the amounts do not. A goat is worth many bags of salt, and a goat cannot be cut into pieces without being killed. So Kofi must either take far more salt than he wants or not trade. Check: this is the problem of goods that cannot be divided, which money solves because it comes in small units. ✓
-
A village market has 6 different goods. (a) How many barter prices are there? (b) How many money prices? (c) Repeat for a town market with 40 goods.
Hint 1
Barter needs one price for each pair of goods.
Hint 2
The number of pairs from goods is .
Full answer
(a) barter prices. (b) 6 money prices, one for each good. (c) barter prices, against 40 money prices. Check for 6 goods by listing the pairs for one good: it pairs with 5 others; doing that for all 6 goods counts every pair twice, so . ✓
-
In an invented country, prices are rising so fast that they double every month. Workers spend their wages on the day they are paid. Shops begin writing their prices in a foreign currency. Which functions of money is the country's own money failing to do? Which one is it still doing?
Hint 1
Spending wages immediately is a sign that money is not being kept. Which function is about keeping?
Hint 2
Writing prices in another currency means the money is no longer the measuring stick.
Full answer
It is failing as a store of value, because money loses half its buying power in a month, so nobody holds it. It is failing as a unit of account, because shops measure prices in a different currency. It is still a medium of exchange, because workers are paid in it and shops still accept it, at least for now. Check: each failure matches one behaviour in the question. ✓ When the third function fails too, people turn to the foreign currency or to barter, as Russian firms did in the 1990s.
-
A stretch. A school runs a week-long camp on an island with no shops. The organiser gives every student 20 tokens, and students trade snacks, chores and borrowed equipment. (a) Before the tokens, students could have used apples, pebbles from the beach, or the organiser's tokens as money. Judge each one as money. (b) Halfway through the week, the organiser gives every student 20 more tokens, but the number of snacks does not change. Predict what happens to prices in tokens, and say which camp in this lecture saw the same thing.
Hint 1
(a) Use the qualities of cigarettes in the camp: wanted, easy to carry, easy to count, easy to recognise, divisible, and not easy to make more of.
Hint 2
(b) Twice as many tokens chase the same snacks. What will sellers do when buyers can offer more?
Full answer
(a) Apples are wanted and easy to recognise, but they go bad and cannot be split easily, so they are a poor store of value. Pebbles are easy to carry, but anyone can pick up more from the beach, so their value would collapse. Tokens are light, countable, recognisable and hard to copy, and only the organiser can make more of them, so they are the best choice, as long as everyone accepts them. (b) Students now hold twice as many tokens, but there are no more snacks to buy. Buyers compete by offering more tokens, so prices in tokens rise, roughly doubling if nothing else changes. This is what happened in the prisoner-of-war camp when a large delivery of cigarettes arrived. Check: the snacks are no scarcer than before; only the amount of money has changed, so the change shows up in prices. ✓
Money has taken many forms: shells, cattle, metal coins, paper notes, numbers in a bank account, and payments made by tapping a phone. The form keeps changing, but the test does not. Whatever people accept in payment, use to write prices, and trust to hold value is money. Money is, at heart, an agreement. A note has value because millions of people expect that others will take it.
That makes money one of the great inventions in economics, whether or not it grew out of barter. It lets a fisher in one town and a shoemaker in another trade without ever meeting. It lets a student save for next year. And it lets anyone compare the value of a meal, a phone and an hour of work with one number. The next lecture follows the money: how households earn it and how they decide to spend it.
- Barter is the direct exchange of goods and services for other goods and services, without money.
- A barter trade needs a double coincidence of wants: each person must have what the other wants, at the same time and in matching amounts.
- Money is a medium of exchange, a unit of account and a store of value, and each function solves one problem of barter.
- With many goods, barter needs one price for every pair of goods, while money needs only one price for each good.
- People accept money because they are confident that others will accept it, as cigarettes were accepted in a prisoner-of-war camp.
- The logic of why money beats barter is clear, but whether money historically grew out of barter is still debated.