- Total and marginal utility
- Opportunity cost
- Gradient — steepness and direction · coming soon
- Consumer equilibrium — maximising utility formally
- Income and substitution effects
- Indifference curves — formal properties · coming soon
How much do you prefer it?
Would you rather spend a free afternoon at the beach or at home? Now a second question: by how many utils do you prefer the beach?
That question has no honest answer. You can rank the two afternoons, but you cannot measure the gap. This is a real problem for the last lecture, which gave every dumpling a number of utils. Nobody has ever measured a util.
The last lecture promised that rankings are enough. Here is how. A consumer only has to say "I prefer A to B", "I prefer B to A" or "I do not mind". From those rankings alone, we will draw a map of what the consumer wants, add what she can afford, and find her best choice. The hard part is the slope of the curves, and why they bend. Spend your time there.
Bundles and three simple assumptions
Amara drinks coffee and tea (invented example). A bundle is one combination: (15, 20) means 15 cups of coffee and 20 cups of tea per week.
Economists make three weak assumptions about how a person ranks bundles. Weak means that almost everyone would accept them.
- Completeness. For any two bundles, Amara can say which she prefers, or that she does not mind.
- Transitivity. If she prefers A to B and B to C, then she prefers A to C. Her rankings do not go round in a circle.
- More is better (also called monotonicity). More of one good, and no less of the other, is preferred.
Bundles up and to the right of A have more of both goods, so they are better. Bundles down and to the left are worse. So a bundle exactly as good as A must have more of one good and less of the other.
Join all the bundles Amara likes exactly as much as A. The line you get is an indifference curve: she is indifferent between all the bundles on it. The picture has already proved its first property. Indifference curves slope downwards: to stay as happy when she gains coffee, she must lose some tea.
The slope: what Amara would give up
The slope of the curve is a trade: how many cups of tea Amara would give up for one more cup of coffee and stay just as happy. Here are six bundles on one of her curves.
| Bundle (coffee, tea) | Move to the next bundle | Tea given up per extra coffee |
|---|---|---|
| (10, 30) | +2 coffee, −5 tea | 2.5 |
| (12, 25) | +3 coffee, −5 tea | ≈ 1.67 |
| (15, 20) | +5 coffee, −5 tea | 1 |
| (20, 15) | +5 coffee, −3 tea | 0.6 |
| (25, 12) | +5 coffee, −2 tea | 0.4 |
| (30, 10) | end | — |
This trade is the marginal rate of substitution (MRS) of coffee for tea: the tea Amara would give up for one more cup of coffee, staying on the same curve. On the graph, it is the steepness of the curve.
It connects to marginal utility. If Amara gives up ΔT cups of tea and gains ΔC cups of coffee, she loses about MUT × ΔT and gains about MUC × ΔC. On an indifference curve, the two are equal. So:
Here ΔT and ΔC are positive amounts. The slope of the curve itself is −MRS, because tea falls as coffee rises.
Why the curve bends
Look at the last column of the table. The MRS falls from 2.5 to 0.4 as Amara moves to the right. With little coffee, one more cup is worth a lot of tea to her. With plenty of coffee, it is worth very little. This is the diminishing marginal rate of substitution. The curve is steep on the left and flat on the right: it bows in towards the origin, which economists call convex.
It is tempting to say this comes from diminishing marginal utility. That is not enough. The MRS is a ratio of two marginal utilities, and one good's marginal utility can depend on how much of the other good a person has.
The curve bends because of a fourth assumption: people prefer balanced bundles to extremes. Amara likes (10, 30) and (30, 10) equally. Halfway between them is (20, 20), and she prefers it to either extreme. So the halfway point lies on a higher curve, above the curve through the two extremes. That is exactly what a curve that bows inwards looks like.
Moving from (10, 30), Amara gives up 2.5 cups of tea per extra coffee. Moving from (25, 12), she gives up only 0.4. Does this mean she likes tea less when she has more coffee?
Show the answer
No. Her tastes have not changed at all. The two points lie on the same indifference curve, which describes one fixed set of preferences.
What changed is the bundle she holds. Near (10, 30), coffee is scarce in her bundle, so one more cup is worth a lot of tea. Near (25, 12), coffee is plentiful and tea is scarce, so one more coffee is worth little tea. The MRS describes the trade at a point, not a change in taste.
A map of preferences
Through every bundle there is an indifference curve. Draw a few of them and you get an indifference map.
Curves further from the origin are preferred, because "more is better". But IC₃ is not "50% better" than IC₂. Any labels that keep the same order describe Amara equally well: 1, 2, 3 or 10, 20, 900.
That is it. That is the whole idea. A ranking of bundles is enough to draw the whole map. We no longer need to measure utility.
The map has one more property. Indifference curves never cross. Here is the proof.
Suppose two curves cross at A. Amara likes B as much as A (curve 1), and C as much as A (curve 2). By transitivity, she likes B and C equally. But C has the same coffee as B and more tea, so by "more is better" she prefers C. Both cannot be true, so the curves cannot cross.
Two special shapes
Perfect substitutes are goods the consumer sees as identical. She always trades one for one, so the MRS never changes and the curves are straight lines. Perfect complements are only useful together. An extra left shoe without a right shoe adds nothing, so the curves are right angles. Most goods lie between these extremes, which is why the usual curve is bent, but not into a corner.
What Amara can afford: the budget line
Preferences say what Amara wants. Now add what she can pay for. Suppose she has $120 a week, coffee costs $4 a cup and tea costs $3 a cup. Every bundle that costs exactly $120 satisfies
In general, with income I and prices PC and PT, the budget line is . Rearranged for tea, it is a straight line:
All tea gives I ÷ PT = 40 cups, and all coffee gives I ÷ PC = 30 cups. The gradient is −PC ÷ PT = −4/3: each extra coffee costs $4, the price of 4/3 cups of tea.
So the slope of the budget line is the opportunity cost of coffee, measured in tea. It is the market's rate of exchange, set by prices. The MRS is Amara's own rate of exchange, set by her preferences. The rest of the lecture compares these two rates.
A change in income moves both ends by the same proportion, and the slope does not change. So the line shifts in parallel. What happens when a price changes? Commit to an answer first.
Amara still has $120 and coffee still costs $4. The price of tea rises from $3 to $4 a cup. What happens to her budget line?
When the price of tea rises from $3 to $4, the budget line pivots inward around the coffee end.
The rule: a price change moves only that good's end of the line, and the line pivots around the other end.
The best affordable bundle
Now put the two pictures together. Amara wants the highest indifference curve she can reach on her budget line. Find it yourself.
Amara spends all $120. Choose how many cups of coffee she buys; the rest of the money buys tea. The curve in colour is the indifference curve through her bundle. Find the bundle on the highest curve. Watch her MRS and the price ratio, 4/3 ≈ 1.33.
Bundles on the budget line 4C + 3T = 120, with Amara's MRS at each one (invented preferences). The best bundle is E = (15, 20), where the MRS equals the price ratio 4/3.
| Bundle (C, T) | Amara's MRS | Compared with 4/3 | Better move |
|---|---|---|---|
| (6, 32) | ≈ 5.33 | higher | more coffee |
| (10, ≈ 26.7) | ≈ 2.67 | higher | more coffee |
| (15, 20) | ≈ 1.33 | equal | none: best |
| (20, ≈ 13.3) | ≈ 0.67 | lower | less coffee |
| (24, 8) | ≈ 0.33 | lower | less coffee |
Away from 15 cups, the budget line cuts through the curve, so some affordable bundles lie above it. At (15, 20), the line only touches the curve: it is tangent there, and the two slopes are equal.
When the best bundle contains some of both goods, the budget line is tangent to the highest indifference curve it can reach. There:
, which is the same as
The second form is the last lecture's equimarginal principle. There it was a rule about spending each dollar where it buys most. Here it is a picture: the consumer's own rate of exchange equals the market's. The next lecture finds this point with algebra, and deals with cases where the best bundle has none of one good.
Worked examples
Income is $120, coffee costs $4 and tea costs $3.
Ends. All tea: 120 ÷ 3 = 40 cups. All coffee: 120 ÷ 4 = 30 cups.
Slope. −4/3. One more coffee costs 4/3 cups of tea.
Tea rises to $4. The tea end becomes 120 ÷ 4 = 30. The coffee end stays at 30. The new slope is −4/4 = −1. Coffee's opportunity cost has fallen to one cup of tea, because tea is now dearer.
Income and both prices double ($240, $8, $6). The ends are 240 ÷ 6 = 40 and 240 ÷ 8 = 30, as at the start. Only income compared with prices matters.
Check. (15, 20) costs 4 × 15 + 3 × 20 = 120. ✓
Prices are $4 for coffee and $3 for tea. Amara buys (6, 32), which costs 24 + 96 = $120. At this bundle, she says she would give up about 5 cups of tea for one more coffee.
Compare the two rates. Her MRS is about 5. The market asks only 4/3 ≈ 1.33 cups of tea for a coffee: give up 4/3 cups of tea, saving $4, and buy one coffee.
Decide. She would have given up 5 cups and only has to give up 1.33. So she is better off. She should keep buying more coffee and less tea.
When to stop. As she gains coffee, her MRS falls. She stops when it reaches 4/3, at (15, 20).
The other side. At (24, 8), her MRS is about 1/3. Giving up a coffee returns 4/3 cups of tea, but she needs only 1/3 of a cup to feel the same. So she should buy less coffee.
A real case: cash or a food basket?
The policy. Governments that help poor households can give cash, or help in kind, such as food. In 2003, Mexico began a food assistance programme, the Programa de Apoyo Alimentario (PAL), in poor rural villages. The researcher Jesse Cunha used it as an experiment. In eight southern states, 208 villages were chosen at random to receive a monthly food basket, monthly cash, or nothing (Cunha, American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 2014).
The prediction. Cash moves the budget line out in parallel. A food basket moves it out only for food. The food cannot become other goods, so the new line has a flat part.
Household A already spends more on food than the voucher, so for A the voucher is just like cash. Household B, given cash, would spend less on food than the voucher. B is pushed to the corner K, onto a lower indifference curve.
What happened. The basket was worth about 205 pesos a month at local prices. The cash was 150 pesos, about what the government paid wholesale for one basket. For total food spending, the basket behaved like cash for almost every household: the two raised food consumption by amounts that could not be told apart. But single items were different. About 90% of households would have consumed less powdered milk than the basket gave them. With the basket, milk powder consumption averaged about 25 pesos a month, against about 5 pesos with cash. Child health was almost the same in the two groups, and delivering the basket cost at least about 18% more than delivering cash.
Verdict. The prediction held. For total food, households were like A, so the basket worked like cash. For particular foods, many were like B, pushed to eat things they would not have chosen, for little measurable health gain and a higher delivery cost. The case for cash is strong. Governments still choose in-kind help when they value a particular good for its own sake. That is a value judgement, which the diagram can show but cannot settle.
A parallel shift means the slope is unchanged, which happens only when income changes, or all prices change by the same proportion. When one price changes, only that good's end of the line moves. The line pivots around the other end.
IC₃ is preferred to IC₂, but not "by 50%". The labels show order only. Any numbers that keep the same order describe the same preferences.
With coffee along the bottom, the slope of the budget line is −PC ÷ PT: the price of the good along the bottom goes on top. To check, divide the rise (I ÷ PT) by the run (I ÷ PC). The answer is PC ÷ PT.
Work each one on paper first. Open a hint only when you are stuck.
-
Lena has $60 a week to spend on fruit at $5 a kilogram and bread at $2 a loaf. Fruit goes along the bottom. (a) Find both ends of her budget line and its slope. What does the slope mean? (b) Describe the line if her income rises to $80. (c) Describe it instead if fruit falls to $4 a kilogram.
Hint 1
Each end is income divided by one price.
Hint 2
The slope is −(price of the good along the bottom) ÷ (price of the good up the side).
Full answer
(a) All fruit: 60 ÷ 5 = 12 kg. All bread: 60 ÷ 2 = 30 loaves. Slope = −5/2 = −2.5. Each extra kilogram of fruit costs 2.5 loaves of bread.
(b) The ends become 80 ÷ 5 = 16 and 80 ÷ 2 = 40. The slope is still −2.5, so the line shifts out in parallel.
(c) The fruit end moves to 60 ÷ 4 = 15 kg. The bread end stays at 30. The line pivots outward around the bread end, and the slope becomes −2.
Check: in (c), 15 kg × $4 = $60 and 30 × $2 = $60. ✓
-
Three students drew indifference maps. Siddharth's curves slope upwards. Mei's curves cross. Tomás's curves bow outwards, away from the origin. Which assumption about preferences does each drawing break?
Hint 1
Use the four-region figure for the first, and the proof with points A, B and C for the second.
Hint 2
For the third, take two points on one curve and look at the bundle halfway between them.
Full answer
Siddharth: an upward slope puts an equally good bundle up and to the right, with more of both goods. That breaks "more is better".
Mei: crossing curves give B ~ C, while C has more of one good than B. That breaks transitivity together with "more is better".
Tomás: on an outward-bowed curve, the halfway bundle lies below the curve, so it is worse than the extremes. That breaks the preference for balanced bundles. The MRS would rise, not fall, along the curve.
-
Kofi buys 10 units of X and 5 units of Y. X costs $2 and Y costs $1. At this bundle, he would give up 3 units of Y for one more X. Should he change what he buys? Explain using both the MRS and marginal utility per dollar.
Hint 1
Compare his MRS, 3, with the price ratio PX ÷ PY.
Hint 2
MRS = MUX ÷ MUY = 3. Divide each marginal utility by its price.
Full answer
The price ratio is 2 ÷ 1 = 2. Kofi values one X at 3 units of Y, and the market charges only 2. So he should buy more X and less Y.
In marginal utility: MUX = 3 × MUY. Per dollar, X gives 3MUY ÷ 2 = 1.5MUY, while Y gives MUY ÷ 1 = MUY. A dollar on X buys more, so move spending to X.
As he buys more X, his MRS falls. He stops when it reaches 2. Check: both methods give the same direction, as the theorem box says they must. ✓
-
Two invented households each have $100 a month for food and other goods ($1 per unit of each). A government gives each a $40 food voucher. With $40 of cash instead, household P would choose 70 food and 70 other goods, and household Q would choose 28 food and 112 other goods. (a) What does each household choose with the voucher? (b) Which household would prefer cash, and why? (c) The government says, "The voucher made Q eat more food, so it worked." Give one argument for and one against this claim.
Hint 1
Draw the voucher budget set: the flat part from (0, 100) to (40, 100), then the line down to (140, 0).
Hint 2
Is P's cash choice inside the voucher set? Is Q's? If Q's is not, which voucher bundle is closest to it?
Full answer
(a) P's choice, (70, 70), is on the voucher line, because 70 is more than 40. So P chooses (70, 70) either way. Q's choice, (28, 112), needs $12 of the voucher spent on other goods, which is not allowed. Q's best voucher bundle is the corner (40, 100): all the voucher on food and all the cash on other goods.
(b) Q prefers cash. (28, 112) was affordable with cash and Q chose it over (40, 100). P does not mind: both give the same bundle.
(c) For: if the government values Q's nutrition beyond what Q values it, then 40 units of food instead of 28 is a gain, a judgement about merit goods. Against: by Q's own ranking, Q is worse off. In the Mexican case, the extra items gave little measurable health gain, and the basket cost at least 18% more to deliver. The claim needs evidence that the extra food improved something, not only that it was eaten.
Francis Ysidro Edgeworth first drew indifference curves in 1881, in Mathematical Psychics, but he still built them from measured utility. Vilfredo Pareto saw in 1906 that the curves needed only rankings. In 1934, John Hicks and Roy Allen rebuilt the theory of demand on rankings alone, in an article in Economica.
The same picture appears far beyond coffee and tea. A worker choosing between rest and income, or a family choosing between spending now and saving, faces a constraint and ranks the options. The best choice is where the rate the chooser would accept equals the rate the market offers.
- An indifference curve joins all the bundles a consumer likes equally, and it needs only a ranking of bundles, not measured utility.
- Indifference curves slope downwards because more is better, never cross because of transitivity, and are further from the origin when preferred.
- The marginal rate of substitution is the amount of one good a consumer would give up for one more unit of the other, and it equals the ratio of their marginal utilities.
- Indifference curves bow towards the origin because people prefer balanced bundles to extremes, so the marginal rate of substitution falls along the curve.
- The budget line shows every bundle that costs exactly the consumer's income; a change in income shifts it in parallel, and a change in one price pivots it around the other end.
- The best affordable bundle with some of each good is where the budget line is tangent to the highest indifference curve, so the marginal rate of substitution equals the price ratio.