- GDP — measuring a country's output
- Mean, median, mode · coming soon
- The circular flow
- Market failure
- Limitations of GDP as a welfare measure
- Measuring development — beyond GDP · coming soon
A rich country and a happier one
In 2024, the United States produced about $84 500 of output per person. Costa Rica, a small country in Central America, produced about $18 600 per person. By GDP per head, the average American produces about 4.5 times as much as the average Costa Rican.
Now look at two other numbers. A baby born in Costa Rica in 2023 could expect to live about 80.8 years. A baby born in the United States could expect about 79.3 years. And in the World Happiness Report of 2025, which asks people in each country to rate their own lives, Costa Rica came 6th in the world. The United States came 24th.
| Country | GDP per head, 2024 | Life expectancy, 2023 | Happiness rank, 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|
| United States | ≈ $84 500 | 79.3 years | 24th |
| Costa Rica | ≈ $18 600 | 80.8 years | 6th |
Sources: World Bank, World Development Indicators (GDP per head, current US dollars); UNDP, Human Development Report 2025 (life expectancy); World Happiness Report 2025 (average of 2022–2024 survey answers).
If GDP per head measured how well people live, this table could not happen. It does happen. So GDP per head must be measuring something else.
The last lecture ended with a warning. GDP measures output: things that are made and sold at a price. It promised to look closely at what the average hides, and at the other gaps: unpaid work, free time, health and the environment. Here they are.
What GDP was built to see
Remember how GDP is built. It adds up the market value of final goods and services. Market value means price times quantity. So GDP can only see things that have a price.
How well people live is a bigger question. Economists call it wellbeing, or welfare. It includes income, but also health, safety, free time, friends and family, clean air, and the feeling that life is going well. Some of these have prices. Most do not.
So the difference is not a mistake in GDP. GDP does its own job well. The mistake is to use it for a job it was never built to do. The gaps below show where that goes wrong.
Gap 1: the average hides who gets the output
GDP per head is a mean. It takes the whole output and shares it equally between every person. Real countries never share equally. So the mean can describe a person who does not exist.
Here is an extreme case. Imagine a country of one million people. One person earns $1 billion a year. The other 999 999 people each earn $5 a year. The total is dollars. Divide by one million people, and the mean is about $1 005 per person. But nobody earns anything like $1 005. Almost everyone earns $5.
A better guide to the typical person is the median. Line everyone up from the poorest to the richest, and take the person in the middle. In this country the median income is $5, because the person in the middle is one of the 999 999.
That is it. That is the whole idea of this gap. The mean answers "how much is there per person?" The median answers "how much does the typical person have?" When output is shared very unequally, the two answers are far apart.
Try it on a small invented island below. Its output never changes. Only the way it is shared changes.
An invented island has 10 people and produces $100 000 a year. Move the slider to choose how much of it goes to the richest person. The other nine share the rest equally. The chart rescales so the tallest bar always fits. Watch where the dashed mean line sits against the nine bars.
Presets:
What this model leaves out: taxes and government help, prices that differ for rich and poor, and people whose incomes are not equal among the nine. Real countries have all of these.
The two charts show the same invented island, with $100 000 of output and 10 people, so GDP per head is $10 000 in both. In the first, everyone gets an equal share. In the second, the richest person gets 82%.
The mean never moved. GDP per head was $10 000 every time. But the life of the typical islander changed completely. This is why a country's GDP per head can rise while most people feel no better off. The extra output may go mostly to the people at the top.
Gap 2: work without a price is invisible
The last lecture sorted "a parent cooking dinner for the family" into "not counted", and promised to come back to it. Here it is.
Cooking, cleaning, caring for children and looking after older relatives are real work. They produce real meals, clean homes and cared-for people. But when a family does this work for itself, nobody pays a price. GDP needs a price, so it counts nothing.
This work is not small. In 2019, India's National Statistical Office ran its first national time use survey. It asked people what they did, minute by minute, over a day. Among those who did unpaid domestic work for their household, women spent about 299 minutes a day on it, almost five hours. Men who did it spent about 97 minutes. About 81% of women did this work on a typical day, compared with about 26% of men. None of these hours appears in GDP.
Two neighbours, Amira and Joon, each cook dinner for their own family. One day they make a deal. Amira cooks for Joon's family, and Joon pays her $400 a month. Joon cooks for Amira's family, and Amira pays him $400 a month. The meals are exactly the same as before. What happens to GDP? Are the two families better off?
Show the answer
GDP rises by $800 a month, which is $9 600 a year, because two cooking services are now sold at a price. But nothing real has changed. The same meals are cooked, and each family's money just goes round in a circle. The families are no better off. If anything, they are slightly worse off, because they now carry food between houses.
This is the gap in one picture. GDP does not measure work. It measures work that is paid for.
Gap 3: free time does not count
Imagine two invented countries with the same GDP per head. In the first, people work 50 hours a week. In the second, they work 38 hours a week and produce the same output, because their work is more productive. GDP per head says the two are equal. But people in the second country have 12 more hours every week for family, rest, sport or study.
Free time has no price, so GDP gives it a value of zero. In fact, if people in the second country chose to work longer and produce more, GDP would rise, even if they were more tired and less happy. GDP cannot tell whether extra output was worth the time it cost.
Gap 4: harm can make GDP go up
This gap surprises most people. Read the situation below and make a prediction before you read on.
A flood destroys 1 000 homes in a country. The next year, builders are paid to rebuild all 1 000 homes, exactly as they were. What does the rebuilding do to GDP in that year?
The rebuilding raises GDP. Building homes is output with a price, so it is counted. The homes that were destroyed are not subtracted, because GDP measures what is produced in a year, not what is lost. At the end, the country has the same homes it had before the flood. Its people are not better off, and they lived through a disaster, but GDP went up.
The same thing happens in many places. When crime rises, people spend more on locks, guards and lawyers, and all of that is counted. When a factory pollutes a river, the town may buy water filters, and those are counted too. When a forest is cut down, the timber is counted as output. The lost forest, the cleaner air it gave and the animals that lived in it are not subtracted. GDP only adds. It never asks whether the spending was for something good or to repair something bad.
Gap 5: a long and healthy life
Look back at the table at the start. Costa Ricans produce far less per person, yet live longer on average. Richer countries usually do have longer lives, because they can pay for clean water, doctors and hospitals. But GDP per head and health are not the same thing. A country can spend its income well or badly. It can spread good health care to everyone, or only to people who can pay.
Better measures: adding health and education
If GDP per head misses so much, what else can we use? The best-known answer is the Human Development Index (HDI), first published by the United Nations Development Programme in 1990. It puts three things into one number.
Health is measured by life expectancy: how long a newborn baby can expect to live. Knowledge is measured by years of schooling: the years adults have already had, and the years a child starting school can expect. A decent standard of living is measured by income per head. The three are turned into scores between 0 and 1 and combined into one number between 0 and 1. (The method of combining them is called a geometric mean. A later lecture explains it.) The closer to 1, the better.
Here are three countries from the Human Development Report 2025, which uses data for 2023.
| Country | HDI | HDI rank | Life expectancy | Mean years of schooling (adults) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Singapore | 0.946 | 13th | 83.7 | 12.0 |
| United States | 0.938 | 17th | 79.3 | 13.9 |
| Costa Rica | 0.833 | 62nd | 80.8 | 8.8 |
Source: UNDP, Human Development Report 2025, Table 1.
Question 1. Costa Rica beats the United States on life expectancy. Why is its HDI still much lower?
The HDI has three parts, and health is only one. Adults in Costa Rica have had about 8.8 years of school on average, against 13.9 in the United States. And income per head is much lower. Two of the three parts favour the United States, so its HDI is higher.
Question 2. So does the HDI agree with GDP after all?
Not exactly. The HDI tells a fuller story, but it is still built from averages. It has no score for how equally income is shared, for unpaid work, for free time, or for happiness. So it can still rank a country above another where people say they are happier. No single number captures everything.
Check: Singapore ranks above the United States on HDI. In the table, it has the longer life expectancy, and its income per head is also higher (the last lecture gave its GDP per head as about $90 700). That outweighs its fewer years of adult schooling.
A real case: New Zealand's "wellbeing budget"
Can a government aim at wellbeing instead of only at GDP? New Zealand tried.
The policy. In 2018, New Zealand passed the Child Poverty Reduction Act. It made the government set targets for child poverty and report on them every year. In May 2019, the government presented its first "Wellbeing Budget". Every new spending plan had to show how it would improve wellbeing, not only output. Reducing child poverty was one of its main priorities.
The prediction. The government set three-year targets, to be reached by June 2021. One was about material hardship: children in homes that go without basic things, such as enough food, warm clothes or heating. The target was to cut it from about 13.3% of children to 10.3%. Another was to cut the share of children in low-income homes, before housing costs, from 16.5% to 10.5%.
What happened. In February 2022, Statistics New Zealand published the results for the year to June 2021. Material hardship had fallen to 11.0%. That was a real fall, but it did not reach the target of 10.3% (it was within the survey's margin of error). The low-income measure had fallen to 13.6%, which missed its target of 10.5%. A third measure, after housing costs, did meet its target. Later surveys showed hardship rising again, to about 12.8% of children in the year to June 2023, in a period when prices were rising quickly.
The verdict. The policy did not solve child poverty, and the improvement did not last. But it changed what was measured and published. Because the government had to report hardship every year, anyone could check whether children's lives were improving. Under GDP alone, a year of fast growth could have hidden a rise in hardship. The lesson is a balanced one. Measuring wellbeing does not fix a problem by itself, but it makes the problem harder to ignore.
Usually, richer countries do have longer lives and more schooling. But GDP per head is an average of output with a price. It can rise while the typical person gains nothing, while people work longer, or while the environment is damaged. Say "GDP per head is higher", and then check the other measures before you say "people are better off".
This is the opposite mistake. GDP is the best measure we have of how much an economy produces, and of whether it is growing or shrinking. Falling GDP usually means lost jobs and lower incomes. The right conclusion is that GDP is necessary but not enough. Read it beside other measures.
GDP per head is the mean output per person, including babies, and including output that goes abroad or to firms. It is not anyone's income. When you want the typical person, look for the median.
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.
-
An invented village has five households. Their yearly incomes are $3 000, $3 000, $4 000, $5 000 and $35 000. Find the mean and the median. Which one describes a typical household better, and why?
Hint 1
The mean is the total divided by the number of households. The median is the middle value when they are in order.
Hint 2
The total is $50 000. The incomes are already in order, so the median is the third one.
Full answer
Mean = $50 000 ÷ 5 = $10 000. Median = $4 000, the third of five. The median describes a typical household better. Four of the five households earn $5 000 or less, so the mean of $10 000 is pulled up by one rich household. Check: four households are below the mean and only one is above it, which is exactly what a very unequal share looks like.
-
For each event, say whether GDP goes up, down or stays the same, and whether people are clearly better off. (a) A family stops cleaning its own home and pays a cleaner. (b) A factory pollutes a river, and the town buys water filters. (c) Workers choose a four-day week, produce a little less, and spend the extra day with their families.
Hint 1
Ask two separate questions each time: "Is more output sold at a price?" and "Are people's lives better?"
Hint 2
In (b), think about what the filters are for. In (c), think about what GDP gives to free time.
Full answer
(a) GDP goes up, because cleaning is now sold. The home is equally clean, so the gain in wellbeing is only the family's free time, which GDP does not see. (b) GDP goes up, because the filters are sold. People are worse off than before the pollution: the spending only repairs part of the harm. (c) GDP goes down a little, because less is produced. But the workers chose this, so they probably value the free time more than the lost output. GDP and wellbeing move in opposite directions in (b) and (c).
-
Two invented countries have these figures. Pallonia: GDP per head $40 000, life expectancy 68 years, average adult schooling 7 years. Verdena: GDP per head $25 000, life expectancy 81 years, average adult schooling 12 years. Which country is ahead on GDP per head? Which is likely to be ahead on the HDI? Explain.
Hint 1
Remember the HDI's three parts and that income is only one of them.
Hint 2
Count how many of the three parts each country wins.
Full answer
Pallonia is ahead on GDP per head. Verdena is likely to be ahead on the HDI, because it wins two of the three parts by a wide margin: 13 more years of life expectancy and 5 more years of schooling. Pallonia wins only income. So the two measures rank the countries in opposite orders. Check: this is the same pattern as the United States and Costa Rica on life expectancy, but stronger, because here schooling also favours the poorer country.
-
In one year, an invented country's GDP per head rises by 3%, but its median income falls by 1%. The population does not change. How can both be true? Build a five-person example to show it.
Hint 1
The mean depends on the total. The median depends only on the person in the middle.
Hint 2
Start with incomes of 2, 3, 4, 5 and 36 (in thousands of dollars). Cut the first four by 1%, and choose the richest person's new income so that the total rises by 3%.
Full answer
Before: 2, 3, 4, 5, 36, total 50, mean 10, median 4 (thousands of dollars). After: the first four each fall by 1%, to 1.98, 2.97, 3.96 and 4.95. For the mean to rise by 3%, the total must become 51.5. So the richest person must have . Now the mean is , up 3%, and the median is 3.96, down 1%.
Both are true because all the growth, and a little more, went to the richest person. Check: 37.64 is about 4.6% more than 36, and nobody else gained. This is why some countries now publish median household income beside GDP per head.
What a country measures shapes what it aims for. If the headline number is GDP, governments are praised for growth, even when growth comes from long hours, damaged rivers or gains for a few. If the headline numbers include life expectancy, schooling, hardship and how people rate their own lives, governments are judged on those too.
This is why many countries and international bodies now talk about going "beyond GDP". They do not throw GDP away. They read it beside a dashboard of other measures, each one built to see something GDP cannot. A skilled economist does the same. The question is never only "how much did we produce?" It is also "who got it, what did it cost, and are people's lives better?"
- GDP measures output that has a price, while wellbeing also includes health, free time, safety, relationships and the environment.
- GDP per head is a mean, so it hides how output is shared, and the median is a better guide to the typical person.
- Unpaid work such as cooking and caring is real work that GDP does not count, because it has no price.
- GDP gives free time a value of zero and never subtracts harm, so disasters, crime and pollution can make it rise.
- The Human Development Index combines life expectancy, years of schooling and income per head into one number between 0 and 1.
- No single number captures how well people live, so GDP is necessary but must be read beside other measures.