- Surface area of 3D shapes
- Volume of cuboids and prisms · coming soon
- Similar triangles · coming soon
- Similar shapes: area and volume scale factors
- Volumes of revolution · coming soon
- Pressure in liquids: depth and density · coming soon
Why a cone is not half of its cylinder
A triangle inside a rectangle, with the same base and height, is exactly half of the rectangle. You have known this for years.
Now go up one dimension. Put a cone inside a cylinder with the same base radius and the same height. It looks like the same picture. So it is natural to guess that the cone is half of the cylinder.
It is not half. Fill the cone with water and pour it into the cylinder. You need three cones to fill the cylinder, not two. The cone is one third.
So the old picture breaks. A square-based pyramid is also a third of its box. Where does the third come from? This lecture finds out, and then uses the same idea to find the volume of a ball. The formulas are short. The difficulty is in seeing why the number is .
Volume as a stack of thin slices
Start with what you know. A prism has the same cross-section all the way up, so its volume is the cross-section's area times the height. A cylinder is .
Here is another way to see it. Cut the solid into very thin horizontal slices, like a stack of coins. Each slice has volume equal to its area times its thickness, and the slices add up to the solid. For a prism, every slice has the same area. A cone and a pyramid are different. Their slices get smaller as you go up, until they shrink to a point at the tip. That shrinking is where the comes from.
Take a square-based pyramid with base side . Halfway up, the slice is a square with side . The side has halved. But the slice is a square, so its area has gone down to of the base. The slice shrinks in two directions at once: from left to right, and from front to back.
Now compare a triangle. Its "slices" are line segments. Halfway up, a segment is half as long as the base. It shrinks in only one direction. A flat shape that tapers loses length. A solid that tapers loses area, and area shrinks faster.
Build a stepped pyramid from square layers in the explorer below, and watch the two fractions.
Change the number of layers. Each layer is a square slab, and the top layer is the smallest. The picture is the view from the front. Compare the two fractions as the layers get thinner.
Presets:
The picture shows the front view of a stepped pyramid made of 10 square layers inside its box. The table compares the front view, a flat staircase, with the solid. The front view covers a fraction of the square that heads towards . The solid fills a fraction of the box that heads towards .
| Layers | Front view: fraction of the square | Solid: fraction of the box |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1 | 1 |
| 4 | 0.625 | ≈ 0.469 |
| 10 | 0.55 | 0.385 |
| 40 | ≈ 0.513 | ≈ 0.346 |
As the layers get thinner, the front view heads towards , just like a triangle. But the solid heads towards . The front view hides the fact that every layer is also shrinking in depth.
The explorer shows that the answer is close to a third. To prove that it is exactly a third, you need a cube and a knife.
A cube cut into three equal pyramids
Take a cube with edge . Choose one corner, . Three faces of the cube do not touch . In the picture, they are the three faces you can see.
Join to the corners of those three faces. Each face becomes the base of a pyramid with its tip at , and the three pyramids fill the cube exactly.
Now look at the three pyramids. Each one has a square base of area . Each one has height , because is one edge-length away from the face opposite it. And the three are identical in shape. You can see this by turning the cube about the long diagonal from to the opposite corner. A turn of one third of a full turn moves face 1 to face 2, face 2 to face 3, and face 3 to face 1.
Three identical pieces fill a cube of volume . So each piece has volume . Write that as . The base area is and the height is , so
That is it. That is the whole idea. The third is not a rough rule. It comes from three equal pyramids filling one box.
From one pyramid to every pyramid, and the cone
Step 1: any height. Stretch the whole cube upwards, so that it becomes a box with base and height . Every piece stretches by the same factor, so each pyramid is still a third of the box. Look at the pyramid whose base is the top face. Its base is still , and its tip is now below it. Its volume is . The rule still holds.
Step 2: any base. Now take two pyramids with the same height and equal base areas. One base is a square. The other is any shape, such as a triangle. Cut both at the same height. Each slice is a smaller copy of its own base. If the cut is a fraction of the way down from the tip, every length in the slice is times the length in the base. So each slice has area times its base area. The two bases have the same area, so the two slices have the same area too, at every height.
Two solids with the same height and the same slice area at every level have the same volume. Picture a stack of coins pushed sideways so that it leans: it still holds the same coins. This idea is called Cavalieri's principle, after the Italian mathematician Bonaventura Cavalieri, who published it in 1635. Archimedes had already used the same idea, and in China, Zu Gengzhi used it for the sphere around the year 500.
So every pyramid has volume , whatever its base. A cone is a pyramid with a circular base of area . So its volume is , one third of the cylinder, just as the water showed.
Pyramid: , where is the area of the base and is the perpendicular height.
Cone: , where is the vertical height, not the slant height.
A square-based pyramid has its tip directly above the centre of its base. You slide the tip sideways, keeping it at the same height, so the pyramid leans. Does its volume go up, go down, or stay the same?
Show the answer
It stays the same. At every height, the slice is the same square, only moved sideways, like a coin in a leaning stack. Same slices, same volume. This is why the formula uses the perpendicular height, straight up from the base to the tip, and not the length of a sloping edge.
A cone has base radius 6 cm and vertical height 9 cm. Find its volume, exactly and to 3 significant figures (3 s.f.).
Base area. cm².
Volume. cm³ (3 s.f.).
Keep as a letter until the last line, so that nothing is rounded too early.
Check: the matching cylinder is , and . ✓
A pyramid has a rectangular base 8 cm by 5 cm. Its tip is 12 cm above the base. Find its volume.
Base area first, on its own line. cm². Writing this step down stops you from mixing up the three lengths.
Volume. cm³.
Check: the box around it is cm³, and is a third of . ✓
The ball: Archimedes again
A ball does not taper to one point, so the pyramid idea seems useless here. It is not. First, make a prediction.
A tin has radius r and height 2r. A cone and a ball each fit exactly inside it: the cone has radius r and height 2r, and the ball has radius r. Fill the cone and the ball with water, and pour both into the empty tin. What happens? Choose one.
The picture shows a cone, a ball and a tin, each with radius and height . Their volumes are in the ratio 1 : 2 : 3. So the cone and the ball together fill the tin exactly.
The tin has volume . The cone is a third of that, . If the cone and the ball fill the tin together, the ball must be the other two thirds: . So the cone, the ball and the tin are in the ratio 1 : 2 : 3. Now you need the reason for the ball's share.
The last lecture gives it. That lecture showed that the surface of a ball is . Now cut the ball into a huge number of very thin pieces, all meeting at the centre , like the segments of an orange cut very finely in every direction.
Each thin piece is almost a cone. Its tip is at , its base is a tiny patch of the surface, and its height is for every piece. So each piece has volume .
Now add them all. Every piece has the same and the same . So the total is (all the patches added together). All the patches together make the whole surface, . So
This is the same answer the tin gave. The patches are very slightly curved, but the thinner the pieces, the smaller that difference becomes, as with the thin bands in the last lecture.
A sphere of radius has volume .
In words: two thirds of the cylinder that fits around it. A hemisphere has half of this, .
Notice that the surface area and the volume are linked. The volume is the surface area times . If you ever forget one formula, you can rebuild it from the other.
A solid copper ball has diameter 6 cm. Copper has a density of 8.96 g/cm³. Find the mass of the ball.
Density is mass per unit volume: . So . The volume comes first.
Radius. cm.
Volume. cm³.
Mass. g, which is about 1.01 kg.
Check: the tin around the ball is , and two thirds of is . ✓
A cone with its top cut off
A bucket and a flower pot have the same shape: a cone with its top cut off parallel to the base. This shape is called a frustum. You do not need a new formula for it. Rebuild the whole cone, find its volume, and subtract the small cone that was cut away.
If the small cone's height is not given, use similar triangles. The two cones have the same shape, so all their lengths are in the same ratio.
A cone has base radius 10 cm and height 15 cm. A cut parallel to the base leaves a top circle of radius 4 cm. Find the volume of the frustum below the cut.
Height of the small cone. The two cones are similar. The radii are in the ratio , so the heights are too: , which gives cm. The frustum is cm high.
Whole cone. .
Small cone. .
Frustum. cm³ (3 s.f.).
Check: the answer must lie between two cylinders 9 cm high. One has radius 4: . The other has radius 10: . And lies between them. ✓
What soap bubbles already know
The last lecture promised a test of what soap bubbles know: for a fixed volume, a sphere has the least surface. Here it is.
A cube and a sphere each hold 1000 cm³. Compare their surface areas.
Cube. The edge is 10 cm, because . Surface: cm².
Sphere. , so and cm. Surface: cm².
The sphere needs about 19% less surface than the cube to hold the same amount. A bubble's skin pulls itself as small as it can, so a floating bubble becomes a sphere.
Check: . ✓
The last lecture's surface formula used the slant height. The volume formula uses the vertical height , measured straight up from the base to the tip. If a question gives the slant height, find with Pythagoras first: .
In the radius is cubed. Using the diameter makes the answer times too big. Halve the diameter before anything else.
The height of the frustum is not the height of either cone. Find the small cone's height with similar triangles. Then use the whole cone's height for the whole cone, and the small cone's height for the small cone.
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.
-
A cone has base radius 5 cm and slant height 13 cm. Find its volume, exactly and to 3 s.f.
Hint 1
The volume needs the vertical height, not the slant height.
Hint 2
.
Full answer
cm. cm³ (3 s.f.). Check: is shorter than , as it must be. ✓
-
A pyramid has a square base of side 6 cm. Its volume is 96 cm³. Find its height.
Hint 1
Write the formula, put in what you know, and solve for .
Hint 2
, so .
Full answer
Base area cm². , so cm. Check: . ✓
-
A sphere has volume cm³. Find its radius and its surface area. Your two answers have the same number in front of . Is that a coincidence?
Hint 1
Solve for first.
Hint 2
. For the second part, set and see which makes it true.
Full answer
, so and cm. Surface: cm². The match happens only because . The volume is the surface times , and . For any other radius the numbers differ. And the two answers are not really equal anyway: one is in cm³ and the other in cm². Check: . ✓
-
A bucket is a frustum. Its bottom has radius 10 cm, its open top has radius 15 cm, and it is 24 cm deep. How many litres does it hold? (1 litre = 1000 cm³.)
Hint 1
Turn the bucket upside down in your mind and extend its sides until they meet. The bucket is a big cone minus a small cone. Call the small cone's height .
Hint 2
By similar triangles, .
Full answer
, so and cm. The big cone is cm high. Big cone: . Small cone: . Bucket: cm³, about 11.9 litres. Check: the answer lies between a cylinder of radius 10 () and one of radius 15 (), each 24 cm high. ✓
The third in the cone is very old. Archimedes wrote that Democritus first stated it and Eudoxus first proved it, more than 2 300 years ago. Archimedes found the ball's two thirds himself. The sphere and cylinder on his tomb celebrate both his results: the ball has two thirds of the tin's volume, and two thirds of its total surface, out of .
The method in this lecture is bigger than any one formula. Cut a solid into thin slices, find each slice, and add them up. When the slices get thinner and thinner, the adding becomes exact. That is the central idea of integral calculus. In a later course you will rotate a curve to make a solid, and find its volume by exactly this kind of adding.
The next lecture asks how the volumes of two solids with the same shape but different sizes compare. The slices here already hint at the answer: when every length is multiplied by , each slice's area is multiplied by .
- A pyramid's slices shrink in two directions at once, so it fills one third of its box, not one half.
- A cube can be cut into three identical pyramids, which shows that a pyramid's volume is exactly base area height.
- Equal slices at every level give equal volumes, so the rule works for any base, including a cone's circle: .
- A ball is many thin cones meeting at its centre, so its volume is , two thirds of the cylinder around it.
- A frustum is a whole cone minus the small cone cut from it, and similar triangles give the missing height.
- Mass is density times volume, so the volume is found first.