MathemagiciansLibraryExplorationsDeep Dives
← Chemistry · Upper Secondary
ChemistryUpper Secondary

Oxidation states — assigning them systematically

CU8 — Redox and Electrochemistry › CU8.1 — RedoxLecture 2 of 3~2120 words

A fire with no ions in it

Natural gas burns in a cooker flame:

CH₄(g) + 2O₂(g) → CO₂(g) + 2H₂O(l)

Every chemist calls this an oxidation. Carbon gains oxygen, so in the old sense it is clearly oxidised. But the last lecture said that oxidation really means losing electrons. Look for the electrons here, and you will not find them moving. Methane, oxygen, carbon dioxide and water are all covalent molecules. No ions form. Nothing obviously gives an electron to anything else.

So does the electron definition fail for most of the reactions that keep us warm and alive? It does not. But we need a new tool to see the electrons. The last lecture promised a bookkeeping tool for reactions where electrons are shared rather than fully transferred. Here it is: oxidation states.

The idea: give every shared pair to the stronger puller

In a covalent bond, two atoms share a pair of electrons. The lecture on bond polarity showed that the sharing is usually unequal. The more electronegative atom pulls the pair closer to itself.

An oxidation state takes that idea to its extreme. We pretend, for bookkeeping only, that the more electronegative atom takes the shared pair completely. Then every bond becomes ionic, and every atom gets a charge. That pretend charge is the atom's oxidation state.

Oxidation state

The oxidation state of an atom is the charge it would have if every bond it forms were ionic, with each shared pair of electrons given to the more electronegative atom. A bond between two atoms of the same element is shared equally, one electron each.

Let us use it on the cooker flame. The Pauling electronegativities are C 2.55, H 2.20 and O 3.44.

In methane, carbon is more electronegative than hydrogen, so carbon takes all 8 bonding electrons. A carbon atom normally has 4 outer electrons. Now it "owns" 8, so it has 4 extra: its oxidation state is −4. Each hydrogen atom normally has 1 electron and now owns none, so each is +1.

H+1H+1H+1H+1C−4CH₄C 2.55 · H 2.20O−2O−2C+4CO₂C 2.55 · O 3.44
Bookkeeping in methane and carbon dioxide. Each shared pair (green dots) is given to the more electronegative atom. In CH₄, carbon takes all four pairs and is −4. In CO₂, the oxygens take all the bonding electrons, so carbon is +4 and each oxygen is −2. Grey dots are lone pairs.

In carbon dioxide, oxygen is more electronegative than carbon, so the oxygens take all 8 bonding electrons. Carbon owns none of its usual 4, so it is +4. Each oxygen owns its 4 lone-pair electrons plus 4 bonding electrons: 8 instead of its usual 6. So each oxygen is −2.

Now compare. Carbon goes from −4 in methane to +4 in carbon dioxide. On paper, it has lost 8 electrons. Each oxygen atom goes from 0 in O₂, where the bond is between identical atoms, to −2. On paper, each has gained 2. The four oxygen atoms gain 8 between them, exactly what carbon lost.

That is it. That is the whole idea. A rise in oxidation state is oxidation, and a fall is reduction. The electrons did not jump from atom to atom as they did in the zinc and copper reaction. But they did shift: towards oxygen, and away from carbon. Oxidation states measure that shift with whole numbers.

Stop and think

Carbon is +4 in carbon dioxide. Does the carbon atom in a CO₂ molecule really carry a charge of 4+?

Show the answer

No. The real carbon atom carries only a small partial positive charge, because the electrons in the bonds are shared, unequally but not completely. The +4 is a bookkeeping number that comes from pretending every bond is ionic. It is still very useful, because it changes in the right direction and by the right amount when electrons shift. Only for a simple ion, such as Na⁺ or Cl⁻, is the oxidation state the same as a real charge.

Shortcuts that come from the idea

Drawing every bond would be slow. Fortunately, the idea gives a few rules that do the counting for you. Each rule has a reason, and the reasons tell you when a rule can fail. When two rules disagree, the one higher in this list wins.

Assigning oxidation states

Rule 3 is the one that finds the unknown. Assign the atoms you are sure of, then make the total match the charge.

Two writing habits keep oxidation states and charges apart. An oxidation state is written with its sign first: +3, −2. A charge is written with its number first: Fe³⁺, O²⁻. And an oxidation state belongs to one atom, never to a whole ion. "The sulfate ion has a charge of 2−" is right. "The oxidation state of sulfate is −2" is not; sulfur and oxygen each have their own.

Worked examples

Worked Example 1 — Sulfur in sulfuric acid, and its family

Find the oxidation state of sulfur in H₂SO₄.

Think first. H is bonded to O, a non-metal, so H is +1. O is −2. The molecule is neutral, so the total is 0. Call sulfur's oxidation state .

So , and .

The same method gives sulfur's oxidation state in other compounds: −2 in H₂S and +4 in SO₂, while sulfur itself is 0. Placed on a scale, these show at a glance which changes are oxidations.

−2−10+1+2+3+4+5+6H₂SSSO₂H₂SO₄oxidationreductionOxidation state of S
Sulfur's oxidation states. Moving up the scale is oxidation, and moving down is reduction. Burning H₂S to SO₂ moves sulfur from −2 to +4: an oxidation.

Check. Sulfur has 6 outer electrons, so +6 is the most it can reach: every outer electron has been given away on paper. ✓

Worked Example 2 — Manganese in the manganate(VII) ion

Find the oxidation state of manganese in MnO₄⁻.

Think first. This is an ion, so the total is its charge, −1, not 0.

So . The ion is called the manganate(VII) ion, and KMnO₄ is potassium manganate(VII). Its older name, permanganate, is still common.

The Roman numeral in a name is the oxidation state. This is the Stock system, proposed by the German chemist Alfred Stock in 1919. It is why iron(II) chloride is FeCl₂ and iron(III) chloride is FeCl₃. (Source: Wikipedia, "Stock nomenclature".)

Check. Manganese has 7 electrons outside its noble-gas core (3d⁵ 4s²), so +7 is its highest possible state. ✓

Worked Example 3 — When the usual values fail

Find the oxidation state of oxygen in H₂O₂ and in OF₂, and of hydrogen in NaH.

H₂O₂ (hydrogen peroxide). Its structure is H–O–O–H. Each H is +1. The O–O bond is between identical atoms, so it is split equally. Then , so each oxygen is −1. Rule 7's "usually" has met its first exception.

OF₂. Fluorine is more electronegative than oxygen, so rule 4 beats rule 7. Each F is −1, so and oxygen is +2.

NaH (sodium hydride). Sodium is +1 (rule 5), so hydrogen must be −1. Sodium's electronegativity is only 0.93, so hydrogen (2.20) wins the pair. This matches rule 6.

Check. In each case, the atom that wins the electrons has the negative oxidation state. ✓

Now try the method on dichromate, Cr₂O₇²⁻. It has two chromium atoms, and that is where students slip. Find the slip below.

Spot the error — chromium in dichromate

A student finds the oxidation state of chromium in Cr₂O₇²⁻. One line contains the mistake. Tap the line where it first goes wrong.

This box shows a student's working for chromium in Cr₂O₇²⁻, with the line where it goes wrong.

  • The overall charge is −2. Correct.
  • Each O is −2, so seven oxygens give 7 × (−2) = −14. Correct.
  • Let the oxidation state of chromium be x. Correct.
  • x + (−14) = −2. This is the error. There are two chromium atoms, so the sum must contain 2x.
  • x = +12, so chromium is +12. These follow from the wrong line.

The correct line is , so and each chromium is +6. A check would have caught the error: chromium has only 6 electrons outside its noble-gas core, so it cannot be +12.

Always count the atoms of the unknown element, and divide at the end. The answer is the oxidation state of each atom.

Worked Example 4 — What is oxidised, what is reduced?

In acid, manganate(VII) ions react with iron(II) ions: MnO₄⁻ + Fe²⁺ → Mn²⁺ + Fe³⁺ (not yet balanced). Identify what is oxidised and what is reduced.

Manganese goes from +7 to +2. It falls by 5, so manganese is reduced: each Mn atom gains 5 electrons. Iron goes from +2 to +3. It rises by 1, so iron is oxidised: each Fe²⁺ ion loses 1 electron. Oxygen is −2 throughout, so it is neither.

The electrons lost must equal the electrons gained. So one MnO₄⁻ ion needs five Fe²⁺ ions. The next lecture uses exactly this count to balance the full equation.

Check. The oxidising agent (MnO₄⁻) is the one that is reduced, as in the last lecture. ✓

Worked Example 5 — A fraction: iron in magnetite

Magnetite, the magnetic iron ore, is Fe₃O₄. Find the oxidation state of iron.

So . No single atom can be +2.67. The fraction is an average. Fe₃O₄ is one compound, not a mixture, but it contains iron in two oxidation states: for every Fe²⁺ ion there are two Fe³⁺ ions. Check: , and . ✓ Its Stock name is iron(II,III) oxide.

A fraction is a signal that atoms of one element sit in different places. The step-through below shows this happening inside one molecule, ethanol, where the two carbon atoms have different oxidation states.

Step through — the two carbons in ethanol

Ethanol is CH₃–CH₂–OH. Press Next step to give each shared pair to the stronger puller, one kind of bond at a time.

Each step below gives one line of the bookkeeping for ethanol, CH₃–CH₂–OH, and the reason.

  • Step 1. Each C–H bond: the pair goes to carbon. Reason: C (2.55) is more electronegative than H (2.20).
  • Step 2. The C–C bond: one electron to each carbon. Reason: identical atoms share equally.
  • Step 3. The C–O and O–H bonds: both pairs go to oxygen. Reason: O (3.44) beats both C and H.
  • Step 4. The CH₃ carbon owns 3 × 2 + 1 = 7 electrons, against its usual 4: it is −3.
  • Step 5. The CH₂ carbon owns 2 × 2 + 1 + 0 = 5 electrons: it is −1.
  • Step 6. Each H owns 0 electrons, so each is +1. Oxygen owns 4 + 2 + 2 = 8 against its usual 6, so it is −2.
  • Step 7. Check: −3 + (−1) + 6(+1) + (−2) = 0. Reason: the molecule is neutral.

Conclusion. The two carbons are −3 and −1. The rules on the formula C₂H₆O give only their average, −2.

This matters when ethanol is oxidised. Only the carbon attached to oxygen changes. In ethanoic acid, CH₃COOH, that carbon is +3, while the CH₃ carbon stays −3. The formula rules alone would hide where the change happened.

Three traps

Trap 1 — Forgetting how many atoms there are

In Cr₂O₇²⁻, the sum contains 2x, not x. Multiply each oxidation state by the number of atoms, then divide your answer by the number of atoms of the unknown element. A value above the element's number of outer electrons is a sure sign of this slip.

Trap 2 — Mixing up charges and oxidation states

Write charges number first (Fe³⁺, SO₄²⁻) and oxidation states sign first (+3). A whole ion has a charge; each atom in it has an oxidation state. In SO₄²⁻, the ion's charge is 2−, sulfur is +6 and each oxygen is −2.

Trap 3 — Applying "O = −2" and "H = +1" without looking

Peroxides (O–O bonds), compounds with fluorine and metal hydrides break these rules. Before you use a rule, ask its reason: who wins each shared pair? If the answer changes, so does the number.

Try it yourself

Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.

  1. Find the oxidation state of: (a) N in NH₄⁺ (b) N in NO₃⁻ (c) S in SO₃²⁻ (d) Cl in ClO₃⁻.

    Hint 1

    Each one is an ion, so the total is the ion's charge, not zero.

    Hint 2

    (a) . (b) .

    Full answer

    (a) , so N is −3. (b) , so N is +5. (c) , so S is +4. (d) , so Cl is +5. Check: N has 5 outer electrons, so it can range from −3 (gaining 3 to fill its shell) to +5 (giving all 5 away). Both answers sit at the ends of that range. ✓

  2. (a) Name FeCl₃, Cu₂O and MnO₂ using the Stock system. (b) Write the formula of chromium(III) oxide.

    Hint 1

    Find the metal's oxidation state from the other element, then write it as a Roman numeral in brackets after the metal's name.

    Hint 2

    (b) Cr is +3 and O is −2. Find the smallest numbers of each atom that make the total zero.

    Full answer

    (a) In FeCl₃, three Cl at −1 make −3, so Fe is +3: iron(III) chloride. In Cu₂O, O is −2, so each of the two Cu is +1: copper(I) oxide. In MnO₂, two O make −4, so Mn is +4: manganese(IV) oxide. (b) Two Cr at +3 make +6, and three O at −2 make −6. So the formula is Cr₂O₃. Check: . ✓

  3. When hydrogen sulfide and sulfur dioxide gases meet, they react to form yellow sulfur: . Show that this is a redox reaction, and say what is oxidised and what is reduced.

    Hint 1

    Find the oxidation state of sulfur in each sulfur-containing substance. Check H and O too.

    Hint 2

    Sulfur is −2 in H₂S, +4 in SO₂ and 0 in S.

    Full answer

    The sulfur in H₂S rises from −2 to 0, so it is oxidised. The sulfur in SO₂ falls from +4 to 0, so it is reduced. Hydrogen stays +1 and oxygen stays −2. Check the electrons: two H₂S molecules each lose 2, a total of 4, and one SO₂ gains 4. They match. ✓ So H₂S is the reducing agent and SO₂ is the oxidising agent, even though both contain the same element.

  4. A stretch. Household bleach is made by passing chlorine into cold sodium hydroxide solution: . (a) Find the oxidation state of chlorine in Cl₂, NaCl and NaClO. (b) What is unusual about this redox reaction? (c) Give the Stock name of NaClO.

    Hint 1

    In NaClO, Na is +1 and O is −2.

    Hint 2

    Compare the two chlorine atoms that start in one Cl₂ molecule. Where does each one end up?

    Full answer

    (a) Cl₂: 0. NaCl: −1. NaClO: , so Cl is +1. (b) One chlorine atom from the same molecule is reduced (0 to −1) while the other is oxidised (0 to +1). The same element is both oxidised and reduced in one reaction. This is called disproportionation. (c) Sodium chlorate(I). Check: one electron is lost and one gained, so the electrons balance with one Cl₂ giving one Cl⁻ and one ClO⁻, as the equation shows. ✓

The bigger idea

Oxidation states let you see redox where no ions form. Your own body depends on it. In respiration, glucose, C₆H₁₂O₆, reacts with oxygen to give carbon dioxide and water. The average oxidation state of carbon in glucose is 0, from . In CO₂ it is +4. So each glucose molecule gives up 6 × 4 = 24 electrons on paper, and the six O₂ molecules take them: 12 oxygen atoms, each falling from 0 to −2. Respiration is the cooker flame, done slowly and in many small steps, so the energy can be captured.

Remember what oxidation states are: a bookkeeping system, not real charges. Their power comes from being consistent. The same rules work for a metal burning, a battery and a living cell. The next lecture uses the electron counts they give, like the 1 : 5 for manganate(VII) and iron(II), to balance redox equations step by step.

Key concepts in this lesson