- Nucleophilic addition to aldehydes and ketones · coming soon
- Carboxylic acids and their derivatives · coming soon
The crossroads of organic chemistry
The last lecture made alcohols from halogenoalkanes, using hydroxide ions. It ended with a promise: the next lecture follows the alcohols you made, and what they in turn can become. Here it is.
Alcohols sit at a crossroads. You have already met three ways to make them: adding steam to an alkene, hydrolysing a halogenoalkane, and fermenting sugar. Now you will meet three ways to change them: oxidation, dehydration and esterification. Between them, these six reactions connect almost every family you have studied.
Here is a puzzle to solve along the way. Propan-1-ol and propan-2-ol have exactly the same formula, C₃H₈O. Yet when each is warmed with the same orange oxidising agent, they give different products. And 2-methylpropan-2-ol, an alcohol with one more carbon, gives no reaction at all. The −OH group is the same in all three. So what decides?
Primary, secondary and tertiary
The answer is the carbon atom that carries the −OH group. Count how many other carbon atoms are joined to it.
- Primary (1°): one other carbon. Examples: ethanol CH₃CH₂OH, propan-1-ol CH₃CH₂CH₂OH. (Methanol, with no other carbon, behaves as primary.)
- Secondary (2°): two other carbons. Example: propan-2-ol CH₃CH(OH)CH₃.
- Tertiary (3°): three other carbons. Example: 2-methylpropan-2-ol (CH₃)₃COH.
This is the same counting you used for carbocations and halogenoalkanes. But here, count the other way round too. The C–OH carbon has four bonds: one to O, and the rest to carbons or hydrogens. So a primary C–OH carbon has two hydrogens, a secondary one has one hydrogen, and a tertiary one has none. That hydrogen count is what matters for oxidation.
Oxidation: losing hydrogen
The usual oxidising agent is acidified potassium dichromate(VI): K₂Cr₂O₇ with dilute sulfuric acid. It is orange. When it oxidises something, the chromium is reduced from +6 to +3, and the solution turns green. So a colour change from orange to green shows that oxidation has happened.
What happens to the alcohol? To make a C=O double bond, two hydrogen atoms are removed: the H on the oxygen, and an H on the C–OH carbon. The oxidising agent takes them away as water. In equations, chemists write the oxidising agent's contribution as [O], "oxygen from the oxidising agent":
Now the puzzle solves itself.
- A primary alcohol has an H to lose, so it forms an aldehyde (–CHO). The aldehyde carbon still has one H, so it can be oxidised again, to a carboxylic acid (–COOH).
- A secondary alcohol forms a ketone (C=O inside the chain). The ketone carbon has no H left, so oxidation stops there.
- A tertiary alcohol has no H on the C–OH carbon. To oxidise it, a C–C bond would have to break, and acidified dichromate cannot do that. So there is no reaction, and the solution stays orange.
That is it. That is the whole idea of alcohol oxidation: count the hydrogens on the C–OH carbon. Two hydrogens allow two steps, one allows one step, and none allows none.
Stopping at the aldehyde
A primary alcohol can give either product, so how do chemists choose? By using the boiling points. Ethanal boils at about 20 °C, ethanol at 78 °C and ethanoic acid at 118 °C. The aldehyde boils lowest because, unlike the alcohol and the acid, its molecules cannot hydrogen-bond to each other.
- To get the aldehyde: warm the alcohol with a limited amount of dichromate and distil the aldehyde off as soon as it forms. It leaves the flask before it can be oxidised again.
- To get the acid: use excess dichromate and heat under reflux. A condenser fixed upright returns every vapour to the flask, so the aldehyde stays and is oxidised again.
Try every combination below.
Choose an alcohol and a method. The picture shows the carbon carrying −OH, with its hydrogens highlighted, and the colour of the dichromate afterwards.
Alcohol:
Method:
The table shows what acidified potassium dichromate(VI) does to five alcohols, with each method. The primary and secondary alcohols turn it from orange to green; the tertiary alcohol leaves it orange.
| Alcohol | Type | Distil as it forms | Reflux, excess |
|---|---|---|---|
| ethanol | 1° | ethanal | ethanoic acid |
| propan-1-ol | 1° | propanal | propanoic acid |
| propan-2-ol | 2° | propanone | propanone |
| butan-2-ol | 2° | butanone | butanone |
| 2-methylpropan-2-ol | 3° | no reaction | no reaction |
Notice that the method only matters for primary alcohols. For secondary and tertiary alcohols, the hydrogen count has already decided the outcome.
Sanjay warms an unknown alcohol with acidified dichromate. The solution turns green. He says: "So it must be a primary alcohol." Is he right? What could he do next?
Show the answer
Not yet. Green shows only that the alcohol was oxidised, so it is primary or secondary. A tertiary alcohol is the only one ruled out.
To decide, he can distil off the product and test it. An aldehyde (from a primary alcohol) can still be oxidised, and a ketone cannot. Two reagents use this: Tollens' reagent (silver nitrate in aqueous ammonia) gives a silver mirror with an aldehyde, and Fehling's solution (an alkaline copper(II) solution) turns from blue to a brick-red precipitate of copper(I) oxide. A ketone gives neither.
The oxidation-states lecture found that the CH₂OH carbon in ethanol has an oxidation state of −1. Follow it through ethanal and ethanoic acid, then write the full equation for the first step with dichromate.
Ethanal, CH₃CHO. The CHO carbon has one bond to H (−1 for carbon, since carbon is more electronegative), two bonds to O (+2), and one to C (0). Oxidation state: +1.
Ethanoic acid, CH₃COOH. The COOH carbon has three bonds to O (+3) and one to C (0). Oxidation state: +3.
So −1 → +1 → +3: each step is an oxidation by 2. Each step loses two electrons.
Full equation. Dichromate's half-equation is Cr₂O₇²⁻ + 14H⁺ + 6e⁻ → 2Cr³⁺ + 7H₂O, so one dichromate oxidises three ethanol molecules:
Check. H: 18 + 8 = 26 on the left, 12 + 14 = 26 on the right. O: 3 + 7 = 10 on each side. Charge: −2 + 8 = +6 on the left, 2 × 3 = +6 on the right. ✓ The [O] equation is a shorthand for this.
Dehydration: back to an alkene
Heat ethanol with an excess of concentrated sulfuric acid at about 170 °C, and ethene comes off. Concentrated phosphoric(V) acid works too, and is often preferred because it is not an oxidising agent and gives a cleaner product. Or pass ethanol vapour over heated aluminium oxide.
The −OH and a hydrogen from the next carbon are removed together as water, and a C=C forms between those two carbons. Removing a small molecule to make a double bond is called elimination. The halogenoalkanes lecture named elimination once; this is your first full example.
Look back at the alkenes lecture. There, steam was added to ethene, with a phosphoric acid catalyst at about 300 °C and 60–70 atm. Here, water is removed from ethanol. It is the same reaction run in reverse. High pressure and plenty of steam push it towards ethanol. A strong acid that soaks up water, and ethene escaping as a gas, push it towards ethene. This is Le Chatelier's principle choosing the direction.
Which alkenes can form when butan-2-ol, CH₃CH(OH)CH₂CH₃, is dehydrated?
Find the neighbours. The C–OH carbon is carbon 2. Its neighbours, carbon 1 and carbon 3, both carry hydrogens.
Remove H from carbon 1. The C=C forms between carbons 1 and 2: CH₂=CHCH₂CH₃, but-1-ene.
Remove H from carbon 3. The C=C forms between carbons 2 and 3: CH₃CH=CHCH₃, but-2-ene. (At Pre-University you will see that but-2-ene itself comes in two forms, because the C=C cannot rotate.)
Check. Both products are C₄H₈: butan-2-ol, C₄H₁₀O, minus H₂O. ✓ Ethanol, by contrast, can give only ethene, because both of its carbons lead to the same double bond.
Esterification: alcohol plus acid
Warm an alcohol with a carboxylic acid and a few drops of concentrated sulfuric acid, and a sweet, fruity smell appears. The product is an ester, and water is the other product:
Ethanoic acid and ethanol give ethyl ethanoate, a solvent in some nail-polish removers and glues. Many fruit smells and flavours are esters.
Naming. The name has two words. The first comes from the alcohol, as an alkyl group: ethanol → ethyl. The second comes from the acid, ending in -oate: ethanoic acid → ethanoate. Notice that the formula is usually written the other way round, with the acid part first: CH₃COO–CH₂CH₃. This mismatch is the most common naming mistake.
The reaction is reversible, as the ⇌ shows. The sulfuric acid is a catalyst, so it speeds up both directions. You met this exact reaction in the equilibrium lectures: Berthelot found that equal amounts of acid and alcohol go only about two-thirds of the way, which gives Kc ≈ 4. Find the error in a student's working below.
A student makes an ester from propan-1-ol and ethanoic acid. One line is wrong. Tap it.
The student's working, line by line, with the error marked.
- The alcohol is propan-1-ol and the acid is ethanoic acid. (Correct.)
- Warm them with a few drops of concentrated sulfuric acid as a catalyst. (Correct.)
- CH₃COOH(l) + CH₃CH₂CH₂OH(l) ⇌ CH₃COOCH₂CH₂CH₃(l) + H₂O(l). (Correct.)
- The ester is named acid first, then alcohol: ethyl propanoate. (Error. The alcohol gives the first word: propan-1-ol → propyl. The acid gives the second: ethanoate. The ester is propyl ethanoate.)
- The reaction is reversible, so the yield is less than 100%. (Correct.)
A student mixes 6.0 g of ethanoic acid (Mr 60) with ethanol and a catalyst, and lets the mixture reach equilibrium. Use Kc = 4. Find the mass of ethyl ethanoate (Mr 88) if (a) equal amounts in moles of acid and ethanol are used; (b) three times as much ethanol is used.
Moles of acid. mol.
(a) As in the equilibrium lecture, equal amounts go two-thirds of the way. Ester: mol, so g, about 67% of the 8.8 g possible.
(b) Let x mol of ester form, with 0.300 mol of ethanol. Then , which gives . The quadratic formula gives (the other root, 0.443, is more than the acid available). Mass: g, about 90%.
Check. Adding more of one reactant pushes the equilibrium to the right, as Le Chatelier predicts. 90% is more than 67%. ✓
Where alcohols are used
- Ethanol as a fuel. It burns completely to carbon dioxide and water: C₂H₅OH(l) + 3O₂(g) → 2CO₂(g) + 3H₂O(l). Made by fermenting sugar from plants, it can replace part of the petrol in cars; many countries sell petrol containing 10% ethanol. Whether it really saves carbon dioxide depends on how the crops are grown and processed.
- Ethanol as a solvent. It dissolves both water-loving and oily substances, so it is used in perfumes, medicines and food flavourings.
- Propan-2-ol as an antiseptic. It kills microbes on skin and surfaces, as in many hand sanitisers.
- Methanol is a fuel and a starting material for other chemicals. It is highly toxic: even a small amount swallowed can cause blindness or death, so it must never be confused with ethanol.
Tertiary alcohols do not react with acidified dichromate, because the C–OH carbon has no hydrogen to lose. Do not write a ketone or an acid as the product. Count the hydrogens on the C–OH carbon first.
Acidified dichromate changes from orange to green when it oxidises an alcohol. It is not decolourised. With a tertiary alcohol it simply stays orange.
The alcohol gives the first word (ethyl, propyl) and the acid the second (ethanoate, propanoate), even though the formula is usually written with the acid part first.
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.
-
Classify each alcohol, and give the product (if any) of heating it under reflux with excess acidified dichromate: (a) butan-1-ol; (b) butan-2-ol; (c) 2-methylbutan-2-ol; (d) pentan-3-ol.
Hint 1
Draw the C–OH carbon and count the carbons joined to it.
Hint 2
Under reflux, a primary alcohol goes all the way to the acid.
Full answer
(a) Primary → butanoic acid, CH₃CH₂CH₂COOH. (b) Secondary → butanone, CH₃COCH₂CH₃. (c) Tertiary (the C–OH carbon carries two methyl groups and an ethyl group) → no reaction; stays orange. (d) Secondary → pentan-3-one, CH₃CH₂COCH₂CH₃.
Check: only (a) and the ketones keep the same number of carbons, and none of the products needed a C–C bond to break. ✓
-
Three bottles have lost their labels. They contain propan-1-ol, propan-2-ol and 2-methylpropan-2-ol. Plan tests to identify each.
Hint 1
One test picks out the tertiary alcohol at once.
Hint 2
For the other two, oxidise gently, distil, and test the product.
Full answer
Warm a little of each with acidified dichromate. The one that stays orange is 2-methylpropan-2-ol. The other two turn green.
Repeat with those two, distilling off the product. Warm each distillate with Tollens' reagent. Propan-1-ol gives propanal, which gives a silver mirror. Propan-2-ol gives propanone, which gives no mirror. (Fehling's solution works the same way: brick-red with the aldehyde only.)
Check: each bottle is identified by a different result. ✓
-
Write the equation, with state symbols, for making an ester from methanol and butanoic acid. Name the ester and find its Mr (C = 12, H = 1, O = 16).
Hint 1
Water is removed from the −COOH of the acid and the −OH of the alcohol.
Hint 2
Methanol gives "methyl"; butanoic acid gives "butanoate".
Full answer
CH₃CH₂CH₂COOH(l) + CH₃OH(l) ⇌ CH₃CH₂CH₂COOCH₃(l) + H₂O(l). The ester is methyl butanoate, C₅H₁₀O₂.
Mr = .
Check: the alcohol gives the first word, and the formula still balances: C₅H₁₂O₃ on each side. ✓
-
A liquid X has the formula C₃H₈O. It reacts with acidified dichromate (orange → green). The product, distilled off as it forms, gives a silver mirror with Tollens' reagent. When X is heated with concentrated phosphoric acid, it gives a single alkene. Identify X, the oxidation product and the alkene. Then explain why a third compound with the formula C₃H₈O, CH₃OCH₂CH₃, gives none of these results.
Hint 1
Which result shows a primary alcohol?
Hint 2
CH₃OCH₂CH₃ has no −OH group: it is an ether.
Full answer
The silver mirror shows an aldehyde, so X is a primary alcohol: propan-1-ol, CH₃CH₂CH₂OH. The oxidation product is propanal, CH₃CH₂CHO. The alkene is propene, CH₂=CHCH₃ (it is the only alkene possible, since only one carbon is next to the C–OH carbon).
Propan-2-ol would also give propene, but its oxidation product, propanone, gives no silver mirror. Methoxyethane, CH₃OCH₂CH₃, has no −OH group and no C–OH carbon. So it has no hydrogen to lose in oxidation, and no −OH to eliminate as water. All three reactions in this lecture belong to the −OH group.
Check: propan-1-ol, propan-2-ol and methoxyethane are the three structural isomers of C₃H₈O. ✓
An alcohol is two parts in one molecule: the −OH, which behaves a little like water, and the carbon chain, which behaves like an alkane. The −OH can hydrogen-bond to water, so methanol, ethanol and the propanols mix with water in any amount. As the chain grows, the oily part takes over: butan-1-ol only partly dissolves, and long-chain alcohols hardly dissolve at all.
The same balance between a water-loving end and an oily tail runs through biology and everyday life. Soap molecules hold grease with their tails and water with their heads. The membranes around every living cell are built from molecules with a water-loving head and two oily tails. Look for this pattern: the same reasoning about polar and non-polar parts explains a great deal of chemistry.
- An alcohol is primary, secondary or tertiary according to how many carbons are joined to the C–OH carbon, so its C–OH carbon carries two, one or no hydrogens.
- Acidified dichromate oxidises primary alcohols to aldehydes and then carboxylic acids, and secondary alcohols to ketones, turning from orange to green.
- Tertiary alcohols are not oxidised by acidified dichromate, because there is no hydrogen on the C–OH carbon to remove.
- Distilling the product as it forms gives the aldehyde, and heating under reflux with excess oxidising agent gives the acid.
- Dehydration with a hot acid catalyst eliminates water to give an alkene, the reverse of the hydration of an alkene.
- An alcohol and a carboxylic acid react reversibly to give an ester and water, and the ester is named alcohol part first.