- The photoelectric effect: Einstein's explanation · coming soon
- de Broglie wavelength: matter waves · coming soon
- Alpha, beta and gamma radiation
Bright red light that does nothing
Take a clean plate of zinc and shine ultraviolet light on it. Electrons fly out of the metal. That part is not surprising. Light carries energy, and some of it reaches the electrons.
Now make two changes. First, make the ultraviolet very dim. Electrons still come out, and they start at once. Second, switch to red light, and make it as bright as you like. No electrons come out at all. You can wait an hour. Still nothing.
This is the opposite of what anyone expected. A bright light carries far more energy than a dim one. So how can the dim light win?
The last lecture promised this question. It said that light shining on a metal can knock electrons out, and that the way it does so shows that light really travels in packets. The electromagnetic spectrum lecture made a similar promise: this is the experiment that forced physicists to accept photons. Here it is.
What a wave should do
Before photons, light was understood as a wave. The wave picture had a lot of success: it explained interference and diffraction very well. So start by asking what a wave predicts here.
In a wave, energy arrives smoothly and continuously, spread over the whole wave front. A brighter wave carries more energy each second. So the wave picture makes three predictions:
- Any colour should work, if it is bright enough. Even red light should shake an electron free in the end.
- Dim light should take time. An electron must collect energy until it has enough to escape.
- Brighter light should give faster electrons, because each electron collects more energy.
How long would "take time" be? Here is an estimate. Dim ultraviolet light might deliver 0.01 W to each square metre of the zinc. One electron can only collect the energy falling on a tiny area, about the size of one atom, roughly . It needs about 4.3 eV, which is J, to escape from zinc. So the waiting time would be
which is nearly two hours. In fact, the electrons come out with no delay that anyone has been able to measure. The wave picture is wrong by a huge factor. Before reading on, test your own instinct.
A clean zinc plate is in a vacuum. Lamp A gives very bright red light (wavelength 650 nm). Lamp B gives very dim ultraviolet light (wavelength 254 nm). Each lamp shines on the plate for ten minutes. Which lamp makes electrons come out of the zinc? Choose one.
The chart compares the energy of one photon of each light with the energy an electron needs to escape from zinc. Only the ultraviolet photon has enough. So only the dim ultraviolet lamp makes electrons come out. (The bars are drawn in the colour of each light, as in a spectrum.)
What the experiments showed
The effect was found in the 1880s. In 1902, Philipp Lenard made the first careful measurements of the electrons' energy. Others followed, and the results settled into a clear pattern. The usual apparatus looks like this.
The tube has no air, so the electrons do not hit air molecules on the way across. The current tells you how many electrons leave the plate each second. The variable supply is used to measure their energy, as you will see later. Four results came out of experiments like this:
- 1. A threshold frequency. For each metal, there is a lowest frequency, called the threshold frequency . Below it, no electrons come out, however bright the light.
- 2. No delay. Above , electrons come out as soon as the light arrives, even when it is very dim.
- 3. Energy depends on frequency. The fastest electrons have more kinetic energy when the frequency is higher. Their energy does not depend on how bright the light is.
- 4. Number depends on brightness. Brighter light (of the same frequency) gives more electrons each second, so a larger current.
The wave picture predicts the opposite of results 1, 2 and 3. Something about light itself had to change.
Einstein's idea: one photon, one electron
In 1905, Albert Einstein proposed that light delivers its energy in separate packets, now called photons. The electromagnetic spectrum lecture gave you a first look at them. A photon of frequency carries energy
where J s is the Planck constant. Bright light does not mean bigger photons. It means more photons each second. The size of each photon is set by the frequency alone.
Now add one more idea. An electron absorbs one whole photon, or none. It cannot collect a little energy from several photons over time. With ordinary light, the chance of one electron absorbing two photons at the same moment is far too small to matter.
Inside a metal, the electrons are free to move around, but they are held in. To escape through the surface, an electron must be given a minimum amount of energy. This minimum is called the work function of the metal, written (the Greek letter phi). It is different for each metal: about 2.28 eV for sodium and about 4.3 eV for zinc.
So follow the energy of one photon. It is handed to one electron. Part of it, at least , is used to get the electron out of the metal. What is left over becomes the electron's kinetic energy.
The photon's energy pays the work function first. The rest is the kinetic energy of the fastest electrons. Electrons come out only if , so the threshold frequency is .
Why "max"? An electron at the very surface needs exactly to escape, so it keeps all the rest. An electron a little deeper loses some energy on the way out, so it leaves more slowly. The equation gives the energy of the fastest electrons.
Now check the four results:
- 1. Below , every photon has . No single photon can free an electron, and photons cannot team up. Brightness only adds more photons that are too small.
- 2. One photon frees one electron at the moment it is absorbed. Nothing has to build up.
- 3. grows with . Brightness does not appear in the equation at all.
- 4. Brighter light means more photons each second, so more electrons each second.
That is it. That is the whole idea. Light's energy comes in packets of , and each electron gets one packet. Every strange result follows from that.
Light of some frequency gives electrons with a maximum kinetic energy of 1.0 eV. You double the frequency. Does the maximum kinetic energy double to 2.0 eV?
Show the answer
No, it more than doubles. The photon's energy doubles, but the work function stays the same. Suppose eV. Then eV at first, and eV after doubling. The maximum kinetic energy goes from eV to eV.
The kinetic energy rises in a straight line with frequency, but it is not proportional to it, because the work function is taken off first.
Test all four results yourself in the simulation below.
Choose a metal. Change the wavelength of the light and its brightness, and watch the photons arrive and the electrons leave. Press Play to run it, or Step to move on a little at a time.
Metal:
Photons are drawn as small diamonds and electrons as round dots. The light and its photons are drawn in their own colour, as in a spectrum; ultraviolet, which you cannot see, is drawn in purple. The numbers use J s, m/s and 1 eV = J. The simulation leaves out that only some photons free an electron in a real metal.
The table shows what happens for sodium (φ = 2.28 eV) and zinc (φ = 4.3 eV) at several wavelengths. Brightness changes only the number of electrons each second, never the energies in the table.
| λ (nm) | Photon (eV) | Sodium: max Ek (eV) | Zinc: max Ek (eV) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 650 red | 1.91 | none | none |
| 500 green | 2.49 | 0.21 | none |
| 400 violet | 3.11 | 0.83 | none |
| 250 UV | 4.97 | 2.69 | 0.67 |
| 200 UV | 6.22 | 3.94 | 1.92 |
Notice three things. Moving the wavelength across the threshold switches the electrons on or off, whatever the brightness. Shorter wavelengths, which mean higher frequencies, give faster electrons. And brightness changes only how many electrons leave, never how fast the fastest ones go.
Measuring the energy: the stopping potential difference
How can anyone measure the kinetic energy of an electron? Use the variable supply in the apparatus. Make the collector negative. Now the electrons must travel "uphill" against the electric field to reach it, and they slow down as they go.
Increase this reverse potential difference until the current just falls to zero. At that point, even the fastest electrons are turned back just before the collector. This is called the stopping potential difference . The electric potential lecture showed that a charge moving through a potential difference changes its energy by . So the fastest electrons lose all their kinetic energy, :
This is why the electronvolt is so useful here. If the fastest electrons have 1.5 eV, the stopping potential difference is 1.5 V. The number is the same.
Now plot against . The equation has the form , so the graph is a straight line.
Every metal gives a line with the same gradient, because the gradient is , a constant of nature. Only the work function changes, which moves the line sideways. In 1916, the American physicist Robert Millikan measured lines like these with great care. He found the gradient agreed with Planck's constant. Yet he wrote that he still could not believe the physical idea behind Einstein's equation.
Ultraviolet light of frequency Hz falls on a metal with work function 3.0 eV. Find the maximum kinetic energy of the electrons, in joules and in eV, and the stopping potential difference.
Work function in joules. J.
Photon energy. J.
Maximum kinetic energy. J. In eV: eV.
Stopping potential difference. V.
Check: the photon is eV, and eV. ✓
A metal has threshold frequency Hz. Find its work function. Will light of wavelength 600 nm free electrons from it?
Work function. At the threshold, the photon just pays the work function: J, which is about 2.5 eV.
Frequency of the light. Hz.
Decision. Hz is below the threshold. Each photon has less energy than the work function, so no electrons come out, however bright the light.
Check: the threshold wavelength is nm. Longer wavelengths, such as 600 nm, have smaller photons. ✓
A violet laser of power 1.0 mW and wavelength 405 nm shines on sodium. How many photons arrive each second? What is the largest current this could produce?
Energy of one photon. J, about 3.07 eV. This is above sodium's 2.28 eV, so electrons can come out.
Photons each second. Power is energy each second: photons per second.
Largest current. At most one electron per photon: A, about 0.33 mA.
In a real metal, most photons do not free an electron, so the real current is much smaller. But doubling the laser's power doubles the photons, and so doubles the current. That is result 4.
Check: photons × J ≈ J each second. ✓
For one metal, light of frequency Hz gives a stopping potential difference of 0.21 V. Light of frequency Hz gives 1.04 V. Find , the threshold frequency and the work function.
Gradient. , so . The gradient of against is : V s.
Planck constant. J s.
Threshold. falls by 0.21 V for every Hz below Hz, since Hz. So Hz.
Work function. J, about 2.3 eV. This metal is probably sodium.
Check: at Hz, V. ✓
Brightness controls the number of photons, so it controls the current. The energy of each electron depends only on the frequency and the metal. If a question changes only the brightness, the maximum kinetic energy and the stopping potential difference stay the same.
from is in joules. Work functions are usually given in eV. Convert one of them before you subtract, using 1 eV = J. Never subtract eV from J.
Photon energy is , so a longer wavelength means a smaller photon. Red light (long wavelength) has small photons; ultraviolet (short wavelength) has large ones. The threshold is a longest wavelength, not a shortest one.
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck. Use J s, m/s and 1 eV = J.
-
Blue light of wavelength 450 nm falls on potassium, with work function 2.3 eV. Find the energy of one photon in eV and the maximum kinetic energy of the electrons.
Hint 1
Find the photon energy with , in joules first.
Hint 2
Divide by to get eV, then subtract 2.3 eV.
Full answer
J eV. eV.
Check: 0.46 eV is positive, so electrons do come out, and the stopping potential difference would be about 0.46 V. ✓
-
Caesium has a work function of about 2.1 eV. Find its threshold wavelength. Will deep red light of wavelength 700 nm free electrons from it?
Hint 1
At the threshold, , so .
Hint 2
Change 2.1 eV into joules first: .
Full answer
J. m, about 590 nm. Light of 700 nm has a longer wavelength, so its photons (about 1.78 eV) are too small. No electrons.
Check: 590 nm is yellow-orange light, so caesium responds to most visible light but not to deep red. ✓
-
A student doubles the brightness of the light in Question 1 and also halves its wavelength to 225 nm. Describe what happens to (a) the number of electrons each second and (b) the maximum kinetic energy.
Hint 1
Treat the two changes separately. Which one changes the size of each photon?
Hint 2
Halving the wavelength doubles the photon energy. Be careful with "brightness" when the photons get bigger.
Full answer
(b) The photon energy doubles, to about 5.5 eV, so eV, about seven times larger than 0.46 eV. It does not simply double, because the work function is taken off.
(a) Doubling the brightness doubles the energy arriving each second. But each photon now carries twice the energy, so the number of photons each second is about the same as before. So the number of electrons each second stays roughly the same.
Check: power = (photons each second) × (energy of each photon), so doubling both the power and the photon size leaves the photon count unchanged. ✓
-
A student shines light of wavelength 400 nm on a metal and measures a stopping potential difference of 0.86 V. With light of wavelength 300 nm, she measures 1.89 V. Use only these readings, with and , to find a value for and the work function of the metal.
Hint 1
Change both wavelengths to frequencies with .
Hint 2
The gradient of against is , as in Worked Example 4.
Full answer
Frequencies: Hz and Hz. Gradient: V s. So J s.
Work function: at 400 nm, V, so eV.
Check: at 300 nm, V. ✓ Two readings give without knowing anything about the metal, which is what made Millikan's measurement so powerful.
Einstein won the Nobel Prize in Physics for 1921. The citation praised "his discovery of the law of the photoelectric effect". It did not mention relativity. The prize was held back for a year and handed over in 1922.
But photons did not replace waves. Light still shows interference and diffraction, which only waves can explain. So light travels like a wave, and gives up its energy in packets, like particles. Physics had to accept both at once. The Pre-University lectures take the next step: electrons, which everyone thought were particles, also behave like waves.
The one-photon rule is everywhere around you. Solar panels and the sensors in phone cameras work because each photon can give one electron its energy, inside the material rather than out of it. And it explains why ultraviolet light can damage your skin while much brighter red light cannot: it is the size of each packet that matters.
- Light shining on a metal can free electrons, but only if its frequency is above a threshold frequency that depends on the metal.
- Light delivers its energy in photons of energy , and one electron absorbs one whole photon.
- The work function is the least energy an electron needs to escape, so .
- Brighter light means more photons, so more electrons each second, but the same maximum kinetic energy.
- The stopping potential difference measures the fastest electrons' energy, since .
- A graph of against is a straight line with gradient , crossing the frequency axis at .