MathemagiciansLibraryExplorationsDeep Dives
← Chemistry · Upper Secondary
ChemistryUpper Secondary

Structural isomers — same formula different structure

CU9 — Organic Chemistry › CU9.1 — Introduction to OrganicLecture 3 of 4~2320 words

Seven substances, one formula

The last lecture ended with a stretch question: draw and name every alcohol with the formula C₄H₁₀O. There are four: butan-1-ol, butan-2-ol, 2-methylpropan-1-ol and 2-methylpropan-2-ol. The lecture promised that the next one would give these molecules a name. Here it is.

But four is not the end of the story. The same ten hydrogens, four carbons and one oxygen can also be joined so that the oxygen sits between two carbons, with no −OH group at all. There are three ways to do that. So C₄H₁₀O is the formula of at least seven different substances.

And they really are different. Butan-1-ol boils at about 118 °C. Ethoxyethane, one of the other three, boils at about 35 °C. A liquid that is hard to boil and a liquid that boils in a warm hand have exactly the same formula.

So a molecular formula only counts atoms. It does not say how they are joined. This lecture is about what changes when the joins change, and how to find every possibility without missing one or counting one twice.

Same formula, different structure

Molecules with the same molecular formula but atoms joined in a different order are called structural isomers. ("Isomer" comes from Greek words meaning "equal parts".) Some books call them constitutional isomers.

Structural isomers

Structural isomers have the same molecular formula but a different order of joined atoms. They are different compounds, with different names and different properties.

The key words are "order of joined atoms". To compare two structures, ask for each atom: what is it bonded to? If every atom has the same neighbours in both, the two drawings show one molecule. If any atom has different neighbours, they are isomers.

That test matters, because one molecule can be drawn in many ways. Look at the three drawings below.

CCCCA zigzag4 carbons in one chainCCCCBent into an Lstill 4 carbons in one chainCCCCA stepstill 4 carbons in one chain
Three drawings of one molecule, butane, C₄H₁₀. Carbons in green; hydrogens are left out. In every drawing the four carbons form one unbranched chain, so all three show the same compound.

All three are butane. In each one, the four carbons form one chain: an end carbon, two middle carbons, another end carbon. A chain is flexible. Single bonds can rotate, and the molecule bends and twists all the time. A drawing on paper freezes one moment. It does not create a new compound.

Stop and think

Arjun draws CH₃CH₂CH₂CH₂CH₃ in a straight line. Then he draws five carbons in a chain that turns a corner at the third carbon, and says he has found a second isomer of C₅H₁₂. Is he right?

Show the answer

No. Follow the bonds. In both drawings, the five carbons form one unbranched chain: each end carbon joins one other carbon, and each middle carbon joins two. That is pentane twice. A quick check: name each drawing. Both are "pentane", and one name means one molecule. A real second isomer needs a different pattern of joins, such as a carbon joined to three other carbons.

Type 1: chain isomers

Structural isomers come in three types. The first changes the carbon skeleton itself.

Chain isomers have the same formula but a different carbon chain: a longer straight chain, or a shorter chain with branches. C₄H₁₀ has two. Butane is a chain of four, CH₃CH₂CH₂CH₃. Methylpropane is a chain of three with a methyl branch on the middle carbon, CH₃CH(CH₃)CH₃. (Its full name is 2-methylpropane. The 2 can be left out, because carbon 2 is the only place a branch can go.)

They behave differently. Butane boils at about −0.5 °C. Methylpropane boils at about −12 °C. Why should one branch lower the boiling point by more than 11 degrees?

The answer is in the forces between molecules. Alkane molecules attract each other only by weak London dispersion forces, and these act where the molecules touch. Long straight molecules can lie side by side along their whole length, with a lot of contact. A branched molecule is more compact, closer to a ball, and touches its neighbours over a smaller area. Weaker attraction means less energy is needed to pull the molecules apart, so the boiling point is lower.

Worked Example 1 — All the isomers of C₅H₁₂

Find every structural isomer of C₅H₁₂, and name each one.

Think first. Work in order, from the longest chain to the shortest. Name every candidate, so that repeats show themselves.

A chain of 5. CH₃CH₂CH₂CH₂CH₃: pentane.

A chain of 4, with one carbon as a branch. The branch cannot go on an end carbon: a methyl on carbon 1 just makes the chain five long again, which is pentane. On carbon 2, it gives 2-methylbutane. On carbon 3? Count from the other end: carbon 3 becomes carbon 2. So it is 2-methylbutane again. One new isomer.

A chain of 3, with two carbons as branches. Both branches must go on the middle carbon. (A two-carbon ethyl branch on the middle carbon would make a chain of 4 again.) This gives 2,2-dimethylpropane, a central carbon joined to four others.

A chain of 2 cannot hold three more carbons without making a longer chain. So there are exactly three isomers.

CCCCCpentaneboiling point 36.0 °CCCCCC2-methylbutaneboiling point 27.7 °CCCCCC2,2-dimethylpropaneboiling point 9.5 °C
The three isomers of C₅H₁₂. The main chain is in green; branch carbons are white. Hydrogens are left out.

Check. Each structure has 5 carbons. Count hydrogens so that every carbon has four bonds: each gives C₅H₁₂. ✓ The first lecture in this topic gave the same count of skeletons for four carbons (2), and the numbers grow fast: 75 for ten carbons.

Before you look at the boiling points, predict the order.

Predict — boiling points of the three C₅H₁₂ isomers

Pentane, 2-methylbutane and 2,2-dimethylpropane all have the formula C₅H₁₂ and the same mass. What happens to their boiling points? Choose before you read on.

010203040pentane36.0 °C2-methylbutane27.7 °C2,2-dimethylpropane9.5 °CBoiling point in °C
Boiling points of the three isomers of C₅H₁₂.

The more branched the molecule, the lower its boiling point: pentane 36.0 °C, 2-methylbutane 27.7 °C, 2,2-dimethylpropane 9.5 °C. Same formula, same mass, but different shapes, so different areas of contact between molecules.

You should have seen a difference of more than 26 degrees between molecules made of exactly the same atoms. For alkanes, more branching usually means a lower boiling point. It is a strong tendency, explained by contact area, not a law: with other functional groups, other forces can matter more.

Type 2: position isomers

Position isomers have the same carbon skeleton and the same functional group, but the group is in a different place on the chain.

Propan-1-ol, CH₃CH₂CH₂OH, has the −OH on an end carbon. Propan-2-ol, CH₃CH(OH)CH₃, has it on the middle carbon. Both are C₃H₈O, and both are alcohols. Their boiling points are close but not equal: about 97 °C and 82 °C.

Position can also change the chemistry. In propan-1-ol, the carbon holding the −OH is joined to one other carbon. In propan-2-ol, it is joined to two. A later lecture on alcohols shows that this decides what they turn into when they react with an oxidising agent. Propan-1-ol can form an aldehyde and then a carboxylic acid. Propan-2-ol forms a ketone instead.

The same idea works for a double bond. But-1-ene, CH₂=CHCH₂CH₃, and but-2-ene, CH₃CH=CHCH₃, are position isomers of C₄H₈. (But-2-ene has one more kind of isomerism, from the way groups are arranged around the double bond in space. That is a different family of isomers, called stereoisomers, and it comes later.)

A warning that comes straight from naming: moving a group to the "other end" does not make a new isomer. "Propan-3-ol" is just propan-1-ol counted from the wrong end. The naming rule, lowest number to the functional group, exists so that one molecule has one name.

Type 3: functional group isomers

The biggest change is when the same atoms make a different kind of compound. These are functional group isomers: the same molecular formula, but a different functional group, so they belong to different families.

CCOHethanol, CH₃CH₂OHan alcohol · boiling point 78 °CCOCmethoxymethane, CH₃OCH₃an ether · boiling point −24 °C
The two isomers of C₂H₆O, with hydrogens on carbon left out. In ethanol the oxygen carries a hydrogen; in methoxymethane it sits between two carbons.

C₂H₆O is the clearest example. Ethanol, CH₃CH₂OH, is an alcohol: its oxygen joins a carbon and a hydrogen. Methoxymethane, CH₃OCH₃, is an ether: its oxygen sits between two carbons. Ethanol boils at 78 °C and is a liquid at room temperature. Methoxymethane boils at −24 °C and is a gas.

The difference is hydrogen bonding. In ethanol, a hydrogen is joined directly to the oxygen. That hydrogen can form a hydrogen bond with the oxygen of a neighbouring molecule. Methoxymethane has no hydrogen on its oxygen, so its molecules cannot hydrogen bond to each other. Same atoms, a different join, and a difference of about 100 degrees.

That is it. That is the whole idea of isomerism. Properties do not come from the list of atoms. They come from how the atoms are joined.

C₃H₆O gives a second pair. Propanal, CH₃CH₂CHO, is an aldehyde. Propanone, CH₃COCH₃, is a ketone. The C=O group is at the end of the chain in one and in the middle in the other. That one change makes a different family. Aldehydes can be oxidised easily, and ketones cannot, which gives chemists a simple test to tell them apart in a later lecture.

Now sort some pairs yourself. For each pair, decide whether it is one molecule drawn twice, or a pair of isomers of a particular type, or not isomers at all.

Sort — what is the relationship?

Put each pair in a box. Every card gives its reason after you place it.

Ten pairs of structures, and how each pair is related.

PairRelationship
CH₃CH₂CH₂CH₃ and CH₃CH(CH₃)CH₃Chain isomers
CH₃CH₂CH₂CH₂CH₃ and C(CH₃)₄Chain isomers
CH₃CH₂CH₂OH and CH₃CH(OH)CH₃Position isomers
CH₂=CHCH₂CH₃ and CH₃CH=CHCH₃Position isomers
CH₃CH₂CH₂Cl and CH₃CHClCH₃Position isomers
CH₃CH₂OH and CH₃OCH₃Functional group isomers
CH₃CH₂CHO and CH₃COCH₃Functional group isomers
CH₃CH(CH₃)CH₂CH₃ and CH₃CH₂CH(CH₃)CH₃One molecule (2-methylbutane, written from each end)
Butane drawn as a zigzag and butane drawn as an LOne molecule
CH₃CH₂CH₂CH₃ and CH₃CH₂CH₂CH₂CH₃Not isomers: C₄H₁₀ and C₅H₁₂

The two "one molecule" cards are the ones most students place wrongly. Before you call two structures isomers, always name them both. Two different names mean two different molecules.

Worked examples

Worked Example 2 — The isomers of C₃H₇Cl

Draw and name every structural isomer of C₃H₇Cl, and say what type of isomerism links them.

Think first. Three carbons can only make one skeleton, a straight chain. So the only freedom is where the chlorine goes.

On an end carbon: CH₃CH₂CH₂Cl, 1-chloropropane. On the middle carbon: CH₃CHClCH₃, 2-chloropropane. On the other end carbon: that is 1-chloropropane again, counted from the other end.

So there are two isomers, and they are position isomers.

Check. Both have 3 carbons, 7 hydrogens and 1 chlorine. ✓ Their names differ, so they are different molecules. ✓

Worked Example 3 — Completing C₄H₁₀O

Find the three ethers with the formula C₄H₁₀O, the ones the opening said exist besides the four alcohols.

Think first. In an ether, the oxygen sits between two carbon groups. Share the four carbons between the two sides.

One carbon on one side and three on the other: CH₃OCH₂CH₂CH₃, methoxypropane. The three-carbon side can also be branched, joined to the oxygen through its middle carbon: CH₃OCH(CH₃)₂, 2-methoxypropane. Two carbons on each side: CH₃CH₂OCH₂CH₃, ethoxyethane.

The four alcohols and these three ethers make seven isomers of C₄H₁₀O. Every ether is a functional group isomer of every alcohol. Among the alcohols, butan-1-ol and butan-2-ol are position isomers, and butan-1-ol and 2-methylpropan-1-ol are chain isomers.

Check. CH₃CH₂OCH₂CH₃ has 4 carbons, 10 hydrogens and 1 oxygen. ✓ Ethers are named with "methoxy" or "ethoxy" for the smaller side, as in methoxymethane.

Worked Example 4 — Which pair is which?

Classify each pair: (a) but-1-ene and methylpropene, CH₂=C(CH₃)CH₃; (b) propanone and propan-2-ol; (c) butan-2-ol written as CH₃CH(OH)CH₂CH₃ and as CH₃CH₂CH(OH)CH₃.

Think first. Count atoms first. Then compare the joins.

(a) Both are C₄H₈ alkenes. But-1-ene has a straight chain of four; methylpropene has a branched chain of three. Chain isomers.

(b) Propanone is C₃H₆O. Propan-2-ol is C₃H₈O. Different formulas, so they are not isomers at all, even though both have an oxygen on the middle carbon.

(c) Read the second formula from the right: CH₃CH(OH)CH₂CH₃. It is the same molecule, butan-2-ol, written from the other end.

Check. In (c), both formulas give the name butan-2-ol by the lowest-number rule. One name, one molecule. ✓

Three traps

Trap 1 — A bent chain is not a new isomer

Single bonds rotate, so a chain can be drawn straight, bent or folded. It is still the same molecule. Before counting a structure as new, follow the bonds or name it. If the name is one you already have, it is not new.

Trap 2 — A branch on the end carbon

A methyl group on carbon 1 does not make a branched molecule. It just makes the chain one carbon longer. "1-methylbutane" is pentane. When you look for branched isomers, put branches only on carbons that are not at the ends.

Trap 3 — Counting from the wrong end

"3-methylbutane" and "2-methylbutane" are one molecule, numbered from different ends. In the same way, "propan-3-ol" is propan-1-ol. Use the lowest-number rule from the naming lecture, and the false isomers disappear.

Try it yourself

Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.

  1. Draw and name the two structural isomers of C₃H₇Br. What type of isomerism is this?

    Hint 1

    Three carbons make only one skeleton. Where can the bromine go?

    Hint 2

    Try an end carbon and the middle carbon. The other end gives the first one again.

    Full answer

    CH₃CH₂CH₂Br, 1-bromopropane, and CH₃CHBrCH₃, 2-bromopropane. The skeleton and the group are the same, and only the position changes, so they are position isomers. Check: both are C₃H₇Br, and they have different names. ✓

  2. Classify each pair: (a) CH₃CH₂CH₂CH₂OH and CH₃CH₂OCH₂CH₃; (b) CH₃CH₂CH₂CH₂OH and (CH₃)₂CHCH₂OH; (c) CH₃COCH₂CH₃ and CH₃CH₂CH₂CHO.

    Hint 1

    Check that each pair has the same formula. Then look at the functional group and the skeleton.

    Hint 2

    (a) is an alcohol and an ether. (b) has the same group on two different skeletons. (c) has a C=O in two places.

    Full answer

    (a) Both C₄H₁₀O: butan-1-ol (alcohol) and ethoxyethane (ether). Functional group isomers. (b) Both C₄H₁₀O alcohols with −OH on an end carbon: butan-1-ol and 2-methylpropan-1-ol. The skeleton differs, so chain isomers. (c) Both C₄H₈O: butanone (ketone) and butanal (aldehyde). Functional group isomers. Check: count the atoms in each formula. ✓

  3. Three alkenes have the formula C₄H₈ and an unbranched or branched chain: but-1-ene, but-2-ene and methylpropene. Draw all three. Which pairs are position isomers, and which are chain isomers?

    Hint 1

    Two of them share a straight four-carbon chain.

    Hint 2

    Methylpropene is CH₂=C(CH₃)CH₃: a chain of three with a branch.

    Full answer

    But-1-ene CH₂=CHCH₂CH₃ and but-2-ene CH₃CH=CHCH₃ have the same straight chain with the C=C in different places: position isomers. Methylpropene CH₂=C(CH₃)CH₃ has a branched skeleton, so it is a chain isomer of each of the other two. Check: all three are C₄H₈. ✓ (C₄H₈ also has isomers with a ring of carbons and no double bond, such as cyclobutane. They are functional group isomers of the alkenes.)

  4. A stretch. C₆H₁₄ has five structural isomers. Find and name all five, working from the longest chain down. Then predict which one has the highest boiling point and which has the lowest, and explain your prediction.

    Hint 1

    Chain of 6: one. Chain of 5 with one methyl: put it on carbon 2 or carbon 3. Chain of 4 with two methyls: both on one carbon, or one on each middle carbon.

    Hint 2

    A chain of 4 with an ethyl branch, or a chain of 3, only gives isomers you already have, or a longer chain. Check each candidate by naming it.

    Full answer

    Hexane; 2-methylpentane; 3-methylpentane; 2,2-dimethylbutane; 2,3-dimethylbutane. (An ethyl on carbon 2 of butane makes a five-carbon chain: that is 3-methylpentane again. A chain of three cannot carry three carbons as branches without making a longer chain.) Prediction: hexane, the straight chain, has the most contact between molecules and the highest boiling point. 2,2-dimethylbutane, the most compact, has the lowest. Measured values agree: about 69 °C for hexane and about 50 °C for 2,2-dimethylbutane. Check: each name has 6 carbons in total, for example 2,2-dimethylbutane = 4 + 1 + 1. ✓

The bigger idea

Isomers were a shock when they were first found. In 1823–24, Friedrich Wöhler and Justus von Liebig analysed two different substances, silver cyanate and silver fulminate, and found the same composition. One compound was stable and the other exploded. Each chemist at first suspected the other of a mistake. Chemists had believed that the same elements in the same amounts must give the same substance. Around 1830, Jöns Jacob Berzelius gave the new idea its name, isomerism.

The lesson changed chemistry: a substance is not just its atoms, it is the way they are joined. That is why chemists draw structures, and why names must describe joins and not just counts. Living things show the same lesson. Enzymes recognise molecules by their shape, so two isomers can behave very differently inside the body. Structural isomers are only the first kind. Later you will meet stereoisomers, which have the same joins but a different arrangement in space, and that difference can matter just as much.

Key concepts in this lesson