MathemagiciansLibraryExplorationsDeep Dives
← Mathematics · Upper Secondary
MathematicsUpper Secondary

Using vectors to prove geometric results

U3 — Geometry Advanced › U3.4 — VectorsLecture 5 of 5~2700 words

Five checks, and still wrong

The last lecture ended with a question. In one parallelogram, with corners (1, 1), (5, 2), (6, 6) and (2, 5), the two diagonals had the same midpoint, (3.5, 3.5). Is that true for every parallelogram?

You could draw ten more parallelograms and measure them. Every one would agree. Is that enough? Before you answer, look at a pattern that fooled many people.

Put some points on a circle. Join every pair of points with a straight line. Then count the regions the lines cut the circle into. Choose the points so that no three lines meet at one point inside the circle.

Points on the circleRegions
11
22
34
48
516
6?

The pattern doubles every time, so six points should give 32. Count carefully. You get 31. With seven points you get 57, not 64.

Five checks agreed, and the pattern was still wrong. This is the disruption. Checking examples can make you confident. It cannot make you certain. A check only tells you about the cases you checked.

A proof is different. It is a chain of reasons that shows a statement must be true in every case, including the cases nobody has drawn. This lecture shows you how vectors give you that chain for shapes. The difficulty is not in the algebra. The algebra is the same as in the last two lectures. The difficulty is in the idea that one calculation can cover every shape at once. Spend time on that idea.

How letters cover every shape

In the last lecture, the midpoint came out as . The letters and did not stand for particular arrows. They stood for any two position vectors. So the result is about every line segment at once.

A vector proof uses the same trick on a whole shape. Give the important arrows letters. Write every other arrow in terms of those letters, using rules you already trust. If the result you want appears, it is true whatever the letters are, so it is true for every shape of that kind.

You need only four tools, and you have met all of them.

The four tools of a vector proof

1. Finish minus start: .

2. A route: any chain of known arrows from one point to another gives the vector between them.

3. Points on a line: the midpoint is , and the point a fraction of the way from A to B is .

4. Parallel means "a multiple of": if , then PQ is parallel to RS and times as long.

The hard part of a proof question is usually the first step: turning the geometry words into vector statements. This table is the dictionary.

The geometry saysThe vectors say
M is the midpoint of AB
P divides AB in the ratio 2 : 1
PQ is parallel to RS for some number
ABCD is a parallelogram (opposite sides are equal vectors)
Two lines bisect each otherthey have the same midpoint

Look at the fourth row closely. A parallelogram has opposite sides that are parallel and equal in length. That is exactly what "equal vectors" means: same length, same direction. So one vector equation holds the whole definition.

Proving the parallelogram fact

Here is the promise from the last lecture. Let OABC be any parallelogram. Choose the corner O as the origin. This is allowed, because the last lecture showed that the choice of origin never changes a fact about the shape. Call and .

OABCaca + c½(a + c)
Parallelogram OABC with O as the origin. Because opposite sides are equal vectors, B has position vector a + c. The dashed diagonals cross at ½(a + c), as the proof below shows.

Step through the proof below. Each line comes with the reason it is allowed. Read the reason before you press Next.

Step through — the diagonals of a parallelogram

Press Next to add one line of the proof. Read why each line is allowed before you go on.

The proof has six lines. Each line is followed by the reason it is allowed.

  1. Let O be the origin, with →OA = a and →OC = c. Reason: any origin may be chosen, and a corner makes the working short.
  2. →CB = →OA = a. Reason: OABC is a parallelogram, so opposite sides are equal vectors.
  3. b = →OB = →OC + →CB = c + a. Reason: a route from O to B along known arrows.
  4. The midpoint of OB is ½(0 + b) = ½(a + c). Reason: a midpoint is the average of the two ends, and the position vector of O is the zero vector.
  5. The midpoint of AC is ½(a + c). Reason: the average of a and c.
  6. The two midpoints are the same point. Reason: they have the same position vector from the same origin.

So each diagonal passes through the midpoint of the other. The diagonals bisect each other, in every parallelogram.

Look at what happened. We never measured a diagonal. We never chose numbers. We used one fact, that opposite sides are equal vectors, and the rest followed by rules. The letters and can be any two arrows that are not parallel. So the proof covers a long thin parallelogram, a square, a slanted one, and every parallelogram anyone will ever draw.

That is it. That is the whole idea. A proof with letters does once what a million drawings cannot do.

The midpoint theorem

The same method proves a famous fact about triangles. Take any triangle OAB, with and . Let M be the midpoint of OA and N the midpoint of OB. What can you say about the line MN?

OABMNabb − a½(b − a)
M and N are the midpoints of OA and OB. The thick arrow from M to N is ½(b − a), half of the side from A to B.

Write both position vectors. M is halfway from O to A, so . N is halfway from O to B, so . Now use finish minus start:

And the third side is . So .

Now read that equation with tool 4. MN is a multiple of AB, so the two lines are parallel. The multiple is , so MN is half as long as AB.

The midpoint theorem

The line joining the midpoints of two sides of a triangle is parallel to the third side and half as long.

A proof has to end with a sentence in words, not only an equation. The equation is the evidence. "So MN is parallel to AB and half its length" is the conclusion. Examiners look for both.

One more detail about tool 4. The number can be negative. For example, . A negative multiple points the opposite way, but the lines are still parallel. The sign tells you the direction. The size tells you how many times as long.

Parallel is not the same as on one line

Three points are collinear if one straight line passes through all three. Vectors can prove this too, but there is a trap in it.

Look at the two arrows in the first picture. and . They are parallel. But they lie on two different lines.

PQRS(3, 1)(6, 2) = 2 × (3, 1)ABC(3, 1)A to C: (9, 3) = 3 × (3, 1)
Top: P to Q and R to S are parallel, but they lie on two different lines. Bottom: A to B and A to C are parallel and share the point A, so A, B and C lie on one line.

In the second picture, . The arrows are parallel again. This time they both start at A. Two parallel lines that share a point cannot be two different lines. They must be the same line. So A, B and C are collinear.

Collinear points

A, B and C are collinear if for some number . The two vectors must share a point, here A.

Stop and think

Kiran finds that and . He writes: ", so A, B, C and D are on one straight line." Is he right?

Show the answer

Not from this evidence. The equation shows that AB and CD are parallel. It says nothing about where CD is. The two lines could be side by side, like the rails of a railway track. To prove that the points are collinear, he needs two parallel vectors that share a point, such as and .

Worked examples

Worked Example 1 — Collinear points with numbers

A is (−2, 1), B is (1, 3) and C is (7, 7). Show that A, B and C are collinear, and find the ratio AB : BC.

Think first. Find two vectors that start at the same point, and test whether one is a multiple of the other.

and .

From the top numbers, . The bottom numbers agree: . So . The vectors are parallel and share the point A, so A, B and C are collinear.

AC is 3 times AB, so B is of the way from A to C. That leaves for BC, so AB : BC = 1 : 2.

Check. . BC is twice AB. ✓

Worked Example 2 — Two thirds of the way along

In triangle OAB, and . P divides OA in the ratio 2 : 1 and Q divides OB in the ratio 2 : 1. Prove that PQ is parallel to AB, and find PQ : AB.

Think first. OP : PA = 2 : 1, so P is of the way from O to A. O is the origin, so the route is short.

and . So .

PQ is a multiple of AB, so PQ is parallel to AB. The multiple is , so PQ : AB = 2 : 3.

Check. Try one triangle: , . Then P is (4, 0), Q is (2, 4), and . And of is . ✓ This check is not the proof. It only catches slips. The midpoint theorem is the case where the fraction is .

Worked Example 3 — Collinear points with letters

In triangle OAB, and . M is the midpoint of OA. N is on AB with AN : NB = 2 : 1. The line OB is extended to X, so that . Prove that M, N and X are collinear.

Think first. Write , and . Then find two vectors that start at M.

. N is of the way from A to B, so . And .

.

.

Both contain the same bracket, . Since , we get . The vectors are parallel and share the point M, so M, N and X are collinear. N is of the way from M to X.

Check. With and : M is (3, 0), N is (2, 2) and X is (0, 6). and , three times as long. ✓

The useful habit here: factorise each vector until the same bracket appears. When the brackets match, the numbers outside them give .

A parallelogram hiding in every quadrilateral

Now a result that surprises almost everyone. Draw any four-sided shape at all, as untidy as you like. Mark the midpoint of each side, and join the four midpoints in order. What shape do you get?

Try it in the explorer first. Move the corner D anywhere, and watch the teal shape.

Explore — the midpoints of any quadrilateral

A, B and C stay fixed. Move D with the sliders, or choose a shape. P, Q, R and S are the midpoints of the four sides. Watch the vectors along the sides of PQRS.

Shapes:

The figure shows A(0, 0), B(8, 1), C(9, 6) and D(2, 7), with the midpoints of the four sides joined. The table also gives a dented shape, with D moved to (6, 3). Vectors are written (across, up).

ABCDPQRS
The midpoints P, Q, R and S of the sides of ABCD, joined in order, make a parallelogram.
DP to QS to RP to SQ to R
(2, 7)(4.5, 3)(4.5, 3)(−3, 3)(−3, 3)
(6, 3)(4.5, 3)(4.5, 3)(−1, 1)(−1, 1)

In both rows, opposite sides of PQRS are equal vectors. So PQRS is a parallelogram, even when ABCD is dented.

You should have seen the same thing every time. The teal shape is always a parallelogram, even when ABCD is dented inwards or its sides cross. Notice also that P to Q never changes while D moves. It is always half of A to C. Now prove it.

Worked Example 4 — The midpoint parallelogram

ABCD is any quadrilateral. P, Q, R and S are the midpoints of AB, BC, CD and DA. Prove that PQRS is a parallelogram.

Think first. No corner is special, so use any origin and keep all four position vectors.

, , and .

.

.

So . In the same way, . Both pairs of opposite sides are equal vectors, so PQRS is a parallelogram.

Check. The explorer's readouts are this proof with numbers: is half of A to C. The proof also explains why P to Q never moved: D does not appear in .

This result is called Varignon's theorem, after the French mathematician Pierre Varignon. His proof was published in 1731, nine years after his death, in a textbook his colleagues built from his notes. The vector proof above takes three lines.

Three traps

Trap 1 — Parallel, but not proved collinear

shows two parallel lines. It does not put four points on one line. For collinear points, the two vectors must share a point: and , or and . Then say so in words: "parallel, with a common point M".

Trap 2 — Proving with one drawing

Choosing numbers for and , or measuring a careful drawing, checks one case only. The circle pattern at the start was right five times and still wrong. In a "prove that" question, keep the letters to the end. Use numbers only as a check afterwards.

Trap 3 — Starting from what you want to prove

In the parallelogram proof, do not begin with "the midpoint of OB equals the midpoint of AC". That is the conclusion. A proof starts from what you are given (opposite sides are equal vectors) and works towards the result. Work out each side of the result separately, then show the two are equal.

Try it yourself

Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.

  1. (a) A is (2, −1), B is (4, 3) and C is (9, 13). Show that A, B and C are collinear, and find AB : BC. (b) P is (0, 1), Q is (3, 3) and R is (8, 6). Are P, Q and R collinear?

    Hint 1

    In each part, find two vectors that start at the first point.

    Hint 2

    Find from the top numbers. Then check whether the same works for the bottom numbers.

    Full answer

    (a) and . From the top, , and . ✓ So , with A shared: collinear. , so AB : BC = 1 : 2.5 = 2 : 5.

    (b) and . The top gives , but , not 5. No single works, so P, Q and R are not collinear. Check: on a careful drawing R sits just below the line through P and Q.

  2. OABC is a trapezium. , and . M is the midpoint of OC and N is the midpoint of AB. Find in terms of . What does your answer say about MN?

    Hint 1

    Write first, by a route from O through C.

    Hint 2

    . Then and .

    Full answer

    . So . MN is a multiple of , so it is parallel to OA and to CB, the two parallel sides. Its length is , which is the average of the parallel sides' lengths, and . Check: with and , M is (0.5, 1.5), N is (3.5, 1.5), and . ✓

  3. OABC is a parallelogram with and . M is the midpoint of BC. X is the point on AC with AX : XC = 2 : 1. Prove that O, X and M are collinear, and find OX : XM.

    Hint 1

    B has position vector , as in the parallelogram proof. Write and .

    Hint 2

    and . Look for a number that turns one into the other.

    Full answer

    . . So . The vectors are parallel and share O, so O, X and M are collinear. OM is 1.5 times OX, so XM is half of OX: OX : XM = 2 : 1. Check: with and , M is (3, 3) and X is (2, 2), and . ✓

  4. A stretch. The parallelogram proof showed: in a parallelogram, the diagonals bisect each other. Prove the reverse. ABCD is a quadrilateral, lettered in order, whose diagonals AC and BD bisect each other. Prove that ABCD is a parallelogram.

    Hint 1

    "Bisect each other" means that AC and BD have the same midpoint. Write that as an equation.

    Hint 2

    . Multiply by 2, then rearrange to get on one side.

    Full answer

    The midpoints are equal: , so . Subtract and from both sides: . That says . Opposite sides AB and DC are equal vectors, so ABCD is a parallelogram. (Rearranging the other way gives as well.)

    Together with the lecture's proof, this shows that a quadrilateral is a parallelogram exactly when its diagonals bisect each other. So "the diagonals bisect each other" can be used as a test for a parallelogram. Check: for A(1, 1), B(5, 2), C(6, 6), D(2, 5) from the start of the lecture, , and . ✓

The bigger idea

Every result in this lecture is about parallel lines, midpoints and fractions along a line. Hold a wire triangle in sunlight, so that its shadow falls on a slanted wall. The shadow is stretched and slanted, but midpoints in the shadow are still midpoints, and parallel lines are still parallel. That is why vectors with only adding and scaling can prove these facts. It is also why they cannot prove facts about right angles, or compare lengths in different directions: a slanted shadow changes those. For angles you need a new way of multiplying two vectors, which comes at Pre-University level.

The bigger lesson is about knowing. Checking examples builds confidence. A proof builds certainty. The circle pattern at the start shows why mathematicians insist on the difference.

Key concepts in this lesson